Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66562 (KAR)
M/S BASAVARAJ PATIL CONTRACTOR v. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
WP/201595/2025 · 2025-12-02
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66562 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66562 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
$#%!#!#
&!'
!"#"""
$
%
& '(
)* ' +'
*"#"
%
& '(
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
,
(
- * *'
$*"
"$
)* (
* ,#$ )*
(
*
,&( (
-
. .
/
'
& ./
'
(
0123 4256789:6 1; 306 <635351962 5= 3083 26=<19>693 1*8?301253@59;?2306289:631306=01A:8?=69135:683 996B?26*08=<8==6>30612>62>836>,#$8=<62 996B?26* ?9>62 6:3519 &C( 1; 306 ' 89> :3:8DD594?<19306<63535196231<8@89844264836 =?E 1; =#,##* A05:0 59:D?=576 1; 593626=3 89> <698D3@;12306;5989:58D@682C*
- 3 -
68296>:1?9=6D;12306<635351962=?FE53=3083 30619D@268=19;123068==6==5941;;5:62310876:1E631 306 :19:D?=519 1; <8@E693 1; =?:0 D58F5D53@ 5= 919* <21>?:35191;:1<56=1;30684266E693A05:0A8=693626> 5931 F@ 306 <635351962*8==6==66 A530 306 E859 :19328:312 ;126B6:?35191;A12G:19328:36F2594=313069135:61; 3061?23<828428<011;306=01A:8?=69135:6A05:0 5=265362836>83<828428<011;<8461;3065E<?496> 12>62 6 ;?23062 =?FE53= 3083 301?40 306 26<26=69383576 1; 306 <635351962 08> 8<<6826> F6;126 306 26=<19>693* ==6==594;;5:62306>1:?E693=:1?D>913F6;?295=06>8= 306 <635351962 A8= ?9>6241594 32683E693 ;12 087594 F669 >58491=6>1;$89>">5=G:1DD8<=6A53028>5:?D1<830@ 8384821=<538D6948D?2?6=?FE53=3083F6:8?=61;
306 6B54693 :52:?E=389:6= 306 >1:?E693= :1?D> 913 F6 ;?295=06> 31 306 8==6==594 1;;5:62 3021?40 306 26<26=69383576 26=?D3594 59 306 5E<?496> 12>62 087594 F669<8==6>6;?23062=?FE53=5;301=6>1:?E693=A626 ;?295=06> 306 D58F5D53@ A1?D> 0876 >28=35:8DD@ 26>?:6>
- 4 -
69:6 06 =66G= ;12 89 1<<123?953@ 31 F6 <2175>6> 6 ;?23062 =?FE53= 3083 306 =85> 84266E693= 826 306 2645=3626> 84266E693= 693626> 5931 F63A669 306 <635351962*8==6==66 A530 306 17629E693 8?30125356= 0626;126 06 =?FE53= 3083 E626 919*<21>?:3519 1; 306 =85> >1:?E693 ;12 306 268=19= 8= 8F176 =08DD 913 F6 306 421?9> ;12 >6<257594 306 <635351962 1; 89 1<<123?953@ 1; F65940682>F@30626=<19>693*8?301253@
68296>301?4026=5=3=89>59=5=3=3083306 <635351962 08= 89 8D3629836 26E6>@ 1; ;5D594 89 8<<68D 01A6762 ;852D@ =?FE53= 3083 5; 8 35E6 <6251> 5= ;5B6> >526:3594 306 <635351962 31 ;?295=0 306 >1:?E693 89> 306 8==6==5941;;5:6231<8==8<<21<2583612>62306<?2<1=61; <6353519F6=6276> $ 682><62?=6>30626:12>=
" 0619D@268=19A05:05=;1230:1E594;21E306 =01A :8?=6 9135:6 <21>?:6> 83 996B?26* 89> 306 5E<?496> 12>62 83 996B?26* A01 826 306 26=<19>693*
- 5 -
8==6==5948?301253@318==6==89><8@306=0123<8@E693 1; 306 38B ;12 306 <6251> ;5989:58D <6251> C* 5= 919 <21>?:35191;306A12G:19328:3A05:08>E5336>D@693626> 5931F63A669306<63535196289>30638368?30125356=89> 306=?F*:19328:312=59;?2306289:631A12G:19328:35==?6> F@ 306 3836 8?30125356= 59:6 306 =85> >1:?E693= 826 2645=3626> >1:?E693= 306 8?306935:53@ 1; A05:0 <25E8* ;8:56=389>=6=38FD5=06> , 06 26:12> <21>?:6> 83 996B?26* 59>5:836 3083 306 <635351962 83 26D67893 35E6 A8= ?9>6241594 32683E693;1205=$89>">5=::1DD8<=6=30626;12630626 5=;12:659306=?FE5==519E8>6F@D68296>:1?9=6D;12306 <635351962 3083 06 A8= 59:8<8FD6 1; ;?295=0594 306 =85> >1:?E693 19=5>62594 05= 068D30 306 421?9> 89> 306 =?FE5==519 E8>6 F@ D68296> :1?9=6D ;12 306 <82356= 305= 1?23<8==306;1DD1A594H
&8( 06<63535195=8DD1A6>
- 6 -
&F( 06 5E<?496> 12>62 83 996B?26* 5= I?8=06> &:( 06 E83362 5= 26E5336> 31 306 26=<19>693* 8==6==5941;;5:62 &>( 06 <635351962 =08DD =?FE53 306 26=<19=6 31 306 =01A :8?=6 9135:6 83 996B?26* 8D194 A530 306 >1:?E693= A05:0 5= =1?403 31 F6 <21>?:6> A53059 >8@= ;21E 306 >836 1; 26:65<31;:6235;56>:1<@1;305=12>62 &6( 0626=<19>6938?301253@=08DD306268;362<8== 12>62 A53059 >8@= ;21E 306 >836 1; =?FE5==5191;306=85>>1:?E693=
!() &#!#' %
5=31.D1.
. '