Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66570 (KAR)
M/S PRUDENTIAL PROPERTIES v. THE JOINT COMMISSIONER
WP/202518/2025 · 2025-11-04
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66570 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66570 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$%
&%'!%!%
(!)
! " #
"" ! $
"
$
! $
"
%
$ &
"
& '
(
"
"!$
"
#
" $
)
" ! $
*&
&
( "
"! $
*&
%
$
! ' ! "
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
"
#
# $ "
*
&*&
(
$
& '
$
$ & $
(
+
( #
&
# # ,$
&
"
$ "
" #
-
- .$ &' &&&! - .$ &' &&&! /0 1023234506 37 809460 2/37 4:62 700;35< 94==4>35< 60=309,7-
! "
#$
"
%
&
'
" (""
)#
#$) *
# +
)$, ""! *
)$ -$ .,
!') ,
/ "
"
, )
""
)
- 3 -
' 0
'
, ""
))
$ '
"
""
) %
* '' '
/ )/
'
. 1 (#)
' *$
*, ,' ' '* '
, '
2
,& ' 3 $ 4
& /0 1023234506 37 60<372060? >32/ 2/0 01@62A0524944?7@5?06B3C0@D>32/2/060<3726@2345
4& +
*)( 45 +&&*& /@2 @ 7/4> C@:705423C0?@20?&&E>@7377:0?8F607145?052
4&9462/010634?*+16414735<24?0A@5?@5? =0C263C32FC/@6<07"
@5?C/@6<07@5?2/035206072 452/080=@20?93=35<49602:657E$9462/07/462 1@FA05249&/@22/01023234506>@7@=74706B0?>32/ 2/07:AA@6F7/4>C@:705423C0?@20?&&E3546A 8F 607145?052 4&& /060@9206" @5 46?06 ?@20? E&E& >@7 1@770? 8F 607145?052 4&" C45936A35< 2/0 ?0A@5? A@?0 8F 607145?052 4&& /0 7@3? 46?06 >@7 1@770? >32/4:2 8050932 49 /0@635< 2/0 1023234506& $035< @<<630B0?" 1023234506 74:</2 946 60C2393C@2345492/07@3?0D1@62046?068F93=35<@11=3C@2345
- 4 -
45 +&E&" >/3C/ C@A0 24 80 60G0C20? B3?0 05?4670A052 ?@20? &E&" @7 2/0 @11=3C@2345 946 60C2393C@2345>@793=0?80F45?2/010634?49+?@F7&$035< @<<630B0?" 1023234506 /@? 16090660? @ >632 10232345 35 #&& 4&&/374:62?371470?492/07@3?>632 10232345 60706B35< =38062F 24 2/0 1023234506 24 @B@3= 2/0 @=2065@23B060A0?F:5?062/0164B373457490C234549 2/0
C2"&023234506/@?@CC46?35<=F93=0? @5@110@=8094602/0607145?052 4&
110==@20@:2/4632F& $F46?06?@20?&*&"607145?052 4&"60G0C20?2/0 7@3? @110@= 45 2/0 <64:5?492/07@A0 /@B35< 8@660? 8F =3A32@2345& $035< @<<630B0?" 2/0 1023234506 37 809460 2/37 4:62& E& 0@650? C4:570= 946 2/0 1023234506 603206@235< 2/0<64:5?7352/0A0A46@5?:A49102323457:8A3272/@2 @50D1@620@?G:?3C@234546?06>@71@770?8F607145?052
4& 45 E&E&& /0 7@3? 46?06 C@A0 24 2/0 ;54>=0?<0 49 1023234506 >/05 2/0 8@5; @CC4:52 49 2/0 1023234506,7 >@7 @22@C/0? 946 2/0 1:61470 49 60C4B06F 49
- 5 -
2/0 & 023234506 7445 2/060@9206 /@? 16090660? @5 @11=3C@2345 700;35< 60C2393C@234549 2/0 @?G:?3C@2345 46?06& /0 7@3? @11=3C@2345 >@7 60G0C20? @7 2/0 7@A0 /@? 8005 93=0? 80F45? + ?@F7& 0@650? C4:570= 946 2/0 1023234506 7:8A327 2/@2 2/0 @110@= >/3C/ >@7 93=0? @<@3572 2/0 7@3?
46?06/@7@=74800560G0C20?8F607145?052 4&?0C=3535< 24 C45?450 2/0 ?0=@F 49 E* ?@F7& 0 7:8A327 2/@2 2/0 607145?052 4:</2 24 /@B0 2@;05 3524 C4573?06@2345 2/0 ?@2049;54>=0?<0&/:7"392/0=3A32@234537C@=C:=@20?@7 7:C/"2/0?0=@F>4:=?80@84:2+?@F7& & 0 60=307 :145 2/0 46?067 1@770? 8F 2/0 4 46?35@20$05C/492/374:62"352/073A3=@6>632102323457" 5@A0=F" 3#&& 4&*+*?@20?&&" 33#&& 4&+?@20?*&&" 333#&& 4&?@20?&E&" 3B#&& 4&+?@20?*&E&"@5? B#&& 4&*?@20?&&&
& 0=F35< :145 2/0 46?067 1@770? 8F 2/0 4 46?35@20$05C/492/37C4:62@7@84B0"2/0=0@650?C4:570=
- 6 -
242/010232345067:8A3272/@22/023A0C457:A0?3593=35< 2/0 >632 10232345 35 #&& 4& @5? 327 ?37147@= 3&0&"802>005&&24&&3760H:360?2480 0DC=:?0?& & 0@650? @110@635< 946 2/0 607145?0527 ?407542?371:202/09@C22/@2:5?062/073A3=@69@C27@5? C36C:A72@5C07 49 2/0 A@2206" 2/0 446?35@20 $05C/07 49 2/37 4:62 /@? C45?450? 2/0 ?0=@F @5? 60A3220? 2/0 A@2206 24 607145?052 4& 24 C4573?06 2/0 A@2206 45 327 A06327&35C02/0102323450637@=7473A3=@6=F732:@20?"2/37 4:62?4542700@5F60@745542240D205?2/0805093249 C45?45@2345 49 ?0=@F 35 160906635< 2/0 @110@= :5?06 2/0 9@C2:@=7C05@6346090660?24/06035@84B0& & 52/@2B30>492/0A@2206"2/094==4>35<-
@ /010232345371@62=F@==4>0?& 8 /0 46?06 ?@20? &*& 1@770? 8F 607145?052 4&?0C=3535<24C45?4502/0?0=@F @5? C4570H:052=F 60G0C235< 2/0 @110@= 37 702
- 7 -
@73?0& 0=@F 49 + ?@F7 35 160906635< 2/0 @110@=37C45?450?& C @22063760A3220?24607145?052 4&
110==@20 @:2/4632F" >/4 7/@== >32/4:2 @?B06235< 24 2/0 377:0 49 =3A32@2345" 164C00? 24 @?G:?3C@20 :145 2/0A06327492/0C@70@9206@9946?35<7:993C3052 411462:53230724 2/01@62307@5?1@77 46?067 35 @CC46?@5C0>32/=@>&
!*+ (%!%) '
372 4&-= 4&-E -!