Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66650 (KAR)

HAMEEDMIYYA S/O DASTAGIR SAB v. THE STATE THROUGH

CRL.RP/200040/2021 · 2025-08-29

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $ ## #% &'&()* '+& )) , ! " ! #$%&" ! " '() *&% %% &%( + , &%$ $) &%( %, % && + Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - - ! - " ./ 0/123245 6/727245/0 8/259 7./ :;;<3/= 25 4, &%$457./>2?/4>7./?/:05/=025;26:?212? <=9/ :5= :?:8<:092 !>40 3.407 @7./ 02:? 4<07A" 0/9237/0/= 23 2B6<95259 7./ C<=9B/57 4> ;4512;7245 :5= 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/ =:7/= &%%&%( ;4512;7259 7./ :;;<3/=>407./>407./4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/<5=/0 /;72453 )(:5='&*#4>7./5=2:5/5:?4=/!>403.407@A" 0 D %$) 4> ;7 D.2;. D:3 ;45>20B/= 25 02B25:? 66/:? 4$) &%( 45 7./ >2?/ 4> 7./ ==? 23702;7 :5= /332453 <=9/ :?:8<0:92 !>40 3.407 @7./ 2037 66/??:7/ 4<07A" 8E =23B233259 7./ :66/:? 12=/ C<=9B/57 =:7/= %,%&& - 3 - ./>:;734>7./;:3/25802/>:0/7.:77./>:7./0 4> 7./ =/;/:3/= ?4=9/= 7./ >2037 25>40B:7245 D27. 0:>>2; 4?2;/ 7:7245 <?8:09::9:25377./=021/04>7./0:;740# 0:2?/0 8/:0259 0/92370:7245 4#' #,'* #,' :??/9259 7.:7 45 %*%&%) :7 %'& 6B D./5 .23 345 D:3 70E259 74 ;0433 7./ 04:= 7./ =021/0 4> 7./ 4>>/5=259 70:;740#70:2?/0 =041/ 7./ 3:B/ 25 : 0:3. :5= 5/9?29/57 B:55/0 :5= =:3./= 74 7./ 84E :3 : 0/3<?7 4> D.2;. ./ 3<37:25/=>:7:?25C<02/3./=021/04>7./70:;740#70:2?/00:5 :D:E >04B 7./ 3647 ?/:1259 7./ 1/.2;?/ 7./0/ 273/?> ./ 25C<0/= D:3 7:F/5 74 7./ 43627:? 8<7 ./ 3<;;<B8/= 74 7./25C<02/3457./3:B/=:E:7%%'&6B./0/>40/7./ 25>40B:570/G</37/=7./64?2;/740/9237/07./;:3/:5=74 25272:7/ ?/9:? :;7245 ;;40=259?E 7./ ;:B/ 74 8/ 0/9237/0/= ' >7/0251/3729:72457./>25:?0/6407;:B/748/ >2?/= :9:2537 .2B >40 7./ :841/ 3:2= 4>>/5;/3 /:05/= :92370:7/744F;4952H:5;/4>7./4>>/5;/3:5=0/9237/0/= 7./ ;:3/ 25 4, &%$ ./ :;;<3/= :66/:0/= - 4 - 8/>40/ 7./ 02:? 4<07 6?/:=/= 547 9<2?7E :5= ;?:2B/= 74 8/ 702/= 4 6041/ 273 ;457/57245 7./ 6043/;<7245 /I:B25/=3%74%&:5=947B:0F/=I3%74%(./ :;;<3/==/52/=:??7./25;02B25:7259B:7/02:?3:1:2?:8?/45 0/;40=8<7.:3547;.43/574?/:=:5E/12=/5;/253<66407 4>.23=/>/5;/ * ./ 02:? 4<07 :>7/0 7:F259 2574 ;4532=/0:7245 :?? 7./ B:7/02:?3 45 0/;40= ;:B/ 74 7./ ;45;?<3245 7.:7 7./ 6043/;<7245 23 3<;;/33><? 25 6041259 7./ 9<2?7 4> 7./ :;;<3/= >40 7./ :>40/3:2= 4>>/5;/3 :5= :;;40=259?E ;4512;7/=:5=3/57/5;/=.2B /259:9902/1/=8E7./3:B/7./:;;<3/=.:3 60/>/00/=:66/:?2502B25:?66/:? 4$) &%(./2037 66/??:7/ 4<07 45 0/#:660/;2:7245 4> 7./ B:7/02:?3 45 0/;40==23B233/=7./:66/:?:5=;45>20B/=7./C<=9B/57 4> ;4512;7245 :5= 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/ 6:33/= 8E 7./ 02:? 4<07/259:9902/1/=8E7./3:B/7./:;;<3/=238/>40/ 7.234<07 - 5 - , /:0= 02 .:57:5< 0:=//6 <B:0 ?/:05/= B2;<3 <02:/ >40 7./ 0/123245 6/727245/0 :5= 02 46:?F023.5: :=:1 ?/:05/= 29. 4<07 41/05B/57 ?/:=/0 >40 7./ 0/3645=/57# 7:7/ /0<3/= 7./ B:7/02:?3 450/;40= ) 5 12/D 4> 7./ 021:? 3<8B2332453 B:=/ 8E 7./ ?/:05/=;4<53/?>40847.7./6:072/37./642577.:7D4<?= :023/>40BE;4532=/0:724523 $ E :53D/0 74 7./ :841/ 64257 23 25 7./ >407./>4??4D259 ( 7237./;457/572454>7./6043/;<72457.:77./ :;;<3/= 8/259 7./ =021/0 4> 7./ 4>>/5=259 70:;740#70:2?/0 - 6 - =041/ 7./ 3:B/ 25 : 0:3. :5= 5/9?29/57 B:55/0 :5= =:3./=747./=/;/:3/=:3:0/3<?74>D.2;../3<37:25/= >:7:? 25C<02/3 :5= =2/= 25 7./ 43627:? 4D/1/0 7./ :;;<3/=.:354725>40B/=7./>:;7<B4>7./25;2=/57747./ 5/:0/37 64?2;/ 540 =2= ./ .:3 3.2>7 7./ 25C<0/= 74 7./ 43627:? :5= 7./0/8E ./ .:3 ;4BB277/= 7./ 4>>/5;/ :3 37:7/=:841/ %& 1/5 7.4<9. 7./ ;:B/ 74 8/ 0/9237/0/= :9:2537 :5 <5F54D5 6/0345 D27.4<7 5:B259 7./ 0/123245 6/727245/0 ./0/25 27 D:3 0/9237/0/= :9:2537 7./ =021/0 4> 7./ 4>>/5=259 70:;740#70:2?/0 <0259 251/3729:7245 27 D:3 >4<5= 7.:7 27 D:3 7./ :;;<3/= D.4 D:3 =021259 7./ 4>>/5=259 70:;740#70:2?/0 25 : 0:3. :5= 5/9?29/57 B:55/0 D.2;. 0/3<?7/= 25 7./ :;;2=/57 / D:3 :660/./5=/= :5= >25:?0/6407;:B/748/>2?/= %% ./ 6043/;<7245 .:3 /I:B25/= '# 7./ 7/:;./0 4> 7./ 3;.44? 25 D.2;. 7./ =/;/:3/= D:3 37<=2/= :5=237./37<=/5737<=2/=257./3:B/3;.44?D.4 :0/ 7./ /E/#D275/33/3 74 7./ 25;2=/57 47. 3' :5= - 7 - .:1/3<66407/=7./;:3/4>7./6043/;<72451/57.4<9. 27 23 3<99/37/= 74 ' 7.:7 7./ D275/33 .:3 3//5 7./ :;;<3/= >40 7./ >2037 72B/ 8/>40/ 7./ 4<07 3<;. 3<99/37245 D:3 =/52/= 8E 7./ D275/33 ./0/ :0/ :834?<7/?E 54 0/:3453 74 =238/?2/1/ 7./ 1/03245 4> 3' :5= % 23 : D275/33 74 I'#7./ 25G</37 B:.:H:0 I*#23 7./ 3/2H<0/ B:.:H:0 <5=/0 D.2;. 7./ 70:;740#70:2?/0 D:3 3/2H/= I#23 7./ 3647 B:.:H:0 =0:D5:77./3647%237./>:7./04>7./=/;/:3/=D.4 ?4=9/= 7./ >2037 25>40B:7245 :>7/0 7./ 25;2=/57 ) 23 : >40B:?D275/33D.4604=<;/=7./0:;740#0:2?/08/>40/7./ 64?2;/$237./4740/.2;?/536/;740D.4233</=7./ 0/6407:36/0I%':>7/02536/;72597./4>>/5=2591/.2;?/ I%'237./4740/.2;?/536/;740A30/6407:;;40=25974 D.2;.7./:;;2=/57D:3547;:<3/==</74:5EB/;.:52;:? =/>/;7257./1/.2;?/ %' ( 23 7./ =4;740 D.4 25272:??E 233</= 7./ D4<5= ;/072>2;:7/ :3 6/0 I%* :5= 7./ 6437 B407/B - 8 - 0/6407 :3 6/0 I% 3 6/0 I%* 7./ 25C<0/= D:3 804<9.7 74 7./ 43627:? D27. 7./ .23740E 4> 04:= 70:>>2; :;;2=/57./.:=3<37:25/=;<7?:;/0:7/=D4<5=3B<?726?/ :80:32453 3 6/0 I%#7./ 6437 B407/B 7./ 25C<0/= 3<37:25/=;457<324541/0.233;:?6847.45>0457:?:5=82# 6:02/7:? 0/9245 B/:3<0259 %) ;B3 I $ ;B D27. 54 5:3:? 8?//=25960/3/57./0/D/0/B<?726?/:80:32453029.76/0# 40827:? /=/B: 90:H/= :80:3245 :?? 41/0 7./ 84=E ./ =/:7. D:3 =</ 74 3.4;F :5= ./B400.:9/ :3 : 0/3<?7 4> ./:=25C<0E3<37:25/=.//12=/5;/4>7.//E/#D275/33/3 3' :5= 23 3<66407/= 8E 7./ /12=/5;/ 4> 47./0 D275/33/3:5=7./=4;<B/5730/?2/=458E7./6043/;<7245 7 6041/3 7./ 9<2?7 4> 7./ :;;<3/= 8/E45= 0/:345:8?/ =4<87 ./ :;;<3/= .:3 547 7:F/5 :5E 36/;2>2; =/>/5;/ /1/5 7.4<9. :5 :77/B67 D:3 B:=/ 74 ;457/5= 7.:7 ./ D:35477./=021/04>7./1/.2;?/:77./72B/4>:;;2=/57 547.259 .:3 8//5 /?2;27/= >04B 7./ B:7/02:? D275/33/3# 3':5=7236/0725/5774547/7.:7*237./4D5/0 4>7./4>>/5=25970:;740#70:2?/0./36/;2>2;:??E=/643/=7.:7 - 9 - 27 D:3 7./ :;;<3/= D.4 D:3=021259 7./ 70:;740#70:2?/0 45 7./ =:7/ 4> 7./ 25;2=/57 5 12/D 4> :?? 7./3/ >:;73 :5= ;20;<B37:5;/3:B4>7./46252457.:77./6043/;<724523 3<;;/33><? 25 6041259 7./ 9<2?7 4> 7./ :;;<3/= 8/E45= 0/:345:8?/=4<87 %* .:1/945/7.04<9.7./2B6<95/=C<=9B/574> ;4512;7245:5=40=/04>3/57/5;/6:33/=8E7./02:?4<07 :3 D/?? :3 8E 7./ 2037 66/??:7/ 4<07 47. 7./4<073 .:1/;453237/57?E;4532=/0/= 7./ B:7/02:?3 450/;40= :5= .:1/ :0021/= :7 7./ 029.7 ;45;?<3245 =4 547 >25= :5E 0/:34574257/0>/0/D27.7./3:B/;;40=259?E:53D/0 7./ :841/ 64257 25 7./ 5/9:721/ :5= 604;//= 74 6:33 7./ >4??4D259 .//123245/72724523 />40/ 6:07259 D27. 7./ B:77/0 7./ >//3 4> B2;<3 <02:/23>2I/=:73%&&&& # - 10 - ./ ?/:05/= ==27245:? /92370:0 /5/0:? 23 =20/;7/= 74B:F/5/;/33:0E:00:59/B/573>406:EB/574>7./>//3 747./B2;<3<02:/ -* &##) $ B30 237 4% ? 4'