Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66678 (KAR)
SIDDRAMAYYA v. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY AND ORS
WP/201423/2024 · 2025-10-15
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66678 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66678 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"!#
$ %&"%"%
'""(
! " #
! $
%
&&&$
%
$
'
%
$&
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
%%
%%
$&
! ")% $ '*
% ( #
% + %
% #
%
& & &' ",
#
& &$ &('
",# -#
% .#
/
%
%
%
%
- 3 -
0 )
! " 0 )
#
12324545672859-2:6824159
6;84-257<=<<852>2?-@ 412 27?6892A274 ?=42? & & &' =9 328 772B;82 599;2?-@829367?2746 =9 C2DD =9 412 .6AA;75.=4567 ?=42? & &$ &( 386?;.2? =4 772B;82 599;2? -@ 829367?274 6 ' "23=84A274 6: ?;.=4567# ?2.D5757< 46 .6795?28 159 823829274=4567 :68 =336574A274 67 .6A3=99567=42<86;7? 12 .=92 6: 412 3245456728 59 41=4 159 :=4128 85 =7.1=@=;8=75EC=9C68E57<=9F/86;32A3D6@22 57 829367?274 6 =5?2? 79454;4567 =7? 12 ?52? ?;857< 159928>5.267$ &+ && 1282;367C5:26:412?2.2=92? 2A3D6@229;-A5442?=33D5.=4567?=42?+ &' &$922E57< =336574A274:68412324545672867.6A3=99567=42<86;7?9 29367?274 6 ( :68C=8?2? 386369=D 46 829367?274 6 ' 67 $ $& & =D67< C541 =DD 82G;59542 ?6.;A2749
- 4 -
82.6AA27?57< =336574A274 6: 3245456728 46 412 3694 6:
F267/ 67 .6A3=99567=42 <86;7? 7 27?6892A274 >5?2 772B;82
.=A2 46 -2 599;2? -@ 412 829367?274 6 .5457< 767=>=5D=-5D54@ 6: F/ 86;3 36949 :68 767 .6795?28=45676:15982G;294
' 1282=:428 412 829367?274 6 96;<14 .D=85:5.=4567:86A829367?2746 '67$ & &$C1657 4;87 1=? 96;<14 :68 9;.1 57:68A=4567 :86A 829367?274 6 ( 67 $ &H &$ 12 829367?274 6 1=? .=DD2? :68 412 8296D;4567 :86A 412 829367?274 6 ' C16 57 4;87 :68C=8?2?412.63@6:4128296D;4567C15.11=?8296D>2? 46 =336574 412 3245456728 =9 F267/ 67 .6A3=99567=42 <86;7?57829367?2746 79454;42
( 293542 :68C=8?57< 9;.1 8296D;4567 46 .6795?28 41282G;2946:41232454567284641236946:F
/86;3=912 1=? 82G;582? G;=D5:5.=4567 76 =.4567 C=9 4=E27 -@ 412 829367?274 6 C16 57942=? 599;2? .6AA;75.=4567 =4 772B;82 825428=457< 412 .6742749 6: 2=8D528
- 5 -
.6AA;75.=4567 =4 772B;82
257< =<<852>2? -@ 412 9=A2412324545672859-2:6824159
6;84
2=872? .6;792D :68 412 3245456728 825428=457< 412<86;7?9;8<2?57412A2A68=7?;A6:324545679;-A549 41=4412;D2?62976438615-54412829367?274946.6795?28 412 82G;294 6: 412 3245456728 :68 =7@ 9;54=-D2 3694 5: 412 82G;2942? 3694 C=9 764 =>=5D=-D2 2 9;-A549 41=4 412 829367?274 6 C5416;4 .6795?2857< 4159 =932.4 6: 412 A=4428 1=9 ;75D=428=DD@ =7? =8-548=85D@ 599;2? 412 27?6892A274 .67948=5757< 412 3245456728 46 =3386=.1 4159 6;84
2=872? .6;792D =332=857< :68 412 829367?274 69 (=7?9;-A54941=4412@1=>2=D82=?@:68C=8?2?412 386369=D =D67< C541 8296D;4567 46 412 829367?274 6 ' 46 .6795?28 412 82G;294 6: 412 3245456728 :68 =336574A274 46 41236946:F267/=7?412@1=>2?59.1=8<2?412583=846: 412?;4@;367412=33D5.=456796:5D2?-@4123245456728
- 6 -
+ 2=872? ??54567=D 6>287A274 ?>6.=42 =332=857< :68 412 829367?274 69 $ 46 ' 57 4;87 9;-A549 41=4 412 3245456728 C=9 764 G;=D5:52?
:68 412 6: F/ 86;3 3694 =9 67 412 ?=42 C127 412 =33D5.=4567 922E57< .6A3=99567=42 =336574A274 C=9 A=?2 1282:682 412 =33D5.=4567.6;D?764-2.6795?282? 12 94=7? 4=E27 -@ 829367?274 6 59 ;7427=-D2 12 3;83692 6: <8=7457< .6A3=99567=42 =336574A274 59 46 452 6>28 412 :57=7.5=D ?5948299 6: 412 A2A-289 6: 412 -282=>2? :=A5D@ 386>5?2? 412@ A224 412 82G;582A274.6742A3D=42?;7?28D=C7=A2D@;D26:412 =87=4=E=
5>5D 28>5.29 "336574A274 67
6A3=99567=42 86;7?9# ;D29 $HH ":68 91684 F
;D29 $HH/# 5416;4 D66E57< 5746 4159 =932.4 6: 412 A=4428 412 829367?274 6 .6;D? 764 1=>2 82I2.42? 412 =33D5.=4567 A282D@ 67 412 3;836842? <86;7? 41=4 3245456728 764 A22457<41282G;582?G;=D5:5.=45672D5<5-D2.854285=
- 7 -
H >27 64128C592 ;D2 6: 412
;D29 $HH ?629 764 .6742A3D=42 412 ?2327?274 6: 412 ?2.2=92? 2A3D6@22 922E57< .6A3=99567=42 =336574A274 46 1=>2 82G;582? G;=D5:5.=4567 :68 412 3694 41=4 C=9 12D? -@ 412 ?2.2=92? DD41=454C=88=749.6795?28=45676:41282G;294 6:412=33D5.=74;7?28412.6A3=99567=42?6A=5746=7@6:
412 9;54=-D2 36949 159 =932.4 6: 412 A=4428 764 1=>57< -227 ?2=D4 C541 412 5A3;<72? 27?6892A274 =7? .6AA;75.=4567 =4 772B;82
=7? 599;2? -@ 412 829367?274 6 =82 ;79;94=57=-D2 =7? D5=-D2 46 -2 G;=912? $& ..68?57<D@412:6DD6C57<
"5# 12C8543245456759=DD6C2?573=84
"55# 12 27?6892A274 >5?2 772B;82
=7? .6AA;75.=4567 >5?2 772B;82 =82 1282-@G;=912? "555# 12 829367?274 6 59 ?582.42? 46 82 .6795?28 412 82G;294 =33D5.=4567 6: 412
- 8 -
3245456728 46 =7@ 9;54=-D2 3694 =:428 9=459:@57<C54182<=8?4615927454D2A274:68 =336574A274 67 .6A3=99567=42 <86;7? 57 =..68?=7.2C541D=C
"5># 8?28 57 4159 82<=8? -2 3=992? =7? .6AA;75.=42? 46 412 3245456728 C54157 =7 6;428D5A54 6:41822 A67419 :86A 412 ?=42 6:82.25346:.2845:52?.63@6:415968?28
")* '%"%( &! $ (