Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66699 (KAR)
MAHESH S/O DHRUVA PATTAR AND ANR v. RIYAZ AHAMAD S/O JAFFARSAB BANGI
RSA/200196/2014 · 2025-11-12
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66699 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66699 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%""
&&
'(&) (* &&
'(&)
(
*
! "
! !#$%&
'
!#$%&
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!#$%&
(
) *+
)
+
#
&+
!#$%&
$&+'&,
)
&&
)
"
'&&*'&-
)
&-'&'
,&-'&'
-'&
)
- 3 -
(
*
! "
! !#$%&
(
) *+
)
+
#
&+
!#$%&
!#$%&
'
!#$%&
- 4 -
,&''&,
)
&&
)
"
'&&*'&-
)
&*'&'
,&-'&'
&''&&$
)
',&'&'#
. /
)
(
!%" (
01213452165789::19;29<1=>;18?@:;9>73>==2>7
5&''&&$ AB123>57>7C 301 DB8CE173 5= 301 816<11 89318 '&&*'&- :92218 ?@ 88; >23<>63 B8C1 >D9:B< >7
52&*'&' 978 &-'&'
- 5 -
5'&&,+'&->2=>;189229>;>7C301DB8CE173978816<11 <1781<18 ?@ 301 ::1;;931 5B<3 >7 5&-'&' 978
5'&&,%'&- >2 =>;18 9229>;>7C 301 DB8CE173 978 816<11>75&*'&' ' 5< 301 29F1 5= ?<1G>3@ 301 <97F 5= :9<3>12 <1=1<<18 35 92 :1< 301>< <97F>7C >7 5&''&&$ =5< 192@<1=1<1761 * 9632<1;93>7C3530169219<192=5;;542 7 301 :<12173 6921 301 98E>3318 =963B9; E93<>H <1G19;23093571579::99339<4923015<>C>79;5471<5= 30>2 2B>3 26018B;1 :<5:1<3@ :57 0>2 81E>21 301 29>8 :<5:1<3@ 81G5;G18 B:57 0>2 30<11 2572 79E1;@ <9::9 I 11<9::9 929::9 978 >309; I >339::9 3 >2 9;25 B78>2:B318 =963 3093 1;81< 257 <9::9 8>18 >22B1;122 5721AB173;@ 301 2B<G>G>7C 2572 929::9 978 >339::9 2B6611818 35 301 123931 5= 301>< =9301< 1960 09G>7C 96AB><1897B78>G>81809;=209<1>73012B>3:<5:1<3@
- 6 -
- 1=178973 5 >7 5&''&&$ >2 3<96>7C 3>3;1 30<5BC0 0>2 C<978=9301< 79E1;@ 92>E29? 97C> 40>;1:;9>73>==29<13<96>7C3>3;130<5BC0>339::9(2?<9760 1=5<1 30>2 5B<3:<561182 =B<301<301 6921570978 092 C53 6016F1<18 0>235<@ 978 301<1=5<1 30>2 5B<3 71182 35 :17 8547 301 2>C7>=>6973 8139>;2 5= 301 ;>3>C93>57 ?134117 301:9<3>122=5<=><2381=178973301929::9405098 09;= 209<1 >7 301 :<5:1<3@ >7 1H1<6>21 5= 0>2 5471<20>: <>C0325G1<0>2B78>G>818209<11H16B318979C<11E1735= 29;1 89318 &$&,-# >7 =9G5B< 5= 571 92>E29? 97C> C<978=9301<5=81=1789735>7<12:1635= 5--, 517=5<6130129>89C<11E17392>E29?97C>>723>3B318 9 2B>3 =5< 2:16>=>6 :1<=5<E9761 >7 5&#,-# 1=178973 5 9;25 65731782 3093 929::9 09G>7C 1H16B318 97 9C<11E173 5= 29;1 >7 =9G5B< 5= =><23 81=178973(2 C<978=9301< 25;8 301 :<5:1<3@ >7 =9G5B< 5= 0>E9<9@ 978 579::9 B781< <1C>231<18 29;1 8118 89318 &%&*,-# 01<1=5<1 =><23 81=178973(2 C<978=9301< 92>E29?97C>40>;1=>;>7C3012:16>=>6:1<=5<E97612B>3
- 7 -
>E:;198180>E9<9@978579::99281=1789735*978 81=1789735- # 012B>3=>;18?@92>E29?97C>492B;3>E931;@ 816<118978>G>;5B<3B:578B19::<16>93>575=1G>81761 01;8 3093 81=178973 5* 978 81=178973 5- 41<1 753 ?579 =>81 :B<60921<2 =5< G9;B1 4>305B3 753>61 16<11 =5< 2:16>=>6 :1<=5<E9761 492 2B?21AB173;@ 1H16B318 >7 5'*#,#& 401<1>7 301 5B<3 65EE>22>571< 1H16B318 30129;1811857?109;=5=DB8CE17381?35<929::9978 1=1789735*9781=1789735-978D5>73:522122>57 5=301:<5:1<3@49281;>G1<183592>E29?97C>:B<2B973 35301816<11 % 01 :;9>73>==2 >7 5&''&&$ 9<1 3<96>7C 301>< 3>3;1 30<5BC0 >339::9 301 ?<5301< 5= 929::9 978 6;9>E35?19?25;B315471<25=173><12B>3:<5:1<3@7301 29>8 2B>3 301@ 9<1 8>2:B3>7C 301 3>3;1 5= 81=178973 5 405>2301C<9782575=92>E29?97C>?@6573178>7C3093 816<11 5?39>718 ?@ 92>E29?
97C> >7 5&#,-# 8512753657=1<97@17=5<619?;1<>C03B:5730181=178973
- 8 -
01:;9>73>==2=B<301<8>2:B31<1;93>5720>:5=81=1789735 4>30 301 5<>C>79; 816<11 05;81< >1 92>E29? 97C> 3 >2 9;25 <1;1G973 35 7531 3093 301 4>=1 5= 929::9 79E1;@ 97CB?9>0989;251H16B3189<1C>231<1829;1811889318 ''&',-% >7 =9G5B< 5= 571 097B 9339< :B<:5<3>7C 35 657G1@ 29E1 :<5:1<3@ >1 5--, :57 301 81E>21 5= 097B 9339< 0>2 4>854 57B?9> >723>3B318 9 :9<3>3>57 2B>3 >7 5+,,-$ 401<1 9 :<1;>E>79<@ 816<11 492 :92218978>71H16B3>575=816<1141231<7:5<3>575=301 :<5:1<3@4929;;5331835>339::9401<19219231<7:5<3>57 4929;;5331835 57B?9> + 01 :<12173 :;9>73>==2 >7 5&''&&$ 3<961 301><3>3;130<5BC0 57B?9>922978>339::99789221<3 3093>339::9(289BC031<1H16B318979C<11E1735=29;157 %&,'&&#=5;;5418?@<1C>231<1829;189315=''&'&&+ >7 301>< =9G5B< 9218 57 30>2 609>7 5= 3<972963>572 301@ 9221<3 9?25;B31 5471<20>: 5G1< 301 173><1 2B>3 26018B;1 :<5:1<3@
- 9 -
$ 73015301<097881=17897350929;25=>;18 92B>3211F>7C<1;>1=5=816;9<93>57978=5<:522122>57>7
5-'&1=17897356;9>E>7C92301C<978257978 ;1C9; 01>< 5= 92>E29? 97C> <1;>12 B:57 301 816<11 5= 2:16>=>6:1<=5<E9761>7 5&#,-#1=1789735 >7 301 2B>3 =>;18 ?@ 0>E 65731782 3093 0>2 :<18161225< 92>E29? 97C> 09G>7C 5?39>718 9 816<11 978 216B<18 :522122>575=B78>G>81809;=209<15=929::90989G9;>8 978 2B?2>23>7C 3>3;1 35 3093 1H3173 01<1=5<1 01 9;;1C12 3093:<12173 :;9>73>==2 ?921857 979C<11E173 35 21;;978 29;1 8118 89318 ''&'&&+ 09G1 8>2:52212218 301 81=178973517613012B>3 , 530 301 2B>32 41<1 6;B??18 978 65EE57 1G>81761 492 <165<818 ?@ 301 <>9; 5B<3 <>9; 5B<3 816<1183012B>3=>;18?@301:;9>73>==2>7 5&''&&$ 301<1?@816;9<>7C301:;9>73>==2929?25;B315471<2978>7 :522122>57 5721AB173;@ 2B>3 =>;18 ?@ 81=178973 75 >7
5-'&>28>2E>2218
- 10 -
& 1=178973 5 9229>;>7C 301 DB8CE173 978 816<11C<97318>7 5&''&&$9789;25=11;>7C9C<118 ?@ 8>2E>229; 5= 2B>3 >7 5-'& =>;18 345 9::19;2>7 5&*'&'9785&-'&'
01 ::1;;931 5B<3 B:57 <1!9::<16>93>57 5= 1G>81761 <1G1<218 301 =>78>7C2 5= 301 <>9; 5B<3 978 9;;5418?5303019::19;2=>;18?@1=17897375301<1?@ <165C7>J>7C 301 3>3;1 5= =><23 81=178973 0121 8>G1<C173 =>78>7C2 =5<E 301 2B?D163 E9331< 5= 609;;17C1 >7 301 :<121739::19;2=>;18?@:;9>73>==2>7 5&''&&$ ' 0>2 5B<3 G>81 5<81< 89318 '*&+'&, 092 =5<EB;9318=5;;54>7C2B?23973>9;AB123>5725=;94 K>)01301<301=>78>7C5=30165B<32?1;543093
<> 92>E29?
97C> 492 173>3;18 35 3>3;1 978 :522122>575=09;=9:5<3>575=3012B>3:<5:1<3@ ?169B215=301816<115=2:16>=>6:1<=5<E9761>7
5&#,-# 978 301 65721AB173>9; 29;1 811889318&%&,#->2?9218571G>81761L
- 11 -
>>)01301<3019::;>693>57=>;18B781<<81<M B;1 '+ 5= 35 :<58B61 301 988>3>579;
856BE1732 G>J :;9>73 >7 5&+,%& 978 301 5<81< 20113 >7 5*&&,% <1AB><12 35 ?19;;5418LN * 0>25B<309G>7C1H3172>G1;@019<8301;19<718
17>5< 65B721; 9::19<>7C =5< :;9>73>==2 978 301 65B721;
9::19<>7C =5< 81=178973 5 811E2 >3 =>3 35 =5<EB;931 988>3>579;2B?23973>9;AB123>575=;94 K>>>)01301<301816<11C<97318?@301::1;;931 5B<3 697753 ?1 1H16B318 =5< 4973 5= 26018B;1 978 301<1=5<1 301 <1;>1=2 71182 35 ?1 E5B;818 978<1;>1=5=:9<3>3>577118235?1C<97318>7301 692157097835852B?23973>9;DB23>61LN +,-+,.,/0123,2+345/612+,37+ - 01 65<1 AB123>57 3093 71182 6572>81<93>57 93 301 09782 5= 30>2 5B<3 >2 92 35 401301< :;9>73>==2 09G1 ;56B223978>358>2:B313>3;15=92>E29?97C>>7G>145= 816<11:92218>7 5&#,-#B<301<30>25B<39;25
- 12 -
71182 35 1H9E>71 92 35 401301< 29;1 8118 89318 ''&',-% 1H16B318 ?@ 97CB?9> 4>854 5= 929::9 657=1<297@G9;>8<>C03>7=9G5B<5=571097B9339<978>7 3B<7 301 816<11 5?39>718 ?@ 0>2 4>854 57B?9> >7
5+,,-$ 0>2 5B<3 9;25 71182 35 1H9E>71 92 35 401301<301816<115?39>718?@ 57B?9>>7 5+,,-$ 9==16323013>3;15=92>E29?97C> # 01:;9>73>==24059<13<96>7C301><3>3;130<5BC0 >339::9 697 ;9@ 6;9>E 57;@ 35 97 B78>G>818 09;= 209<1 5= >339::9 01@09G175E9771<5=<>C035<>731<123>7301 09;= 209<1 5<>C>79;;@ ?1;57C>7C 35 929::9 40>60 23558 ;94=B;;@657G1@18>7=9G5B<5=92>E29?97C>:B<2B97335 301 816<11 >7 5&#,-# 761 301 816<11 492 1H16B318 978 D5>73 :522122>57 492 81;>G1<18 301 3>3;1 5= 929::9(2 ?<9760 23558 65E:;131;@ 8>G12318 01<1=5<1 301 29;1 >2 1H16B318 ?@ 97CB?9> 4>854 5= 929::9 >7 =9G5B<5=97B9339<>2;1C9;;@757!123297CB?9>098 75>781:1781735<2B?2>23>7C<>C0335657G1@97@:5<3>575= 301 2B>3 :<5:1<3@ 01 <165<8 8>26;5212 3093 929::9 098
- 13 -
9;<198@ 1731<18 >735 9 ?>78>7C 6573<963 35 21;; 57 &$&,-# 4>30 92>E29? 97C> C<978=9301< 5= 81=178973540>606B;E>79318>79816<11=5<2:16>=>6 :1<=5<E97613>29;25<1;1G9733575313093>730129>82B>3 929::90>E21;= 98E>33181H16B3>575=9C<11E1735=29;1 978 9661:318 301 816<11 0B2 97CB?9>/2 9;>1793>57 ?1>7C2B?21AB173353019C<11E173978>781<5C93>575=>3 6<1931275<>C03>7=9G5B<5=01<3<972=1<11 % 01<1=5<1 301 2B?21AB173 2B>3 >723>3B318 ?@
57>9>4>8545=097B9339<>7 5+,,-$8512 75398G9761301:;9>73>==2/6921>725=9<92301><6;9>E35301 173><1 1H3173 5= 301 2B>3 :<5:1<3@ >2 65761<718 01 :;9>73>==2?1>7C30160>;8<175= 57B?9>211F3581<>G13>3;1 3509;=209<130<5BC0301><E5301<541G1<30129;18118 <1;>18 B:57 1H16B318 >7 =9G5B< 5= 57B?9>/2 0B2?978 ?@ 301 4>854 5= 301 5<>C>79; 5471< 929::9 405 0>E21;= 01;8 57;@ 9 09;= 209<1 978 8>8 G9;>8;@ 657G1@ 3>3;1 35 92>E 29?
978 301<1=5<1 929::9/2 4>854 4>305B3 2B?2>23>7C9B305<>3@65B;875309G13<972=1<<18979?25;B31
- 14 -
>731<123>7301:<5:1<3@5721AB173;@30129;13<972963>57 >2 ;1C9;;@ 757 123 978 >769:9?;1 5= 657=1<<>7C 97@ <>C03 3>3;15<>731<12357301:;9>73>==2 + 1G1<301;122301:;9>73>==209G1:;9618<1;>9761 57301816<115?39>718?@301><E5301< 57B?9>>7
5+,,-$353<961301><<>C039783>3;135571!09;=209<1 5=3012B>3:<5:1<3@ 01@9;25211F351239?;>203>3;15G1< 301<1E9>7>7C09;=209<130<5BC030189BC031<5=>339;I >309::940598E>3318;@01;83015301<09;=209<1)0>;1 301:;9>73>==2 6573178 1H6;B2>G1 5471<20>: 5G1< 301173><1 :<5:1<3@ 301 E931<>9; 57 <165<8 57;@ 2B::5<32 301>< 173>3;1E173 35 571!09;= 209<1 01 81=178973 5 405 3<96120>23>3;130<5BC092>E29?9;258512753;9@6;9>E 35 97@30>7C ?1@578 571!09;= 209<1 0B2 57 9 69<1=B; 9::<16>93>575=3011G>81761>3?165E126;19<3093305BC0 301 :;9>73>==2 =9>; 35 :<5G1 1H6;B2>G1 3>3;1 35 301 405;1 1H3173 301@ 09G1 293>2=9635<>;@ 1239?;>2018 301>< ;94=B; 5471<20>:35571!09;=209<1>73012B>3:<5:1<3@
- 15 -
$ 01<1=5<1301816<115?39>718?@ 57B09>>7
5+,,-$ 8512 753 E931<>9;;@ 9==163 301 3>3;1 5= 92>E29?97C>> 016573173>575=301 17>5<65B721;3093 92>E29?97C>8>8753609;;17C1301816<115?39>718?@
57B9>>7:9<3>3>572B>3>7 5+,,-$>2>EE931<>9; 01 29>8 816<11 492 ?134117 301 01><2 5= >339::9 >1
57B?9> 978 97B 9339< 71>301< 5= 405E 098 97@ 17=5<619?;1 <>C03 >7 301 09;= 209<1 5= 929::9 9;<198@ 816<118 >7 =9G5B< 5= 92>E29? 97C> 01 5E>22>57 35 609;;17C1 2B60 9 816<11 8512 753 81<5C931 =<5E 5< 1H3>7CB>20 92>E29?(2 3>3;1 81<>G18 B781< 9 :<>5< DB8>6>9; 816<11176130>26573173>5709235?1<1D16318 , 01 :;9>73>==2 405 9<1 3<96>7C 301>< <>C03 978 3>3;130<5BC0>339::998E>3318;@6977539221<33>3;135301 173><1 1H3173 01 3>3;1 856BE1732 5?39>718 ?@ :;9>73>==2 30<5BC0 301 89BC031< 5= >339::9 8512 753 657G1@ 97@ <>C039783>3;135301173><11H3173>339::998E>3318;@098 09;=209<1>73012B>326018B;1:<5:1<3@978301<1=5<10>2 89BC031<697753657G1@3>3;1?1@57809;=209<1 01<1=5<1
- 16 -
30129;181185?39>718?@:;9>73>==235301173><11H3173>2 >7G9;>83301E52330129;181185?39>718?@:;9>73>==2>2 G9;>857;@353011H31735=>339::9/209;=209<1 01<1=5<1 301 2B?23973>9; AB123>57 5= ;94 5> >2 97241<18 >7 301 ./ 301<1?@ 05;8>7C 3093 ::1;;931 5B<3 492 DB23>=>18>7816;9<>7C92>E29?97C>925471<35971H3173 5=09;=209<1 +,-+,.,/0123,2+345/612+,37++ '& 5< 301 =><23 3>E1 >7 301 216578 9::19; 301 9::1;;9732 09G1 =>;18 979::;>693>57 B781< <81< MB;1 '+9 211F>7C ;19G1 35 :<58B61 61<39>7 988>3>579;
856BE1732 301 :<>76>:9; 9E57C 301E ?1>7C 301 61<3>=>18 65:@5=301DB8CE173<1781<18>7 5+,%,=>;18?@ 301 4>854 978 60>;8<17 5= 92>E 9? 301 C<978=9301< 5= 301=><2381=178973 01;19<718 17>5<5B721;9::19<>7C =5<3019::1;;973265731782309330129>82B>3492571=5< :9<3>3>57O 305BC0 >7>3>9;;@ 816<118 301 816<11 492 213 92>81 >7 9::19; 978 301 E9331< <1E97818 401<19=31< 9 65E:<5E>214921731<18>7353>22B?E>33183093>731<E2
- 17 -
5= ;9B21 * 5= 301 65E:<5E>21 816<11 :<58B618 92 56BE1735-3014>85497860>;8<175=92>E 9?098 C>G17 B: 301>< <>C03 >7 301 :<5:1<3@ <121<G>7C 57;@ 301 <>C03 35 <165G1< 9 ?9;9761 5= 2,&&!
4>30 >731<123 3 >2 301<1=5<19<CB183093>7G>145=30>265E:<5E>21816<11 3012B>3=>;18?@81=1789735>7 5-'&492753 E9>739>79?;1 4>305B3 =><23 609;;17C>7C 301 65E:<5E>21 816<115=,%& ' 1< 6573<9 301 ;19<718 65B721; =5< 301 =><23 <12:578173 65731782 3093 :9<9C<9:0 , 5= 301 :;9>73 57;@ <1=1<23592133;1E1735B35=65B<3978301<1>2752:16>=>6 :;198>7C>7<1C9<8353019;;1C1865E:<5E>21816<115<>32 ;1C9;65721AB17612 01988>3>579;856BE173275425BC03 35 ?1 :<58B618 9<1 30B2 81 05<2 301 :;198>7C2 978 9<1 >7317818E1<1;@35=>;;B:;96B791>73019::1;;9732/6921 69B2>7C21<>5B2:<1DB8>6135301=><23<12:578173 '' 7 9 69<1=B; :1<B29; 5= 301 9G1<E1732 >7 301 9==>89G>3 =>;18 >7 2B::5<3 5= 301 :<12173 9::;>693>57 30>2 5B<3 =>782 3093 301<1 9<1 75 2:16>=>6 :;198>7C2 >7 301
- 18 -
:;9>7365<<12:578>7C35301988>3>579;856BE173225BC0335 ?1 >73<58B618 01 :;198>7C2 75401<1 <1=1< 35
5+,%, 35 301 65E:<5E>21 5< 35 97@ 98E>22>57 5< <1;>7AB>20E173?@30101><25=92>E 9? 0141;;!2133;18 :<>76>:;1 5= ;94 >2 3093 75 9E5B73 5= 1G>81761 697 ?1 ;55F18 >735 B7;122 301<1 9<1 =5B7893>579; :;198>7C2 7
2B:<9 301 57/?;1
B:<1E1 5B<3 01;8 3093 K9 6921 753 :;19818 1G17 >= :<5G18 ?@ 1G>81761 697753 ?1 301 ?92>2 5= 9 816<11N
>E>;9<;@ >7 ! "
#$$ %&
'(('>34925?21<G183093K>7301 9?217615=:;198>7C21G>81761>=;18C512>7G9>7=5<301 5301< :9<3@ >2 817>18 301 5::5<3B7>3@ 5= E113>7C >3N 01 29E1:<>76>:;1092?117<1>31<9318>7)$*)$
+) & #% ,
-./ ''' 978 >7 # 0% &1 2
(.
401<1 30>2 5B<301;83093 1G>81761 988B618 4>305B33017161229<@:;198>7C>2>798E>22>?;1978697753 ?1;55F18>735?@3015B<3
- 19 -
'* 725=9<92301265:15=<81<MB;1'+>2 65761<718301:1H5B<3>73 & &4 3 % ,
/ -
- 1H09B23>G1;@ ;9>8 8547 301 6578>3>572 B781< 40>60 988>3>579; 1G>81761 E9@ ?1 :1<E>3318 3 492 01;8 3093 988>3>579; 1G>81761 697 ?1 98E>3318 57;@ >= 301 :9<3@ 1239?;>2012 3093 812:>31 8B1 8>;>C1761 2B60 1G>81761 65B;8 753 ?1 :<58B618 93 97 19<;>1<239C197830933011G>8176125BC0335?1988B618 >27161229<@=5<:<575B76>7C9:<5:1<DB8CE173 015B<3 =B<301< 69B3>5718 3093 <81< M B;1 '+ 697753 ?1 >7G5F18 35 :9360 B: 419F :5>732 5< =>;; B: 5E>22>572 >7 1G>81761 01 29E1 G>14 092 ?117 =5;;5418 ?@ 301 9<7939F9 >C0 5B<3 >7 2+)0
#%&1
(2
05;8>7C3093856BE1732 :<58B618 =5< 301 =><23 3>E1 >7 216578 9::19; 4>305B3 :;198>7C2 5< 1H:;9793>57 =5< 757!:<58B63>57 697753 ?1 9661:318 '- 7 301 :<12173 6921 301 988>3>579; 856BE1732 9<1 753 65731E:5<9715B2 4>30 301 >22B12 <9>218 >7 301
- 20 -
:;198>7C275<09297@<19257?1172054740@301@65B;8 753 ?1 :<58B618 ?1=5<1 301 <>9; 5B<3 5< ><23 ::1;;931 5B<3 01 9331E:3 6;19<;@ 9::19<2 35 ?1 35 >73<58B61 9 714 =963B9; =5B7893>57 ?@ <1;@>7C 57 97 9;;1C18 65E:<5E>21 816<11 40>60 45B;8 2B?23973>9;;@ 9;31< 301 793B<15=30169211<E>33>7C2B601G>817619330>2239C1 45B;8 21<>5B2;@ :<1DB8>61 301 =><23 81=178973 978 45B;8 5==178 301 2133;18 :<>76>:;12 C5G1<7>7C 216578 9::1;;931 DB<>28>63>57B781< 163>57&&401<1=>78>7C25==963 697753?1<15:17181H61:3572B?23973>9;AB123>575=;94 '# 5<15G1<1G17922BE>7C9<CB1785309330125! 69;;18 65E:<5E>21 816<11 >7 5+,%, >2 C17B>71 ;9B21 * 301<15= 92 <1;>18 B:57 ?@ 301 9::1;;9732 :B<:5<32 35 6<1931 5< 1H3>7CB>20 <>C032 >7 >EE5G9?;1 :<5:1<3@ =5< 301 =><23 3>E1 3 >2 41;; 2133;18 3093 9 65E:<5E>21 816<11 40>60 6<19312 714 <>C032 >7 >EE5G9?;1 :<5:1<3@ 45<30 E5<1 3097 2&&!
<1AB><12 <1C>23<93>57B781< 163>57+?5=3011C>23<93>5763 ,&$73019?217615=<1C>23<93>572B609816<11697753
- 21 -
9==163301>EE5G9?;1:<5:1<3@ 0>2:<>76>:;1092?117;9>8 8547 ?@ 301 57/?;1 B:<1E1 5B<3 >7 $ #
# %,
'/'.401<1>349201;8 3093K>=30165E:<5E>21816<111E?58>12931<E40>60?@ >321;= 45B;8 <1AB><1 <1C>23<93>57 2B60 816<11 697753 ?1 ;55F18 >735 B7;122 <1C>231<18N 01 29E1 <93>5 092 ?117 6572>23173;@ =5;;5418 >7 2 5$)0 5 + % ,
./ (
05;8>7C 3093 97 B7<1C>231<18 65E:<5E>21 816<11 40>60 =><23 816;9<12 3<972=1<25<1H3>7CB>2012<>C032>7>EE5G9?;1:<5:1<3@>2 B717=5<619?;1>7;94 '% 7 G>14 5= 301 9?5G1 9B305<>393>G1 :<575B761E1732 30>2 5B<3 >2 5= 301 6572>81<18 5:>7>57 3093 301 988>3>579; 856BE1732 25BC03 35 ?1 >73<58B618 697753?1<161>G18>71G>81761=5<3456;19<<192572 301<1 9<1 75 :;198>7C2 65<<12:578>7C 35 301 9;;1C1865E:<5E>215<301816<115=,%&O978 301 29>8 856BE1732 1G17 >= 9661:318 93 =961 G9;B1:B<:5<3356<19315<1H3>7CB>20<>C032>7>EE5G9?;1
- 22 -
:<5:1<3@ 978 ?1>7C B7<1C>231<18 9<1 >798E>22>?;1 >7 1G>81761 '+ 665<8>7C;@ 301 9::;>693>57 =>;18 B781< <81< M B;1 '+9 >2 <1D16318 978 301 856BE1732 :<58B618 301<14>30 209;; 753 ?1 ;55F18 >735 =5< 97@ :B<:521 >7 301 :<12173 216578 9::19; 5< 301 <192572 2393182B:<92B?23973>9;AB123>575>>>297241<18>7301 .#/ +,-+,.,/0123,2+348/612+,+++ '$ 0>2 5B<3 8512 =>78 25E1 2B?239761 >7 301 9<CBE1732 98G97618 ?@ 301 ;19<718 17>5< 5B721;
9::19<>7C 35 301 :;9>73>==2 3 >2 3<B1 3093 301 :;9>73>==2 :;9>73 8512 753 8>26;521 2:16>=>6 ?5B789<>12 5= 301 2B>3 :<5:1<3@ 978 1G17 >7 301 816<11 =5< 2:16>=>6 :1<=5<E9761 5?39>718 ?@ 301 C<978=9301< 5= =><23 81=178973 79E1;@ 92>E29? 97C> >7 5&#,-# 301 :522122>57 81;>G1<184928126<>?1892D5>73:522122>57 ', 534>3023978>7C 301 9?21761 5= :<16>21 E1312 978 ?5B782 301 3>3;1 5= 92>E 9? 35 97 B78>G>818 09;=
- 23 -
209<1 >7 301 2B>3 :<5:1<3@ 239782 6576;B818 ?@ 9 G9;>8 816<11=5<2:16>=>6:1<=5<E976140>60092?1171H16B318 >75'*#,#& 01=><2381=178973?1>7C301;>719; 81261789739782B661225<5=92>E 9?09230B26;19<;@ 1239?;>2018 0>2 ;94=B; <>C03 978 3>3;1 35 09;= 209<1 >7 301 2B>3:<5:1<3@ *& 7 2B60 6><6BE2397612 E1<1;@ ?169B21 301 ?5B789<>12 9<1 753 81;>719318 >7 301 :;9>73 5< >7 301 816<1130129E1697753<1781<301816<11>71H16B39?;15< 81=193301<>C0325=9:9<3@4050925301<4>211239?;>2018 3>3;1 3 >2 754 9 2133;18 :<>76>:;1 5= ;94 3093 301 5B<3 :522122124>818>26<13>579<@:541<35E5B;8301<1;>1=35 172B<130932B?23973>9;DB23>61>2960>1G18978301<>C0325= :9<3>12 9<1 753 <1781<18 >;;B25<@ 57 9665B73 5= 31607>69; 81=>6>176>12>7301:;198>7C25<8126<>:3>575=:<5:1<3@ * 7 6+)$) 78+9)
" * ! +% ,
.'/
..
+% ,
.'/
.. 301 57/?;1
B:<1E1 5B<3 01;8 3093 K>= 9 =963 9<>2>7C 9=31< 301 >723>3B3>57 5= 301 2B>3 092 9 =B789E1739; >E:963 57 301
- 24 -
<>C0335<1;>1=3015B<3>2?5B783539F165C7>J97615=301 6097C18 6><6BE2397612 978 E5B;8301<1;>1= 9665<8>7C;@N
>E>;9<;@ >7 #9 6+ )% & .(' >3 492 5?21<G18 3093 4017 301 122173>9;
=9632 9<1 ?1=5<1 3015B<3 978 ?530 :9<3>12 09G1 C571 35 3<>9; =B;;@ F754>7C 1960 5301</2 6921 301 5B<3 >2 753 :541<;122 35 C<973 9::<5:<>931 <1;>1= 1G17 >= >3 >2 753 :<16>21;@45<818>7301:;198>7C2 *' B<301<>7 % ,-/
. 301 :1H 5B<3 <1>31<9318 3093 305BC0 9 5B<3 5<8>79<>;@ 697753 C<973 9 <1;>1= 753 2:16>=>69;;@ :<9@18 =5< 97 1H61:3>57 1H>232 401<1 301 =5B7893>579; =9632 9<1 :;19818 978 1239?;>2018 >7 2B60 9 69213015B<3E9@E5B;85<E58>=@301<1;>1=35<1781< 65E:;131 DB23>61 01 29E1 :<>76>:;1 492 <19==><E18 >7 +9 : % ,
./
401<1 >3 492 01;8 3093 301 K=B763>57 5= 9 5B<3 5= DB23>61 >2 35 85 2B?23973>9;DB23>6197875335?1E>2;18?@31607>69;>3>12N
- 25 -
** 3>23<B13093301816<11>7=9G5B<5=81=178973 585127532:16>=@3011H963E1312978?5B7825=0>2 09;= 209<1 541G1< 301 :<12173 6921 092 9 601AB1<18 0>235<@ 5= :<5;57C18 978 <1:19318 ;>3>C93>57 ?134117 301 :9<3>12 12:>31 301 816<11 =5< 2:16>=>6 :1<=5<E9761 5?39>718 ?@ 81=178973 5 >7 5&#'&&# 301 :9<3>12 09G1 6573>7B18 35 ;>3>C931 4>305B3 <125;B3>57 301<1?@=<B23<93>7C301=<B>325=301816<11978:<5;57C>7C 301 8>2:B31 =5< 5G1< 9 816981 7 2B60 6><6BE2397612 >3 ?165E12 301 ?5B7817 8B3@ 5= 301 5B<3 35 172B<1 3093 DB23>61 >2 753 <1781<18 >;;B25<@ ?@ 31607>69;>3>12 5< ?@ ;19G>7C301:9<3>1235@13975301<<5B785=:<56118>7C2 *- 0157/?;1 B:<1E15B<3>7
2B:<9 6+)$) 78+9)
"*! +2B:<9 6)4
) 5+ 2)+ ;& . .< 978 +9 : 2B:<9 092 6572>23173;@ 01;8 30935B<32:5221229E:;1:541<35E5B;8301<1;>1=3585 65E:;131 DB23>61 1G17 401<1 301 :<16>21 <1;>1= >2 753
- 26 -
1H:<122;@:<9@18=5<:<5G>8183017161229<@=5B7893>579;
=9632 9<1 57 <165<8 AB9;;@ >7 #9 6+
)2B:<9 >3 092 ?117 <1>31<9318 3093 4017 :9<3>1209G1C571353<>9;=B;;@949<15=19605301</26;9>E2 978 09G1 ;18 1G>81761 9665<8>7C;@ 301 5B<3 >2 1E:541<1835C<9733019::<5:<>931<1;>1=7534>3023978>7C >E:1<=163>572>7301:;198>7C2 *# ::;@>7C3012141;;!2133;18:<>76>:;1230>25B<3 >25=3016572>81<18G>1430939;305BC0301816<11>7
5-'& 8512 753 81;>71931 301 :<16>21 ?5B789<>12 5= 81=178973 5/2 09;= 209<1 0>2 173>3;1E173 35 97 B78>G>818 09;= 209<1 >7 301 2B>3 :<5:1<3@ 9;<198@ 239782 DB8>6>9;;@9==><E1875<81<359G5>8=B<301<EB;3>:;>6>3@5= :<56118>7C2 35 C>G1 =B;; 1==163 35 301 816<11 9;<198@ >7 :;961 978 35 ?<>7C AB>13B2 35 30>2 ;57C!8<947 ;>3>C93>57 30>2 5B<3 811E2 >3 9::<5:<>931 35 E5B;8 301 <1;>1= 978 8><163 :9<3>3>57 ?@ 8<94>7C 9 :<1;>E>79<@ 816<11 0>2 9::<59609;57145B;8216B<165E:;131DB23>61?134117301
- 27 -
:9<3>12 978 172B<1 3093 301 <>C032 6<@239;;>218 ?@ 19<;>1< 98DB8>693>579<1=>79;;@9781==163>G1;@>E:;1E17318 *% ::;@>7C 301 9?5G1 :<>76>:;12 35 301 6921 93 09785761>3>2=5B78309381=1789735092:<5G183>3;1 3597B78>G>81809;=209<130<5BC00>2C<978=9301<92>E
9?
301 9?21761 5= ?5B789<>12 >7 301 :;9>73 5< 816<11 697753?1 9 C<5B7835817@ 5< =<B23<93130117=5<61E173 5=2B60<>C03 01:<5:1<65B<21301<1=5<1>235E5B;8301 <1;>1= 978 8><163 3093 301 816<11 209;; ?1 45<F18 5B3 ?@ >8173>=@>7C 978 9;;533>7C 301 09;= 209<1 5= 81=178973 5 30<5BC0 81E9<693>57 >7 1H16B3>57 :<56118>7C2 0>2 9::<5960 9;571 45B;8 21<G1 301 1782 5= DB23>61 978 :<1G173 =B<301< EB;3>:;>6>3@ 5= ;>3>C93>57 665<8>7C;@ 2B?23973>9; AB123>57 5= ;94 5>>> >2 97241<18 >7 301 .=
> 530 9::19;2 9<1 9 $ 01 =>78>7C 5= 301 ><23 ::1;;931 5B<3
- 28 -
<165C7>J>7C 301 81=178973/2 09;= 209<1 >2 01<1?@9==><E18 >> 541G1< 35 <1781< 65E:;131 DB23>61 30>2 5B<3E5B;82301<1;>1=?@8><163>7C3093301 :<5:1<3@209;;?1:9<3>3>5718?@E1312978 ?5B782?134117301?<97605=>339::9978 301?<97605=92>E 9?30<5BC0929::9 >71AB9;09;G12 >>> <94:<1;>E>79<@816<119665<8>7C;@ >G 01 <>9;5B<3209;;922>C7921:9<931 7BE?1<6578B63>79;16<11<56118>7C2 978172B<1963B9;81;>G1<@5=:522122>575= 301 <12:163>G1 09;= 209<12 35 301 173>3;18 :9<3>12 G 9<3>1235?19<301><54765232
-( '"") %
>235 * ;5