- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ !$%! "" &%' ( ! " # $ ! ! %! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! %! ! &'$ ( ) ( ! ! %! ! &'$ ( )*+",) !,, %! ! &'$ ( "- ) ,) "$+"+"(") + '' "("" % % ! ! . . - 3 - $ !. /01 233425 67849 4:;0<7 ,) <= ;/4 <;<9 4/0:541:;>$$/494072=;4994=49948;<21?;/4:;@=<9 1/<9;/21A447=0548AB;/423345527;+716927:4 <C327B A407D 2DD904E48 AB ;/4 F68DC47; 82;48 "$""(") 321148AB;/4880;0<725470<9 0E0568D4278 G 2; 20:/69 07 <'' "("" H641;0<707D ;/4 502A050;B=21;4748<70; " 2:;1 D0E07D 9014 ;< ;/4 =0507D <= ;/4 233425 A904=5B1;2;48294;/2;<7"'(>"(""2;2A<6; (2C I/47;/484:4214847J2;41/I/<I21I<9J07D212 <3492;<92785<2807DD<<81033495<99B21J489413<7847; < ;< A907D /01 ;03349 ;< ;/4 5<2807D 13<; /47 ;/4 84:42148I2194;69707D;<I2981;/4 9413<7847;< 89<E4 ;/4 ;03349 5<99B 07 94E4914 2A963;5B 07 921/ 278 74D50D47; C27749 278 821/48 ;/4 84:42148 47J2;41/ :26107D /0C ;< =255 8<I7 1 2 94165; <= ;/4 2=<941208 - 4 - 2::0847; ;/4 84:42148 161;20748 D904E<61 07F69041 278 16::6CA48;<;/407F69041 ) /4:520C27;1=0548234;0;0<7678494:;0<7** <= ;/4 <;<9 4/0:541 :; 144J07D :<C34712;0<7 <= 1* (((((+=<9;/4842;/<=84:42148I0;/07;4941;2; ;/4 92;4 <= "K 349 2776C <7 ;/4 D9<678 ;/2; ;/4 84:42148 I21 I<9J07D 21 2 <3492;<9 07 C /2J;0 ;<74 961/492:;<9B278I21429707D1)((((+3C 278/4I21251<D4;;07DA2;;2<=1)((+34982B 7 149E0:4 <= 7<;0:4 9413<7847; <1 278 " =0548 I90;;47 1;2;4C47; 07 I/0:/ ;/4 2E49C47;1 C284 07 ;/434;0;0<7I494847048;I21:<7;47848;/2;;/4;03349 5<99B I21 0716948 I0;/ ;/4 716927:4 <C327B 278 ;/4 890E49 <= ;/4 <==47807D E4/0:54 /458 E2508 890E07D 50:47:4 116:/0;I2116AC0;;48;/2;0=27B:<C34712;0<701;<A4 3208 0; 01 ;/4 502A050;B <7 ;/4 716927:4 <C327B ::<9807D5B9413<7847;<1278"392B48=<9801C01125 <=;/434;0;0<7 - 5 - ' /4 9413<7847; <)+716927:4 :<C327B =0548 143292;4 I90;;47 1;2;4C47; 847B07D ;/4 47;094 2E49C47;1 C28407;/434;0;0<7;I21:<7;47848;/2;;/494I217< 74D50D47:4<7;/4329;<=;/4890E49<=;/4;0334969;/49 0;I211;2;48;/2;;/4890E49<=;/4;03349I217<;/<5807D 134:0=0::5211<=890E07D50:47:4278E0<52;48;/4;49C1278 :<780;0<71 <= ;/4 3<50:B /4 716927:4 <C327B 2554D48 A942:/<=3<50:B:<780;0<71AB;/4<I749<=;/4;03349278 8470480;1502A050;B;<32B:<C34712;0<7 * 7;/4A2101<=;/43542807D1<=;/4329;041;/4 520C190A6725=92C48;/4011641278;/4942=;4994:<9848 ;/44E0847:4/4:520C27;107<9849;<39<E4;/409:214 4L2C0748 :520C27; < 21 + 278 D<; 4L/0A0;48 8<:6C47;1 72C45B L ;< L 7 A4/25= <= 9413<7847;1 /<614 21/2 I21 4L2C0748 21 + 278 D<; 4L/0A0;48 8<:6C47;1 72C45B L ;< L) 278 L( 278 27J272D<682 I21 4L2C0748 21 +" 278 D<; 4L/0A0;48 8<:6C47;1 72C45B L ;< L> /4 520C1 90A6725 AB ;/4 0C36D748 F68DC47; - 6 - /458 ;/2; ;/4 2::0847; ;<<J 352:4 <7 2::<67; <=921/ 278 74D50D47;890E07D<=;/4<==47807DE4/0:54AB0;1890E49212 94165; <= I/0:/ ;/4 84:42148 161;20748 07F69041 278 16::6CA48;< ;/4 07F69041 /4 90A6725 =69;/49/458;/2; ;/4 :520C27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< :<C34712;0<7 <= 1")*""((+25<7DI0;/07;4941;2;;/492;4<=*K32 407D 2DD904E48 AB ;/4 1208 F68DC47; ;/4 0716927:4 :<C327B/21=0548;/01233425 , 90 27F672;/ 2552BB2/4;;B5429748:<67145 23342907D =<9 ;/4 716927:4 <C327B :<7;47848 ;/2; 21 <7 ;/4 82;4 <= ;/4 2::0847; ;/4 890E49 <= ;/4 <==47807D E4/0:54 808 7<; 3<11411 2 E2508 278 4==4:;0E4 890E07D 50:47:4;0116AC0;;48;/2;;/494I217<9474I25<=;/4 890E07D50:47:4=9<C($"("(;<((>"(")21349;/4 4L;92:;<=;/4890E07D50:47:447:4;/013490<801;942;48 21 ?E25080;B D23 3490<8@ 07:4 ;/4 2::0847; <::69948 <7 "'(>"("" 0; 01 :<7;47848 ;/2; <7 ;/4 82;4 <= ;/4 2::0847; ;/4 890E49 <= ;/4 <==47807D E4/0:54 I21 7<; /<5807D27BE2508 2784==4:;0E4890E07D50:47:4/494=<94 - 7 - ;/4 90A6725 /21 :<CC0;;48 27 499<9 07 =21;4707D ;/4 502A050;B <7 ;/4 716927:4 <C327B 7 1633<9; <= /01 :<7;47;0<7/4/21945048<7;/4F68DC47;<=;/01 <69;07 ;/4:214<= 07 <)">,"(> 8013<148 <= <7)( "(") $ 49:<7;929027D27D<6820928295429748 :<67145 23342907D =<9 ;/4 :520C27;1 :<7;47848 ;/2; 4E47 2116C07D;/4890E49<=;/4<==47807DE4/0:548087<;/2E4 27B E2508 278 4==4:;0E4 890E07D 50:47:4 071<=29 21 ;/4 :520C27;1294:<7:49748;/4716927:4:<C327B01502A54 ;<32B;/4:<C34712;0<7I0;/50A49;B;<94:<E49;/412C4 =9<C;/4<I749<=;/4<==47807DE4/0:5471633<9;<=/01 :<7;47;0<7/4/21945048<7;/4F68DC47;<=;/4<7@A54 34L <69;07;/4:214<= 943<9;48 07 !"#$ %& '(!278;/484:010<707)*+ ,% - . /0 1 943<9;4807+ ! ! 2( - 8 - > 4298 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 23342907D =<9 ;/4 329;041 278 3496148 ;/4 F68DC47; 278 2I298 <= ;/4 90A6725 ( ;017<;0780136;4;/2;47J2;41/8048079<28 ;92==0: 2::0847; <::69948 <7 "'(>"("" 864 ;< 921/ 278 74D50D47;890E07D<=;/4890E49<=;03349;01251<7<;07 80136;4;/2;21<7;/482;4<=;/42::0847;;/4890E49<= ;/4<==47807DE4/0:548087<;/2E427BE25082784==4:;0E4 890E07D50:47:41349;/44L;92:;<=;/4890E07D50:47:40; 01E49B:5429;/2;;/494I217<9474I25<=;/450:47:4=9<C ($"("(;<((>"(");/013490<8/21A447;942;4821 ?E25080;B D23 3490<8@ 7849 ;/414 :09:6C1;27:41 ;/4 90A6725 /21 49948 07 /<5807D ;/2; ;/4 890E49 <= ;/4 <==47807DE4/0:54I21/<5807D2E25082784==4:;0E4890E07D 50:47:4 07:4 ;/4 0716948 /21 E0<52;48 ;/4 3<50:B :<780;0<71;/4716927:4 <C327B017<;502A54;<32B;/4 :<C34712;0<7 <I4E49 /4 <7@A54 34L <69; 07 ;/4 :214<=16392278;/465547:/<=;/01 <69;07 ;/4:214<=1 16392/2E4/458;/2;0794134:;<= - 9 - :520C27;1 ;/4 716927:4 <C327B 01 502A54 ;< 32B ;/4 :<C34712;0<7 2C<67; I0;/ 50A49;B ;< 94:<E49 ;/4 12C4 =9<C;/4<I749<=;/4<==47807DE4/0:54::<9807D5BI4 39<:448;<3211;/4=<55<I07D! 0 /423342501 * 00 /4F68DC47;2782I298321148AB;/4 520C1 90A672501C<80=048<75B0794134:;<=502A050;B 000 /4 716927:4 <C327B 01 8094:;48 ;< 843<10; ;/4 47;094 :<C34712;0<7 2C<67; 2I29848 AB ;/490A672525<7DI0;/07;4941;2;*K32=9<C ;/4 82;4 <= =0507D <= ;/4 :520C 34;0;0<7 ;055 ;/4 82;4<=94250M2;0<7I0;/0723490<8<=10LI44J1 =9<C ;/4 82;4 <= 94:403; <= :<3B <= ;/01 F68DC47;I0;/50A49;B;<94:<E49;/412C4=9<C ;/4<I749<=;/4<==47807DE4/0:54 - 10 - 0E /4 2C<67; 843<10;48 A4=<94 ;/01 <69; 01 ;9271C0;;48;<;/4:<7:4974890A6725 )* &" ' $ )* &!$%!' $ 01;<!5<!)"