Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66640 (KAR)
DR SIDRAMAPPA v. THE UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURALS SCIENCE
WP/203530/2025 · 2025-11-26
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66640 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66640 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%""
&'
! " #
$
%
&
&! '
&!&
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! " #
%
( '' '') (* '
$
$ $
'!' '
!&&'!'
+
(
,-$
# ,-$%
./0/012.3 04 5.613. /704 183/ 4..902: 61;;1<02: 3.;0.64
!"#$%&&'()!* (*++(), - !./
0
1
2
' 7.=>4.16/7.?./0/012.304/7>/7.04<13902: >4 >2 441=0>/. 316.4413 02 /7. 3.4?12@.2/ 1 :30=8;/83>; .4.>3=7 .2/3. 0@>3 82@.3 /7. >.:04 16
- 3 -
3.4?12@.2/1&20A.340/B7>/7.<>4.;0:05;.613/7. ?14/ 16 441=0>/. 316.4413 02 A0.< 16 =1C?;./012 16 4/0?8;>/.@ ?.301@ 613 ?31C1/012 ==13@02:;B 7. <>4 ?31C1/.@ >4 4404/>2/ 316.4413 16 .2./0=4 >2@ ;>2/ 3..@02: :30=8;/83. .4.>3=7 />/012 0@>3 12 &!'!' 7>/ /702:4 4/11@ /784 3.4?12@.2/ 1' 0448.@0C?8:2.@13@.3@>/.@!&&'!' /3>246.3302:/7. ?./0/012.3 /1 /7. :30=8;/83>; 20A.340/B 7..C>3>B>2>:8@0 <0/7 0CC.@0>/. .66.=/ 12 >@C0204/3>/0A.:3182@4.02:>::30.A.@/7.?./0/012.304 5.613./704183/
.>32.@ =1824.; 613 /7. ?./0/012.3 />902: /704 183/ /7318:7 /7. 3.=13@4 A.7.C.2/;B 485C0/4 /7>/ /7. 0C?8:2.@/3>246.313@.37>45..2?>44.@02/7.C0@@;.16 /7. >=>@.C0= B.>3 <70=7 =>84.4 :3>A. 7>3@470? /1 /7. ?./0/012.37>/704C0213412044/8@B02:02&!/74/>2@>3@ #% >/ 0@>3 <71 3.D803.4 =>3. >2@ :80@>2=. 16 /7. ?./0/012.3>2@/7.51>3@.E>C4>3.4=7.@8;.@/15.7.;@ 02/7.C12/716>3=7'!'7>/<06.16/7.?./0/012.304
- 4 -
<13902: >/ $>;>583>:0 4 48=7 /7. 412 16 /7. ?./0/012.3 =>221/5.;.6/<0/718/>2B>//.2@>2/>2@:80@>2=. 4 3.:>3@4 /7. :3182@4 16 >@C0204/3>/0A. 3.>4124 0/ 04 =12/.2/.@ /7>/ ?./0/012.3 04 >441=0>/.@ <0/7 /7. =1;;>513>/0A. 3.4.>3=7 ?31:3>CC.4 <0/7 7>57> /1C0= .4.>3=7 .2/.3 8C5>0 02A1;A02: C8/>/012 53..@02:>2@A>30./>;0C?31A.C.2/16?8;4.=31?4>2@/7. 4>0@?31F.=/04>/=38=0>;4/>:.160/4.E?.30C.2/>/012>2@ @>/> >2>;B404 <70=7 3.D803.4 ?./0/012.3,4 =12/028184 48?.3A04012 >/ /7. :30=8;/83. .4.>3=7 .2/.3 0@>3 784 /7. :3182@ 16 >@C0204/3>/0A. 3.>412 04 >;41 21/ /.2>5;..2=./704?./0/012
5F.=/0124/>/.C.2/7>45..260;.@@.2B02:/7. >A.3C.2/4 C>@. 02 /7. ?./0/012 / 04 =12/.2/.@ /7>/ ?./0/012.3 <71 7>4 5..2 ?31C1/.@ >4 /7. 441=0>/. 316.4413 82@.3 .?>3/C.2/ 16 .2./0=4 >2@ ;>2/ 3..@02: 82@.3
4=7.C. #>330.3 @A>2=.C.2/ =7.C.%<0/7.66.=/631C'!''!' <>4=12/028.@02704
- 5 -
?14/02:>/:30=8;/83>;.4.>3=7.2/3.0@>32A0.<16 /7. ?31C1/012 7. 04 3.D803.@ 613 /.>=702: 6>=8;/B >/ 1;;.:. 16 :30=8;/83. 02 7..C>3>B>2>:8@0 <7.3. /7.3. 04>=8/.4713/>:.16/.>=702:6>=8;/B7>/02A0.<16/7. 4>0@ 3.D803.C.2/ /7. ?./0/012.3 7>4 5..2 /3>246.33.@ /1 /7. 4>0@ ?14/ >4 704 4.3A0=.4 >3. 21/ 3.D803.@ >/ 0@>3 <70=7 04 12;B > 3.4.>3=7 =.2/3. / 04 683/7.3 =12/.2@.@ /7>//7.?./0/012.37>45..2>/0@>320A.340/B402=.'!&& 0.7.4/>B.@02/7.4>0@?14/613>518/&B.>34.2=. 418:7/613@04C044>;16/7.?./0/012
.>32.@=1824.;613/7.?./0/012.3>6/.3>3:802: /7.C>//.3>/;.2:/7485C0//.@/7>//7.?./0/012.3<18;@ :0A.>282@.3/>902:/7>/7.<0;;3.?13//1/7.?14/<7.3. 7. 04 /3>246.33.@ 5B .2@ 16 >3=7 '!' 0. 4112 >6/.3 =1C?;./012 16 .E>C02>/012 16 704 412 <71 04 02 &!/7 4/>2@>3@ . 485C0//.@ /7>/ 402=. 704 <06. 04 >;41 /3>246.33.@ >/ $>;>583>:0 >2@ 21/ >A>0;>5;. /7.3. 04 21 12./1/>9.=>3.16704412>2@/7043.D8.4/5.=1240@.3.@ 1278C>20/>30>2:3182@
- 6 -
) 23.4?124.;.>32.@=1824.;613/7.3.4?12@.2/ 1&G20A.340/B12024/38=/0124485C0/4/7>/06><30//.2 3.D8.4/ 04 C>@. 5B /7. ?./0/012.3 /7. 3.4?12@.2/ 20A.340/B<0;;=1240@.34.2@02:70C12@.?8/>/012613/<1 @>B4> <..9>2@<0;; C>9.>33>2:.C.2/.2>5;02:70C/1 <139>/7..C>3>B>2>:8@05./<..212@>B/17834@>B >2@ 7. <0;; 5.
?.3C0//.@ /1 <139 >/ 0@>3 12 30@>B >2@ >/83@>B.485C0/4/7>//7040412;B9..?02:02A0.<16 /7.3.D8.4/C>@.5B/7.?./0/012.35.613./704183/02/7. ;0:7/16.E0:.2=B167044125.02:02704602>;?7>4.16&!/7 4/>2@>3@
85C04401204/>9.2123.=13@
./0/012 04 @03.=/02: /7. ?./0/012.3 7.3.02/1C>9.>3.?3.4.2/>/01202<30/02:>2@>;41:0A02:
>2 82@.3/>902: /1 /7. 3.4?12@.2/ G 20A.340/B /7>/ 7. <18;@3.?13//1704?14/02:>/7..C>3>B>2>:8@0<0/718/ 4..902: >2B .E/.24012 12 >2B >==182/ <7>/41.A.3 .66.=/0A. 631C 3+
45 (* ?12 48=7 3.?3.4.2/>/012 H133.=/.@A0@.183/13@.3@>/.@& &''!'
- 7 -
5.02: C>@. /7. 3.4?12@.2/ G 20A.340/B 47>;; =1240@.3 ?31A0@02: >33>2:.C.2/ >4 485C0//.@ 5B ;.>32.@ =1824.;
21/.@7.3.02>51A. 7. 0C?8:2.@ 13@.3 04 9.?/ 02 >5.B>2=. /0;; &4/ >3=7 '!' /1 /7. .E/.2/ ?./0/012.3 04 =12=.32.@ .4?12@.2/ G 20A.340/B 47>;; ?>44 13@.34 12 48=7 3.?3.4.2/>/012<0/702& @>B4631C/1@>B
() &""' %
($ 04/1&;1'&