Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66671 (KAR)
PRATIBHA AND ANR v. AJAY
RPFC/200007/2024 · 2025-09-17
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66671 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66671 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#$!$ $
! %
!"
#
" # $#
# ##
##
% &
#
$
#
%
# '! #
(# #
# )"
&
## $ ##
%
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ( #
# $*%
(
(
# # # # ###
( """+ # ( ## # # #
(
##
* " '""'# #
(#,
(
#
# (
#
##
#-
# ##
./0 12/0/34 15/5/34 /0 6/718 9: ;15/5/341<0 =/61 >48 8>?@.51< 36 5.1 <10;348145 A.>7714@/4@ 434 >=><8 36 B>/4514>4A1 53 ;15/5/341< #3 >48 >=><8 36 73=1< B>/4514>4A1 53 ;15/5/341< #3 9: 5.1 88/5/34>7 ?8@1 (>B/7: 3?<5 /C>:>;?<> /4 <7/0A#3* " 8>518 '""'
1><8 71><418 A3?4017 63< ;15/5/341<0 >48 71><418 A3?401763<5.1<10;348145
' 15/5/341< #3 /0 =/61 >48 ;15/5/341< #3 /0 8>?@.51<365.1<10;34814515/5/341<0.>216/71;15/5/34?481< 1A5/3436<9163<16>B/7:3?<5011D/4@B>/4514>4A1 36 0"""+ 63< ;15/5/341< #3 >48 0""""+ 63< ;15/5/341< #3 5 /0 5.1 A>01 36 ;15/5/341<0 5.>5 5.1
- 3 -
<10;348145 >5 /405/@>5/34 36 ./0 6>B/7: B1B91<0 05><518 53 53<5?<1.1<>4863<A/4@.1<539</4@83=<:360)7>D.06<3B .1< ;><1450 .14 ;15/5/341< #3 1E;<10010 .1< /4>9/7/5: 53 B115 3?5 ./0 81B>48 .1 05><518 53<5?</4@ .1< B145>77: >48 ;.:0/A>77:>488101<518.1<>48.1<8>?@.51<8?</4@5.1B345. 36><A.+".1:A345148185.>55.1<10;348145/0=3<D/4@ >0>0./1</45>51 >4D3648/>>48.1@155/4@5.10>7><:36 0""""+;1<B345. * .1 <10;348145 /4 ./0 05>51B145 36 39C1A5/340 .>0 814/18>77>771@>5/340B>81>@>/405 ./B.1<10;348145.>0 >8B/5518 <17>5/340./;
1 A34514818 5.>5 >651< 5.1 9/<5. 36 ;15/5/341< #3 ;15/5/341< #3 >5 /405/@>5/34 36 .1< 9<35.1<0 05><518 53 F?><<17 =/5. ./B >48 ./0 6>B/7: B1B91<0 63< 0/77:
<1>0340 .1 <10;348145 A34514818 5.>5 .1 /0 .>2/4@ B35.1< >@18 >93?5 "" :1><0 >48 .1 .>0 53 5>D1 A><1 36 .1< 1 A345148185.>5>651<5.181>5.36./06>5.1<.1@35C39>55>51 >4D 36 48/> 34 A3B;>00/34>51 @<3?48 1 A34514818 5.>5 ;15/5/341< #3 /0 83/4@ 5>/73</4@ =3<D >48 >703 .>2/4@ A3B;?51< D43=718@1 >48 @155/4@ /4A3B1 36 0 """+ 53 0""""+;1<B345. 1A345148185.>5.1.>06/718;15/5/34 ?481<1A5/3436 /48?><</>@1A5>@>/405;15/5/341<.1
- 4 -
6>B/7: 3?<5 <1A3<818 12/814A1 36 ;15/5/341<0 >48 <10;348145 >485.1<1>651<;>00185.1/B;?@4183<81<36B>/4514>4A153 ;15/5/341< #3 /4 0?B 36 0)"""+ >48 <1C1A5/4@ A7>/B 36 ;15/5/341<#363<B>/4514>4A1
@@</1218 9: 5.1 0>/8 3<81< 36 5.1 (>B/7: 3?<5 ;15/5/341<0><19163<15./03?<5
! 1><418A3?401763<;15/5/341<0=3?78A3451485.>5 ;15/5/341<#3/07165.1<B>5</B34/>7.3?018?153.><>00B145 9:5.1<10;348145.1/0435.>2/4@>4:/4A3B1(>B/7:3?<5 .>0 1<<18 /4 <1C1A5/4@ 5.1 A7>/B 36 B>/4514>4A1 36 ;15/5/341< #3 347: 34 5.1 @<3?48 5.>5 0.1 /40/0518 5.1 <10;348145 53 B>D101;><>51.3?0153<10/8101;><>517:6<3B./0B35.1<>48 0.1.>07165B>5</B34/>7.3?01237?45></7:=/5.3?5>4:<1>034
1 A34514818 5.>5 5.1 <10;348145 /0 @155/4@ 0>7><: 36 0!)"""+>0;1<./0;>:07/;E'340/81</4@5.10>B1 B>/4514>4A1/40?B360)"""+;1<B345./03473=1<0/81 /5.
5.101 .1 ;<>:18 53 B38/6:/4@ 5.1 3<81< ;>0018 9: 5.1 (>B/7:3?<59:>=><8/4@B>/4514>4A153;15/5/341<#3 >48 >=><8 B>/4514>4A1 ./@.1< 5.>4 >=><818 9: 6>B/7: 3?<5 53 ;15/5/341<#3
- 5 -
) 1><418A3?401763<5.1<10;348145=3?78A345148 5.>5 12/814A1 36 /48/A>51 5.>5 0.1 /0 /40/05/4@ 5.1 <10;34814553B>D101;><>51.3?0153<10/8101;><>517:6<3B ./0B35.1<=/5.;15/5/341<0>480.1.>07165B>5</B34/>7.3?01 237?45></7: =/5.3?5 >4: <1>034 1 0?9B/50 5.>5 A340/81</4@ 5.10>/8>0;1A55.16>B/7:3?<5.>0</@.57:<1C1A5185.1A7>/B 36;15/5/341<#3 16?<5.1<0?9B/505.>5A340/81</4@5.1>@1 36 ;15/5/341< #3 >48 0>7><: 36 <10;348145 #3 5.1 6>B/7:
3?<5 .>0 </@.57: >=><818 B>/4514>4A1 36 0)"""+ 53 ;15/5/341<#3/5.5.101.1;<>:0538/0B/005.1;15/5/34
>2/4@ .1><8 71><418 A3?40170 5./0 3?<5 .>0 ;1<?018/B;?@4183<81<>485</>73?<5<1A3<80
17>5/340./; 915=114 ;><5/10 /0 435 /4 8/0;?51 15/5/341<#3/0=/61>48;15/5/341<#3/08>?@.51<365.1 <10;3481455/0>703435/48/0;?515.>5<10;348145/0=3<D/4@ >0A>0./1</45>51 >4D3648/>
" 4 <1>8/4@ A./16 1E>B/4>5/34 36 >48 145/<1 A<300 1E>B/4>5/34 /5 /0 A71>< 5.>5 ;15/5/341< #3 .>0 7165 .1< B>5</B34/>7.3?01>00.1=>0.><>00189:.1<B35.1</47>= >48 81B>48/4@ A>0. >48 @378 3<4>B1450 >48 >703 0.1 .>0 9114.><>00189:5.1<10;348145>55.1/405/@>5/3436./06>B/7:
- 6 -
B1B91<0.1(>B/7:3?<5A340/81</4@03B1;3<5/3436A<300 1E>B/4>5/3436.>01<<18/4.378/4@5.>5;15/5/341<#3 237?45></7: 7165 B>5</B34/>7 .3?01 =/5.3?5 >4: <1>034 340/81</4@145/<112/814A136/5/0A71><5.>5.>0 7165 .1< B>5</B34/>7 .3?01 8?1 53 .><>00B145 B>81 9: 5.1 <10;348145.1<163<1;15/5/341<#3/0145/571863<>=><836 B>/4514>4A1
E' /0 0>7><: 07/; 36 <10;348145 #3 63< 5.1 B345.36>4?><:"">48./0@<3000>7><:/00""*"+>48 ./04150>7><:/00)"+>651<A3B;?703<:818?A5/340/1 (>48>70373>4/405>77B1450>48;<1B/?B03B;?703<:
818?A5/340 ( >48 ;<36100/34>7 5>E A3B10 53 0!!""+ 340/81</4@5.10>/86>A55.1<10;348145/0@155/4@4150>7><: 360*'*""+
15/5/341<#3=>0>@18"*:1><0>0345.18>5136 ;15/5/34 340/81</4@ 5.1 0>/8 6>A5 >=><8 36 B>/4514>4A1 /4 0?B360)"""+53;15/5/341<#3/0C?05>48;<3;1<36>< ;15/5/341<#3/0A34A1<418>00.1/0=/6136A>0./1<365>51 >4D 36 48/> >48 53 71>8 7/61 >0 0?A. 0.1 /0 145/571 53 B>/4514>4A1/40?B360""""+;1<B345. - 7 -
' 42/1=365.1>93215.163773=/4@
/% .112/0/3415/5/34/0
//% .1/B;?@4183<81<;>00189:5.1(>B/7:3?<5<1C1A5/4@ 5.1 A7>/B 36 ;15/5/341< #3 >=><8/4@ 36 B>/4514>4A1 /0 015>0/81 ///% 15/5/341<#3/0145/5718B>/4514>4A1360""""+;1< B345.6<3B5.18>5136;15/5/34 /2% .1>=><836B>/4514>4A1/4<10;1A536;15/5/341<#3/4 0?B360)"""+/0<1B>/418?4>751<18
&' ($!$) #
/05#37#3*