Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66557 (KAR)
GOVERDHAN FINANCE (R) v. ANNARAO S/O GURUBASAPPA BIRADAR
CRL.A/200121/2023 · 2025-09-18
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66557 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66557 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$""
"!! %&
%'!()*+%((
,
!"
# $%&%'#
()&"
'#'#'#(
)!"#''*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+
$"
+
,- ./012345356 45 /)!"#''* /5 6,- 742- /7 6,- 2-385-9 845.4132
4:42 ;9<- 359
36 323=;83<4 >7/8 ?,/86 @6,- 8432
/;86AB 4? 401;<545< 6,- C;9<0-56 936-9 '#'#'#( 3.D;46645< 8-?1/59-56$3..;?-9 7/8 6,- /77-5.- 1;54?,3=2- ;59-8 -.64/5 (& /7 -</643=2- 5?68;0-56? .6&&>7/8?,/86@6,- .6AB
# ,- 73.6? /7 6,- .3?- 45 =84-7 38- 6,36 6,- ./012345356 =-45< 3 74535.- ./0135E 742-9 184:36- ./0123456 45 /%)(#''& =-7/8- 6,- 8432
/;86 3<345?6 6,- 3..;?-9 322-<45< ./004??4/5 /7 6,- /77-5.- 1;54?,3=2- ;59-8 -.64/5 (& /7 6,- .6 6 4? 6,- ./56-564/5 /7 6,- ./012345356 6,36 46 4? 9/45< 74535.- =;?45-??;59-86,-530-359?6E2-/7@/:-89,354535.- A 5- 3224F38C;5 / ,4:3?,3853113 ;94 G,/ G3? - 3 -
8;5545<=;?45-??;59-86,-530-?84?,3423224F38C;5 59;?68E,393:342-9=-5-746/7
2/35/7?('''''$ ,-3..;?-9?6//93?<;38356/86/6,-?3492/353<8--45< 6/8-13E6,-?30-G46,45*'93E?,-56,-./012345356 45?4?6-9 7/8 8-13E0-56 /7 6,- 2/35 6,- 3..;?-9 4??;-9 .,-D;-7/8?(%'''$3?1-8H$,-56,-.,-D;- G3?18-?-56-97/8-5.3?,0-566,-?30-G3?94?,/5/;8-9 3? 6,-8- G3? 45?;774.4-56 7;59? 45 6,- 3../;56 /7 6,- 3..;?-96/,/5/;86,-.,-D;--<325/64.-G3?4??;-96/ 6,- 3..;?-9 457/8045< ,40 3=/;6 6,- 94?,/5/8 /7 .,-D;- 359.32245<;1/5,406/13E6,-.,-D;-30/;565?146- /7?-8:4.-/75/64.-6,-3..;?-97342-96/8-13E6,-.,-D;- 30/;56 359 6,-8-=E ./00466-9 6,- /77-5.- 1;54?,3=2- ;59-8 -.64/5 (& /7 .6 ,-8-7/8- ,- 8-D;-?6-9 6,- 8432
/;86 6/ 63F- ./<54I35.- /7 6,- /77-5.- 359 6/ 4546436-2-<323.64/5
( ../8945<2E /)!"#''* .30- 6/ =- 8-<4?6-8-9 ,- ./012345356 -H3045-9 46? 0353<45< 13865-8 3? $ 359 </6 038F-9 H?$ 6/ $( 45
- 4 -
?;11/86 /7 46? ./56-564/5 ..;?-9 9-54-9 322 6,- 45.840453645< 036-8432? 3:3423=2- /5 8-./89 =;6 ,3? 5/6 .,/?-5 6/ 2-39 35E -:49-5.- 45 ?;11/86 /7 ,4? 9-7-5.- ,- 8432
/;86 376-8 63F45< 456/ ./5?49-8364/5 322 6,-?- 036-8432? /5 8-./89 13??-9 6,- 401;<5-9 C;9<0-56 3.D;46645<6,-3..;?-9-45<3<<84-:-9=E6,-?30-6,- ./0123453564?=-7/8-6,4? /;86
" -389 06 -03 ;2F3854 2-385-9 ./;5?-2 7/8 6,- 311-22356 359 84 :453?, 123/5F38 2-385-9 ./;5?-2 7/8 6,- 8-?1/59-56 -8;?-9 6,- 036-8432? /5 8-./8945.2;945<6,-8342
/;868-./89? % 5 :4-G /7 6,- 84:32 ./56-564/5? ;8<-9 =E 2-385-9./;5?-27/8=/6,6,-13864-?6,-1/4566,36G/;29 384?-7/80E./5?49-8364/54? E35?G-86/6,-3=/:-1/4564?456,-@A7/8 6,-7/22/G45<
- 5 -
! 64?6,-./56-564/5/76,-./0123453566,366,- 3..;?-9 ,39 ?6//9 3? <;38356/8 7/8 6,-
2/35 /7 ?('''''$ 3:342-9 =E /5- 3224F38C;5 / ,4:3?,3853113 ;94 /G389? 8-13E0-56 /7 6,- 2/35 30/;56 3..;?-9 4??;-9 .,-D;- $ H$ ,- ?30- G3? 94?,/5/;8-93?6,-8-G3?45?;774.4-567;59456,-3../;56 /76,-3..;?-93?1-8H$#-<325/64.-3?1-8H$( G3? 4??;-9 359 ?30- G3? ?-8:-9 /5 6,- 3..;?-9 3? 1-8 H$%,-13865-8?,419--94?3?1-8H$!H?$)6/ '38-6,-9/.;0-56?8-236-96/6,-13865-8?,41H$ 4?6,-31124.364/57/8=422?94?./;56H$#4?6,-18/5/6- H$(4?6,-8-.-416
) 6 4? =8/;<,6 6/ 6,- 5/64.- /7 6,-
/;86 6,36 45464322E 6,- ./012345356 ,3? 2-9 -:49-5.- =E -H304545< $ G46,/;6 038F45< 35E 9/.;0-56?
,- 8432
/;86 45464322E 3.D;466-9 6,- 3..;?-9 =E 13??45< 6,- C;9<0-56 936-9"'!#'(,/2945<6,36$4?5/63;6,/84I-96/ 8-18-?-56 6,- 13865-8?,41 7480 359 6,-8-7/8- ,- .355/6
- 6 -
8-18-?-566,-13865-8?,4174806/034563456,-./0123456 -./592E46G3?,-296,365/9/.;0-56?G-8-038F-9/5 =-,327 /7 6,- ./012345356 359;59-8 ?;., .48.;0?635.-? 6,- 3..;?-9 4? -56462-9 7/8 3.D;46632 -45< 3<<84-:-9 =E 6,-?30-6,-./012345356,3918-7-88-9
8404532 11-32
/(!#*#'( =-7/8- 6,4? /;86 359 32?/ 742-9 35 31124.364/5 ;59-8 -.64/5 (* /7
8
7/8 399464/532 9/.;0-56? ,- 31124.364/5 359 6,- 311-32 .30- 6/ =- 322/G-9 =E 6,4? /;86 :49- /89-8 936-9 #'#'# 359 8-0359-96,-0366-86/6,-8432
/;86G46,24=-86E6/=/6, 6,-13864-?6/2-396,-48-:49-5.-=E18/9;.45<399464/532 9/.;0-56? 6 4? 6,-8-376-8 $ G3? -H3045-9 =-7/8- 6,-8432
/;86359H?$6/$(G-8-038F-9
& ,- ?1-.474. 9-7-5.- 63F-5 =E 6,- 3..;?-9 4? 6,36 $ G3? 5/6 3;6,/84I-9 6/ 8-18-?-56 6,- ./012345356 5 6,4? 8-<389 0E 366-564/5 G3? 983G5 6/ 6,-13865-8?,419--9038F-93?H$! 23;?-$&/76,- 13865-8?,419--98-39?3?;59-8
- 7 -
! " # $ %
$ &$ '
(&
%
$
$
%
$
#) %
*+ -01,3?4??;1124-9
=38-8-3945</76,-.23;?-03F-?46.2-386,36-:-56,- 0353<45< 13865-8 ,3? 6/ =- 3;6,/84I-9 =E 6,- /6,-8 13865-8?6/8-18-?-566,-74804535E2-<3218/.--945<? * 6 4? 1-8645-56 6/ 5/6- 6,36 45464322E 6,- ./0123456 .30- 6/ =- 94?04??-9 359 6,- 3..;?-9 G3? 3.D;466-9 =E 6,- 8432
/;86 :49- C;9<0-56 936-9
"'!#'( /5 ?404238 <8/;59 6,36 $ G3? 5/6 3;6,/84I-9 6/ 8-18-?-56 6,- 13865-8?,41 7480 :-5 376-8 8-0359 =E 6,4? /;86 1-8046645< 6,- ./012345356 6/ 18/9;.- 399464/532 9/.;0-56? 359 6/ 399;.- /832 -:49-5.- 5/ ?;.,3;6,/84I364/5 G3?18/9;.-9 =-7/8- 6,- 8432
/;8659-8?;.,.48.;0?635.-?9/5/6745935E
- 8 -
8-3?/56/,/296,366,-./0123453564?8-18-?-56-9=E35E 3;6,/84I-91-8?/5
' E 366-564/5 G3? 32?/ 983G5 =E 6,- 2-385-9 ./;5?-27/86,-8-?1/59-566,36$G3?5/6,3:45<35E F5/G2-9<- 3=/;6 6,- 6835?3.64/5 359 -:-5 6,/;<, 6,- 24.-5?-6/.388E/56,-74535.-=;?45-??G3?18/9;.-93? 1-8H$'6,-?30-G3?7/86,-?;=?-D;-561-84/94- 78/0''"#''&6/('(#'(G,4.,4?5/631124.3=2-6/ 6,-6835?3.64/545D;-?64/564?32?/=8/;<,66/6,-5/64.- /7 6,-
/;86 6,36 6,- ./012345356 4? 35 ;58-<4?6-8-9 13865-8?,41 7480 359 ;59-8 ?;., .48.;0?635.-? 3;6,/84I364/5 4? 3 0;?6 G46, 24.-5?- 6/ .388E /5 6,- =;?45-??7459./5?49-83=2-7/8.-456,-./56-564/563F-5 =E6,-2-385-9./;5?-27/86,-8-?1/59-563596,-8-7/8- 30/76,-/1454/56,366,-3..;?-94?-56462-97/83.D;46632
,3:-</5-6,8/;<,6,-401;<5-9C;9<0-56/7 3.D;46632 13??-9 =E 6,- 8432
/;86 G,4., ,3? 63F-5 456/ ./5?49-8364/5 322 6,- 036-8432? /5 8-./89 359 ,3? 3884:-9
- 9 -
36 6,- 84<,6 ./5.2;?4/5 9/ 5/6 7459 35E 8-3?/5 6/ 456-87-8-G46,6,-?30-
# 5:4-G/76,-3=/:-35?G-86,-3=/:-1/456 456,-@5-<364:-A35918/.--96/13??6,-7/22/G45<
,-
8404532 11-324? -) %""( $
4?6 /2 /#(