- 1 - !" # $%&!%!% '!!( !"# $ % & " ' (" ! ) * !(" ) !"# # % & Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"# + # !"# $ %' ", ! #, & + !!- !!. &+ (.""!(!# # ) " ! "-"!!(!# *(! -!!(!#!! # ) ,& + ! # ".(!!(!# "-("!(! ) , & / + 0 ' - 3 - % 0 ' & 123234516378194612:374;628135<=<<631>1?8@2:1 6174A;2345?=21?(.""!(!#B=771?8@617B45?1524#C 6=D =5E:=@=2 B64?;E1? =2 551F;61" 24 2:1 1F2152 61A=235<24=BB4352D15249617B45?1524242:1B47249 3AA 4AA1E246 =5? =A74 8135< =<<631>1? 8@ 2:1 =BB64>=A ?=21?"-"!!(!#=EE46?1?8@617B45?1524!242:17=3? =BB4352D152 ! :1 E=71 49 2:1 B123234516 37 2:=2 :1 :=>35< E4DBA121? :37 :=? =BBA31? 946 2:1 B472 49 ;DB B16=24635617B45?1524#6=D=5E:=@=242B=G=35 617B4571 24 2:1 542393E=2345 377;1? 8@ 617B45?152 4# 6=DB=5E:=@=235>3235<2:1=BBA3E=23457964D2:11A3<38A1 E=5?3?=217:1=BBA3E=2345492:1B123234516H=7=EE1B21? =5? :1 H=7 71A1E21? 946 2:1 B472 49 ;DB B16=246 37 =BB4352D152 H=7 =BB64>1? 8@ 617B45?1? 4!*3AA= =5E:=@=2>3?1D1D46=5?;D?=21?"(((#!(":;7 - 4 - 1>16735E12:1=BB4352D152492:1B123234516242:1B47249 ;DB B16=24635617B45?1524#6=D=5E:=@=2:1 :=7 8115 ?37E:=6<35< :37 ?;2317 61<;A=6A@ 24 2:1 7=2379=E234549:371DBA4@161232345162:;7:=7B;2;B:37 716>3E149D4612:=5"(@1=67=7;DB B16=246:=235 216D7 49 E:1?;A1 49 2:1 =65=2=G= 6=D H=6=I =5? =5E:=@=2 =I %2=9935< =22165 E=A1 49 =@ 12:4? 49 1E6;32D152=5?42:1645?3234574916>3E149 DBA4@117 496=D==5E:=@=2&;A17!(!(%:16135=92166191661?24 =7 2:1 ;A17& B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 =5? A16GE;D=2= 526@ B16=24637 61J;361?248193AA1?8@B64D42345964D 2:1 E=?61 49 +=216 B16=2462215?=52A1=5167 45 2:1 8=73749E4D8351?71534632@H:3E:37?1216D351?8@A15<2: 49 716>3E1 615?161? 35 2:1 617B1E23>1 E=?61 2 9;62:16 B64>3?17 2:=2 2:1 7=3? B472 E=5 81 93AA1? 8@ ?361E2 61E6;32D152452:18=73749D1632392:11A3<38A1E=5?3?=217 =61542=>=3A=8A1946B64D42345:1E=71492:1B123234516 372:=2:1:=>35<E4DBA121?35323=A93>1@1=6749:37716>3E1 =7;DB B16=24681E=D11A3<38A12481=BB43521?242:1 - 5 - B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 8@ B64D42345 45 =5? 964D (#(.!(!( +:15 2:35<7 7244? 2:;7 451 15G=2=BB= 4 :3D=BB=H:4H=7H46G35<=73AA4AA1E246352:14993E1 49 617B45?152 4#6=D =5E:=@=2 ?31? ?;635< :37 716>3E13145(-(!(!":161;B45:37H391617B45?152 4 93A1? =5 =BBA3E=2345 711G35< =BB4352D152 45 E4DB=77345=21<64;5?2=BB1=677:1:=?542B4771771? 61J;361?J;=A393E=23459462:1B472493AA4AA1E2465=D1A@ B=7735< 49 1F=D35=2345 46 B47717735< 1J;3>=A152 J;=A393E=2345H32:=55=?==7451492:1A=5<;=<1462:37 61=745:16=BBA3E=2345H=7G1B2B15?35<:1617B45?152 4 =BB1=67 24 :=>1 E4DBA121? :16 J;=A393E=2345 35 2:1@1=6!(!#4571J;152;B45H:3E::16=BBA3E=2345946 E4573?16=2345 49 =BB4352D152 45 E4DB=77345=21 <64;5? H=72=G15;B8@617B45?1524#6=D=5E:=@=25327 6174A;2345 B=771? 45 (.""!(!# %551F;61"& 2:1 617B45?152 4# 6174A>1? 24 =BB4352 617B45?152 4 24 2:1B472493AA4AA1E246H:3E:6174A;2345:=77;871J;152A@ - 6 - 8115 =BB64>1? 8@ 617B45?152 4!*3AA= =5E:=@=2 <<631>1?8@2:372:1B123234516378194612:374;62 # 636;B=7=<=6=23AA1=651?E4;571A=BB1=635< 946B1232345162=G35<2:374;622:64;<:2:161E46?7=5?2:1 ;A176191661?:16135=84>1>1:1D152A@7;8D3272:=2H:15 2:1B123234516:=>35<B;235D353D;D716>3E14993>1@1=67 =7;DB B16=2468135<=>=3A=8A1=71A3<38A1E=5?3?=2124 81 B64D421? 24 2:1 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 =7 1=6A@ =7 (#(.!(!(:14;<:224:=>18115B64D421?242:1B472 493AA4AA1E246H:3E:91AA>=E=5245(-(!(!";B452:1 ?1D37149 15G=2=BB=17;8D32732H=75424B159462:1 617B45?152=;2:463231724:=>1G1B22:17=3?B472>=E=52 45A@ 24 =EE4DD4?=21 617B45?152 4 23AA 7:1 =EJ;361? 2:1 61J;361? J;=A393E=2345 49 H:3E: :=BB151? 45A@ 35 2:1 @1=6 !(!# 1 7;8D327 2:161 37 54 7;E: B64>37345 B64>3?1? 35 2:1 ;A17 946 617B45?152 4# 24 B=77 = 6174A;2345 =9216 94;6 @1=67 H32:4;2 93AA35< 2:1 >=E=5E@ 8@ =BB435235< 2:1 B123234516 H:4 H=7 1A3<38A1 =7 B16 2:1 ;A17 :;7 :1 7;8D327 2:1 B64E1?;61 =?4B21? 8@ - 7 - 617B45?1524#=BB64>1?8@617B45?1524!37E4526=6@ 242:1A=H=BBA3E=8A1=5?7=D13761J;361?2481712=73?1 4571J;152A@:17;8D3272:=22:1617B45?15247!24# 81 ?361E21? 24 E4573?16 2:1 B123234516 24 2:1 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 =7 :1 37 1A3<38A1 24 81 =BB43521? 8@ B64D42345 B64>3?1?;5?162:1E2 1=651? E4;571A =BB1=635< 946 617B45?152 47! 24 # ?417 542 ?37B;21 2:1 ;A17 B64>3?35< 2:1 1A3<383A32@ E632163= =5? 2:1 D12:4? 49 =BB4352D152 24 2:1 B472493AA4AA1E246H:3E:37964D 2:1=>=3A=83A32@49 2:1 E=5?3?=217 H:4 :=>1 B;2 35 93>1 @1=67 49 716>3E1 35 2:1 B47249;DB B16=24612E1=A74?417542?37B;212:=2 2:1;A17?4542B64>3?1946G11B35<2:17=3?B472>=E=52 23AA =5@ 42:16 E=5?3?=217 D;E: A177 617B45?152 4 =EJ;3635< 2:1 61J;361? J;=A393E=2345 H:15 1A3<38A1 E=5?3?=2137=>=3A=8A12481B64D421? - 1=651?E4;571A=BB1=635<946617B45?1524 :4H1>16>1:1D152A@7;8D3272:=2=7452:1?=21H:152:1 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 91AA >=E=52 ;B45 ?1D371 49 :16 - 8 - :;78=5? 7:1 :=? B4771771? J;=A393E=2345 2:64;<: B15 53>16732@ 35E1 2:1 ;A17 61J;361? :16 24 :=>1 482=351?2:1J;=A393E=23452:64;<:61<;A=653>16732@ 7:1:=?24=EJ;361?B617E6381?J;=A393E=23452:16194612:1 617B45?152 =;2:4632317 :=>1 E4DD3221? 54 H645< 35 G11B35<2:17=3?B472>=E=5223AA7:1=EJ;361?2:161J;361? J;=A393E=2345 . A2165=23>1A@:17;8D3272:=239352:11>15249 2:374;62E4D35<242:1E45EA;7345492:1=BB4352D15249 617B45?15248135<3661<;A=6=51E177=6@?361E234581 <3>15 24 617B45?152 =;2:4632317 24 E4573?16 :16 =BBA3E=2345946=5@7;32=8A1B472 5 617B4571 A1=651? E4;571A 946 617B45?152 47!24#7;8D3272:=22:1=BBA3E=234549617B45?1524 H4;A? 81 E4573?161? 39 2:161 =61 =5@ 7;32=8A1 B472 35 617B45?1524#C6=D=5E:=@=2 94617=3?7;8D3773457=612=G154561E46? "( 1=6?16;71?2:161E46?7 - 9 - "" :161 37 54 ?37B;21 49 2:1 9=E2 2:=2 2:1 B123234516:16135:=>35<B4771771?61J;361?J;=A393E=234524 2:1 B472 49 ;DB B16=246 :=? 8115 =BB43521? =<=3572 7=5E23451? B4727 2:64;<: 2:1 B64E177 49 61E6;32D152 8@ 35>3235<=BBA3E=23458@542393E=2345:16137=A7454?37B;21 2:=2:1:=7E4DBA121?:37B648=2345=6@B1634?=5?:=7B;2 35 D353D;D 716>3E1 49 93>1 @1=67 24 81 E4573?161? 946 =BB4352D152 49 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 E:1?;A1 24 2:1 ;A17!(!(6191661?24=84>161=?=7;5?16 E:1?;A1 %7116;A1!=5?& A 4 =21<46@49B4727 12:4?49 1E6;32D152 353D;D;=A393E=2345 " ! # " 3AA4AA1E246=5? EA16GE;D=2= 526@ B16=246 @B64D42345964D 2:1 " E=?61 +=216 B16=246 2215?=52 A1=5167 45 2:1 8=737 49 E4D8351? 71534632@ 1534632@ 8135< ?1216D351? 8@ A15<2: 49 16>3E1 615?16 35 2:1 617B1E23>1 E=?617 @ ?361E2 61E6;32D152452:1 8=737 49 D1632 9 1A3<38A1 E=5?3?=217 ) )*+,-%"& ;72 :=>1 B=771? F=D35=2345 46 1J;3>=A152 F=D35=23457 H32: =55=?= =7 451 49 2:1 7;8I1E2,=5? %!&;72 :=>1 B;2 35 = 716>3E1 49 542 A177 2:=5 93>1 @1=67 35 2:1 E=?61 49 +=216 B16=246 2215?=52A1=5167 ).,)/0+)/0)1,+*/-+ %"&;72:=>1B=771? 1F=D35=2345 46 B477177 - 10 - =61 542 =>=3A=8A1 946B64D42345 1J;3>=A152 J;=A393E=2345 H32:=55=?==7451492:1 A=5<;=<1, %!& ;72 B477177 = E162393E=2149 2:611D452:7 E4DB;216 26=3535< E4;671 964D =5@ 357232;21 61E4<53K1?8@2:12=2146 1526=A4>165D152, "! 16;7=A 49 =94617=3? ;A1 7:4H7 2:=2 =BB4352D152 24 2:1 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 =5? A16GE;D =2= 526@ B16=246E=581D=?18@B64D42345964D2:1 E=?6149;DB B16=2462215?=52A1=516452:18=73749 E4D8351? 71534632@ :1 D12:4? 49 61E6;32D152 9;62:16 EA=6393172:=22:1?361E261E6;32D152242:17=3?B4728=71? 45D16327E=581?45145A@392:11A3<38A1E=5?3?=217H161 542=>=3A=8A1 " :;7 617B45?152 4#6=D =5E:=@=2 2:1 E4573?161? >31H 49 2:37 4;62 :=7 1661? 45 2H4 E4;527 B123234516:=>35<E4DBA121?:37D353D;DA15<2:49 716>3E1352:1B47249+=216 B16=2468135<=>=3A=8A1=745 2:1 ?=21 H:15 2:1 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 91AA >=E=52 ;B45 - 11 - 2:1 ?1D371 49 15G=2=BB= :;78=5? 49 617B45?152 4 :1 617B45?152 4# C 6=D =5E:=@=2 E4;A? 542 :=>1 4B21? ?361E2 61E6;32D152 B64E177 5 42:16 H46?7 H:15 B123234516 4" H=7 =>=3A=8A1 1>15 39 617B45?152 4 H391 49 15G=2=BB= :=? B4771771? 61J;361? J;=A393E=2345 E=5?3?=2;61 49 B123234516 4;<:2 24 :=>1 8115 E4573?161? 54 6;A1 46 =5@ B64>37345 49 A=H 864;<:2 24 2:1 5423E1 49 2:37 4;62 I;7239@35< 617B45?152 4#6=D =5E:=@=2 24 G11B 2:1 7=3? B472 >=E=52 23AA 617B45?152 4=EJ;361?2:161J;361?J;=A393E=2345:;745842:2:1 E4;527 2:1 D12:4? =5? 2:1 B64E1?;61 =?4B21? 8@ 617B45?152 4# 35 93AA35< ;B 2:1 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 E=554281E4;5215=5E1? "# 52:=2>31H492:1D=2216B12323457;EE11?7 " :1 3DB;<51? 6174A;2345 ?=21? (.""!(!# B64?;E1? =2 551F;61" =5? 2:1 =BB64>=A =EE46?1? 8@ 617B45?152 4! ?=21? "-"!!(!# B64?;E1? =2 551F;61=61:1618@J;=7:1? - 12 - "- 17B45?15247!24#=61?361E21?24E4573?16 2:1 E=5?3?=2;61 49 2:1 B123234516 24 2:1 B472 49 3AA 4AA1E246 39 :1 42:16H371 7=2379317 2:1 61J;361? 1A3<38A1 E632163==7B162:1;A17!(!(2481=BB43521?242:17=3? B472 ". 17B45?152 4# C 6=D =5E:=@=2 7:=AA =A74 E4573?162:1=BBA3E=234549617B45?1524946=5@42:16 7;32=8A1B47224:16J;=A393E=234535=EE46?=5E1H32:A=H !.2 '%!%( & 3724"A4#(