- 1 - !"# $ % & && '#( ) ! " # $ %"# & % %' ' ! " '%( # ' ' )*"# ' + ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) % ) % %% ' + ' ' ' + , % -./0- 1-2 344235 67 567128 9.: 38;6776.< =61- 1-2 >.<72<1 .9 523:<28 >./<725 9.: 1-2 43:1627 61 67 13?2< /4 9.:96<358674.735 % -67 344235 67 96528 3036<71 1-2 @/80;2<1 3<8 3=3:8 83128 % %% 437728 AB 1-2 88616.<35 2<6.: 6C65 /802 3<8 . 6@3B34/:3 6< . ).9% ) * -2>536;3<13028 B23:78.6<030:6>/51/:2 =.:?;21=61-3<3>>682<1.<% D% 3<87/7136<28 0:62C./76<@/:27-2:29.:2-2965283>536;421616.<A29.:2 1-2 :6A/<35 >536;6<0 >.;42<7316.< .9 7 =61- 6<12:271 31 E 43 -2 :6A/<35 >.<7682:6<0 1-2 - 3 - 2<16:2 2C682<>2 .< :2>.:8 0:3<128 >.;42<7316.< .9 7%$ % =61- 6<12:271 31 E 43 9:.; 1-2 8312 .9 421616.<1655:23567316.<3<886:2>128:274.<82<1..=<2: 1. 824.761 1-2 73;2 3<8 1-2 <7/:3<>2 .;43<B =37 2F.<2:31289:.;1-2563A6561B $ 00:62C28AB1-27368@/80;2<13<83=3:81-2 6<@/:28 >536;3<1 -37 4:292::28 1-67 344235 8674/16<0 1-2 G/3<1/; 37 =255 37 563A6561B 3<8 >.<12<828 1-31 -2 7/7136<289:3>1/:2.9:60-192;/:3<86<@/:627355.C2:1-2 A.8B(1-28.>1.:377277281-28673A6561B31% E1.%%E1. 1-2 :60-1 5.=2: 56;A A/1 1-2 :6A/<35 -37 13?2< 1-2 8673A6561B 31 .<5B )E 2 =37 23:<6<0 7 42: ;.<1- A/1 1-2 :6A/<35 -37 13?2< -67 6<>.;2 .<5B 31 7 42: ;.<1- 3<8 ;230:2 3;./<17 3:2 0:3<128 /<82: .1-2: -2387 1-2:29.:2 :2G/27128 9.: 2<-3<>2;2<1 .9>.;42<7316.<1679/:1-2:>.<12<8281-3161673>372 .9 <. 8:6C6<0 56>2<>2 3<8 :25628 /4.< 1-2 @/80;2<1 6< - 4 - 3<8:2G/271289.:43B3<8:2>.C2:B.:82: 23:81-23:0/;2<17.9A.1-76827 -2 3442553<1 -37 7/7136<28 867453>28 7-391 9:3>1/:2 .9 :60-1 92;/: 2 -37 86996>/51B 6< 7G/3116<0 76116<0>:.77520?<2256<03<8713<86<0.<3992>12843:19.: 5.<016;23<81-2:2=37;6581.;.82:312=3716<0.9:60-1 1-60-;/7>527 >.;43:281. 5291 7682 3<81-/7 1-2 8.>1.: 377277281-28673A6561B31% E1.%%E1.1-2:60-15.=2: 56;A-28.>1.:7131281-311-29:3>1/:273:2>.;452125B /<61283<86<12:5.>?6<0<36596F281.1-2:60-11-60-6771655 761/3128 -2 :6A/<35 -37 :60-15B 13?2< *:8 .9 1-2 7368 8673A6561B37)E3<861<2287<.6<12:92:2<>2-./0-1-2 3442553<1 713128 1-31 -2 =37 23:<6<0 7 42: ;.<1--2-37<.14:.8/>283<B6<>.;24:..9-2:29.:2 371-23>>682<167.91-2B23:% 3742:1-20/68256<27 .9 1-2 H3:<313?3 1312 2035 2:C6>27 /1-.:61B -67 <.16.<356<>.;2671.A213?2<317) 42:;.<1- 1 (2018) 3 SCC 208 - 5 - 2 =37 3028 D B23:7 3<8 1-2:29.:2 1-2 ;/5164562: =37 :60-15B 13?2< 37 IDJ -/7 1-2 5.77 .9 9/1/:2 23:<6<07 =./58A2 7) F%FDF)EK7* ) -2 :6A/<35 -37 3=3:828 3< 3;./<1 .9 7 )*% 1.=3:87;286>352F42<7273<861<2287<.1 6<12:92:2<>2 -2 3442553<1 =37 38;61128 6< 1-2 -.746135 9.: 83B7 .<7682:6<01-2<31/:2 .96<@/:6273<842:6.8.9 -.74613567316.< 1-67 ./:1 96<87 61 :237.<3A52 1. 0:3<1 3< 3;./<1.97 9.:436<3<87/992:6<07* 9.: 5.77 .9 3;2<61627 3<8 7* 9.: 1:3<74.:1316.< 2F1:3<./:67-;2<13<83112<83<1>-3:027 D -2 3442553<1 ;60-1 <.1 -3C2 3112<828 3<B =.:? 31 52371 9.: 3 42:6.8 .9 9./: ;.<1-7 8/2 1. 1-2 6<@/:6277/7136<28-2:29.:21-67./:196<8761:237.<3A52 1.0:3<13<3;./<1.97$) "7) F$#9.:5.77 .96<>.;28/:6<05368/442:6.8 - 6 - 2<>21-23442553<1672<1615289.:1-2;.869628 >.;42<7316.</<82:86992:2<1-238737A25.= 36<3<87/992:6<0 7 286>352F42<727 7 )*% .77.99/1/:223:<6<07 7* .77.96<>.;28/:6<05368/442:6.8 7$) :3<74.:1316.<2F1:3<./:67-;2<13<8 3112<83<1>-3:027 7* .77.93;2<61627 7* *+, -. / 0 -/7 1-2 3442553<1 67 2<161528 9.: 1-2 1.135 >.;42<7316.< .9 7*%D% =61- 6<12:271 31 E 42: 3<</; -2:6A/<35-3793712<281-22<16:2563A6561B.< :274.<82<1 ..=<2: .9 1-2 C2-6>52 3<8 :274.<82<1 .%<7/:3<>2 .;43<B =37 2F.<2:3128 9:.; 1-2 563A6561B.=2C2:3761673>372.9<.8:6C6<056>2<>21-67 ./:196<8761:237.<3A521.:25B/4.<1-2@/80;2<1.91-2 .<JA52 42F ./:1 6< ">61287/4:3#3<8.:82:9.: 43B 3<8 :2>.C2:B 1. 1-2 <7/:3<>2 .;43<B -2:29.:2 :274.<82<1 .% <7/:3<>2 .;43<B 67 86:2>128 1. - 7 - 824.761 1-2 1.135 >.;42<7316.< .9 7*%D% =61- 6<12:27131E43=61-56A2:1B1.:2>.C2:1-273;29:.; :274.<82<1..=<2:.91-2C2-6>52 % <1-2:27/511-29.55.=6<0.:82:67437728 "6# 4423567355.=286<43:1 "66# -2 3442553<1 >536;3<1 67 2<161528 9.: 1-2 1.135 >.;42<7316.< .9 7*%D% =61- 6<12:271 31 E 42: 3<</; 9:.; 1-2 8312 .9 421616.<16551-28312.9:2356L316.< "666# 274.<82<1 .%<7/:3<>2 .;43<B 6786:2>1281.824.7611-239.:27368>.;42<7316.< 3;./<1 =61-6< .<2 ;.<1- 9:.; 1-2 8312 .9 1-67 @/80;2<1 .=2C2: 1-2 <7/:3<>2 .;43<B 67 31 56A2:1B 1. :2>.C2: 1-2 7368 3;./<1 9:.; :274.<82<1..=<2:.91-2C2-6>52 "6C# < 7/>- 824.761 1-2 3442553<1 67 42:;61128 1. =61-8:3= 1-2 2<16:2 3;./<1 35.<0 =61-6<12:2713>>:/28.<61 -10 '& ( % 671. 5.$