Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66706 (KAR)
SMT SOUMYA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/202624/2025 · 2025-11-19
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66706 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66706 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$%
&$'$$
($)
!"#$
% &
# '
& ($$$#
'
!#$#
& !#$#
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" )'' '' !"#$#
% *
'
( ' ' ! ' $
'
)
$$ &
+
)
! $($!$ &
+
"
'
)
& #( #! '
!$ & +
#!" $" #$$"&
+
'
,
*
- 3 -
,
*
-./012345.61.23234537839.67..:35;<=07->.5248 2-. 4?6.? 353230235; 637/319350?@ 1?4/..635;7 A.0?35; 4
071.? 55.B=?.)1077.6A@2-.7./456?.71456.52056 2-. 3>1=;5.6 5423/. A.0?35; 4 ! 602.6 $($!$ C36. 55.B=?. 377=.6 A@ 2-. 84=?2- ?.71456.52 -.1.232345.? 37 09747..:35; <=07->.5248 2-.3>1=;5.6 ?.>0?:74A7.?C023457>06. 02 10?07#(24 #! 056 4?6.? 357480? 07 63?./235; 0/2345 0;03572 2-. 1.232345.?071.? 55.B=?. '0/279.0635;242-./07.0?.07=56.? -. 1.232345.? D07 0114352.6 07 0 493/. =A 571./24? 45 #($E$#( 056 D07 7.?C35; 07 2-. 202345 4=7. 883/.? 48 356-05=?= 4D5 493/. 202345 8?4> $"#$$# /?3>3509 /4>190352 35 4E$$#( 35C49C35; >=92319. 0//=7.6 -06 A..5 ?.8.??.6 84? - 4 -
35C.723;02345 =56.? ./2345 # ( 48 2-. ? 145 /4>19.2345 48 35C.723;02345 0 /-0?;. 7-..2 D07 839.6 0;03572 /.?2035 0//=7.6 1.?7457 84? 488.5/.7 1=537-0A9. =56.?./23457#$"( "E#"$(056"$?.06D32- ./2345"482-.56305.50946.#!($
5##$$#2-.'?.14?21.?203535;242-. 7036/07.D07?./.3C.6A@2-.1.232345.?8?4>2-.4883/.48 2-..1=2@=1.?352.56.5248493/.4D.C.?2-.?.14?2 D07 06>322.69@ 542 84?D0?6.6 24 2-. F=?3763/234509 0;372?02.457.<=.529@2-.9.0?5.60;372?02.A@4?6.? 602.6 $E$#$ 0994D.6 2-. 637/-0?;. 01193/02345 056 637/-0?;.60992-.0//=7.6452-.;?4=562-02547=883/3.52 35/?3>350235; >02.?309 D07 190/.6 A.84?. 2-. 4=?2 24 F=7238@/45235=02345481?4/..635;7 ;;?3.C.6A@2-.7036 4?6.? 2-. 202. 1?.8.??.6 ?3>3509 .C37345 .232345 4!$
" 5 2-. A0/:6?41 48 2-. 80/2 2-02 2-. 4?3;3509 64/=>.52 056 2-. ' ?.14?2 D.?. 542 84?D0?6.6 24 2-. - 5 -
0;372?02. 2399 $E$#$ 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 244:7.?34=7542.482-.9017.022?3A=235;32242-./456=/2 48 2-. 1.232345.? 056 377=.6 0 7-4D/0=7. 5423/. 602.6 #G$G$" 099.;35; 5.;93;.5/. 056 6.?.93/2345 48 6=2@ -.1.232345.?7=A>322.60?.19@602.6$E#$$"720235; 2-02 7-. -06 4?099@ 63?./2.6 45. ?0:07- 4"# D-4D0707737235;-.?247=A>322-.'?.14?20562-02 05@6.90@D07749.9@022?3A=20A9.242-.7=A4?63502.4883/.? 05654224-.? -. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 35 2-. ?.C37345 1?4/..635;7 ?./4?6.6 4A7.?C023457 02 10?0;?01-7 #( 24 #! -49635; 2-02 2-. 1.232345.? -06 A..5 5.;93;.52 35 2-. 637/-0?;. 48 -.? 6=23.7 056 63?./2.6 2-. 7./456 ?.71456.52571./24?.5.?0948493/.2420:.011?41?302. 0/2345 =?7=052 2-.?.24 0 /4>>=53/02345 602.6 #$$" D07 377=.6 24 2-. 7./456 ?.71456.52 1?.93>350?@.5<=3?@D072-.?.082.?/456=/2.6A@2-.493/. 571./24?D-435-37?.14?2602.6$##$"/45/9=6.6 2-02 2-. 1.232345.? D07 5.;93;.52 056 6.?.93/2 35 6=2@
- 6 -
07.6 45 2-37 ?.14?2 637/319350?@ 1?4/..635;7 D.?. 3532302.6071.? 55.B=?.)0560637/319350?@5423/.D07 377=.6071.? 55.B=?. ( .0?5.6/4=57.9 84? 2-.1.232345.? -07 077039.6 2-.3>1=;5.60/23451?35/31099@452D4;?4=567
3 2-02 2-. 7-4D/0=7. 5423/. 377=.6 A@ 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 6=?35; ?.C3734509 1?4/..635;7 056 2-. /457.<=.52309 /4>>=53/02345 48 2-. 7./456 ?.71456.52 0?. D32-4=2 F=?3763/2345 056 2-.?.84?. 399.;09 2-.?.A@ C3230235; 2-. 7=A7.<=.52 637/319350?@ 0/2345H056
33 2-02 2-. 1.232345.?
-07 A..5 6.53.6 0 >.0535;8=9 056.88./23C. 4114?2=532@ 24 6.8.56 -.?7.980562-022-.>02.?309?.93.6=14564.7 542 /457232=2. .C36.5/. 7=883/3.52 35 90D 24 7=720350835635;485.;93;.5/. E 5 7=114?2 48 2-.7. 7=A>3773457 9.0?5.6 /4=57.9 -07 190/.6 ?.9305/. 45 2-. F=6;>.52 48 2-. 45IA9. =1?.>. 4=?2 35
- 7 -
! "# $ %% ! "& 056 2-. F=6;>.52 48 2-. --02237;0?-3;-4=?235'()
*
# + !%,& ! -- . !! ,/ 8=?2-.? /452.52345 37 ?037.6 2-02 2-. .B190502345 602.6 $E#$$" 1=?14?2.6 24 -0C. A..5 7=A>322.6 35 ?.71457.242-..773457*=6;.I77-4D/0=7.5423/.D07 542 0=2-4?.6 A@ 2-. 1.232345.? A=2 D07 84?;.6 A@ -.? 7=A4?63502. 2 37 2-.?.84?. /452.56.6 2-02 2-.?. 37 0 102.52 C34902345 48 1?4/.6=?09 803?5.77 3507>=/- 07 2-. 1.232345.? D07 6.53.6 2-. 4114?2=532@ 24 488.? 0 ;.5=35. .B190502345 D-3/- /4=96 -0C. 0C.?2.6 2-. 3532302345 48 637/319350?@1?4/..635;7
! 90/35; ?.9305/. 45 2-. 0A4C. 0=2-4?323.7 32 37 0?;=.6 2-02 2-.?. D07 0A749=2.9@ 54 >02.?309 A.84?. 2-. 9.0?5.6.773457*=6;.24F=7238@2-.377=05/.4807-4D /0=7. 5423/. 24 2-. 1.232345.? 4? 2-. /457.<=.52309 63?./2345242-.7./456?.71456.52243532302.0/234582-. 3>1=;5.6 1?4/..635;7 0?. 1.?>322.6 24 72056 2-. - 8 -
1.232345.? D4=96 7=88.? ;?0C. 1?.F=63/. 088./235; -.? 7.?C3/./0?..?352-.493/..10?2>.52
G .? /452?0 9.0?5.6 3;- 4=?2 4C.?5>.52 9.06.? 06C.?235; 24 2-. 4A7.?C023457 48 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;.3510?0;?01-7 #( 24 #! 7=A>327 2-02 2-. .773457 4=?2 -07 /9.0?9@ 84=56 2-. 1.232345.? ;=392@ 48 6.?.93/2345486=2@.7132.-0C35;?./.3C.62-.'?.14?2 2-.1.232345.?8039.62484?D0?632242-.0;372?02.D32-4=2 05@F=72383/02345 /235;452-.F=63/30963?./2345377=.6A@ 2-.9.0?5.6.773457*=6;.2-.7./456?.71456.52?3;-29@ 3532302.61?4/..635;72372-.?.84?.0?;=.62-022-.7/41. 48 352.?8.?.5/. =56.? ?23/9. E 48 2-. 457232=2345 48 563037.B2?.>.9@93>32.60562-0254352.?8.?.5/.D32-2-. 45;435;637/319350?@1?4/..635;737D0??052.6
#$ 82.?-.0?35;2-.9.0?5.6/4=57.945A42-736.7 2-.84994D35;1435270?37.84?/45736.?02345
- 9 -
! "
" # $%&'(
)
" *
! *
(
*+,*+-.+/010123*+0. ## .84?. 2-37 4=?2 6.9C.7 3524 2-. >022.? 32 D4=96 A.
0114732. 84? 2-37 4=?2 24 .B2?0/2 2-. 4A7.?C023457 >06. A@ 2-. .C3734509 4=?29.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 02 10?0;?01-7#( 24 #! 35 ?3>3509 .C37345 .232345 4!$ 07 D.99 07 2-. ?.9.C052 41.?023C.14?2345482-.4?6.?-.70>.37.B2?0/2.6056 ?.06707=56.? +, - #. "
'/'0
"
'1,''0
#. # $0,2&3 #4
* * ! 5.6
)
. * *4
- 10 -
" * # $0,2
! 7
#. )
,1 - *
! #.&. .) 5.6
! ) *
! !)
- !)
!
- *4
4
- *
. " # &
" - . "
8"
" !) . .) #. ! )
,% - . .) #. " ! 3 # 9) 4
* *
! 4
. .) #. 01 $ *
2
. ) 3
# :
9) *
- 11 -
* )
*
) " !) . .) #. 4
. .) #. * * *
! ! 4 ;
# -. 0A4C. .B2?0/2.6 4A7.?C023457 ?./4?6.6 A@ 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 0?. 2-. 7=AF./2 >022.? 48 /-099.5;.352-.1?.7.52D?321.232345 7542.6352-.7036 4A7.?C0234573237542356371=2.2-022-.'?.14?2602.6 !$E$# 0945; D32- 2-. 4?3;3509 64/=>.527 D07 ?./.3C.6 35 2-. 1.232345.?I7 4883/. 45 ##$$# 6>322.69@ 2-.7. 64/=>.527 D.?. 542 84?D0?6.6 24 2-. F=?3763/234509 0;372?02. =5239 2-. 637/-0?;. 01193/02345 /0>. 24 A. 06F=63/02.6 -.2-.? 5451?46=/2345 48 2-. ' ?.14?2 D07 6./373C. 35 2-. 4?6.? 48 637/-0?;. 4? D-.2-.? 327 23>.9@ 7=A>377345 D4=96 -0C. 092.?.6 2-. 4=2/4>. 0?. >022.?7 2-02 /05542 A. .B0>35.6 35 2-. 1?.7.521?4/..635;7=56.? ?23/9.(4D.C.?2-.80/2 ?.>03572-022-.?.14?2D07D32--.968?4>##$$#056 D07 542 1?46=/.6 A.84?. 2-. /4>1.2.52 4=?2 02 05@ >02.?309143524823>.35/9=635;07902.07"$"$"4? - 12 -
$!#$$"52-.7./3?/=>7205/.732D07D.99D32-352-. /4>1.2.5/. 48 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. .B.?/3735;
?.C3734509 F=?3763/2345 24 5423/. 056 /4>>.52 =145 7=/-
9017. -. 4A7.?C023457 48 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. .B1?.7735; 72?45; 637011?4C09 48 2-. 1.232345.?I7 /456=/2 64 542 7=88.? 8?4> 05@ F=?3763/234509 3583?>32@ 4? 9.;09 3>1?41?3.2@ D0??05235; 352.?8.?.5/. //4?635;9@ 2-. 1?0@.? 84? .B1=5;35; 2-. ?.>0?:7 >06. 35 ?3>3509 .C37345 .232345 4!$ 37 D-499@ >37/45/.3C.6 056 64.7542>.?320//.1205/. # -. 8?.7- .B190502345 54D 74=;-2 24 A.
8=?537-.6 A@ 2-. 1.232345.? 37 0 >022.? 2-02 >=72 011?41?302.9@ A. .B0>35.6 A@ 2-. 5<=3?@ 883/.? 35 2-. 637/319350?@ 1?4/..635;7 2 37 2?32. 90D 2-02 2-. D?32 F=?3763/2345482-374=?235>022.?7?.90235;24377=05/.48 7-4D/0=7. 5423/.7 /-0?;. 7-..27 056 3532302345 48 6.10?2>.5209.5<=3?3.737.B2?.>.9@93>32.6?6350?39@54 D?32 1.232345 93.7 24 <=07- 0 7-4D/0=7. 5423/.4?/-0?;. 7-..2=59.7732376.>4572?02.62-022-.0=2-4?32@377=35;
- 13 -
32-0654F=?3763/23454?2-.0/234537.B80/3.399.;09-37 4=?264.75427320705011.9902.84?=>24?.011?./302. .C36.5/. 4? 24 06F=63/02. 80/2=09 6371=2.7 -. 4=?2I7 7=1.?C374?@?49.=56.? ?23/9.(37/45835.624.B0>3535;
2-. 6./37345>0:35; 1?4/.77 056 352.?8.?.5/. 37 F=72383.6 459@ D-.?. 2-. 0/2345 7=88.?7 8?4> 0 F=?3763/234509 .??4? 1?4/.6=?093??.;=90?32@A?.0/-48502=?09F=723/.4?D-.?. 2-.
835635; 37 A07.6 45 54 .C36.5/. 4? 37 1.?C.?7. 0?A32?0?@4?7-4/:35;242-.F=63/309/457/3.5/. #" -. 1.232345.? -07 8039.6 24 .720A937- 2-02 2-. 7./456 ?.71456.52 90/:.6 F=?3763/2345 24
3532302. 6.10?2>.52091?4/..635;7-.4A7.?C023457482-.9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 02 10?0;?01-7#( 24 #! 48 2-. ?.C3734509 4?6.? 63?./235; 2-. 7./456 ?.71456.52 24 20:. 011?41?302.0/2345056/457.<=.52/4>>=53/02345242-. 602.6 #$$" /457232=2. 06>35372?023C. 72.17 20:.5 35 8=?2-.?05/. 48 F=63/309 4A7.?C023457 -. 637/319350?@ 0/2345 3532302.6 A@ 2-. 7./456 ?.71456.52 37 2-=7 542 459@ D32-35 F=?3763/2345 A=2 37 0 502=?09
- 14 -
06>35372?023C. /457.<=.5/. 48 2-. 835635;7 ?./4?6.6 A@ 2-.?.C37345094=?2
# -. /452.52345 2-02 092-4=;- 0 7-4D/0=7. 5423/.D07377=.6A@2-.9.0?5.6.773457*=6;.2-.?.19@ 602.6$E#$$"D075420=2-4?.6A@2-.1.232345.?A=2 A@ -.? 7=A4?63502.4883/.?37 0 >022.?35C49C35; 6371=2.6 80/27=/-06371=2.6<=.72345/05542A..B0>35.635D?32 F=?3763/2345 -37 19.0 ?.>0357 41.5 84? 2-. 1.232345.? 24 .720A937- 35 2-. 6.10?2>.5209 1?4/..635;7 A@ 066=/35;
/4;.52 .C36.5/. 6.>4572?0235; 2-02 2-. .B190502345 7=A>322.6A.84?.2-.9.0?5.6 .773457*=6;. D075.32-.? 0=2-4?.6 54? 0=2-4?37.6 A@ -.? 7 >022.?7 72056 2-. ?./4?6 ?.89./27 2-02 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 1?4C36.6 05 4114?2=532@ 24 2-. 1.232345.? 056 0 ?.19@ D07 356..6 8=?537-.6 D-.?.35 2-. 6.90@ D07 022?3A=2.6 24 D4?:9406 0563506C.?2.5/.-.1.232345.?54D7..:724?.2?0/28?4> 2-02 14732345 D-3/- 37 0 7.?34=7 099.;02345 056 >=72 A.
7=A72052302.6 A.84?. 2-. 5<=3?@ 883/.? 542 35 2-.7. 1?4/..635;7
- 15 -
#( .?. ?./4?635; 48 06C.?7. ?.>0?:7 A@ 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 84994D.6 A@ 3532302345 48 6.10?2>.5209 1?4/..635;7 A@ 2-. /4>1.2.52 0=2-4?32@ 64.7542A@327.98/457232=2.0C34902345482-.1?35/319.748 502=?09F=723/.-.1.232345.?D399-0C.08=99056.88./23C. 4114?2=532@ 24 6.8.56 -.?7.98 A.84?. 2-. 5<=3?@ 883/.? 056 A.84?. 2-. 637/319350?@ 0=2-4?32@ 45/. 2-. /-0?;. 7-..2 37 7.?C.6 056 1?4/..635;7 /4>>.5/. 2 2-37 1?.93>350?@ 720;. 54 1?.F=63/. 37 7-4D5 24 -0C. A..5 /0=7.6>.?.9@A@2-.3532302345482-.1?4/.77
#E 593;-2482-.84?.;435;637/=773452-374=?237 48 2-. /45736.?.6 C3.D 2-02 5.32-.? 2-. 4A7.?C023457 ?./4?6.6 A@ 2-. 9.0?5.6 .773457 *=6;. 54? 2-. 6.10?2>.5209 .5<=3?@ 3532302.6 A@ ?.71456.52 4 54? 2-./457.<=.525423/.377=.6A@?.71456.524"D0??052 352.?8.?.5/.35.B.?/37.48D?32F=?3763/2345-.1.232345.? -07 542 6.>4572?02.6 05@ 90/: 48F=?3763/2345 1?4/.6=?09 C34902345 4? 9.;093583?>32@ 35 2-. /-099.5;.6 0/23457 -. - 16 -
72.17 20:.5 A@ 2-. 7./456 ?.71456.52 0?. /9.0?9@ ?.714573C.240562?3;;.?.6A@2-.F=63/3094A7.?C02345748 2-.?.C37345094=?2-.1.232345.?-072-=78039.624>0:. 4=205@/07.84?352.?8.?.5/.022-37720;. #! 32-4=2.B1?.7735;05@4135345452-.>.?32748 2-.099.;0234570;035722-.1.232345.?93A.?2@37?.7.?C.624 -.?24/452.722-.6.10?2>.52091?4/..635;7056?037.099 1.?>3773A9. 6.8.5/.7 35/9=635; 2-47. 0?23/=902.6 35 2-. 1?.7.52D?321.232345'4?2-.84?.;435;?.074572-.D?32 1.232345 37 6.C436 48 >.?32 056 0//4?635;9@ 720567 637>377.6
,4 ($$) '
372494"