- 1 - ! "#! "##$ !! %$& ' !"# $ ! %&' ( )!!! * !! $ +,%' )# !+, +'%* Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! # + %&' ! & ! + %&' ( )! #- !#- * # # )* # # ! # . " ,&, '& ''&'% ! # #! # # /! /! - 3 - # ) /! * 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 )* => <05 =<=: 501;652;<%%)05:5183><5::5>5::59<=32?<05;<@>=: 20=:<*032A558>1659AB<05;631C38<2A518D3DD:15E59AB <05F79DC58<3893G3:993<59''&'%432259AB<05 991<1=83612<:1;<79D5389="1F3B347:18 =,&, '& #3;<2 D1E18D :125 <= <05 >1618D => <05 344536 A:15>6B 2<3<59 3:5 <03< =8 '''& 3< 3A=7< ', 0=7:2 95;53259 7816 3E55: G32 <:3E5618D 18 6<= 3: A53:18D 5D=+, +'% <=G3:92 393423: 785 >:=C 2C383A39 G058 <05 ;3: ;3C5 853: 38976G391 E1663D5=8!3:201+2C383A39:=393<<03<<1C5<059:1E5: => <05 2319 ;3: 9:=E5 <05 23C5 18 3 :320 389 85D61D58< C3885: 389 932059 <= <05 =44=21<5 E501;65 :5276<18D 18 3;;1958< 75 <= G01;0 <05 95;53259 7816 272<31859 053918F7:B3899159=8<0524=< - 4 - 05;631C38<2>1659345<1<1=87895:5;<1=8&& => <05 ;< 255H18D ;=C45823<1=8 >=: <05 953<0 => <05 95;5325978163E55:36=8DG1<018<5:52< , 8 25:E1;5 => 27CC=82 :524=8958< = 34453:59 <0:=7D0 ;=78256 389 >1659 G:1<<58 2<3<5C58< 958B18D <05 3E5:C58<2 C395 18 <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 524=8958< = 919 8=< 34453: A5>=:5 <05 :1A7836 18241<5=>25:E1;5=>8=<1;5389058;5G32463;595I+43:<5 8<05A3212=><054653918D2=><0543:<152<05 631C2:1A7836>:3C59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <055E1958;505;631C38<218=:95:<=4:=E5<05;325 5I3C1859 ;631C38< = G1>5 => <05 95;53259 32 + 389 =<05: <G= G1<852252 32 + 389 + 389 D=< 5I01A1<599=;7C58<283C56BI <=I 8A5036> =>:524=8958<==85G1<8522G325I3C185932+ 05 631C2 :1A7836 AB <05 1C47D859 F79DC58< 0569<03<<053;;1958<<==H463;5=83;;=78<=>:320 38985D61D58<9:1E18D=><05=>>58918DE501;65AB1<29:1E5: 32 3 :5276< => G01;0<0595;53259272<3185918F7:152 389 - 5 - 27;;7CA59<=<0518F7:15205:1A7836>7:<05:0569<03< <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 ;=C45823<1=8 => 2,'''' +36=8DG1<018<5:52<3<<05:3<5=>&J43 38991:5;<59:524=8958<=<=954=21<<05;=C45823<1=8 36=8DG1<018<5:52<!518D3DD:15E59<012344536032A558 >1659 & 05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 ;631C38<2 032 :31259<05>=66=G18D;=8<58<1=82 3* #1:2<6B <05 ;631C38<2 ;631C <03< <05 95;53259 G323D593A=7<&B53:23<<05<1C5=><053;;1958<389 G32 53:818D 2 '''' + 45: C=8<0 AB 9=18D 2<3D5 95;=:3<1=8A72185225G323818;=C5<3I3225225505 95;532599159=8'''&0538873618;=C5>=:<05 B53:' +&G322%' +05:1A7836182<539=> ;=82195:18D <05 388736 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 032 ;=82195:59 <05 3E5:3D5 18;=C5 => 4:5E1=72 >1E5 322522C58<B53:2 A* 5;=896B 32 45: <05 F79DC58< => <05 =8@A65 74:5C5=7:<18<05;325=> - 6 - !"# 53;0 => <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 >=: ;=C45823<1=8 => 2,'''' + 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => 6=E5 389 3>>5;<1=8 389 ;=82=:<17C@ ;* 32<6B;=82195:18D<053D53893E=;3<1=8=><05 95;53259 <05 =E5:366 ;=C45823<1=8 3G3:959 AB <05 :1A783612=8<056=G5:219558;5054:3B2>=:366=G18D <05344536 8<05=<05:0389<05653:859;=78256>=:<05 827:38;5 =C438B 032 :31259 <05 >=66=G18D ;=78<5:+ ;=8<58<1=82 3* #1:2<6B <05 1E121=8 !58;0 => <012 =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => $ %& $ '&'(( & 18 # =' ' 9124=259 => =8 ''',0569<03<G016532252218D<0538873618;=C5=> <0595;532593E5:3D5=><0:55B53:218;=C595;63:59032 <=A5;=82195:5905:5>=:5<05:1A7836032;=82195:59 <05 3E5:3D5 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 =8 <05 A3212 => 18;=C5 <3I :5<7:82 389 32252259 <05 ;=C45823<1=8 - 7 - 3C=78< 05:5>=:5 05 ;=8<58959 <03< ;=82195:18D <05 3D5 389 3E=;3<1=8 => <05 95;53259 <05 =E5:366 ;=C45823<1=83G3:959AB<05:1A783612F72<3894:=45: 3899=528=<:5K71:518<5:>5:58;5 % 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259<05F79DC58<3893G3:9=><05:1A7836 < 12 8=< 18 91247<5 <03< 95;53259 7816 3E55: 9159 18 <05 :=39 <:3>>1; 3;;1958< =;;7::59 =8 '''& 975<=:32038985D61D58<9:1E18D=><05=>>58918DE501;65 AB1<29:1E5:05;631C38<2;631C<03<95;53259G323D59 3A=7< & B53:2 389 G32 53:818D 2 '''' + 45: C=8<0 5G3218;=C5<3I32252255245:<05F79DC58<=><05 1E121=8!58;0=><012=7:<18<05;325=>$ %& )274:3* 18 # =' ' <05 3E5:3D5 18;=C5 >=: 4:5E1=72<0:55322522C58<B53:2032<=A5;=82195:592 45: <05 9=;7C58<2 4:=97;59 AB <05 ;631C38<2 <05 <=<36 388736 18;=C5 >=: <05 322522C58< B53: '+, G32 2 % +- >=: <05 322522C58< B53: ',+ <05 <=<36 388736 18;=C5 G32 2&&% + 389 >=: <05 - 8 - 322522C58< B53: ' +& <05 <=<36 388736 18;=C5 G32 2%' + 05 3E5:3D5 18;=C5 >=: <05 22522C58< 53:2 '+, ',+ 389 ' +& ;=C52 <= 2&,% +0595;5325903243192,'' +<=G3:92 18;=C5 <3I 05:5>=:5 <05 85< 18;=C5 3><5: <3I 12 2 ,% +45:3887C58;5G5;=82195:2,,& + 45:C=8<03218;=C5=><0595;53259 ' =<053>=:5231918;=C5,'J032<=A539959 =83;;=78<=>>7<7:54:=245;<218E15G=><0563G63199=G8 AB <05 =82<1<7<1=8 !58;0 => <05 74:5C5 =7:< 18 ' ) %$&'*& !$++!"072<05C=8<06B18;=C5;=C52<= 2'', + 18;5<05:53:595458958<21<12344:=4:13<5 <= 9597;< ,<0 => <05 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 <=G3:92 45:2=8365I458252389:5C31818D3C=78<032<=A5<3H58 32012;=8<:1A7<1=8<=<05>3C16B0595;53259G323D59 3A=7<&B53:23<<05<1C5=><053;;1958<389C76<14615: 34461;3A65<=0123D5D:=7412? @072<05;631C38<23:5 - 9 - 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8 => 2,' ,' + )2'',II I ,* =8 3;;=78< => ?6=22 => 95458958;B@ 8 3991<1=8 <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8=>2 ''' +=83;;=78<=>?6=22=>52<3<5@ 389 ;=C45823<1=8 => 2 ''' + =8 3;;=78< => ?>785:36 5I458252@ 8 E15G => <05 63G 6319 9=G8 AB <05 74:5C5 =7:<18<05;325=>, -)274:3* ;631C38< = G1>5 => <05 95;53259 12 58<1<659 >=: ;=C45823<1=8 => 2,'''' + 7895: <05 0539 => /6=22 => 24=7236;=82=:<17C/;631C38<=2389;0169:58=><05 95;53259 3:5 58<1<659 >=: ;=C45823<1=8 => 2,'''' + 53;0 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => 43:58<36 ;=82=:<17C@ 389 :524=8958<=05:518C=<05:=><0595;532591258<1<659 >=:;=C45823<1=8=>2,'''' +7895:<050539=>?6=22=> >16136;=82=:<17C@ , 072<05;631C38<23:558<1<659<=<05>=66=G18D ;=C45823<1=8 - 10 - ()*+,-./+ 0+1*21/*2*+. *-1, (0+./+ %,& =22=>95458958;B ,' ,' + #785:365I458252 ''' + =22=>52<3<5 ''' + =22=>24=7236 ;=82=:<17C ,'''' + =22=> 3:58<36 ;=82=:<17C %'''' + =22=>#16136 ;=82=:<17C ,'''' + .-3 4 45 46 8<05:5276<<05>=66=G18D=:95:12432259 3* 0534453612-337*1/+)-2. A* 05 F79DC58< => <05 631C2 :1A7836 12C=91>159 ;* 05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 <=<36 ;=C45823<1=8 => ,4 45 6 32 3D3182< 2,'''' +3G3:959AB<05:1A7836 - 11 - 9* 05827:38;5=C438B1291:5;<59<= 954=21< <05 ;=C45823<1=8 3C=78< 36=8D G1<0 18<5:52< 3< &J 43 >:=C <05 93<5 => >1618D => <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 <166 <05 93<5 => :5361L3<1=8 G1<018 3 45:1=9 => 21I G55H2 >:=C <05 93<5 => :5;514< => ;=4B=><012F79DC58< 5* 05 344=:<1=8C58< 954=21< 389 :565325 => 3C=78< 20366 A5 C395 18 <5:C2 => <05 3G3:9=><05:1A7836 16 %!& # 16 %#$& # 12<=6= !