- 1 - ! " #$!% $% & &'()* +&(( , ! " #$ %#%&' ( " ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ) %#%&'* ( " " ) +$* '& ) , &, ,'& " ) &' ,'&# ) ', ,'&% &, &' ,','!" ) )) '$,' %#*& ) ) ) - " - " & ./0102345678/9.8./0:.1;57:3.8<50=4. 0.>2325: ?.=2=25:.0/;;73.1 /:1 02 "..0/:/9571/ /82?/=28 8./0:.1 294 570= 5>.0:@.:= 8./1.0 <50 =4. 0.3?5:1.:==/=. - 3 - , 4. 0.>2325: ?.=2=25:.0 23 =4. /;;73.1 A45 37<<.0.1/:501.05<;5:>2;=25:2: 5 &' ,''#A42;4 A/3 ;5:<20@.1 2: 08 5 , ,'&% <50 =4. 5<<.:;.3 ?7:234/B8.7:1.0.;=25:3'$,'%#/:1*&5< + 4.=02/8719.?/33.1/:501.05<3.:=.:;./3 7:1.0 ! "#$% & & "#$% '( # - 4 - "#$% #( ') & "#$% #( *# # "#$% #( + , , - 4. 3/@. A/3 ;4/88.:9.1 B.<50. =4. )203= ??.88/=.570=2:08 5 , ,'&%/:18./0:.1719.2: =4.)203=??.88/=.570=/<=.03.;702:9=4.0.;50134./01 =4. /097@.:=3 5< =4. ?/0=2.3 2: 1.=/28 /:1 BC ;5:321.0.1 D719@.:= 1/=.1 &, &' ,',' 123@233.1 =4. /??./8 5< =4. /;;73.1/:1;5:<20@.1=4.501.05<=4.02/8719. - 5 - % .2:9<70=4.0/9902.>.1BC=4.3/@./;;73.123 B.<50.=423570=2:=4230.>2325: )/;=3/3;5781B.3..:<05@=4.0.;50135<=4. 02/8570=345A3=4/=/;5@?8/2:=;/@.=5B.8519.1BC =4. /:/9.0 5< =4. 0234:/ 0/@..: /:6 .A/092 0/:;4 /88.92:9 =4. @23/??05?02/=25: 5< =4. /@57:= BC =4./;;73.1A45A/3;;57:=/:=2:=4.3/21B0/:;4 . 0.@/2:.1/B3.:=B.=A..:'# ' ,''/:1,& '* ,''/:1 =4.0./<=.0 =4.0. A.0. 32E=..: A2=410/A/83 BC <5092:9 15;7@.:=3;/732:98533=5=4..E=.:=5<3 +%'''' * <=.0=45057942:>.3=29/=25:?582;.<28.1;4/09. 34..= /:1 /<=.0 17. =02/8 /;;73.1 A/3 ;5:>2;=.1 <50 =4. /<50.3/215<<.:;.3 # 4. >/8212=C 5< =4. 501.0 5< ;5:>2;=25: A/3 ;4/88.:9.1B.<50.=4.)203=??.88/=.570=BC=4./;;73.1 $ ./0:.1719.2:=4.)203=??.88/=.570=/<=.0 0./??0.;2/=25:5<=4.@/=.02/8.>21.:;.=556:5=.5<</;= =4/==4.;/3.5<=4.?053.;7=25:?0.15@2:/:=8C42:9.15: - 6 - =4.15;7@.:=/0C.>21.:;.0/=4.0=4/:=4.50/8.>21.:;.5< =4.?/0=2.3 &' 1@2==.18C32E=..:A2=410/A/8382?3A42;4A.0. <509.1BC=4./;;73.14/>.B..:3.:==5=4.E?.0=3/:1 :5=.1 =4/= <509.0C 4/3 =/6.: ?8/;. /:1 /: /@57:= 5< 3 +%'''' A/3 A2=410/A: BC =4. /;;73.1 =473 2= 23 ;8./0;/3.5<@23/??05?02/=25:7:1.0.;=25:'$5< && ;;73.1 B.2:9 =4. ;;57:=/:= =4.0. A/3 /: /7=5@/=2; .:=073=@.:= 5< =4. 15;7@.:=3 /:1 =4. ;/34 A2=4 =4. /;;73.1 =4.0.<50. 4. 23 82/B8. <50 =4. /88.9.1 5<<.:;.3 7:1.0 .;=25:3 '$ ,' % # /:1 *& 5< &, 4.: =A5 570=3 4/>. ;/=.9502;/88C 0.;501.1 /: 501.0 5< ;5:>2;=25: 2: =4. /B3.:;. 5< /:C ?8/732B8. .E?8/:/=25: 5<<.0.1 BC =4. /;;73.1 A428. 0.;5012:9 =4. /;;73.1 3=/=.@.:= @.0. 1.:2/8 5< =4. 2:;02@2:/=50C ;20;7@3=/:;.3 A5781 :5= B. 37<<2;2.:= <50 =423 570= =5 /::78=4.501.05<;5:>2;=25: - 7 - &+ /62:9:5=.5<=4.3./3?.;=35<=4.@/==.0=423 570= 23 5< =4. ;5:321.0.1 5?2:25: =4/= =4. 501.0 5< ;5:>2;=25::..13=5B.@/2:=/2:.1 & />2:93/21=473/;;73.123:5A/9.1$C./03 /:1 4. 23 37<<.02:9 <05@ 581 /9. /28@.:=3 /:1 B.2:9 =4. <203= =2@. 5<<.:1.0 2< =4. 3.:=.:;. 5< 2@?0235:@.:= 501.0.1BC=4.02/8/923=0/=.23@512<2.1BC120.;=2:9=4. /;;73.1 =5 7:1.095 32@?8. 2@?0235:@.:= <50 / 1/C /:1 /835 120.;=2:9 42@ =5 ?/C / 37@ 5< 3 &''''' /3 =4. .:4/:;.1 <2:. /@57:= =/62:9 :5=. 5< =4. </;= =4/= =4. @23/??05?02/=.1 /@57:= 5< 3 +%'''' 23 /80./1C 0.;5>.0.1<05@=4./;;73.1.:135<D73=2;.A5781B.@.= &% ;;5012:98C<5885A2:9501.023?/33.1 / .>2325:?.=2=25:23/885A.12:?/0= B 428.@/2:=/2:2:9=4.501.05<;5:>2;=25:5< =4. 0.>2325: ?.=2=25:.0 <50 =4. 5<<.:;.3 ?7:234/B8. 7:1.0 .;=25:3 '$ ,' % # /:1 *& 5< =4. :12/: .:/8 51. - 8 - 3.:=.:;. 5< 2@?0235:@.:= 501.0.1 BC =4. 02/8 /923=0/=. ;5:<20@.1 BC =4. )203= ??.88/=.570=23@512<2.1BC120.;=2:9=4. /;;73.1 0.>2325: ?.=2=25:.0 =5 7:1.095 32@?8.2@?0235:@.:=<50/1/C=2880232:95< =4.570=/:1=5?/C.:4/:;.1<2:./@57:= 5<3 &''''' 5:B.<50.+& '* ,',% ; )/2870.=5?/C=4..:4/:;.1<2:./@57:=5< 3 &''''' 5:50B.<50.+& '* ,',%=4. 501.0 5< 3.:=.:;. ?/33.1 BC =4. 02/8 /923=0/=.;5:<20@.1BC=4.)203=??.88/=. 570=3=/:130.3=50.1/7=5@/=2;/88C 1 7= 5< =4. <2:. /@57:= / 37@ 5< 3 *%''' 23 501.0.1 =5 B. ?/21 /3 ;5@?.:3/=25: =5 0234:/ 0/@..:/ /:6 .A/0927:1.017.21.:=2<2;/=25: . <<2;. 23 120.;=.1 =5 0.=70: =4. 02/8 570= 0.;5013A2=4;5?C5<=423501.0<50=4A2=4<50 2337.5<@512<2.1;5:>2;=25:A/00/:= -) &%( ! 23=5 &85 %#