- 1 - !" #"$%"% !! &'$( ) ! ! ! " # $ % $ &' % ( " )) Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * * * ( *&%+ * * ) !%! * * ) ) * &!' # ) &%+ * * ) ! *) * ) ) # , ) $ $" -./011203./4.32567011233089/524285089:/9: ! 1;07.8< 9: /29 0/.52 9-2 =>5<?289 085 52@;22 50925 ! 10//25 .8 :&%+ 67 9-2 28.:; .A.3 )>5<2-0-01>; -2 ;2/1:85289 130.89.44 -05 4.325 />.9 0<0.8/9 011233089/ 524285089/ :/ 9: ! .8 :%! /22B.8< ;23.24 :4 52@30;09.:8 9-09 130.89.44 ./ :C82; :4 0<;.@>39>;033085620;.8<7:&%?20/>;.8<'0@;2/ !+<>890/:407703.330<2-0-01>;03>B 050<.; - 3 - 5./9;.@9 -2 130.89.44 @:8928525 9-09 -2 ./ :C82; 085 1: p. 2 :; :4 />.9 3085 0;3.2; -./ 409-2; C0/ :C82; 085 1: p. 2 :; :4 9-2 />.9 3085 492; 9-2 5209- :4 130.89.44D/ 409-2;9-2130.89.44./.81: p. 2 .:808528=:7?289:4/>.9 3085 0/ 06/:3>92 :C82; 0;3.2; .8 B-0/0;0 10-08. :4 9-2 />.91;:12;97;2432@9259-280?2:4130.89.44D/409-2;3092; 524285089:/085!C.9-:>9B8:C325<2085@:8/289:4 9-2 130.89.44 085 -./ 409-2; 62-.85 9-2.; 60@B 5232925 9-2 80?2 :4 130.89.44D/ 409-2; 085 <:9 2892;25 B-0;.= B-090 /0;0B0;..89-2;2@:;5/:4;.<-9:49-2/>.91;:12;97-2 /0.55:@>?289/C2;22892;25.89-2;2@:;5:4;.<-9/:49-2 />.91;:12;97./C.9-:>908760/./-2130.89.44<:9.//>25 8:9.@2 9: 524285089 :/ 9: ! >852; 2@9.:8 /22B.8<@:;;2@9.:8/:4;2@:;5:4;.<-9/:4/>.930850859: 2892; 9-2 80?2 :4 130.89.44 8/1.92 :4 /2;A.@2 :4 8:9.@2 524285089/ 5.5 8:9 <.A2 087 ;2137 9: 9-2 32<03 8:9.@2 -2;24:;2 130.89.44 C0/ 4.325 />.9 4:; 52@30;09.:8 085 .8=>8@9.:8 - 4 - ! 24285089 : -0/ 4.325 C;.9928 /9092?289 5287.8< 0A2;?289/ :4 130.89 085 @0/2 :4 9-2 130.89.44 24285089:@:89285259-099-2/>.91;:12;97./B-0;.= B-09089-2720;E9-230859:9-22F9289:4 & 0@;2/ !' <>890/ .8 7 :& C0/ <;08925 9: :82 0350850110 .8<0880 08@-.803 085 ;2?0.8.8< 1;:12;97 9: 9-2 2F9289 :4 ' 0@;2/ !+ <>890/ .8 9-2 /0.5 />;A27 8>?62; ./ $-0;.= B-090 -2 />.9 1;:12;97 -0/ 6228 @:8/.52;25 0/ B-0;.= B-090 /.8@2 ( 085 9-2 />.9 1;:12;97 623:8</ 9: 9-2 :A2;8?289 24285089 : @:8928525 9-09 130.89.44 -0/ 8: .892;2/9 :A2; 9-2 />.9 1;:12;970851;07254:;5./?.//03:49-2/>.9 & 8 9-2 60/./ :4 /0.5 13205.8</ 9-2 9;.03 :>;9 -0/4;0?254:33:C.8<.//>2/G - 5 - ! " # -2 130.89.44 -0/ 6228 2F0?.825 0/ # 2F0?.8259C:C.982//2/0/# 085!085<:9?0;B25 5:@>?289/0/F9:24285089/-0A28:93205087 2A.528@2-29;.03:>;90492;-20;.8<0;<>?289/:86:9- /.52/ 085 011;2@.09.8< 2A.528@2 :8 ;2@:;5 -0/ 08/C2;25 .//>2 :/ 9: & .8 9-2 82<09.A2 085 5./?.//25 9-2 />.9 C.9-@:/9 ' <<;.2A25 67 9-2 /0.5 =>5<?289 :4 9-2 9;.03 :>;9 9-2 130.89.44 -0/ 4.325 011203 .8 :&%+ 624:;29-24.;/911233092:>;9-24.;/911233092:>;9 0492; -20;.8< 0;<>?289/ :8 6:9- /.52/ -0/ 4:;?>30925 1:.89/4:;@:8/.52;09.:8G !" # - 6 - $%&' ( $)* +,- . '*/0 1 2 # 3 4#5 + -2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 -0/ 08/C2;25 1:.89 :/ 085 .8 9-2 044.;?09.A2 085 10//25 .?1><825 =>5<?289033:C.8<9-201120308552@;22.8<9-2/>.9:49-2 130.89.44 085 52@30;25 130.89.44 ./ :C82; 085 1: p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n Civil Appeal No.1760/2022 decided on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eported in AIR 2014 SC 937 - 9 - 1;:5>@25 03:8< C.9- /0.5 05A08@2?289 0113.@09.:8 .2 /-2/-03010-08.08510//259-2.?1><825=>5<?2892 4>;9-2; />6?.9/ 9-09 .8 044.50A.9 4.325 03:8< C.9- 05A08@2?2890113.@09.:89-2;2./?289.:89-099-2130.89.44 C0/ 011233089 9-2;2.8 ./ 4.3.8< 0113.@09.:8 >852; ;52; & >32+:42/>6?.9/9-099-24.;/911233092:>;9 ;2@:;5/5:2/8:9@:890.80870113.@09.:84.325>852;;52; &>32+2/>6?.9/9-099-2/0.55:@>?289;23.25 >1:8 67 9-2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 <:2/ 9: ;::9 :4 9-2 ?0992; 085 .9 ./ ;232A089 9: 52@.52 6229C228 10;9.2/ 2 4>;9-2; />6?.9/ 9-09 011233089/ C-: C2;2 524285089/ 624:;2 9-2 9;.03 :>;9 -0A2 8:9 3205 087 2A.528@2 085 @:8/.52;.8<9-2/0?29-29;.03:>;9-0/08/C2;25.//>2/ :!.89-282<09.A2-:35.8<9-09524285089/:./40.325 9: 1;:A2 9-09 9-2 />.9 1;:12;97 ./ :A2;8?289 3085 2 4>;9-2;/>6?.9/9-09.49-2?0992;./;2?085259:9-24.;/9 11233092:>;94:;@:8/.52;.8<9-20113.@09.:8>852;;52; &>32+:40855:@>?289/1;:5>@25679-2130.89.44 .89-24.;/911233092:>;9C.33 ?229285/:4=>/9.@22 - 10 - 4>;9-2; />6?.9/ 9-09 0/ 12; =>5<?289 085 52@;22 10//25 67 9-2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 9-2 011233089/ -2;2.8 .2 524285089/ -0A2 ?>90925 9-2 80?2 :4 9-2 130.89.44 .8 ;2@:;5:4;.<-9/:49-2/>.91;:12;970859-2;24:;21;2/289 01120362@:?2.84;>@9>:>/ 0A.8< -20;5 320;825 @:>8/23/ 9-./ :>;9 -0/ 12;>/25 9-2 .?1><825 =>5<?289 9;.03 :>;9 ;2@:;5/ 085 011233092:>;9;2@:;5/ ! -2 130.89.44 -0/ /:><-9 52@30;09.:8 :4 9.932 :4 9-2 />.9 1;:12;97 24285089/ -0A2 528.25 9-09 9-2 130.89.44 ./ :C82; :4 9-2 />.9 1;:12;97 24285089/ @:89285259-099-2/>.91;:12;97./:A2;8?2893085-2 130.89.44 -0/ ?0;B25 :82 :4 9-2 />.9 1;:12;97 :4 9-2 720; E! C-2;2.8 .8 @3:( 9-2;2 ./ ?289.:8 :4 B-0;.= B-090 /0;0B0;. F@219 9-2 /0.5 :4 9-2 />.9 1;:12;978::9-2;5:@>?289/0;21;:5>@25C.9-;2<0;59: 9.932:49-2/>.91;:12;97-2130.89.44-051;:5>@25:9-2; D/ :4 9-2 />.9 1;:12;97 C-.@- C2;2 1-:9: @:1.2/ 9-2;24:;2 9-27 C2;2 8:9 ?0;B25 085 :8 12;>/03 :4 9-2 - 11 - 9;.03 :>;9 ;2@:;5/ 9-2 /0.5 1-:9: @:1.2/ 0;2 0A0.30632 -2 9;.03 :>;9 :8 :;03 085 5:@>?2890;7 2A.528@2 .2 F-0/-2359-099-2130.89.44-0/40.3259:1;:A2-./9.932 :A2;9-2/>.91;:12;9724285089/-0A28:93205087:;03 2A.528@20858:91;:5>@250875:@>?289/-29;.03:>;9 03/:-2359-09524285089/-0A240.3259:1;:A29-099-2/>.9 1;:12;97./:A2;8?2893085 & 8 9-2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 0492; 9-2 ?0992; 62.8< -20;5 085 C-28 9-2 @0/2 C0/ 1:/925 4:; 1;:8:>8@2?289 :4 =>5<?289 :8 !& @:>8/23 4:; 9-2 011233089 -0/ 4.325 08 05A08@2?289 0113.@09.:8 :8 !&03:8<C.9-044.50A.9:49-2130.89.440859-2;2./ 08 285:;/2?289 :8 9-2 /0.5 0113.@09.:8 .2 1>9 >1 9-2 @0/2 :8 9-2 /0?2 507 A28 9-:><- 9-2;2 ./ />@- 285:;/2?2899-24.;/911233092:>;9-0/8:9@:8/.52;25 C-79-2/0.505A08@2?2890113.@09.:8./4.32589-2:;52; /-22950925&&.9./?289.:8259-09=>5<?289./ 8:9;2057085?0992;-0/62281:/925:8'&4:; - 12 - 1;:8:>8@2?289:4=>5<?28989-2044.50A.928@3:/25C.9- 05A08@2?2890113.@09.:8.9./?289.:8250/>852;G #3 !*!*+ - ,,4 56 ! ) 2 %% , 71 % .( 1 # 11233092:>;9;2@:;5/03/:@:890.8/5:@>?289 .2 /-2/-030 10-08. -2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 -0/ ;242;;25 9-2 /0.5 /-2/-030 10-08. .8 9-2 .?1><825 =>5<?28908560/25:89-09<;08925;23.249:9-2130.89.44 A28 9-:><- .8 9-2 /0.5 044.50A.9 9-2;2 ./ ?289.:8 :4 130.89.444.3.8<0113.@09.:8>852;;52;&>32+:4 8: 0113.@09.:8 ./ 4:;9- @:?.8< .8 9-2 011233092 :>;9 ;2@:;5/-24.;/911233092:>;9C.9-:>99-2;262.8<087 0113.@09.:8>852;;52;&>32+:4-0/@:8/.52;25 9-25:@>?2891;:5>@25679-2130.89.44C-:C0/011233089 9-2;2.8 .8 9-2 .?1><825 =>5<?289 -2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 :><-9 9: -0A2 3./925 9-2 ?0992; 60/25 :8 9-2 /0.5 05A08@2?289 0113.@09.:8 :8 && 9: @:8/.52; C-7 - 13 - />@- 05A08@2?289 0113.@09.:8 -0/ 6228 ?:A25 4 9-2 /0.5 ?0992; C0/ 3./925 4:; />@- 0/12@9 9-28 9-2 130.89.44 :><-99:-0A24.325080113.@09.:8>852;;52;&>32+ :4 0/ /90925 .8 -./ 044.50A.9 4.325 03:8< C.9- 05A08@2?2890113.@09.:8 ' 20;825 @:>8/23 4:; 9-2 ;2/1:85289 130.89.44 C:>35@:892859-09@:8/.52;.8<9-2/0.55:@>?289679-2 4.;/911233092:>;9./8:91;:12;085@:;;2@99-2130.89.44 /-:>35 8:9 62 521;.A25 :4 08 :11:;9>8.97 9: 1;:5>@2 5:@>?289 03:8< C.9- 0113.@09.:8 >852; ;52; & >32 + :467;2?085.8<9-2?0992;9./;.<-90/@:8928525 67320;82555.9.:8035A:@092282;034:;011233089/9-09 9-2 130.89.44 -0/ 9: 1;:A2 -./ 9.932 627:85 033 ;20/:80632 5:>69/0/-23567:8D63212F:>;9.89-2@0/2:4 % & + 89-23.<-9:406:A2@.;@>?/908@2/9-2130.89.44 /-:>35 8:9 62 521;.A25 :4 08 :11:;9>8.97 :4 /22B.8< 12;?.//.:89:1;:5>@2055.9.:8032A.528@29:2/9063./--./ 9.932 :A2; 9-2 />.9 1;:12;97 -2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 -0/ - 14 - 2;;25.8@:8/.52;.8<9-25:@>?289C.9-:>99-2;262.8<087 0113.@09.:8 >852; ;52; & >32 + :4 085 <;089.8< ;23.249:9-2130.89.44C-:C0/0112330899-2;2.8 8 A.2C :4 9-2 06:A2 9-2 130.89.44 /-:>35 62 <.A2808:11:;9>8.979:4.32080113.@09.:8>852;;52;& >32 + :4 /22B.8< 12;?.//.:8 9: 1;:5>@2 055.9.:803 2A.528@2 0/ 12; -./ 05A08@2?289 0113.@09.:8 4.325 624:;2 9-24.;/911233092 :>;9 0854:; 9-09 9-2 ?0992; ;2H>.;2/ 9:62;2?0852560@B9:9-24.;/911233092:>;9 ( 8 A.2C :4 06:A2 />6/9089.03 H>2/9.:8/ :4 30C 0;208/C2;250@@:;5.8<3789-2;2/>399-24:33:C.8< . -2011203./''( .. -2 =>5<?289 085 52@;22 10//25 67 9-2 4.;/9 11233092 :>;9 .8 :&%+ 67 28.:; .A.3)>5<2-0-01>;.//290/.52 ... -2 ?0992; ./ ;2?08525 60@B 9: 9-2 4.;/9 11233092:>;94:;<.A.8<08:11:;9>8.979:9-2 130.89.44 C-: C0/ 011233089 9-2;2.8 9: 4.32 08 - 15 - 0113.@09.:8 >852; ;52; & >32 + :4 /22B.8< 12;?.//.:8 9: 1;:5>@2 055.9.:803 2A.528@2 .A 0;9.2/ 0;2 5.;2@925 9: 01120; 624:;2 9-2 4.;/9 11233092:>;9:8! A -2130.89.44C-:C0/0112330899-2;2.8/-0334.32 08 0113.@09.:8 >852; ;52; & >32 + :4 :8! A. -24.;/911233092:>;9/-033@:8/.52;9-2/0.5 0113.@09.:8 .80@@:;508@2C.9-30C 0855./1:/2 :49-2011203 A.. 285 60@B 9;.03 :>;9 085 11233092 :>;9 ;2@:;5/ 9: 11233092 :>;9 C.9- @:17 :4 9-./ =>5<?2894:;9-C.9- *' &%"%( $ ./9: 3: