Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66695 (KAR)
PARAPPA S/O JATTEPPA DALAWAI v. YAMANAPPA S/O JATTEPPA DALAWAI AND ORS
RSA/7168/2013 · 2025-09-08
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66695 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66695 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$#%&#&
"" '"( )
!"
# $
% &
' &
()
*
+,
, -
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"
.!/"0
$
.!/"0
# , $
.!/"0
%
.!/"0
'
,
(
1
$/
.!/"0
- 3 -
2 ,, $
.!/"0
3
44
.!/"0
*
+ ,4 +- +- +-5 +4-,
5 ,
/0303! 3 ,
-
4 00 4
0 4 300$
4 6
3 4 &/ 4
4
,
- 4 -
7 , ,
% # 89::'#;<%=='>9:19>'%?=='>><@:A8;B':
;1 =>9<@911 #8>>'<29<2 @8' CD%2E'<@ <% %'#B'' %@'% &030 =::'% 9< ;0300$ ? @8' B':9%9<2 119#'B 4:@ B#F ;DB@6 9C=DB <% @8' CD%2E'<@ <%%'#B''%@'%30&&!=::'%9< ;3&/ ?@8'B>D<:911;DB@9C=DB
03 'B% >'B<'% #;D<:'> 1;B @8' =='>><@: <% >'B<'%#;D<:'>1;B@8'B':=;<%'<@:
0 8' =='>><@: B' : ;1 =>9<@911 <% B':=;<%'<@:B':;1%'1'<%<@
0$ 8' =>9<@911 19>'% :D9@ 1;B =B@9@9;< <% :'=B@'=;::'::9;<;189:G:8B'9<@8':D9@=B;='B@9':
8' :D9@ =B;='B@9': B' +9- ;!00H3 E':DB9<2 #B':032D<@:<%+99-;!00H3E':DB9<2 0$#B':0/2D<@:
- 5 -
0! @ 9: @8' #:' ;1 @8' =>9<@911 '1;B' @8' B9> ;DB@ @8@ =>9<@911 <% %'1'<%<@ B' 1D>> B;@8'B: <% @8'9B1@8'B @@'==%9'%!?'B:2;<%@8':D9@><%:
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
0" 8' %'1'<%<@ 9< 89: AB9@@'< :@@'E'<@ %E9@@'%@8'B'>@9;<:89='@A''<@8'=B@9':<%8:>:;
%E9@@'% @8@ @8' E;@8'B ;1 @8' =B@9': :;>% =B;='B@? E':DB9<2#B':032D<@:9<;!00H31;B>'2> <'#'::9@? ;1@8'9B 1E9>? @; ;<' %>':8' >9F;@ 9< @8' ?'B &$$ 8' %'1'<%<@ #;<@'<%'% @8@ @8' ><% E':DB9<2 0$ #B': 0/ 2D<@: 9< ;!00H3 8:
''< 2B<@'% ? @8' <% B9D<> ;< 3/0&$ <% :D:'KD'<@>?@8'=>9<@9118:'I'#D@'%:>'%''%%@'% $0!&! <% :;>% 89: G :8B' 9< 1J;DB ;1 @8' %'1'<%<@ 8' %'1'<%<@ 8: #;<@'<%'% @8@ @8' :9% %>':8' >9F;@ A8; 8: =DB#8:'% 9@'E ; ;1 :D9@ =B;='B@?8:<;@''<E%':=B@? 0 8' B9> ;DB@ ;< @8' :9: ;1 @8' :9% =>'%9<2:8:1BE'%@8'1;>>;A9<29::D':6
- 7 -
!" # $ %&'()*"(+
)#'),-'
./'(0
1&2%.&)))('(-#
"3)),-#
4
1
+
&54.%.# "")),-'
6
2
- 8 -
2
7
8
7
7
7
9
0/ 8' =>9<@911 8: ''< 'IE9<'% : <% 2;@EBF'%I@;!8'%'1'<%<@8:''<'IE9<'% :
<% 'IE9<'% ;<' A9@<':: :
3 <% 2;@ EBF'%I
@;I
&
0& 8' B9> ;DB@ ==B'#9@9<2 @8' 'J9%'<#' ;< B'#;B%8:<:A'B'%9::D':;3!/&0<%39< @8'<'2@9J'9::D';%;':<;@:DBJ9J'1;B#;<:9%'B@9;< <%<:A'B'%9::D':;$<%"9<@8'119BE@9J'<% 9::D':;<%:='B19<>;B%'B<%%9:E9::'%@8' :D9@;1@8'=>9<@911
- 9 -
0 8':;1=>9<@91119>'%=='>#8>>'<29<2@8' CD%2E'<@ <% %'#B'' =::'% ?
@8' B9> ;DB@ 9< ;0300$ 8' =='>>@' ;DB@ 1@'B 8'B9<2 @8' B2DE'<@: ;< ;@8 :9%': 8: 1;BED>@'% @8' 1;>>;A9<2 =;9<@:1;B#;<:9%'B@9;<6
/ " #
%&'()*"(+
)#'),-'
./'(0
2:
9
- 10 -
8'=='>>@';DB@<:A'B'%=;9<@;:<%$ 9< @8' <'2@9J' <% =;9<@ ;:3 9< @8' 119BE@9J' <% %9:E9::'% @8'=='> 119BE9<2 @8' CD%2E'<@ <%%'#B'' ;1@8'B9>;DB@
3 8':;1@8'=>9<@9118J'#8>>'<2'%@8':9% CD%2E'<@:;1@8'B9>;DB@<%@8'49B:@=='>>@';DB@ 9<@8'=B':'<@=='>
'B<'% #;D<:'> 1;B @8' =='>><@: A;D>% #;<@'<% @8@ @8' :>' ? @8' =>9<@911 9< 1J;DB ;1 @8' %'1'<%<@ ;1 89: :8B' D<%'B @8' :>' %''% %@'% $0!&! +I
- 9: A9@89< 0 E;<@8: ;1 @8' 2B<@ ;1 @8'><%?@8'<%B9D<><%@8@@8'B'9:J9;>@9;<;1 #;<%9@9;<'B<'%#;D<:'>1;B@8'=='>><@:%E9@@'%@8@ @8' :9% %>':8' >9F;@ A8; 8: =DB#8:'% @8' 9@'E ; ;1 @8' :D9@ =B;='B@? 9< @8' ?'B &$$ 8: <;@ ''< E%':=B@? - 11 -
$ 'B<'% #;D<:'> 1;B @8' B':=;<%'<@: A;D>% #;<@'<% @8@ @8':>' ? @8' =>9<@911 ;19@'E ;3 ;1 @8' :D9@=B;='B@?9:A9@89<@8'1E9>?<%@8'=>9<@9118:<;@ =B;%D#'% <? %;#DE'<@: @; :8;A A8@ A'B' @8' #;<%9@9;<:<%A8@#;<%9@9;<8:''<J9;>@'%
! J9<28'B%@8'>'B<'%#;D<:'>:1;B;@8@8' =B@9': @89: ;DB@ ='BD:'% @8' 9E=D2<'% CD%2E'<@: <% @8'B9>;DB@B'#;B%:
" I 9: :>' %''% %@'% 3!0&&$$ A8'B' D<%'B@8'E;@8'B;1=>9<@911<%%'1'<%<@8:'I'#D@'% :>' %''% 9< 1J;DB ;1 %>':8' >9F;@ >9'<@9<2 ;!00H3E':DB9<2#B':032D<@: <@8' :9: ;1 @8' :9% :>' %''% 9' I @8' <E' ;1 %>':8' >9F;@ 8: ''< ED@@'% D<%'B ;33!/ ;< 00$&$" A89#8 9: @ I3 8' :9% %>':8' >9F;@;B89:>'2>8'9B:8J'<;@''<E%':=B@9':@; @8':D9@8'B'1;B'@8'#;<@'<@9;<;1@8'=>9<@911@8@@8' :9% @8' :>' ? E;@8'B ;1 @8' =>9<@911 <% %'1'<%<@ 9: <;@;D@<%;D@:>'8:''<B'C'#@'%?@8'B9>;DB@ <%@8'49B:@=='>>@';DB@
- 12 -
< ='BD:> ;1 @8' :9% :>' %''% 6 I <% @B<:>@'%#;=?;1A89#8@I$%;':<;@9<%9#@'@8@ 9@9:<;@;D@<%;D@:>'<%@8':9%%>':8'>9F;@ 8:<;@''<E%':=B@?@;@8':D9@
/ I 9: @8' ;B929<> :>' %''% %@'% $0!&! 'I'#D@'% ? @8' =>9<@911 9< 1J;DB ;1 @8' %'1'<%<@ >9'<@9<2 89: G :8B' 9< =B;='B@? ;!00H3 E':DB9<2 0$ #B': 0/ 2D<@: 9< 1J;DB;1@8'%'1'<%<@I
"9:@8'#;=?;1;LE ;1 @8' <% B9D<> =B;#''%9<2: 9< ;$&$ A8'B'D<%'B@8'><%'B9<2;!00H38:''< 2B<@'% 9< 1J;DB ;1 @8' ==>9#<@ 8' =>9<@911 8: <;@ =B;%D#'%4;BE;0@;:8;A@8@A8@A:@8'#;<%9@9;< ;1 @8' <% B9D<> A89#8 9: >>'2'% @; ' J9;>@'% 8' :9% :>' %''% 9: A9@89< @8' 1E9>? : ;<' ;1 @8' B;@8'B 8:'I'#D@'%@8':>'%''%>9'<@9<289:G:8B'9<@8' :9%=B;='B@?9<1J;DB;189:B;@8'B
- 13 -
& ;<:9%'B9<2 >> @8':' :='#@: @8' B9> ;DB@ <% @8' 49B:@ =='>>@' ;DB@ 8J' B928@>? %9:E9::'% @8' :D9@ ;1 @8' =>9<@911 ;<:9%'B9<2 @8' :9% :='#@: <; :D:@<@9>KD':@9;<;1>AB9:'1;B#;<:9%'B@9;<'<#' @8'=='>9:
*+ '&#&( %
9:@;>;& ,