Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66662 (KAR)

THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY v. SUNIL KUMAR AGRAWAL

WA/200155/2025 · 2025-09-01

H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "!# "!#! $%& !" " !" !" !" # $%&'( Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' & ' " )* & ) +* # $ % ( ' " , % " ' --!&$ &( % + % ' ) ) .% .% #! $) .% ( /01230456675801 9087:;/5887<=0<=4/7>3:7365117:?@ 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7 >9 4/01 >A34 :547: " 0< ' <>--!&/7>673540B76>340><>90C6A=<7:>3:730151 9>88>21) - 3 - ! " # $" # %# #" # " # $ & # # ' " " " " $ ( # ) * + #, $ ', % - " ' . " / + # $ # " ## %# # # # 0 753<7: ::040><58 :B>;547 7<73585667530<= 9>3 4/7 5667885<4 2>A8: B7/7C7<48@ ;><47<: 4/54 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7/51;>CC0447:5<733>30<588>20<=4/72304674040><7 2>A8: B7/7C7<48@ ;><47<: 0< /01 53=AC7<4 4/54 4/7 >3:73 >9 4/7 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7 01 0887=58 53?04353@ 5<: 204/>A4 56680;540>< >9 DA:0;0>A1 C0<: 7 2>A8: 9A34/73 ;><47<: 4/54 ?79>37 9080<= 4/7 56680;540>< A<:73 7;40>< $( >9 4/7 53<545E5 5<: 7B7<A7 ;4 ," 4> 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 0:53 0< 4/7 @753 ,! !" 4/7 85<: 251 145<:0<=515=>B73<C7<485<: >34/79031440C74/77<43071 145347:594734/7@753,!5<:<>475380735380737<430712737 - 4 - B73@;87534/5451/0?50A<4501<>45<5C7>965340;A85385:@ >3 5447:53 ?A4 04 01 5 45<E 2/0;/ 01 ;5887: 0< 5<<5:5 51 5 A<45 4 01 ;><47<:7: 4/54 A?/51/ /51 =0B7< 56680;540>< 14@80<= /0C1789 51 5 1A;;711>3 >9 >30=0<58 85:@ 51/0?50 A<45 5<:1>A=/49>3;>337;40><0<4/70=/4>97;>3:1$ 1(/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 0:53 >< 4/7 37B010>< A<:73 7;40>< $(;>337;47:4/77<43071<95;44/01015=>B73<C7<485<: 51 9>A<: 93>C 4/7B0885=7 C56>9 4/7@753 ,7B7< 51 673 4/7 376>34 >9 4/7 110145<4 037;4>3 >9 85<: 37;>3:1 2/0;/ 01 5;;>C65<07: ?@ 1E74;/ C56 B0885=7 C56 5<: >4/73 3787B5<4 :>;AC7<41 4 01 9A34/73 ;><47<:7: 4/54 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73/51<>6>2734>CA45474/7=>B73<C7<485<:0< 4/7 <5C7 >9 630B547 6731>< 7 581> 1A?C041 4/54 4/7 =>B73<C7<485<::>71<.48>170410:7<404@5<:>2<731/06A<8711 0401=35<47:704/73?@430?A<58>3?@7B7<A7A4/>304@5<:0< 4/7;517></5<:4/73701<>1A;/=35<4>9=>B73<C7<485<: /7 3716><:7<4 ?@ 935A:A87<48@ C013763717<40<= 4/7 51/0?50 A<45 51 /01 5<;714>3 =>4 4/7 85<: CA4547: 0< /01 <5C7 5<: 15C7 :>71<.4 C5E7 5 =>B73<C7<4 85<: 51 5 5445 85<: >9 630B5476731>< - 5 - 753<7: ::040><58 :B>;547 7<7358 581> ;><47<:7:4/544/737B7<A737;>3:1;87538@:01;8>1714/5404015 FG /535? 85<: A<:73 7;40>< - >9 53<545E5 5<: 7B7<A7 ;4,-5886A?80;3>5:11437741?30:=7174;?78><=4>4/7 =>B73<C7<4 /7 ;>A<178 581> B7/7C7<48@;><47<:7: 4/54 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 0:53 0< 4/7 @753 ,! CA4540<= 4/7 =>B73<C7<485<:515630B54785<:01<>4;>337;45<:4/715C7 251 <>4 45E7< <>47 >9 ?@ 4/7 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7 2/087 65110<= 1A;/ 5< >3:73 7<;7 04 37HA0371 0<4739737<;7 >9 4/01 >A34 " /7 ;>A<178 581> B7/7C7<48@ ;><47<: 4/54 7B7< B0885=7C56;87538@:01;8>1714/540401585E75<:581>?3>A=/44> <>40;7 >9 4/01 >A34 4/54 51 673 7;40>< ! >9 B0:7<;7 ;4 4/7370156371AC640><4/544/785<:0<HA7140><01585E75<: :>;AC7<41 63>:A;7: 581> ;87538@ :01;8>171 4/54 4/7 15C7 01 5 85E7 1 " 8753<7: ;>A<178 5667530<= 9>3 4/7 3716><:7<4;><47<:7:4/544/7>3:7325165117:?@4/776A4@ >CC0110><738><=?5;E5<:581>4/70B010><58>CC0110><73 65117: 5< >3:73 ;><903C0<= 4/7 >3:73 5<: 76A4@ - 6 - >CC0110><73 5<: ?>4/ 4/7 >3:731 /5B7 <>4?77< ;/5887<=7: /7 ;>A<178 581> 1A?C041 4/54 7B7< 4/7 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7 581>4>>E<>47>94/7150:95;40<4>;><10:73540><2/08765110<= 4/7>3:738753<7:0<=87%A:=70<6535=356/<>>94/7>3:73 /78:4/540<1>953514/70C6A=<7:>3:733797330<=4>5/5<0>9 4/7@753,-! -,9>34/76A36>17>9/>8:0<=4/544/7372515 85E70<4/71A?D7;485<:01;><;73<7:4/737B010><674040><9087: ?@4/7A?/51/B7<:>3>94/7674040><731/5B0<=?77<588>27: ?@ 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 5<: ;><903C7: ?@ 4/7 0B010><58 >CC0110><731A?17HA7<48@><,!6A31A5<44>2/0;/ 37B7<A7 37;>3:1& 14>>: 0< /01 <5C7 <> 37805<;7 ;5< ?7 685;7: A6>< 4/7 7538073 5/5<01 9>3 4/7 @753 ,-! -, ?@ 4/7 3716><:7<41 /7;>A<178581>?3>A=/44><>40;7>94/01>A344/7 >?173B540><C5:70<6535=356/<>12/7370<4/01>A34/78: 4/54 ;>8AC< <>$( 1/>21 4/7 <5C7 >9 4/7 =>B73<C7<4 0< 378540>< 4> 4/7 1A?D7;4 85<:1 537 ;><;73<7: 581> ;5<<>4 ?7 5;;7647:7167;0588@2/7<4/7150:7<430712737C5:76A31A5<4 4> 4/7 >3:73 >9 4/7 110145<4 >CC0110><73 0< 63>;77:0<=1 A<:73 7;40>< -, 5<: -, >9 4/7 53<545E5 85<: 79>3C1 - 7 - ;4 5<: >3:73 :547: !, 65117: ?@ /0C 2/0;/ 251 1A?17HA7<48@ HA51/7: ?@ 4/01 >A34 0< ' <>,& :547: ! 5<: ;><17HA7<48@ 7B7< 4/01 ;><47<40>< A3=7:?@4/73716><:7<41;5<<>4?75;;7647: - 753<7:0<=87%A:=72/08765110<=4/7>3:73:7584 204/011A7></5<:0<:745080<6535=356/<>15<:/7 ;>A<178 ?3>A=/4 4> <>40;7 >9 4/01 >A34 4/54 2/7< 4/7 63>;77:0<=1 01 0<040547: A<:73 7;40>< -, 5<: -, >9 4/7 53<545E585<:79>3C1;4437540<=4/715C7510<5=30;A84A37 85<:<>215C7;5<<>4?7:016A47: ! /7;>A<178581>B7/7C7<48@;><47<:4/542/7<4/7 >3:7325165117:8><=?5;E5<:<>2;5<<>4;><47<:4/5404015 =>B73<C7<4 85E7 5<: 2/7< 4/7 >3:73 251<>4 ;/5887<=7: 5<: <>2 ;5<<>4 378@ A6>< 4/7 :>;AC7<41 2/0;/ 537 630>3 4> 4/7 >3:73 >9 76A4@ >CC0110><73 5<: 4/>17 :>;AC7<41 2088 <>4 ;>C714>4/750:>94/74547 , < 3768@ 4> 4/01 53=AC7<4 8753<7: ;>A<178 5667530<=9>34/74547581>?3>A=/44><>40;7>94/01>A340< 6535=356/ <>1, 5<: 2/7370< >?173B540>< 01 C5:7 204/ 37=53:4>378@A6><><750851//5<:352/>5887=7:C5<5=73 - 8 - >94/7674040><730<4/75?17<;7>95<@C54730584>1/>24/54 4/7 150: 50851/ /5<:35 251 4/7 C5<5=73 >9 4/7 674040><73 204/37=53:4>4/7>?D7;40><12/0;/0<:0;54714/543716><:7<4 >/51685;7:37805<;7A6><5<5887=7:1A3B7@5<:581>4/7 B73@ ;><47<40>< 4/54 4/7 :>;AC7<41 537 6376537: 5?>A4 @7531 ?5;E 5<: ;><17HA7<48@ 0< 4/7 80=/4 >9 59>37150: 0<473B7<0<= 7B7<41 4/7 15C7 /51 ?77< ;/5<=7: 5<: 4/01 >?173B540><581>;87538@0<:0;54714/544/763>6734@?78><=14> 4/74547 5B0<=/753:4/78753<7:;>A<1785667530<=9>34/7 5667885<4512788518753<7:;>A<1785667530<=9>33716><:7<4 ;><10:730<=4/7C5473058><37;>3:/76>0<44/542>A8:53017 9>3;><10:73540><?79>374/7>A34 2 * * 3 $ # " 40 2 4 5B0<=/753:4/78753<7:::040><58:B>;5477<735851 2788518753<7:;>A<1785667530<=9>34/73716><:7<4673A17: 4/77<4037C54730585B5085?87><37;>3: - 9 - 753<7: ::040><58 :B>;547 7<7358 <>4 :016A471 4/7 95;4 4/54 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 65117: 5< >3:73 5<: 581>0B010><58>CC0110><737B7<;><903C7:4/7>3:7365117: ?@4/776A4@>CC0110><73/01>A34581>/5B0<=;><10:737: 4/7 15C7 2/7< 4/7 >3:73 >9 76A4@ >CC0110><73 5<: 0B010><58 >CC0110><73 2737 <>4 ;/5887<=7: 5<: 4/01 >A34 /5B0<= /753: 4/7 C54473 >< ! ! !5<:!5<:4>:5@581>0<:745084>>E<>47 >94/795;44/544/7@/5B7<>4;/5887<=7:?>4/>3:731 5B0<= ;><10:737: 4/7 5167;41 >9 <>< ;/5887<=0<= 4/7 >3:73 65117: ?@ 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 5<: 581> 4/7 0B010><58 >CC0110><73 1> 581> >?173B540>< C5:7 ?@ 4/7 0B010><58>CC0110><730<4/7>3:730417894/54C5=<5<0C>A18@ 4/7 >2<731 >9 4/7 63>6734@ 2737 =0B0<= 5< >66>34A<04@ 4> 4/7 >4/73 B0885=731 4> 5B508 4/7 25473 1>A3;71 5<: 581> 2/7< 4/7 150: >?173B540>< 01 C5:7 5<: ;><17HA7<4 A6>< 204/ 4/7 3767547:>?173B540><1C5:7?@4/01>A34><5884/7:54714/54 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 >3:73 5<: 0B010><58 >CC0110><73 >3:73 2737 <>4 ;/5887<=7: 5<: 4547 581> <>4 C5:7 5<@ 7<:75B>A34>;/5887<=74/7150:>3:73A<:734/730?A<585<: - 10 - 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7 5B0<= ;><10:737: 4/7 =3>A<:1 2/0;/ /5B7?77<A3=7:0<6535=356/<>1,5<:5<:65340;A8538@ 45E7< <>47 >9 0< 6535=356/ <>1 5<: 5< >?173B540>< 01 C5:7204/37=53:4>;/5<=7>9<5C70<4/7>3:73>94/776A4@ >CC0110><73 B0:7 >3:73 :547: ,,,!" 5<: 581> 4/7 0B010><58 >CC0110><73 0< 6535=356/ <> C5:7 ;8753 4/54 59473 6A3;/510<= 4/7 1A?D7;4 85<: 93>C 01/25<54/ B0:7 37=014737: 1587 :77: :547: !,!! 4/7 6A3;/5173 07 A?/51/4/7B7<:>3>94/7674040><731>A=/49>337;4090;540><>9 4/77<43071?@9080<=537B010><674040><:A30<=,! 4/7 6A3;/5173 07 A?/51/4/7B7<:>3>94/7674040><731>A=/49>337;4090;540><>9 4/77<43071?@9080<=537B010><674040><:A30<=,! ,!"?79>37 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 2/> >?450<7: 5 376>34 93>C 4/7 5/5108:535<:588>27:4/737B010><674040><>94/7150:A?/51/ B0:7 >3:73 :547: ,,,!" 5<: :78747: 4/7 7<43071 0< 4/7 37B7<A7 37;>3:1& 1 1/>20<= 4/7 <5C7 >9 4/7 >B73<C7<4&45<E5<:0<6A31A5<;7>94/715C74/75/5108:53 ;/5<=7:4/737;>3:15<:7<4737:4/7<5C7>94/7674040><73G1 B7<:>3A?/51/0<378540><4>4/71A?D7;485<:/7150:95;4 25145E7<<>47>95<:4/7B73@;><47<40><>94/745470<4/7 2304 674040>< 581> 4/7 95;4 4/54 7538073 674040><73 /5: 5663>5;/7: 4/01 >A34 0< ' >",& 177E0<= :037;40>< 4> 4/7 3716><:7<41 4> ;><:A;4 6/>:0 2>3E 5<: 4/7 - 11 - 15C7 251 588>27: ?@ 4/01 >A34 B0:7 >3:73 :547: ?@685;0<=37805<;7A6><4/7DA:=C7<4>94/7>A340<4/7;517 >9 *( 5( * # 6 % 4/7 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7 581> 7I435;47: 4/7 >3:73 65117:?@4/01>A340<6535=356/<>-5<:/5B0<=;><10:737: 4/7C54730585B5085?87><37;>3:=0B7<4/73751><0<6535=356/ <>1512788515<:7B7<45E7<<>47>94/795;44/542/7< 4/7 ;><47<40>< >9 4/7 3716><:7<41G ;>A<178 4/54 ;>8AC< <>$(1/>214/7<5C7>94/7=>B73<C7<40<378540><4>4/7 1A?D7;485<:1537;><;73<7:581>;5<<>4?75;;7647: 5B0<= 45E7< <>47 >9 4/7 150: 7<43071 2737 C5:7 6A31A5<44>4/7>3:73>94/7110145<4>CC0110><730:530< 63>;77:0<=1 A<:73 7;40>< -, 5<: -, >9 4/7 53<545E5 5<:79>3C1;45<:>3:73:547:!,65117:?@/0C 2/0;/ 251 1A?17HA7<48@ HA51/7: ?@ 4/01 >A34 0< ' >,& :547: ! 5<: 588 4/717 95;4>31 53745E7<<>47>95<:2/7<4/7753807363>;77:0<=125145E7< A6 ?79>37 4/7 76A4@ >CC0110><73 5<: 0B010><58 >CC0110><73 5<: 581> 7B7< 7;40>< -, 5<: -, >9 4/7 53<545E5 85<: 79>3C1 ;4 63>;77:0<=1 251 45E7< 685;7: - 12 - 2/7370< 581> 7B7< 4/7 85<: 01 437547: 51 5< 5=30;A84A358 85<: /7379>374/7B73@;><47<40><>94/7;>A<1785667530<=9>34/7 5667885<4 4/54 A<:73 7;40>< ! >9 B0:7<;7 ;4 4/737 01 5 6371AC640>< 4> 6371AC7 4/54 4/7 15C7 01 5 85E7 ;5<<>4 ?7 5;;7647: < B072 >9 4/7 :790<047 90<:0<=1 37;>3:7: ?@ 4/7 76A4@>CC0110><73512788514/70B010><58>CC0110><73 5<: 581> 4/7 :037;40>< =0B7< ?@ 4/7 8753<7: 0<=87 %A:=7 4> :78747 4/7 <5C7 >9 4/7 4547 5<: 7<473 4/7 <5C7 >9 4/7 3716><:7<4 /7370< 4/7 ;><47<40><1 >9 4/7 ;>A<178 9>3 4/7 5667885<4 ;5<<>4 ?7 5;;7647: 65340;A8538@ 2/7< 2304 >9 ;7340>3530 63>;77:0<=1 0< 4/7 5?17<;7 >9 5<@ ;/5887<=7 /51 ?77< C5:7 4> 4/7 >3:731 >9 76A4@ >CC0110><73 51 2788 51 0B010><58>CC0110><73 " 4 01 581> 0C6>345<4 4> <>47 4/54 04 01 5 174487: 6>1040>< >9 852 4/54 7B7< 5< 0887=58 >3:73 >3 5< >3:73 B>0: 37HA0371 5 9>3C58 17440<= 510:7 ?@ ;>C6747<4 5A4/>304@&>A34<4/763717<4;517><1A;/>3:73>917440<= 510:7 01 <>4 9>A<: /7379>37 2/7< 0< 5< ;7340>3530 63>;77:0<=1 4/7 B73@ ;><47<40>< >9 4/7 4547 07 8753<7: ::040><58 :B>;547 7<7358 4/54 4/7 >A34 ;5< 7B7< 0<B>E7 - 13 - 7;40>< ! >9 4/7 B0:7<;7 ;4 4> :352 5 630>3 6371AC640>< ;5<<>4 ?7 5;;7647: 7<;7 27 :> <>4 90<: 5<@ =3>A<: 4> 5;;7644/7;><47<40><>94/745475<:4/76>0<4015<12737:51 F 7=540B7G 51 4/7 7538073 >3:73 >9 76A4@ >CC0110><73 5<: ;><903C540>< >3:73 >9 0B010><58 >CC0110><73 537 <>4 ;/5887<=7: <B072>94/7:01;A110><1C5:75?>B72765114/7 9>88>20<=) $0( /7'3046675801 '% $ & # '% $!& # % 014 >)8 >) )