- 1 - !" # $%# $%!%"! ## &"' () ## *+ ( ) ! " # $%&'$()' * + " Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #) + & &$))$ ) ,#+ ++ -($$( * +). + + # + + " $#))$% " #')$' / + + + +" 0 - 3 - *+( ) ,#+ ++ -($$( 1 ,#+ ++ -($$( * ($ ! " ,$ $%&'$()' - 4 - ) #) + & &$))$ * + " . %)$) ) ++ + + # + " $#))$% #')$' " +/ + " 2 " 2 " " - 5 - % 2 " +3)$$))$)$4564789!:;<84=>?@89A74B=; ?@4=C;<8D8=98=A:36;<45DD87;<8A74B=;9489=9 <45 78C7 @8D@858=;;4E85 <E8 !88= B98 5 D@;485. F<8@85 +3)$$,#$)$) 45 64789 !: ;<8 =5?@=A8 3BD=:?=98@8A;43=#36;<83;3@8<4A785A; %'' <8@84=6;8@ @868@@89 ;3 5 G;<8 A;/ 63@ 5<3@; A<778=C4=C ;<8 >?9CB8=; =9 F@9 9;89 $#))$% D5589 !: 997 8=43@ 4E47 "?9C8 =9 7!?@C44=35#')$' ) +A;5 C4E4=C @458 ;3 ;<8 6474=C 36 ;<8 DD875 !@4867: 5;;89@8;<;3=$,$,)$;!3?;#DBF<8=;<8 A74B=;&<4E74=CDD 73=C F4;< <45 =8D<8F F8@8 D@3A8894=C 3= B3;3@A:A78 !8@4=C @8C45;@;43= 3& #) &%) =8@ 377?@ E477C8 3= 7!?@C4&6H7D?@ B4=@39;;<;;4B8 A@?458@"88D!8@4=C@8C45;@;43= 3&)#&')) !84=C 9@4E8= !: 4;5 9@4E8@ ; <4C< 5D889=94=@5<=9=8C74C8=;B==8@95<89;3;<8 - 6 - E8<4A78 36 ;<8 A74B=; 5 @85?7; 36 ;<8 63@8549 AA498=;;<8A74B=;5?5;4=89C@48E3?54=>?@485=9F5 <35D4;74H89 # <8A74B=;64789D8;4;43=?=98@8A;43=((36;<8 A;588I4=CA3BD8=5;43= ;F5D78989;<;<85D8=; 54C=464A=;B3?=;;3F@95B894A78JD8=585A3=E8:=A8 A<@C85 =9 3;<8@ @87;89 A35;5 ; F5 6?@;<8@ D78989 ;<; ;<8 AA498=; 3AA?@@89 53787: 3= AA3?=; 36 @5< =9 =8C74C8=;9@4E4=C36;<83668=94=CE8<4A78!:4;59@4E8@ , D3= 58@E4A8 36 =3;4A8 ;<8 @85D3=98=; 35 DD8@89;<@3?C<A3?=587!?;=3;64789F@4;;8=5;;8B8=; =9 @85D3=98=; 3) DD8@89 ;<@3?C< A3?=587 =9 64789 F@4;;8= 5;;8B8=; 98=:4=C ;<8 E8@B8=;5 B98 4= ;<8 A74BD8;4;43= = ;<8 !545 36 ;<8 D7894=C5 36 ;<8 D@;485 ;<8 74B5@4!?=76@B89;<8455?85=9;<8@86;8@@8A3@989 - 7 - ;<8 8E498=A8 <8 @4!?=7 !: 4BD?C=89 >?9CB8=; =9 F@9<5D@;7:773F89;<8A74BD8;4;43==9<879;<; ;<8 A74B=; 45 8=;4;789 ;3 A3BD8=5;43= 36 5$$)$$&73=CF4;<4=;8@85;;;<8@;836(KD =9 94@8A;89 ;<8 =5?@=A8 3BD=: ;3 98D354; ;<8 A3BD8=5;43= B3?=; 73=C F4;< 4=;8@85; 84=C CC@48E89 ;<8 D@858=; DD87 <5 !88= 64789 !: ;<8 4=>?@89A74B=; ( ?@4=C ;<8 D8=98=A: 36 ;<45 DD87 <4E74=CDD 94899?8;3AA498=;74=>?@485<8@863@8<45F468=953= <E8!88=!@3?C<;3=@8A3@95<4578C7@8D@858=;;4E85 <878@=89A3?=58763@;<8DD877=;5&A74B=;5<5 A3=;8=989 ;<; <4E74=CDD B8; F4;< @39 ;@664A AA498=;3=,$,)$9?8;3@5<=9=8C74C8=;9@4E4=C36 9@4E8@ 36 "88D !8@4=C @8C45;@;43= 3&)#&')) ?8 ;3 ;<8 AA498=; <8 <5 5?668@89 C@48E3?5 4=>?@485 <8@863@8 <8 64789 A74B D8;4;43= !863@8 ;<8 @4!?=7 588I4=C A3BD8=5;43= 36 5$$$$$$& 3=5498@4=C ;<8 - 8 - =;?@8 36 4=>?@485 5?668@89 !: <4E74=CDD ;<8 @4!?=7 <5C@=;89A3BD8=5;43=365$$)$$&73=CF4;< 4=;8@85; 84=C CC@48E89 !: ;<8 5B8 <8 D@868@@89 = DD87 !863@8 ;<45 A3?@; 588I4=C 63@ 8=<=A8B8=; 36 A3BD8=5;43= ?@4=C ;<8 D8=98=A: 36 ;<45 DD87 <4E74=CDD 9489 9?8 ;3 AA498=;7 4=>?@485 8=A8 <45 F468=953=<E8A3B83=@8A3@9578C7@8D@858=;;4E85 36 ;<8 98A8589 <4E74=CDD 3 D@3E8 ;<8 5B8 ;<8: <E8 64789 = DD74A;43= ?=98@ @98@ , ?78 ) 36 D@39?A4=C 994;43=7 93A?B8=;5 455?89 !: 894A7 664A8@ ;<; ;<8 98A8589 9489 9?8 ;3 ;<8 AA498=;7 4=>?@485 8=A8 ;<8: 53?C<; 63@ A3=E8@;4=C ;<45 DD87 F<4A< 45 64789 588I4=C 8=<=A8B8=; 36 A3BD8=5;43= 63@ ;<8 AA498=;7 4=>?@485 5?5;4=89 !: <4E74=CDD 5 ;<8 DD87 588I4=C A3BD8=5;43= 63@ ;<8 98;< 36 <4E74=CDD ' 8@=89 A3?=587 DD8@4=C 63@ ;<8 =5?@=A8 3BD=: <5 A3=;8=;89 ;<; ;<8 A3BD8=5;43= F@989 !:;<8@4!?=74=;<8A58364=>?@:453=;<8<4C<8@5498 - 9 - ; 45 5?!B4;;89 ;<; 6;8@ , :8@5 36 ;<8 AA498=; ;<8 A74B=; <4E74=CDD 9489 8=A8 ;<8@8 45 =3 =8J?5 !8;F88=;<898;<=9;<8AA498=;<8DD877=;5<E8 64789 )$),63@D@39?A;43=36994;43=793A?B8=;563@ ;<864@5;;4B8!863@8;<453?@;<8@845=33DD3@;?=4;:63@ ;<8 =5?@=A8 3BD=: ;3 945D?;8 ;<8 5B8 8 6?@;<8@ A3=;8=989 ;<; ;<8 4=5?@89 <5 E437;89 ;<8 D374A: A3=94;43=<8 =5?@=A83BD=:45=3;74!78;3D:;<8 A3BD8=5;43= ; 45 5?!B4;;89 ;<; ;<8 4=5?@89 <9 =3 D8@B4; ;3 D7: ;<8 E8<4A78 4= @=;I <8@863@8 ;<8 =5?@=A83BD=:45=3;74!78;3D:A3BD8=5;43= % <8 98A8589 <4E74=CDD F<3 5?668@89 = AA498=;7 4=>?@: 4= ;<8 AA498=; 3AA?@@89 3= $,$,)$ 9?8 ;3 ;<8 =8C74C8=A8 36 ;<8 9@4E8@ 36 ;<8 "88D !8@4=C @8C45;@;43= 3&)#&')) 9489 3= $)$) 3F ;<8L?85;43=45F<8;<8@;<898;<36<4E74=CDD459?8;3 ;<8AA498=;74=>?@:3@=3; $ <8@863@8;<878@=89A3?=58763@;<8DD877=;5<5 A3=;8=989 ;<; ;<8 98;< 36 <4E74=CDD 45 9?8 ;3 - 10 - AA498=;7 4=>?@: <8 5B8 <5 !88= 945D?;89 !: ;<8 =5?@=A8 3BD=: = 3@98@ ;3 D@3E8 ;<8 A58 ;<8 A74B=;5 <E8 64789 )$), 588I4=C 63@D@39?A;43= 36 994;43=793A?B8=;5455?89!:894A7664A8@4=A8;<45 45 945D?;89 L?85;43= 36 6A;5 ;<8 B;;8@ @8L?4@85 ;3 !8 @8A3=5498@89!:;<8@4!?=7 =E48F36;<8!3E8F8@836;<83D4=43=;<;;<8 B;;8@ @8L?4@85 ;3 !8 @8B4;;89 !AI ;3 ;<8 @4!?=7 AA3@94=C7:;<863773F4=C3@98@45D5589 3;<;<8DD875@8,--./0 ! "?9CB8=; =9 F@9 D5589 !: ;<8 @4!?=74558;5498 A <8B;;8@45@8B4;;89!AI;3;<8@4!?=7 F4;< 74!8@;: ;3 !3;< ;<8 D@;485 ;3 6478 =8A855@: DD74A;43= 63@ B8=9B8=; =9 63@ 99?A4=C 994;43=7 8E498=A8 =9 D@39?A4=C994;43=793A?B8=;5 - 11 - 9 <8 @4!?=7 45 94@8A;89 ;3 A3=5498@ ;<8 5B8 6;8@ C4E4=C 3DD3@;?=4;: ;3 !3;< ;<8 D@;485 4= AA3@9=A8 F4;< 7F=9D55DD@3D@4;83@98@ 8 <8 D@;485 @8 94@8A;89 ;3 DD8@ !863@8 ;<8 @4!?=7 3= ))$) F4;<3?; F4;4=C 63@ =: 6?@;<8@ =3;4A8 6 <8 @4!?=7 45 94@8A;89 ;3 945D35836 ;<8 A74B D8;4;43= F4;<4= ( B3=;<5 6@3B ;<8 9;8 36 DD8@=A8 36 ;<8 D@;485 C B3?=; 4= 98D354; 45 ;@=568@@89 ;3 ;<8 @4!?=7 <8 @4!?=7 45 94@8A;89 ;3 I88D ;<8 549 B3?=; 4= 64J89 98D354; <8 5B8 45 5?!>8A; ;3 64=7 945D35736;<8A74BD8;4;43= - 12 - < 664A84594@8A;89;3@8;?@=;<83@4C4=7 93A?B8=;5 D@39?A89 73=C F4;< )$), ;3 ;<8 DD877=;5 6;8@ @8;4=4=C;<8M8@3JA3D:36;<85B8 0( &#' % 0( &!%"!' % 45;373,$