Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66701 (KAR)
LAXMI AND ORS v. MOHAMMED ALI AND ANR
MFA/202542/2022 · 2025-12-05
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66701 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66701 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#! "# #$ !! %$& '( !! )
'
(
! !"!#$ !%% !%$
&$'$( )
! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
+
&$'!(! "'
* *&( ( !((!!,(+,!#$ %
(,($ (!+(+($ (!,
-
*
&$'$ (! % %%
&$'$!( ./012.(($,,+!(!(#((( 3/0456.7 ,(' (!+8. +(' (!, )
% * % !( ( ! % % !,! % %
- 3 -
9
% %++#+'((" !':
% *
#( ( *
,, (!, %* ;
) '
(
! -
,
(,
+,
#
'( (
+
%
- 4 -
! !'+, %+! )
! *
+
&$'! "'
* *&( ( !((!!,(+,!#$ %
(,($ (!+(+($ (!, )
% !! ( ! % % !,! %
%
%,$((" !':
% * #( ( *
,$ (!, % *
;
- 5 -
%9
% *
<
*
<
* *
# <
*
! % . ( $( ( =>4?6 ?180.> !,! .5 8@? .8.6 ?@01/?A 18 !#'' @?6?0>358?6 6?5?66?4 8. 3A B8@? 1895.6A@.68@3AC??>50/?4C28@?1/3073>81@3//?>D0>D 8@?E=4D7?>83>43F364438?4 #( ( G3AA?4C28@? 44080.>3/ ?>0.6 0H0/ *=4D? 3>4
3/3C=63D0 0> .,, (!,
% . ( $ ( =>4?6 ?180.> !,! .5 8@? .8.6 ?@01/?A 18 !#'' @?6?0>358?6 6?5?66?4 8. 3A B8@? 1895.6A@.68@3AC??>50/?4C28@?1/3073>8A1@3//?>D0>D 8@?E=4D7?>83>43F364438?4 #( ( G3AA?4C28@? 44080.>3/ ?>0.6 0H0/ *=4D? 3>4
3/3C=63D0 0> .,$ (!,
- 6 -
%318A D0H0>D 60A? 8. 8@? 50/0>D .5 8@? 3GG?3/A C60?5/2 A838?436?8@38.>!(! (!,8@?4?1?3A?4
36?GG33>4 8@? 0>E=6?4 3/3GG3 F?6? G6.1??40>D .> 3 7.8.6121/? C?360>D6?D0A86380.> ."
" '+ 56.760A@>3G=6 8. 3>43D3//0
36?GG3 F3A 6040>D 8@? 7.8.6121/? 3>4 3/3GG3F3A8@?G0//0.>604?6@?>8@?26?31@?4>?368@? 3>43D3//0 137G A08=38?4 .> 8@? @3@3G=6 8. @.63G=6 30>6.34388@38807?3
3@0>463
3I01J GC?360>D 6?D0A86380.>."$",$ F@01@F3AC?0>D460H?>0>3 63A@3>4>?D/0D?>873>>?6137?56.7.GG.A08?A04?3>4 43A@?4 3D30>A8 8@? 7.8.6121/? 6044?> C2 4?1?3A?4 36?GG3 A 3 6?A=/8 .5 8@? 35.6?A304 31104?>8 C.8@ 5?// 4.F> 3>4 A=A830>?4 D60?H.=A 0>E=60?A 3>4
36?GG3 A=11=7C?48.8@?0>E=60?A.>8@?AG.8
@? 1/3073>8A 50/?4 3 G?8080.> =>4?6 ?180.> !++ .5 8@? 18 A??J0>D 1.7G?>A380.> 5.6 8@? 4?38@ .5 8@? 4?1?3A?4
36?GG3 3/.>D F08@ 0>8?6?A8 8 F3A G/?34?4 8@388@?0>E=6?43/3GG3AG?>8A0D>05013>837.=>88.F364A 7?4013/ ?IG?>A?A 1.>H?23>1? 1@36D?A 3>4 .8@?6 6?/38?4
- 7 -
1.A8A 8 F3A 5=68@?6 G/?34?4 8@38 8@? 31104?>8 .11=66?4 A./?/2 .> 311.=>8 .5 63A@ 3>4 >?D/0D?>8 460H0>D .5 8@? .55?>40>DH?@01/?C208A460H?6 $ > .,, (!, =G.> A?6H01? .5 >.801? 6?AG.>4?>8.A! 3>43GG?36?48@6.=D@1.=>A?/3>4 50/?4F6088?>A838?7?>84?>20>D8@?3H?67?>8A734?0>8@? 1/307 G?8080.> @? 6?AG.>4?>8 . 4?AG08? A?6H01? .5 >.801?404>.83GG?36C?5.6?8@?60C=>3/3>4F3AG/31?4 ?I"G368? >
.,$ (!, =G.> A?6H01? .5 >.801? 6?AG.>4?>8 .A! 3>4 3GG?36?4 8@6.=D@ 1.=>A?/ 3>4 50/?4F6088?>A838?7?>84?>20>D8@?3H?67?>8A734?0>8@? 1/307G?8080.>
+ > 8@?
C3A0A .5 8@? G/?340>DA .5 8@? G3680?A 8@? /307A60C=>3/5637?48@?0AA=?A3>48@?6?358?66?1.64?4 8@? ?H04?>1? @? 60C=>3/ C2 07G=D>?4 E=4D7?>8 3>4 3F364@3AG368/23//.F?48@?1/307G?8080.>3>4@?/48@38 8@? 1/3073>8 0>
.,, (!, 0A ?>808/?4 8. 3 1.7G?>A380.> .5 A#( ((" 3/.>D F08@ 0>8?6?A8 38 8@? 638? .5 +: G3 3>4 1/3073>8A 0>
.,$ (!, 36? - 8 -
?>808/?4 8. 3 1.7G?>A380.> .5 A $+((" 3/.>D F08@ 0>8?6?A8388@?638?.5+:G33>4406?18?48@?>A=63>1? .7G3>28.4?G.A088@?1.7G?>A380.>37.=>83/.>DF08@ 0>8?6?A8?0>D3DD60?H?48@?G6?A?>83GG?3/A@3H?C??> 50/?4
'
%$
)' *
&
, @? /?36>?4 1.=>A?/ 3GG?360>D 5.6 8@? 1/3073>8 @3A 630A?48@?5.//.F0>D1.>8?>80.>A 3 %06A8/2 8@? 1/3073>8 3AA?68A 8@38 @? F3A ?36>0>D A!$(((" G?6 7.>8@ C2 F.6J0>D 3A
3A.> 3>4 A (((((" G?6 3>>=7 3A 3D601=/8=60A8 .F?H?6 8@? 60C=>3/ @3A ?66?4 0> 83J0>D 8@? 0>1.7? 3A 7?6?/2 3A A!( $("G?67.>8@ C ?1.>4/2 8@? 1/3073>8 @3A ?I370>?4 8@? 4.18.6 3A
" @?60C=>3/=>4?6H3/=?48@?1/3073>8<AF@./?"C.42 40A3C0/08238!,:1.>86340180>D8@??H04?>1?.58@?4.18.6 8@388@?1/3073>8A=55?6?4$(:40A3C0/0828.F@./?C.42 1 @064/2 4=? 8. 8@? 31104?>8 8@? 1/3073>8 @3A A=A830>?4D60?H.=A0>E=60?A?F3A86?38?43A0>G380?>85.6
- 9 -
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
- 10 -
0>1.7? 8@? 60C=>3/ @3A 60D@8/2 3AA?AA?4 8@? 0>1.7? .5 8@?1/3073>8>.80.>3//2 C ?1.>4/2 ?H?> 8@.=D@ 8@? 4.18.6 4?G.A?4 8@38 8@? 1/3073>8 A=55?6?4 $(: 40A3C0/082 8. 8@? F@./? C.42 8@? 60C=>3/@3A83J?>!64.58@?40A3C0/0823AA?AA?4C28@? 4.18.6 3>4 @3A 1.>A04?6?4 8@? F@./? C.42 40A3C0/082 3A !,:F@01@0AE=A83>46?3A.>3C/? 1 @064/2 1.>A04?60>D 8@? 0>E=60?A A=A830>?4 C2 8@? 1/3073>8 3>4 1.>A04?60>D 8@? 3D? 3>4 3H.1380.> .5 8@? 1/3073>8 8@? .H?63// 1.7G?>A380.> 3F364?4 C2 8@? 60C=>3/ 0A E=A8 3>4 6?3A.>3C/? 3>4 08 4.?A >.8 F3663>8 0>8?65?6?>1? 4 3A8/2 8@? 4.18.6 @3A 4?G.A?4 8@38 8@? 1/3073>8 6?K=06?A A((((" 5.6 6?7.H3/ .5 8@?
07G/3>8 .>A04?60>D 8@? 0>E=60?A A=55?6?4 C2 8@? 1/3073>8 8@? 40A3C0/0821?68050138?3>48@?7?4013/6?1.64A8@?60C=>3/ @3A 60D@8/2 D63>8?4 A!$(((" 8.F364A B%=8=6? 7?4013/ ?IG?>A?A9
- 11 -
08@ 8@? 3C.H? 1.>8?>80.>A 8@? /?36>?4 1.=>A?/ A.=D@88.40A70AA8@?3GG?3/ # ?36>?4 1.=>A?/ 3GG?360>D 5.6 6?AG.>4?>8 . & .7C364 ?>?63/>A=63>1?.7G3>2@3AA=C7088?4 8@388@?60C=>3/@3A>.853A8?>?43>2/03C0/082.>08 !( ?364 8@? /?36>?4 1.=>A?/ 5.6 8@? G3680?A 3>4 G?6=A?48@?E=4D7?>83>43F364.58@?60C=>3/ !! 8 0A >.8 0> 40AG=8? 8@38 8@? 1/3073>8 @3A A=A830>?4 0>E=60?A0>8@?6.34863550131104?>8.11=66?4.>!(! (!, 4=?8.63A@3>4>?D/0D?>8460H0>D.58@?.55?>40>DH?@01/? C208A460H?6
! @?1/3073>81/307A8@38@?F3A?36>0>DA!$(((" G?6 7.>8@ 3A 73A.> 3>4 A (((((" G?6 3>>=7 3A 3D601=/8=60A8 =8 @? @3A >.8 G6.4=1?4 3>2 4.1=7?>8A 8. A=CA83>8038?@0A1/307@?6?5.6?0>8@?3CA?>1?.5G6..5 .5 0>1.7? >.80.>3/ 0>1.7? @3A 8. C? 3AA?AA?4 @? 60C=>3/ @3A 60D@8/2 3AA?AA?4 7.>8@/2 0>1.7? .5 8@? 1/3073>83AA!( $("G?67.>8@
- 12 -
! AG?6F.=>41?68050138?8@?1/3073>8@3AA=A830>?4 C?/.F0>E=60?A
0 .7G.=>4 1.770>=8?4 56318=6? .5 A@358 .5 60D@85?7=6F08@C.>?/.AA
00 .7G.=>4 1.770>=8?4 56318=6? .5 =GG?6 64 60D@880C033>4.8@?6D60?H.=A0>E=60?A.H?68@?H083/G368A .58@?C.42 ! 3J0>D0>8.1.>A04?6380.>8@?4?G.A080.>.58@?4.18.6 8@388@?1/3073>8@3AG30>3>4AF?//0>D0>8@?60D@88@0D@ 3>4 /?D 0A =>3C/? 8. 5./4 @0A 60D@8 J>?? 13>>.8 F3/J F08@.=8A=GG.683>40A=>3C/?8.AK=38.6A0816.AA"/?DD?4 3>4 5=68@?6 1.>A04?60>D 8@38 8@? A=6D?62 .>? 0>1@ A@.68?>0>D .5 8@? 60D@8 /.F?6 /07C 3/.>D F08@ 0>E=60?A 7?>80.>?40>8@?F.=>41?68050138?F?36?.58@?.G0>0.> 8@388@?F@./?C.4240A3C0/082@3A8.C?3AA?AA?438 $: @? 1/3073>8 0A 3D?4 3C.=8 ' 2?36A 38 8@? 807? .5 8@? 31104?>83>47=/80G/0?63GG/013C/?8.@0A3D?D6.=G0AB!$9 @=A 8@? 1/3073>8 0A ?>808/?4 5.6 1.7G?>A380.> .5
- 13 -
+)* ' A!( $(L! L!$L $: .> 311.=>8 .5 </.AA.55=8=6?0>1.7?<
!$ =? 8. 8@? 31104?>8 8@? 1/3073>8 @3A A=55?6?4 D60?H.=A 0>E=60?A 3>4 3/A. =>4?6D.>? A=6D?62 @? 1/3073>8F3A@.AG083/0M?43A3>0>G380?>85.67.6?8@3>+ 432A 0> 8@? @.AG083/ 3>4 A=CA?K=?>8/2 6?1?0H?4 5=68@?6 86?387?>8 .>A04?60>D 8@? G6./.>D?4 G30> 4=60>D 86?387?>83AF?//3A8@?G?673>?>840A3C0/0821?68050?4C2 8@?4.18.6 F? 36? 0>1/0>?4 8. ?>@3>1?8@? 1.7G?>A380.> 3F364?4 C2 8@? 60C=>3/ =>4?6 8@? @?34 .5 <G30> 3>4 A=55?60>DA< 56.7 A ((((" 8. +' 3>4 =>4?6 8@? @?34 .5 </.AA .5 37?>080?A< 56.7 A!((((" 8. +'
!+ /8@.=D@ 8@? ?H04?>1? .5 8@? 4.18.6 A=DD?A8A 8@38 8@? 1/3073>8 6?K=06?A 3GG6.I0738?/2 A((((" 5.6 6?7.H3/ .5 07G/3>8A 8@? 1/3073>8 @3A >.8 G6.H04?4 3>2 ?A80738?5.65=8=6?A=6D?62.>A04?60>D8@?>38=6?.58@? 0>E=60?A3>48@??H04?>1?.58@?4.18.6F?36?0>1/0>?48. - 14 -
?>@3>1?8@?1.7G?>A380.>3F364?4C28@?60C=>3/=>4?6 8@?@?34.5<5=8=6?7?4013/?IG?>A?A<56.7A!$((("8. +)'
!, .>A04?60>D8@?>38=6?.50>E=60?A8@?1.7G?>A380.> 3F364?4 C2 8@? 60C=>3/ =>4?6 .8@?6 @?34A 0A E=A8 3>4 6?3A.>3C/? !' @=A 8@? 1/3073>8 0A ?>808/?4 8. 8@? 5.//.F0>D 1.7G?>A380.>
,-./+012/3/4.5 42.5./1.04+ +06054.4
7819.
5273/0: %+& +06054.4 78192+ 351 %+& 30>3>4A=55?60>DA (((( +(((( 88?>43>8@36D?A%..4 3>4.>H?23>1? @36D?A !'+(( !'+(( .AA.55=8=6?0>1.7? !+$( +! $( ?4013/IG?>408=6? #$!' #$!' %=8=6?7?4013/?IG?>A?A !$((( (((( .AA.50>1.7?4=60>D 6?387?>8 (,$( (,$(
- 15 -
.AA.537?>080?A3>4 >=86080.>5..4 !(((( (((( 10: ;*<) **
<) 3/4.4 ;
) '
%$
' *
& !# @?/?36>?41.=>A?/5.68@?1/3073>8A@3A630A?48@? 5.//.F0>D1.>8?>80.>A 3 %06A8/2 8@? 1/3073>8A 3AA?68 8@38 8@? 4?1?3A?4 F3A 3D?43C.=8 ,2?36A388@?807?.58@?31104?>83>4@343 7.>8@/2 0>1.7? .5 A!$(((" 3>4 A!$(" G?6 432 3A @3883 C2 F.6J0>D 3A 460H?6 =>4?6 @?6?5.6? 8@? 3AA?AA7?>8 .5 7.>8@/2 0>1.7? .5 8@? 4?1?3A?4 38 A!( $("C28@?60C=>3/0A=>E=A8050?43>4?66.>?.=A C ?1.>4/2 3A G?6 8@? /3F /304 4.F> C2 8@? .>9C/? =G6?7? .=68 0> 8@? 13A? .5 =! > * *
? 0> 13A?A F@?6? 8@? 4?1?3A?4 F3A A?/5" ?7G/.2?4.66?1?0H?4350I?4A3/3623>344080.>.5(:.5 8@? ?A83C/0A@?4 0>1.7? 8.F364A B5=8=6? G6.AG?18A9 0A
- 16 -
F3663>8?4 F@?> 8@? 4?1?3A?4 F3A C?/.F 8@? 3D? .5 ( 2?36A @? A304 G60>10G/? 0A 60D@8/2 3GG/0?4 8. 8@? G6?A?>8 13A? 1 @064/23AG?68@?E=4D7?>8.58@?.>9C/?=G6?7? .=680>8@?13A?.5 @$ > *< # < ? ?31@ .5 8@? 1/3073>8A0A?>808/?48.1.7G?>A380.>.5A(((("=>4?6 8@?@?34.5B/.AA.5/.H?3>4355?180.>3>41.>A.680=79 4 3A8/2 1.>A04?60>D 8@? 3D? 3>4 3H.1380.> .5 8@? 4?1?3A?4 8@? .H?63// 1.7G?>A380.> 3F364?4 C2 8@? 60C=>3/0A0>34?K=38?3>4.>8@?/.F?6A04? 08@ 8@? 3C.H? 1.>8?>80.>A 8@? /?36>?4 1.=>A?/ A.=D@88.3//.F8@?3GG?3/
( > 8@? .8@?6 @3>4 8@? /?36>?4 1.=>A?/ 5.6 8@? >A=63>1? .7G3>2 @3A 630A?4 8@? 5.//.F0>D 1.=>8?6" 1.>8?>80.>A 3 %06A8/2 3/8@.=D@ 8@? 1/3073>8A 1/307 8@38 8@? 4?1?3A?4 F3A ?36>0>D A!$(((" G?6 7.>8@ 8@?2 @3H? 530/?4
8. A=CA83>8038? 8@?06 1/307 F08@ A=GG.680>D
- 17 -
4.1=7?>8A .>A?K=?>8/2 8@? 60C=>3/ @3A 1.66?18/2 3AA?AA?48@?0>1.7?.58@?4?1?3A?4>.80.>3//2 C ?1.>4/2 A0>1? 8@? 1/3073>8A @3H? >.8 ?A83C/0A@?4 8@? 0>1.7? .5 8@? 4?1?3A?4 8@?2 36? >.8 ?>808/?4 5.6 1.7G?>A380.>8.F364AB5=8=6?G6.AG?18A9 1 @064/2 .> 3GG6?10380.> .5 .63/ 3>4 4.1=7?>8362 ?H04?>1? 3>4 1.>A04?60>D 8@? 3D? 3>4 3H.1380.> .5 8@? 4?1?3A?4 8@? .H?63// 1.7G?>A380.> 3F364?4 C2 8@? 60C=>3/0AE=A83>46?3A.>3C/? 08@ 8@? 3C.H? 1.>8?>80.>A 8@? /?36>?4 1.=>A?/ A.=D@88.40A70AA8@?3GG?3/
! ?364 8@? /?36>?4 1.=>A?/ 5.6 8@? G3680?A 3>4 G?6=A?48@?E=4D7?>83>43F364.58@?60C=>3/
8 0A >.8 0> 40AG=8? 8@38
36?GG3 40?4 0> 8@? 6.34 8635501 31104?>8 .11=66?4 .> !(! (!, 4=? 8. 63A@ 3>4 >?D/0D?>8460H0>D.58@?.55?>40>DH?@01/?C208A460H?6
@?
1/3073>8A 1/307 8@38 4?1?3A?4 F3A ?36>0>D A!$((("G?67.>8@3>4@3883.5A!$("3A3460H?6
- 18 -
=>4?6 ? @3A ?I370>?4 ?I1?G8 8@38 8@?2 @3H? 530/?4
8. G6.4=1? A=GG.680>D 4.1=7?>8A
8. A=CA83>8038?8@?061/307@?6?5.6?8@?60C=>3/@3A60D@8/2 3AA?AA?4 8@? >.80.>3/ 0>1.7? .5 8@? 4?1?3A?4 3A A!( $("G711.640>D/2/.AA.54?G?>4?>123AA?AA?4 C260C=>3/0AE=A83>46?3A.>3C/? .>A04?60>D 8@? 3D? 3>4 3H.1380.>.5 8@?4?1?3A?4 8@? .H?63// 1.7G?>A380.> 3F364?4 C2 8@? 60C=>3/ .> .8@?6@?34A0AE=A83>46?3A.>3C/?3>4084.?A>.813//5.6 0>8?65?6?>1? 0> 8@? E=4D7?>8 3>4 3F364 G3AA?4 C2 8@? 60C=>3/
$ >8@?6?A=/88@?5.//.F0>D.64?60AG3AA?4
3 @? 3GG?3/ 0>
% . ( $( ( 0A 0::6.4 2/ -051 C @?E=4D7?>8.58@?/307A60C=>3/0A7.4050?4 1 @? 1/3073>8 0A ?>808/?4 8. 3 8.83/ 1.7G?>A380.> .5 +**
<)'
- 19 -
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
4' %!& #
4' % #$ & # 0A8.!/.#