Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66655 (KAR)

LAXMAN AND ORS v. MAHENDRA GOUD K AND ANR

MFA.CROB/200039/2024 · 2025-11-26

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $ %&$ %&!&"! $$ '"( )* & + ) * !" # $ % ! # Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & " # ! & # & ! $ # '()(&*+ ( # # % # &,$) % '(*$$-( . $/ &. ! $/ ( % +& % % +*&$*$& -$* $*$ % - 3 - & + * !) # $ % !& & ) ! ( # ! $ # # # % ,( ,(-!( # &,$) % '(*$$-( $ - 4 - '()**$- $/ % ! $$ % +*&$*$& -$* $*$ % # # 0 0 & # 0 1$*!&*+ $*$& 23 42567 89 :;6 <3=>?<@6 1AB?<9 C;6>6?3 >133 8D6@:21< 1$***&- $*$! 234256789:;6@5?2A?<:3=<76>6@:21<+&14:;61:1> 6;2@563@:-))41>3;1>:E:;6@:F862<G?GG>26H6789 :;6D=7GA6<:?<7?C?>77?:67+*&$*$&B?336789:;6 - 5 - 6<21> 2H25 =7G6 ?<7 ;2<@;152 41> 3;1>: E:;6 >28=<?5F 2< 1-$* $*$ 2<@6 :;6 @;?556<G6 23 :1 :;63?A6D=7GA6<:81:;:;6?BB6?53?>6;6?>7:1G6:;6> ?<7@1AA1<D=7GA6<:23B?3367 $ ?@:3 G2H2<G >236 :1 :;6 4252<G 14 :;6 ?BB6?53 8>26459 3:?:67 ?>6 :;?: 1< *$*($*$ ?: ?81=: +#** C;6< :;6 76@6?367 66>63; C?3 B>1@6672<G :1C?>73 1H2<7?B=>?1<;23A1:1>@9@5686?>2<G 6G 1,* , !+*+C;6<;6>6?@;671:;2,H255?G6<6?>;?>?:;?3 171C< 1<6 5?A1=> 1:1>@9@56 86?>2<G 6G 1, ( ,(-!(@?A64>1A1BB132:632762<>?3;?<7<6G52G6<: A?<<6>C2:;;2G;3B667?<7;2::1:;6A1:1>@9@5614:;6 76@6?367 =6 :1 :;6 ?@@276<: ;6 3=3:?2<67 G>26H1=3 2<D=>263 ?<7 2AA672?:659 ;6 C?3 3;24:67 :1 :;6 1H6><A6<:6<6>?513B2:?5I?;66>?8?741>42>3:?27?<7 :;6>6?4:6> ;6 C?3 3;24:67 :1 976>?8?7 13B2:?5 8=: ;6 72671<:;6C?9:1:;6;13B2:?5?:?81=:#**1<:;6 3?A67?9 - 6 - & ;6 @5?2A?<:3 42567 ? @5?2A B6:2:21< =<76> 6@:21<""14:;6@:366J2<G@1AB6<3?:21<41>:;676?:; 14:;676@6?367?51<GC2:;2<:6>63: ! B1< 36>H2@6 14 <1:2@6 :;6 >63B1<76<: 1$ ?BB6?>67 :;>1=G; @1=<365 ?<7 42567 C>2::6< 3:?:6A6<: 76<92<G :;6 ?H6>A6<:3 A?76 2< :;6 @5?2A B6:2:21< ;6 >63B1<76<: 1763B2:636>H2@614<1:2@6727<1:?BB6?> 8641>6:;6>28=<?5?<7C?3B5?@676K,B?>:6 ( < :;6 8?323 14 B56?72<G3 14 :;6 B?>:263 :;6 5?2A3>28=<?54>?A67:;6233=63?<7:;6>6?4:6>>6@1>767 :;66H276<@6;6@5?2A?<:32<1>76>:1B>1H6:;6@?36 6K?A2<67 @5?2A?<: 1 ?3 %, ?<7 G1: 6K;282:67 71@=A6<:3 <?A659 K :1 K& < 86;?54 14 >63B1<76<:3<11>?51>71@=A6<:?>96H276<@623B>17=@67 ;6 5?2A3 >28=<?5 89 :;6 2AB=G<67 D=7GA6<: ;657:;?::;6?@@276<::11JB5?@61<?@@1=<:14>?3; ?<7<6G52G6<:7>2H2<G14:;61446<72<GH6;2@56892:37>2H6> ?3 ? >63=5: 14 C;2@;:;676@6?3673=3:?2<672<D=>263 ?<7 - 7 - 3=@@=A867:1:;62<D=>263;6>28=<?54=>:;6>;657:;?: :;6 B6:2:21<6> 1$ 23 6<:2:567 :1 ? @1AB6<3?:21< 14 3$$$!"** ,?51<GC2:;2<:6>63:?::;6>?:614"LB? ?<7 72>6@:67 :;6 >63B1<76<:,<3=>?<@6 1AB?<9 :1 76B132: :;6 @1AB6<3?:21< ?A1=<: ?51<G C2:; 2<:6>63: 62<G ?GG>26H67 :;6 <3=>?<@6 1AB?<9 ;?3 42567 :;6 ?BB6?5 366J2<G >67=@:21< 2< @1AB6<3?:21< ?<7 @5?2A?<:3 ;?H642567:;6@>13318D6@:21<?BB6?5366J2<G6<;?<@6A6<: 14@1AB6<3?:21< " 6?><67@1=<36541>:;6<3=>?<@61AB?<9;?3 >?2367:;641551C2<G@1<:6<:21<3# ? 2>3:59 ?: :;6 :2A6 14 ?@@276<: :;6 76@6?367 C?3?G67?81=:-96?>3?<7;6C?3?3:=76<:6C?3 <1: ?< 6?><2<G A6A86> 14 :;6 4?A259 ;6 >28=<?5 @1<3276>2<G :;6 <1:21<?5 2<@1A6 14 :;6 76@6?367 ?: 3!$(* , ;?3 ?3363367 :;6 5133 14 76B6<76<@9 :;6 3?A6231<:;6;2G;6>3276 - 8 - 8 6@1<759 32<@6 :;6 @5?2A?<:3 ;?H6 4?2567 :1 63:?8523; :;6 2<@1A6 14 :;6 76@6?367 :;6 >28=<?5 ;?3 6>>672<G>?<:2<G4=:=>6B>13B6@:3 @ ?3:59;6@1<:6<767:;?:@1<3276>2<G:;6?G614 :;6 76@6?367 :;6 1H6>?55 @1AB6<3?:21< ?C?>767 89 :;6 >28=<?5231<:;6;2G;6>3276?<7>6M=2>67:186>67=@67 6<@6 ;6 31=G;: 41> ?551C2<G :;6 ?BB6?5 42567 89 :;6 <3=>?<@6 1AB?<9 ?<7 723A233?5 14 :;6 @>133 18D6@:21< 4256789:;6@5?2A?<:3 + 6?><67 @1=<365 41> :;6 @5?2A?<:3 ;?3 >?2367 :;641551C2<G@1<:6<:21<3# ? 2>3:59 ?: :;6 :2A6 14 :;6 ?@@276<: :;6 76@6?367C?3?G67?81=:-96?>3?<7;6C?3?3:=76<: ?<7 C?3 712<G @11526 C1>J ?<7 6?><2<G 3(*** , B6> A1<:; ;6 >28=<?5 @1<3276>2<G :;6 6H276<@6 14 :;6 B?>:263 ;?3 >2G;:59 ?3363367 :;6 A1<:;59 2<@1A6 14 :;6 76@6?367?: 3!$(* ,6>652671<:;6D=7GA6<:14:;6 1<F856 =B>6A6 1=>: 2< :;6 @?36 14 - 9 - ! "# " ! 2< 2H25BB6?5 1*$+) $*$(723B1367141<*)*)$*$( 8 6@1<759 2< H26C 14 :;6 D=7GA6<: 14 :;6 1<F856 =B>6A6 1=>: 2< :;6 @?36 14 $ %"! &"'!"( )#*+,"' $"# !-./0 1/236?@;14:;6@5?2A?<:3?>66<:2:56741>@1AB6<3?:21< 14 3!**** ,=<76>:;6;6?714E51331451H6?<7?446@:21< ?<7@1<31>:2=AF @ ?3:59@1<3276>2<G:;6?G6?<7?H1@?:21<14:;6 76@6?367 :;6 1H6>?55 @1AB6<3?:21< ?C?>767 89 :;6 >28=<?5231<:;651C6>32766<@6;6B>?9341>?551C2<G :;6@>13318D6@:21<4256789:;6@5?2A?<:3 ) 6?>7 :;6 56?><67 @1=<365 41> :;6 B?>:263 ?<7 B6>=367:;6D=7GA6<:?<7?C?>714:;6>28=<?5 - :23<1:2<723B=:6:;?:76@6?36766>63;7267 2<:;6>1?7:>?442@?@@276<:1@@=>>671<*$*($*$7=6:1 >?3; ?<7 <6G52G6<: 7>2H2<G 14 :;6 7>2H6> 14 :;6 1446<72<G - 10 - A1:1>@9@5686?>2<G 6G 1,( ,(-!(::;6:2A614 :;6?@@276<::;676@6?367C?3?G67?81=:-96?>3 * ;6 1<F856 B6K 1=>: 2< :;6 @?36 14 3=B>? ;657 :;?: ? A2<1> @;257 C;1 3=446>3 76?:; 1> B6>A?<6<: 723?8252:9 2< ? A1:1> H6;2@56 ?@@276<:@?<<1:86B5?@672<:;63?A6@?:6G1>9?3?<1<, 6?><2<G 2<72H27=?5 41> :;6 B=>B1363 14 ?336332<G :;6 ?A1=<: 14 @1AB6<3?:21< 86@?=36 :;6 @;257 C?3 <1: 6<G?G67 2< G?2<4=5 6AB519A6<: ?: :;6 :2A6 14 :;6 ?@@276<:<3=@;@?363:;6A2<2A=AC?G63B?9?856:1 ?3J25567C1>JA?<?3<1:2426741>:;6>656H?<:B6>2172<:;6 >63B6@:2H63:?:63C;6>6:;6@?=3614?@:21<?>236323:186 ?71B:67 % 2< ;23 6H276<@6 ;?3 @?:6G1>2@?559 3:?:67 :;?: 76@6?367 C?3 6?><2<G 3(*** , B6> A1<:; 89 712<G@11526C1>J1<3276>2<G:;66H276<@614%:;6 ?G6 14 :;6 76@6?367 ?<7;23 ?H1@?:21< :;6>28=<?5 ;?3 >2G;:59 ?3363367 :;6 <1:21<?5 2<@1A6 ?: 3!$(* , B6> A1<:; ?<7 ;?3 @1>>6@:59 ?7767 !*L :1C?>73 4=:=>6 B>13B6@:3 2J6C236 2: ;?3 >2G;:59 767=@:67 (*L 14 :;6 - 11 - 2<@1A6 14 :;6 76@6?367 :1C?>73 B6>31<?5 6KB6<363 ;6>641>6 :;6 @1AB6<3?:21< ?C?>767 89 :;6 >28=<?5 1< ?@@1=<: 14 E5133 14 76B6<76<@9F ?: 3$(!"** , 23 D=3: ?<7>6?31<?856 ;6 @1AB6<3?:21< ?C?>767 89 :;6 >28=<?5 1< ?@@1=<: 14 E5133 14 63:?:6F ?<7 1< ?@@1=<: 14 E4=<6>?5 6KB6<363F23D=3:?<7>6?31<?856 $ < H26C 14 :;6 5?C 5?27 71C< 89 :;6 =B>6A6 1=>:2<:;6@?36144$%"!&"'!"( )#35 3=B>?@5?2A?<: 13?<7$B?>6<:314:;676@6?367?>6 6<:2:567:1 3!**** ,6?@;=<76>:;6;6?714E5133144252?5 @1<31>:2=AF & ;=3:;6@5?2A?<:3?>66<:2:567:1:;641551C2<G @1AB6<3?:21<# ,-./0123/ 4/5.653.6./2 .150 ,4/23/ '0( 1331476B6<76<@9 $(!"** =<6>?56KB6<363 (*** - 12 - 1331463:?:6 (*** 13314252?5 @1<31>:2=A )**** 217 # # ! <:;6>63=5::;641551C2<G1>76>23B?3367# ? ;6?BB6?54256789:;6<3=>?<@61AB?<9 2< 1$*!&*+ $*$&23 8 ;6 ?BB6?5 42567 89 :;6 @5?2A?<:3 2< >18 1$***&- $*$!23 @ ;6 D=7GA6<: 14 :;6 5?2A3 >28=<?5 23 A1724267 7 ;6 @5?2A?<:3 ?>6 6<:2:567 :1 ? :1:?5 @1AB6<3?:21< 14 0 # # ) ?3 ?G?2<3: 3$$$!"** , ?C?>767 89 :;6 >28=<?5 6 ;6 <3=>?<@6 1AB?<9 23 72>6@:67 :1 76B132: :;6 @1AB6<3?:21< ?A1=<: ?51<G C2:; 2<:6>63: ?: "LB? 4>1A :;6 7?:6 14 4252<G 14 :;6 @5?2A B6:2:21< :255 :;6 7?:6 14 >6?52N?:21< C2:;2< ? B6>217 14 32K C66J3 - 13 - 4>1A :;6 7?:6 14 >6@62B: 14 @1B9 14 :;23 D=7GA6<: 4 ;6 ?BB1>:21<A6<: 76B132: ?<7 >656?36 14 ?A1=<: 3;?55 86 A?76 2< :6>A3 14 :;6 ?C?>714:;6>28=<?5 G A1=<: 2< 76B132: 23 72>6@:67 :1 86 :>?<3A2::67:1:;6>28=<?5 5) '$( & 5) '!&"!( & 23: 1#5 1#$"