Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66582 (KAR)
VIJAYLAXMI W/O MALLIKARJUN v. RAJKUMAR S/O TUKKAPPA INAPURE AND ANR
MFA/201185/2021 · 2025-11-14
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66582 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66582 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ % & &&
'#( )* &&
'#(
)
*
!"!#
$%%
"
%%%
&!"' !()(&&'
&
*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
++%*% %!"",,
$% %+&-
"! + + "'#" + %
%% +
,&,&&,&" %
+
"& &,"' %% + +. &%%
)
*
. (
$%%
"
%%%
&!"' !()(&&'
&
*
- 3 -
++%* % %!"",,
$%
%+"- %+&
+ + "'#" + %
%% +
,&,&&,&" %
+
"" &,"' % % + +. &%!%
%%+
/%
% 0123040567756896:58;945<=1:6<>;99;1?@;40405 A1?95?41=856:?5<A12?958=1:40576:4;59405B6:546C5? 27=1:=;?68<;971968 & A1>>1?D2<3>5?4@6976995<1?,&,&&,&" ;? 1"" &,"' 1"& &,"' 6?< 1&,# &,") EB 405 <<;4;1?68 5?;1: ;F;8 2<35 6?<
64 ;<6: =1: 901:4 G405 :;E2?68H + 1&,"(") &,&" ;9 =;85< EB 405 A86;>6?4 ;? - 4 -
1"& &,"' 6?< + 1&,"")( &,&" ;9 =;85< EB 405 A86;>6?4;?1"" &,"' #
)
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
- 5 -
1405: 056<9 05 <1A41: 6995995< 405 <;96E;8;4B 64 I E24 405 :;E2?68 069 46C5? ;4 1?8B )I 05 <:;F5: 1= 405 1==5?<;?3 F50;A85 ;9 06F;?3 F68;< 6?< 5==5A4;F5 <:;F;?3 8;A5?A5644054;>51=4056AA;<5?4E24405:;E2?68=;J5< 4058;6E;8;4B1?8B1?4051@?5:1=405F50;A856?<;4;941E5 >1<;=;5<
56:?5< A12?958 =1: :5971?<5?4 1& 069 :5K25945<40512:4411:<5:=1:76B6?<:5A1F5:B ' 56:<4056:32>5?491=E1409;<59 ) 05:;E2?6806946C5?4056351=4056775886?4 69 & B56:9 :58B;?3 271? J%"& 6?< %" 6?< 46C5? 405 >284;78;5: 69 G'H E24 69 75: J%""!@12?< A5:4;=;A645 ;>>5<;6458B 6=45:4056AA;<5?4 05: 635 @69 901@? 69, B56:9 91 6891 ;? 405 <;96E;8;4B A5:4;=;A645 05: 635 @69 901@? 69 , B56:9 05:5=1:5 405 >284;78;5: ;9 41 E5 46C5? 69 G H 01230 405 6775886?4 94645< 4064 905 @69 56:?;?39"&,,, !75:>1?40905069?147:1<2A5<6?B ;?A1>5 7:11= 05:5=1:5 69 75: 405 32;<58;?59 1= 405
- 6 -
6:?646C6464553685:F;A592401:;4B694056AA;<5?4 ;91=405B56:&,"05:?14;1?68;?A1>5;941E546C5?64 9)'(, ! 75: >1?40 05 6775886?4 069 92946;?5< =:6A42:51=927:6A1?<B86:6?<=:6A42:51=:;304=5>2:@;40 5?45: A1?<B86:
5J45?9;1? J%"& ;9 405 <;9A06:35 92>>6:B 05 @69 0197;468;95< =1: ,' <6B9 6?< 905 5J6>;?5< 405 <1A41: 69 % ( 9 75: 405 @12?< A5:4;=;A645!J%""4056775886?406992946;?5<E82?4056< ;?D2:B 6?< E82?4 ;?D2:B 41 :;304 0;7 1 =:6A42:5 124 1= @0;A0;?D2:B1&;93:;5F129;??642:56?<;?D2:B1";9 9;>785 ;?
?642:5 % (!1A41: 94645< 4064 6775886?4 069 92946;?5<=:6A42:51=<;9468=5>2:@;40;>786?4;?9;42:;304 9;<5905;906F;?3<;==;A284B;?946?<;?31?5==5A45<8;>E C?558;?3A8;>E;?3946;:9@68C;?381?3<;946?A59K2644;?3 5A4 6?< 05 4:5645< 05: 6?< 6995995< 405 <;96E;8;4B 64 I4140596>58;>E
5689194645<4064905:5K2;:5< 1?5 >1:5 92:35:B =1: :5>1F68 1= ;>786?4 6?< 405 594;>645<A194;99#,,,, !419#(,,, !" #:<1=I A1>5941"(IE24405:;E2?6806946C5?405<;96E;8;4B64
- 7 -
)I6?<;4;941E5>1<;=;5<05:5=1:540;912:4=;?<9;4 :5691?6E854146C5405<;96E;8;4B64"(I02940581991= =242:556:?;?39@128<E5 9)'(,J"&J J"(IL9""'(, ! 05 :;E2?68 069 6@6:<5< 6? 6>12?4 1= 9#,,,( !41@6:<9>5<;A685J75?9596975:405:585F6?4 <1A2>5?496?<;4?55<9?14;?45:=5:5?A5
", 05 6775886?4 @69 6<>;445< ;? 405 0197;468 =1:
,' <6B9 1?9;<5:;?3405?642:5 1=;?D2:;596?<75:;1<1= 0197;468;964;1? 40;9 12:4 =;?<9 ;4 :5691?6E85 41 3:6?4 6? 6>12?41=9(,,,, !=1:76;?6?<92==5:;?39&(,,, ! =1: 8199 1= 6>5?;4;59 6?< 9#,,,, ! =1: 4:6?971:464;1? 5J4:6?12:;90>5?46?<6445?<6?4A06:359
"" 05 6775886?4 >;304 ?14 06F5 6445?<5< 6?B @1:C 64 85694 =1: 6 75:;1< 1= =12: >1?409 <25 41 405 ;?D2:;5992946;?5<05:5=1:540;912:4=;?<9;4:5691?6E85 413:6?46?6>12?41=9#(,,, !9)'(,J=1:8199 1=;?A1>5<2:;?386;<2775:;1<
- 8 -
"& 975:4055F;<5?A51=% (40;912:4=;?<9;4 :5691?6E85 41 3:6?4 6? 6>12?4 1= 9#(,,, ! =1: =242:5 >5<;A685J75?959;5=1::5>1F681=;>786?4
"#
5?A54056775886?4;95?4;485<=1:405>1<;=;5< A1>75?964;1?2?<5:<;==5:5?4056<969E581@ %6;?6?<92==5:;?3 9(,,,, ! 5<;A685J75?959 9#,,,( ! +242:5>5<;A685J75?959 9#(,,, ! 1991==242:556:?;?39 9""'(, ! 1991=;?A1>5<2:;?386;<2775:;1< 9#(,,, ! :6?971:464;1? 5J4:6 ?12:;90>5?4 6?<6445?<6?4A06:359 9#,,,, ! 1991=6>5?;4;59 9&(,,, ! +,- ./! )
029 405 6775886?4 ;9 5?4;485< =1: 405 41468 A1>75?964;1? 1= 9#'(( ! @;40 ;?45:594 64 I 75: 6??2>69636;?949"&,( !6@6:<5<EB405:;E2?68
" 05 :;E2?68 058< 4064 405 <:;F5: 1= 405 1==5?<;?3F50;A85@69?1406F;?3F68;<<:;F;?38;A5?A5691? 405 <645 1= 405 6AA;<5?4 6?< 405:5EB =;J5< 405 5?4;:5 8;6E;8;4B 1? 405 1@?5: 1= 405 F50;A85
5?A5 40;9 12:4 =;?<9 ;4 :5691?6E85 41 :58B 271? 405 D2<3>5?4 1= 405
- 9 -
1?HE85 75J 12:4 ;? ! "!#
6?< 1:<5: =1: 76B 6?< :5A1F5:B 41 405 ?92:6?A5 1>76?B 05:5=1:5 :5971?<5?4 1& ! ?92:6?A5 1>76?B ;9 <;:5A45< 41 <5719;4 405 41468 A1>75?964;1? 1= 9#'(( ! @;40 ;?45:59464I76@;408;E5:4B41:5A1F5:40596>5=:1> :5971?<5?41"!1@?5:1=405F50;A85
"(
)
'# !) ( 05A86;>6?4635<(,B56:9<1;?386E12:@1:C>54 @;40 6? 6AA;<5?4 1? "", &," 6?< 92946;?5< 3:;5F129 ;?D2:59 05:5=1:5 905 =;85< 6 A86;> 754;4;1? E5=1:5 405 :;E2?68A86;>;?3A1>75?964;1?1=9&),,,,, ! " 05:;E2?68A1?9;<5:;?34055?4;:55F;<5?A51? :5A1:< 3:6?45< A1>75?964;1? 1= 9& &#, ! @;40 ;?45:59464 I76=:1>405<6451=754;4;1?4;88:568;964;1? 1 (2018) 3 SCC 208
- 10 -
6?< <;:5A45< :5971?<5?4 1"!1@?5: 1= 405 F50;A85 41 <5719;440596>5
"' 33:;5F5<EB40596;<D2<3>5?46?<6@6:<405 ;?D2:5< A86;>6?4 069 7:5=5::5< 40;9 677568 ;?
@0;A0 ;4 ;9 A1?45?<5<40644056775886?4@69635<(,B56:9905@69 <1;?3 86E12: @1:C 6?< @69 56:?;?3 9"&,,, ! 75: >1?40E24405:;E2?68069@:1?38B46C5?05:;?A1>564 9',,, ! 75: >1?40 6?< >563:5 6>12?49 6:5 3:6?45< 2?<5:4051405:056<905<1A41:6995995<405<;96E;8;4B 64(&IE24405:;E2?6806946C5?;41?8B",I05<:;F5:
1= 405 1==5?<;?3 F50;A85 @69 06F;?3 F68;< 6?< 5==5A4;F5 <:;F;?38;A5?A5644054;>51=4056AA;<5?4E24405:;E2?68 =;J5<4058;6E;8;4B1?8B1?4051@?5:1=405F50;A856?<;4;9 41E5>1<;=;5<
") 56:?5< A12?958 =1: :5971?<5?4 1& 069 :5K25945< 405 12:4 41 1:<5: =1: 76B 6?< :5A1F5:B 05:569856:?5<A12?958=1::5971?<5?41"94645<4064 405 <:;F5: @69 06F;?3 F68;< 6?< 5==5A4;F5 <:;F;?3 8;A5?A5
- 11 -
9 92A0 405 ?92:6?A5 1>76?B 069 41 ;?<5>?;=B 405> 6?<405B6:58;6E854176B405A1>75?964;1? "
56:<4056:32>5?491=E1409;<59 &, 9 75: 405 @12?< A5:4;=;A645!J% 405 6775886?406992946;?5<E82?4;?D2:B41:;3040;76?<E82?4 ;?D2:B41:;304C?55D1;?4140405;?D2:;596:53:;5F129;? ?642:5 % !1A41: ;? 0;9 5F;<5?A5 94645< 4064 905 92946;?5< =:6A42:5 1= <;981A64;1? :;304 0;7 =:6A42:5 1= 6A546E282> 6?< 2?<;9786A5< =:6A42:5 1= A1?<B85 1= 4;E;6 6?<7645886:;3049;<56?<6975::6<;1813;A685J6>;?64;1? 905 069 92946;?5< =:6A42:5 1= :;304 6A546E282> @;40 ;>786?4 ;?9;42 ?6::1@;?3 1= D1;?4 976A5 6?< 6995995< 405 <;96E;8;4B64(&I4140596>58;>E6?<=2:405:94645<4064 4056775886?4:5K2;:591?5>1:592:35:B=1::5>1F681=405 ;>786?4 6?< 405 594;>645< A194 ;9 9#,,,, ! 41 9#(,,, !" #:<1=(&IA1>5941"'I05:5=1:540;9 12:4=;?<9;4:5691?6E854146C5405<;96E;8;4B64"'I05 6775886?4@69635<(,B56:96?<405>284;78;5:@69:;3048B 46C5? 69 G"#H 01230 405 6775886?4 94645< 4064 905 @69
- 12 -
56:?;?39"&,,, !75:>1?40905069?147:1<2A5<6?B ;?A1>5 7:11= 05:5=1:5 69 75: 405 32;<58;?59 1= 405 6:?646C6464553685:F;A592401:;4B694056AA;<5?4 ;91=405B56:&,"05:?14;1?68;?A1>5;941E546C5?64 9)'(, ! 75: >1?40 029 405 8199 1= =242:5 56:?;?39 @128<E5 9)'(,J"&J"#J"'IL9&#&,(, ! &" 05 :;E2?68 069 6@6:<5< 6? 6>12?4 1= 9",&", !41@6:<9>5<;A685J75?9596?<;4?55<9?14 ;?45:=5:5?A5 && 05 6775886?4 @69 6<>;445< ;? 405 0197;468 =1:
"( <6B9 1?9;<5:;?3405 ?642:51=;?D2:;596?<75:;1<1= 0197;468;964;1? 40;9 12:4 =;?<9 ;4 :5691?6E85 41 3:6?4 6? 6>12?41=9'(,,, !=1:76;?6?<92==5:;?39&(,,, ! =1: 8199 1= 6>5?;4;59 6?< 9#,,,, ! =1: 4:6?971:464;1? 5J4:6?12:;90>5?46?<6445?<6?4A06:359 &# 05 6775886?4 >;304 ?14 06F5 6445?<5< 6?B @1:C 64 85694 =1: 6 75:;1< 1= =12: >1?409 <25 41 405
- 13 -
;?D2:;5992946;?5<05:5=1:540;912:4=;?<9;4:5691?6E85 413:6?46?6>12?41=9#(,,, !9)'(,J=1:8199 1=;?A1>5<2:;?386;<2775:;1< & 975:4055F;<5?A51=% 40;912:4=;?<9;4 :5691?6E85 41 3:6?4 6? 6>12?4 1= 9#(,,, ! =1: =242:5 >5<;A685J75?959;5=1::5>1F681=;>786?4 &(
5?A54056775886?4;95?4;485<=1:405>1<;=;5< A1>75?964;1?2?<5:<;==5:5?4056<969E581@ %6;?6?<92==5:;?3 9'(,,, ! 5<;A685J75?959 9",&", ! +242:5>5<;A685J75?959 9#(,,, ! 1991==242:556:?;?39 9&#&,(, ! 1991=;?A1>5<2:;?386;<2775:;1< 9#(,,, ! :6?971:464;1? 5J4:6 ?12:;90>5?4 6?<6445?<6?4A06:359 9#,,,, ! 1991=6>5?;4;59 9&(,,, ! +,- ./! )
029 405 6775886?4 ;9 5?4;485< =1: 405 41468 A1>75?964;1? 1= 9(#&", !
@;40 ;?45:594 64 I 75: 6??2>69636;?949& &#, !6@6:<5<EB405:;E2?68 & 05 :;E2?68 058< 4064 405 <:;F5: 1= 405 1==5?<;?3F50;A85@69?1406F;?3F68;<<:;F;?38;A5?A5691? - 14 -
405 <645 1= 405 6AA;<5?4 6?< 405:5EB =;J5< 405 5?4;:5 8;6E;8;4B 1? 405 1@?5: 1= 405 F50;A85
5?A5 40;9 12:4 =;?<9 ;4 :5691?6E85 41 :58B 271? 405 D2<3>5?4 1= 405 1?HE85 75J 12:4 ;? 27:6 6?< 1:<5: =1: 76B 6?< :5A1F5:B 41 405 ?92:6?A5 1>76?B 05:5=1:5 :5971?<5?4 1& ! ?92:6?A5 1>76?B ;9 <;:5A45< 41 <5719;4 405 41468 A1>75?964;1? 1= 9(#&", ! @;40 ;?45:594 64 I 76 @;40 8;E5:4B 41 :5A1F5: 405 96>5 =:1> :5971?<5?4 1"!1@?5: 1= 405 F50;A85 &' ?405:59284405=1881@;?31:<5:;976995< ; 14040567756896:56881@5<;?76:4 ;; 05 6775886?4 ;? + 1&,"(") &,&" ;9 5?4;485< =1: 405 41468 A1>75?964;1? 1= 9#'(( ! @;40 ;?45:59464I75:6??2>=:1>405<6451=754;4;1?4;88405 <6451=:568;964;1? ;;; 05 6775886?4 ;? + 1&,"")( &,&" ;9 5?4;485< =1: 405 41468 A1>75?964;1? 1= 9(#&", ! @;40
- 15 -
;?45:59464I75:6??2>=:1>405<6451=754;4;1?4;88405 <6451=:568;964;1? ;F 5971?<5?4 1&!?92:6?A5 1>76?B ;9 <;:5A45<41<5719;44056=1:596;<A1>75?964;1?6>12?4;? E140 405 6775689 @;40;? 1?5 >1?40 =:1> 405 <645 1= 40;9 D2<3>5?4
1@5F5: :5971?<5?4 1& ;9 64 8;E5:4B 41 :5A1F5: 405 96>5 =:1> :5971?<5?4 1"!1@?5: 1= 405 F50;A85EB<257:1A5991=86@ F ? 92A0 <5719;4 405 6775886?49 ;? E140 405 6775689 6:5 75:>;445< 41 @;40<:6@ 405 5?4;:5 6>12?4 681?3@;40;?45:5946AA:25<1?;4
.0) '& ( %
;941"81#