Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66549 (KAR)

ANNEPPA S/O SANGANBASAPPA TANDOOR v. KALYANAPPA S/O NOORANDAPPA TANDUR

RSA/7413/2010 · 2025-10-09

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$%$ $ && ' ( ) !" ! #" $ % & %' %'' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "! " ( ! !" ( !# ) & ! !" ( * * - 3 - # * # % & #**!' $ % ( & %' %')%'+ %&'%' %&'%'* ' & & ( *, "* & ( %' ( - -! **, & ( %(' & & ( .( % $ % .( ' /01234567082330295:;<4/03925745==2::25957>4/0 ?@8>A074278801B00B0780B08;<4/0&5B:4330992406@B4 57 6 *, C/0B057 4/0 801B00 B0780B08 ;< 4/0 - 4 - B529 6@B4 5: B0D0B:08 278 4/0 :@54 6= 4/0 3925745== 5: 85:A5::08 /0 85D0B>074 =57857> 5: :@;?01408 46 :01678 233029;<4/03925745== * &6B 4/0 :2E0 6= 167D0750710 4/0 32B450: 2B0 B0=0BB08462:30B4/05BB27E;0=6B04/0 B5296@B4 # /0=2A59<4B00B028:2:@780B %' %'%' %'%' %'%' %' %' %F'%' %F*'%F#'% &&' ! &214:902857>:464/012:02B02:@780B /0 6B5>5729 3925745== 72A09< 770332 57:454@408 2 :@54:00E57>280192B245676=6C70B:/53278167:0G@074529 36::0::5676=4/0:@543B630B4< /0:@;?014A2440B6=4/0 - 5 - :@54 5: 27 698 B0:58074529 /6@:0 C/51/ 5: 28A544089< 27 2710:4B29 3B630B4< /0 3925745== :3015=51299< 1925A08 6C70B:/53 6D0B 2 36B4567 6= 4/0 /6@:0 ;02B57> 27829 271/2<246F!# :/6C7 57 B081696@B 278A2BE082: H 57 4/0 /278 :E041/ 2770I08 46 4/0 392574 /0 :E041/ 80351457>4/00745B0B0:58074529/6@:0C2:29:6=59082967> C54/4/0392574 " 116B857> 46 4/0 3925745== 4/0 0745B0 /6@:0 6B5>57299<;0967>08463B636:54@:27>2332C/6/28=6@B :67:J@782332 /5D2;2:2332 2A:/0442332 278 /2B272332 /0 3925745== B03B0:074: 4/0 ;B271/ 6= @7823324/00980:4:67C/5904/080=078274:B03B0:074 4/0 ;B271/ 6= /5D2;2:2332 4/0 :01678 :67 4 C2: 4/0 :3015=51 1674074567 6= 4/0 3925745== 4/24 4/0B0 C2: 2 32B454567 2A67> 4/0 :67: 6= 3B636:54@: 27>2332 @780B C/51/ @782332 C2: 29964408 36B4567: H 278 H 57 4/0 :E041/+ /5D2;2:2332 4/0 =24/0B 6= 80=078274 6 C2: 29964408 36B4567 H+ 278 /2B272332 C2: 29964408 36B4567 HC/51//0:@;:0G@0749<:6984680=0782746 - 6 - /0 3925745== =@B4/0B 2D0BB08 4/24 36B4567: H 278 H ;64/ 2::5>708 @7515329 6F!# B0A25708 57 4/0 0I19@:5D0 36::0::567 6= /5: ;B271/ C/590 36B4567: H 278 H ;0967>08 46 80=078274 6: ;B271/ 278 C0B0 2::5>708 @7515329 6F!! 4 C2: 29:6 167407808 4/24 36B4567: H 278 H C0B0 :427857> 57 4/0 72A0 6= 275E2332 4/0 0980B :67 6= /5D2957>2332 7 4/0 <02B -,#4/0B0C2:276B2932B454567;04C007275E2332278 /5:;B64/0B:%:67:6=/5D2957>2332'@780BC/51/36B4567 HC2:2996440846@782332%80=0782746#'27836B4567 H C2: 29964408 46 27>27;2:2332 4/0 =24/0B 6= 4/0 3925745== /0 3925745== ;057> 4/0 :67 6= 27>27;2:2332 4/B6@>/ /5: :01678 A2BB52>0 1925A08 46 /2D0 80B5D08 6C70B:/534/B6@>/4/0:2586B2932B454567 B2157> /5: 45490 4/B6@>/ 4/0 :258 =2A59< 2BB27>0A074 278 6B29 32B454567 6= -,# 4/0 3925745== 2::0B408 2;:69@40 6C70B:/53 6D0B 36B4567 H 57 4/0 /278 :E041/ /0 :@54 C2: =5908 67 4/0 >B6@78 4/24 80=078274 - 7 - 6278/5::67:/28=6B15;9<42E0736::0::5676=4/0:@54 :1/08@90 3B630B4< A2BE08 2: 36B4567 H 278 /28 807508 4/03925745==:454904/0B0;<7010::542457>4/03B0:074214567 =6B80192B2456727836::0::567 , 367:0BD5106=:@AA67:80=078274:6:46 # 0740B08 23302B2710 278 =5908 2 CB54407 :4240A074 :3015=51299< 85:3@457> 4/03925745==: 1925A /0<167407808 4/24 4/0 85:3@408 36B4567 H C2: 57 =214 29964408 46 /278B2332 4/0 ;B64/0B 6= 4/0 3B636:54@: 27>2332 4 C2:=@B4/0B1674078084/2436B4567H574/0392574:E041/ %;02B57> 6F!#' ?65749< ;0967>08 46 4/0 3925745== 278 80=078274:6:*278#C/0B02:36B4567HC2:4/0:/2B0 6=/278B2332C/51/2=40B/5:80A5:080D69D08@367670 66B2782332 0=078274 6 1925A0846;04/0 2863408 :67 6= 66B2782332 278 67 4/24 ;2:5: 2::0B408 6C70B:/5327836::0::5676D0B4/085:3@40836B4567H - 2:08 67 4/0 B5D29 3902857>: 4/0 B529 6@B4 =B2A084/07010::2B<5::@0:64/:580:288@1086B29278 - 8 - 861@A0742B< 0D580710 57 :@336B4 6= 4/05B B0:30145D0 1925A: 367 2 80425908 233B25:29 6= 4/0 A240B529 67 B016B8 4/0 B529 6@B4 27:C0B08 ::@0 6 57 4/0 2==5BA245D0 /69857> 4/24 4/0 3925745== /28 :@1100808 57 3B6D57> /5: 6C70B:/53 6D0B 4/0 85:3@408 36B4567 A2BE08 H574/0/278:E041/%27829271/2<246F!#' /0 6@B427:C0B08::@06*574/070>245D06;:0BD57>4/24 80=0782746/28=25908460:42;95:/4/244/0:25836B4567 =6BA08 32B46= 3B630B4<;02B57> 6F!! 67:0G@0749< ::@06#C2:27:C0B08574/02==5BA245D0 2784/0:@54 C2: 801B008 80192B57> 4/24 4/0 3925745== 5: 4/0 6C70B 6= 4/085:3@40836B456727885B01457>80=078274646/278 6D0BD2127436::0::5674/0B06= 057>2>>B50D08;<4/0?@8>A074278801B006= 4/0 B5296@B480=07827463B0=0BB0827233029;0=6B0 4/0&5B:4330992406@B4 /0330992406@B4B0D0B:084/0 =57857>:6=4/0 B5296@B43B5A2B59<674/0>B6@784/244/0 3925745==/287640740B084/0C5470::;6I;@4/28:6@>/4 46 288@10 0D580710 4/B6@>/ /5: =24/0B 21457> @780B 2 - 9 - 070B29 6C0B 6= 446B70< /0 33099240 6@B4 635708 4/24 4/0B0 C2: 76 30BA5::567 >B27408 =6B :@1/ B03B0:07424567 278 4/0B0=6B0 85:12B808 4/0 0D580710 :6 40780B08 /0 &5B:4 33099240 6@B4 C/590 578030780749< B0F233B0152457> 4/0 0D580710 =@B4/0B B016B808 2 =57857> 4/24 4/0 2990>08 6B29 32B454567 6= -,# C2: 764 :@;:427452408 ;< 16>074 0D580710 /0 33099240 6@B4 6;:0BD084/244/0861@A074:3B68@108;<4/03925745==858 7640:42;95:/4/244/085:3@40836B4567A2BE082:H574/0 /278:E041/C2:0D0B2996440846/5:;B271/574/0=2A59< 32B454567 67:0G@0749< 4/0 233029 C2: 2996C08 278 4/0 :@54C2:85:A5::08 * /085D0B>074=57857>:6=4/0 B5296@B42784/0 &5B:4330992406@B42B076C@780B1/29907>0;0=6B04/5: 6@B4 /5:6@B4/2D57>=6@784/24:@;:4274529G@0:4567: 6= 92C 2B5:0 =6B 167:580B24567 28A54408 4/0 233029 D580 6B80B82408* - 10 - # 02B8 4/0 902B708 16@7:09 =6B 4/0 233099274 3925745== 2784/0 902B708 16@7:09 =6BB0:3678074 6 80=078274624907>4/ ! 0=6B04/5:6@B428D0B4:464/012:067/278 800A: 54 =54 46 0I2A570 4/0 :@;:4274529 G@0:4567: 6= 92C C/51/B0282:@780B ! " #$# " # %&'( # ) - 11 - *+,-./0+12314,04/,562*14/05,7 " 7 4/0 3B0:074 12:0 4/0 233099240 16@B4 /2: B0D0B:08 4/0 C099FB02:6708 ?@8>A074 6= 4/0 4B529 16@B4 :6909< 67 4/0 >B6@78 4/24 4/0 070B29 6C0B 6= 446B70< %'/6980B/28764:6@>/44/030BA5::5676=4/06@B4 ;0=6B0 8036:57> 2: 2 C5470:: @1/ 2 =57857> C54/ 8@0 B0:3014 5: A5:167105D08 278 1674B2B< 46 4/0 :044908 3B5715390:6=92C>6D0B757>4/00D5807452B<16A30407106= 2/6980B 4 5: 2 C099F0:42;95:/08 3B636:54567 4/24 2 /6980B 860: 764 B0G@5B0 3B56B 30BA5::567 6= 4/0 6@B4 46 0740B4/0C5470::;6I2788036:03B6D58084/040:45A67< :6@>/446;0>5D075: C54/57/5:30B:6729E76C908>0 /0 3B6D5:567: 6= 4/0 680 6= 5D59 B6108@B0 278 4/0 4240 5D59@90:6=B2145104/6@>/B0G@5B57>902D06=4/06@B4 =6B236C0B6=2446B70</6980B46K23302B278214L5739210 6= 2 32B4< =6B 4/0 3@B36:0 6= 1678@1457> 3B6100857>: 86 764 0I4078 46 B0:4B51457> :@1/ 2 30B:67 =B6A >5D57> 0D580710 2: 2 C5470:: 67 =214: C54/57 /5: 30B:6729 - 12 - E76C908>0 /0B0G@5B0A0746=30BA5::567233950:679<46 4/0B5>/46=2@850710278B03B0:07424567764464/02146= 8036:57>2:2C5470:: 7104/0/6980B5:30B:67299< 2C2B06=4/0=214:575::@02785:16A3040744640:45=<46 4/6:0 =214: /5: 0D580710 127764 ;0 0I19@808 A0B09< 67 4/0 >B6@78 4/24 /0 858 764 :00E 3B56B 30BA5::567 46 8036:0 7 4/0 57:4274 12:0 4/0 /6980B 5: 7670 64/0B 4/27 4/0 =24/0B 6= 4/0 3925745== /0 3B630B450: 57 G@0:4567 2B0 28A544089< 2710:4B29 278 =6BA 32B4 6= 4/0 1632B1072B< 3B630B450: 4/24 6B5>57299< ;0967>08 46 4/0 3925745==:>B278=24/0BC/65:29:64/0=24/0B6=4/03B0:074 /6980B /0B0=6B0 4/0 /6980B ;057> 2 85B014 A0A;0B 6= 4/0 1632B1072B< 278 /2D57> C5470::08 4/0 =2A59< 2BB27>0A074: 29964A074: 278 07?6<A074 6= 4/0 2710:4B29 3B630B450: 5: 1902B9< 16A304074 46 8036:0 B0>2B857> 4/0 724@B0 36::0::567 278 07?6<A074 6= 4/0 =2A59<3B630B450:5:0D5807105:764;2:0867/02B:2<6B 4/5B8F32B4< 57=6BA24567 ;@4 :40A: =B6A /5: 30B:6729 - 13 - E76C908>0 21G@5B08 2: 2 1632B1070B 278 2: 670 85B0149< 57D69D0857=2A59<2==25B: , /07 4/0 C5470:: /2: 85B014 278 5745A240 E76C908>0 6= 4/0 :@;?014 A2440B 57 4/5: 12:0 4/0 =2A59< 3B630B450:4/05B6B5>572784/016@B:06=80D69@45674/0 G@0:45676=B0G@5B57>:30152930BA5::567=B6A4/06@B446 40:45=<860:7642B5:0 /0/6980B:16A3040710=96C: 764A0B09<=B6A4/02@4/6B54<167=0BB08;<4/057:4B@A074 6= 36C0B 6= 2446B70< ;@4 =B6A /5: 6C7 36:54567 278 30B:6729 E76C908>0 2: 2 =2A59< A0A;0B /0 @3B0A0 6@B4 57 !"# /2:192B5=5084/242/6980BA2<8036:0B0>2B857>=214: C54/57 /5: 30B:6729 E76C908>0 278 214: 8670 ;< /5A 57 0I0B15:0 6= 4/0 36C0B >B27408 4/6@>/ /0 127764 8036:0 67 A2440B: 4/24 2B0 0I19@:5D09< C54/57 4/0 3B5715329: 30B:6729 E76C908>0 /0 3B5715390 9258 86C7 4/0B057 :G@2B09<:@336B4:4/016A304071<6=4/0/6980B574/0 3B0:07412:0 - 14 - - /023309924016@B4/2:4/@:0BB085785:12B857> 4/0 40:45A67< 6= 4/0 /6980B 67 2 /<30BF401/75129 >B6@78 4/24 76 3B56B 30BA5::567 C2: 6;425708 /07 4/0 =214::/6C4/244/0/6980B/5A:09=5:275740>B2932B4 6= 4/0 1632B1072B< 278 5: 30B:67299< 21G@257408 C54/ 4/0 =2A59< /5:46B< 278 3B630B4< 2==25B: /5: 8036:54567 5: 764 679< 16A304074 ;@4 29:6 6= /5>/0B 3B6;245D0 D29@0 4/27 4/24 6= 4/0 3925745== C/6 80B5D08 /5: E76C908>0 =B6A 4/0 :2A0 :6@B10 /0 B0?014567 6= :@1/ D5429 0D580710 67 4/0 >B6@78 6= C274 6= 30BA5::567 80=024: 4/0 078: 6= ?@:4510 2785:1674B2B<46;64/4/090440B278:35B546=4/092C * 116B857>9< 57 4/0 3B0:074 =214@29 A24B5I 4/0 /6980B ;057> 4/0 =24/0B 6= 4/0 3925745== 278 2 1632B1070B574/0=2A59<C2:=@99<16A304074468036:0 278 76 :032B240 30BA5::567 6= 4/0 6@B4 C2: 054/0B B0G@5B08 6B 7010::2B< /0 233099240 16@B4: B02:6757> 46 4/01674B2B<5:@7:@:42572;9027880:0BD0:46;0:042:580 - 15 - *+,-./0+12314,04/,562*14/05,7 * 7 2 A0451@96@: 0I2A5724567 6= 4/0 /278F :E041/0: 3B68@108 ;< ;64/ 4/0 3925745== 278 80=078274 6 4/0 4636>B23/< 278 167=5>@B24567 6= 4/0 2710:4B29 B0:58074529 /6@:0 2B0 @785:3@408 /0 :@54 B09240: 46 2 36B4567 6= 4/0 8C09957> 4/24 :/2B0: 2 16AA67 074B2710 D0B2782 =2157> 02:4 /0 ;@59857> 2: 8095702408 57 4/0 :E041/0:16A3B5:0:2702:40B7;961E2782C0:40B7;961E :032B2408 ;< 4/0 :258 16AA67 D0B2782 278 2 1074B299< 392108 A257 866BC2< =024@B0: 1/2B2140B5:451 6= 2 4B285456729 16@B4<2B8 32924529 /6@:0 /0 02:40B7 ;961E ;02B: 27829 271/2<24 6F!# 278 5: 54:09= ;5=@B12408 5746 4C6 :@;F36B4567: :54@240 67 4/0 76B4/F02:40B7 278 :6@4/F02:40B7:580:B0:30145D09< /0C0:40B7;961E;02B: 27829 271/2<24 6F!! /@: C/590 6F!! 5: >06>B23/51299<278:4B@14@B299<295>708464/0C0:46F !# 950: 46 4/0 02:4 :3954 5746 4C6 32B4: ;< 4/0 16AA67 D0B27822783B5715329074B2710 /0:3245295807454<6=4/0 ;961E: 2784/05BA@7515329 7@A;0B57> 2:23302B57>=B6A - 16 - 4/0 B016B8 278 4/0 :E041/0: 6= ;64/ :580: 28A54: 6= 76 :0B56@:1/29907>0 ** 6 0:42;95:/ 4/24 4/0 02:40B7 ;961E ;02B57> /6@:0 6F!# =099 46 /5: :/2B0 4/0 3925745== 392108 B0952710 @367 3271/2<24 B0D07@0 B016B8: 30B@:29 6= I:F 46 F# B0D029: 4/24 4/0 36B4567 1925A08 ;< 4/0 3925745==C2:24670:42>02::5>7086 /0F#:0B50: 85:196:0: 4/24 4/0 B0:58074529 /6@:0 6= 4/0 3925745== C2: 02B950BB0=9014082:6F#-2784/2457-,-574/0D0B< :2A0 :0B50: 4/0 85:3@408 02:40B7 36B4567 12A0 46 ;0 B07@A;0B08 2: 6F!# C/0B02: 4/0 C0:40B7 36B4567 B09242;90 46 4/0 ;B271/ 6= 80=078274 6: 2710:46B: :4668 2::5>708 6F!! /0:0 A@7515329 3271/2<24 074B50: 5::@08 24 @785:3@408 36574: 6= 45A0 167:454@40 B0952;90 278 16740A36B2706@: 861@A0742B< 0D580710 A23357> 5807454< 96124567 278 07?6<A074 5>75=512749< ;0=6B0D074@B57>57464/03B66=6=32B4545672=25BB02857> 6= 4/0 CB54407 :4240A074 57851240: 4/24 80=078274 6 /5A:09= 21E76C908>0: 2 32B454567 6= 4/0 B0:58074529 /6@:0 - 17 - ;04C0074/03925745==:;B271/278/5:;B271/+/5:16740:4 5:764464/0=214@A6=32B45456730B:0;@446C/51/:@;F 36B4567 %H' =099 46 C/6A /0 :E041/0: =B6A ;64/ :580: 16BB6;6B2404/092<6@42784B28545672980:5>76=4/0/6@:0 4/0B0;<907857>2::@B2710464/03925745==:12:0675807454< 27896124567 *# = 4/0 0745B04< 6= 4/0 0D580710 4/0 B0D07@0 B016B8:4/0/278F:E041/0:2784/028A5::567:0951540857 4/0 1B6::F0I2A5724567 6= 80=078274 6 5: 167:580B08 /695:451299< 4/5: 6@B4=578: 4/244/0/578 C0:40B736B4567 C2: 29964408 46 4/0 2710:46B: 6= 80=078274 6 278 16BB0:3678:466@:06F!!C/5904/002:40B736B4567 C2:29964408464/02710:46B:6=4/03925745== /085:3@408 36B4567 H 950: 57 4/0 76B4/F02:40B7 G@28B274 6= 4/0 02:40B7;961E0=0782746:80=07105:4/2436B4567H C2: 29964408 46 /278B2332 ;B64/0B 6= 4/0 3B636:54@: 27>2332 278 4/24 @367 /278B2332: 80A5:0 66B2782332 57/0B5408 4/0 :2A0+ 80=078274 6 4/07 1925A: 45490 ;< 28634567 2: 66B2782332: 2863408 :67 - 18 - 6C0D0B761B085;900D580710054/0B3B5A2B<6B:016782B< /2: ;007 3B68@108 46 0:42;95:/ %5' 4/24 36B4567 H C2: 0D0B2996440846/278B2332574/0=2A59<2BB27>0A074%55' 4/080D69@4567@36766B27823326B%555'4/0=214@A278 D295854< 6= 4/0 2990>08 28634567 6= 80=078274 6 ;< 66B2782332 /0;@B80792<:G@2B09<6780=0782746 C/6 B25:08 4/0:0 :301529 3902: 46 9028 1902B 278 16>074 B0;@4429 0D580710 7 4/0 16A39040 2;:0710 6= 27< 28634567800810B0A67<3B66=074B<573@;951B016B8:6B 167:5:40741678@140D5807157>286345676B80D69@45674/0 80=0710B0A257:@73B6D07278:301@9245D0 *! 7 4/0 2;:0710 6= B0;@4429 0D580710 =B6A 80=078274 6 4/0 B529 6@B4: 233B01524567 6= 4/0 6B29 278 861@A0742B< A240B529 32B451@92B9< 4/0 3271/2<24 B016B8: 4/0 28A5::567: 6= 80=078274 6 278 4/0 167:5:4074 4636>B23/5129 72BB245D0 5: :6@78 278 30B:@2:5D0 /0 902B708 B529 (@8>0 @780B466E 2 12B0=@9 2729<:5: 6= B5D29 D0B:567: 278 B021/08 4/0 B02:6708 16719@:567 4/24 4/0 85:3@408 36B4567 H 30B4257: 46 4/0 - 19 - 3925745==: ;B271/ /0 &5B:4 33099240 6@B4: B0D0B:29 5: =@782A074299<=92C085485:16@74: 4/03925745==:0D580710 672401/75129D50CB0>2B857>4/03925745==7640740B57>4/0 C5470:: ;6I 278 4/0 @:0 6= 2 C5470:: C54/6@4 =5B:4 0I2A5757> 4/0 861@A0742B< =6@7824567 278 4/0 28A5::567:574/080=07103902857>:/0B04/0=214@A6= 32B454567 :4278: 0==0145D09< @785:3@408 5740B :0 4/0 3B5715329 ;B271/0: 4/0 33099240 6@B4: 57:5:40710 4/24 4/03925745==B0F3B6D032B45456739210:270BB6706@:;@B807 278 A5:85B014: 4/0 57G@5B<+ 4/0 B029 1674B6D0B:< C2: 29961245676=:@;F36B4567H7644/0611@BB07106=32B454567 54:09= *" < A5:B02857> 4/0 A@7515329 B016B8: 278 6D0B966E57> 4/0 28A5::567: 278 4/0 ;@B807 67 4/0 80=078274: :301529 3902: %32B451@92B9< 28634567' 4/0 33099240 6@B4: =57857>: :@==0B =B6A 30BD0B:54< 278 2A6@74462A5:233B015245676=A240B5290D580710D0767 0G@542;90167:580B24567:=96C57>=B6A4/092<6@4278@:2>0 32440B7B0=901408574/0:E041/0:4/0/29D0::4278;B6289< - 20 - 85:4B5;@408 ;04C007 4/0 ;B271/0: 6= 4/0 3925745== %C54/ 80=078274: * 278 #' 67 4/0 02:4 278 80=078274 6: ;B271/674/0C0:4+4/0330992406@B4:1674B2B<D50C5: 4/@:@7:@:42572;90 * &6B 4/0 =6B0>657> B02:67: 4/0 :@;:4274529 G@0:4567:6=92C=B2A08574/02330292B027:C0B08574/0 0*+,4/8* 57 =2D6@B 6= 4/0 233099274 3925745== 278 2>257:4 B0:3678074 80=078274 6 /0 ?@8>A074 278 801B00 6= 4/0&5B:4330992406@B42B02116B857>9<:042:5802784/0 C099FB02:6708 801B00 6= 4/0 B529 6@B4 5: B0:46B08 67:0G@0749< 4/0 :@54 :4278: 801B008 ;< 80192B57> 4/0 3925745==2:4/06C70B6=4/085:3@40836B4567H5727829 271/2<24 6F!# 278 80=078274 6 5: 85B01408 46 8095D0B D21274 36::0::567 6= 4/0 :258 36B4567 46 4/0 3925745== * &6B4/0=6B0>657>B02:67:4/5:6@B432::0:4/0 =6996C57> - 21 - %5' /02330295:2996C08 %55' /0?@8>A074278801B00B0780B08;<4/0 5D59 (@8>0 %' /571/695 57 *, 82408 "* 5: /0B0;<:042:580 %555' 67:0G@0749< 4/0 ?@8>A074 278 801B00 B0780B08 ;< 4/0 5D59 (@8>0 %(' /571/69557 - -!5:B0:46B08278 2==5BA08 %5D' 66B80B2:4616:4: .9 '$ $( % 5:46*96