- 1 - !"!! ! #$ #%&' $#&& '( ! ) #$ #%&' $#&& ! * #$ #%&' $#&& ' ( !" # $ !" % &' ' ( ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' ' ' ) ' ! "* # ' # ) ' ! ## % &' ' ) + ) #( ) !# ) ,#"#* & #"#* ) *##*( )) $! *#* " " "$ * ) ') ) ' )' ( ," ! ## % &' ' ( - 3 - ) ' ' ' ' ) ' ! "* # ' # ) ' ! "# ! ## % &' ' ) + ) #( ) !# ) ,#"#*& #"#*) *##"#*( ) ' ) )) $! *#* " " "$ * ) ') ) ' *' ( - . * ' ! "# % &' ' ( - 4 - ) ' ' ' ' ) ' ! "* # ' # ) ' ! ## % &' ' ) + ) #( ) !# ) ,#"#*&/ #"#*) *##"#*( ) ' ) ))$! *#* " ""$* )') ) ' ) 0' - 5 - & 0' ( 12 324545/6278 56 75956:; 24545/6 /#""# "#"# <256=:>>?82@/8*:6@324545/6275675956:;24545/6 /#""#$"#"#<256=:>>?82@/#:6@412324545/62756 75956:; 24545/6 /#""**#"# <256= :>>?82@ / 1:A2:337/:>12@4158/?74822B56=4/C?:81412>75956:; 37/>22@56=856545:42@:=:56844129567592/ #"#*/D /926 /;5>2 4:45/6 :;:<?7:=5 54E D/7 412 /DD26>28 3?6581:<;2?6@272>45/68$! *#* " ""$72:@ F541 2>45/6 * /D 6@5:6 26:; /@2 !" &D/7 81/74 GH( 6/F 326@56= 56 /,#"#* /6 412 D5;2 /D 412;2:762@ @@545/6:;5A5;?@=2:6@):;:<?7:=5 # 2:7@75 :;<?7=5;2:762@>/?682;D/7412 324545/627875/3:;B75816:':@:A;2:762@5=1/?74 /A2769264 ;2:@27 D/7 7283/6@264 / I 4:42 :6@ 94 7?6: 1:A:6 ;2:762@ >/?682; D/7 7283/6@264 /#27?82@4129:4275:;8/672>/7@ - 6 - * 6 A52F /D 412 75A:; >/642645/68 ?7=2@ <E 412 ;2:762@>/?682;D/7</414123:745284123/56441:4F/?;@ :7582D/79E>/685@27:45/658 !" E:68F274/412:</A23/5645856412 D/7412D/;;/F56= 283/6@264/#D5;2@412D578456D/79:45/6F541 /926 /;5>2 4:45/6 :;:<?7:=5 :=:5684 :>>?82@ /8 4/ :;;2=56=>/995885/6/D412/DD26>283?6581:<;2?6@27 2>45/68$! *#* " "72:@F5412>45/6*/D 6412<:858/D412D578456D/79:45/6;/@=2@<E7283/6@264 /# ) >:92 4/ <2 72=584272@ 12 3/;5>2 :D427 >/6@?>456=41256A2845=:45/6D5;2@412>1:7=281224:=:5684 412:>>?82@ - 7 - 4 58 412 >/642645/6 /D 412 37/82>?45/6 :8 327 412>1:7=2812245841:4412)>:924/<272=584272@/6 *" #"#* </?4,E2:782:7;5274/72=5847:45/6/D) 7283/6@264/#1:@9:7752@:>>?82@/ >>?82@/ F:8:@@5>42@4/:;>/1/;:6@12?82@4/8?832>4412D5@2;54E /D7283/6@264/# 8:728?;4/DF15>112F:8:<?856= :6@:88:?;456=127:6@472:456=127F541>7?2;4E >>?82@ /8# 4/ ?82@ 4/ :<?82 7283/6@264 /# :6@ :>>?82@ / F:8 56858456= :>>?82@ / 4/ 9:77E 127 6 " #"#* :4 *" 39 :>>?82@ / >:92 4/ 412 1/?82 56 @7?6B26 >/6@545/6 35>B2@ ?3 C?:772; F541 412 56D/79:64 8;:332@ 127 /6 127 >122B :6@ >75956:;;E 564595@:42@4/4:B2:F:E127;5D2283/6@264/#<256= ?6:<;24/4/;27:42412>7?2;4E9242@/?4<E:>>?82@/ 812;2D44129:4759/65:;1/?82:6@84:742@7285@56=56127 3:7264:; 1/?82 6 ," #"#* :4 :</?4 "" 39 :>>?82@ / >:92 4/ 412 1/?82 /D 7283/6@264 /# 35>B2@?3C?:772;F54112756858456=4/826@41257@:?=1427 F541159:<?82@41256D/79:6456D5;41E;:6=?:=28;:332@ - 8 - :6@ >75956:;;E 564595@:42@ 127 :6@ 41272<E 12 1:8 >/995442@412/DD26>283?6581:<;2?6@272>45/68$! *#* " "72:@F5412>45/6*/D 12 832>5D5> >/642645/6 4:B26 <E 412 37/82>?45/6 58 41:4 412 9:775:=2 <24F226 7283/6@264 /#:6@:>>?82@/1:@4:B263;:>2,E2:782:7;5274/ D5;56=/D412D578456D/79:45/6 12:;;2=:45/689:@2<E412 56D/79:6472D27756=4/>7?2;4E9242@/?4<E127<E:>>?82@ /# 4/ :72 <:;@ :6@ =2627:; 56 6:4?72 F541/?4 :6E 832>5D5>@24:5;8 12)>:924/<272=584272@:8:728?;4 /D41256>5@26441:41:@/>>?772@/6 " #"#*:6@:=:56 /6," #"#* 6</4141282@:E854F:8/6;E:>>?82@ / F1/ :<?82@ :6@ :88:?;42@ 412 D5784 56D/79:64 :6@ >/995442@ 412 :;;2=2@ /DD26>28 A26 :>>/7@56= 4/ 7283/6@264 /# 6/62 /D 412 /4127 :>>?82@ 1:A2 >/995442@ 412 /DD26>2 /6 41/82 832>5D5> @:428 6@27 8?>1>57>?984:6>28:9/D412/3565/641:4F15;2D5;56= 412 D5784 56D/79:45/6 :=:5684 :>>?82@ / 7283/6@264 /#1:@7/32@56/4127D:95;E929<278:6@:>>?82@/ - 9 - :8 F2;; <E 9:B56= <:;@ :6@ =2627:; :;;2=:45/68 F15>1 58 6/4 8?DD5>5264 4/ 37/82>?42 4129 26>2 56545:45/6 /D >75956:; 37/>22@56=8 :=:5684 :>>?82@ /8# 4/ 58 56 :<?82/D37/>288/D;:F:6@8:9258;5:<;24/<2C?:812@ , >>/7@56=;E :68F27 412 :</A2 3/564 56 412 :6@37/>22@4/3:88412D/;;/F56= 12>75956:;324545/68:72 12 >75956:; 37/>22@56=8 56545:42@ :=:5684 412 324545/6278:>>?82@ /# 4/ 56 7592 / #"#* /D /926 /;5>2 4:45/6 :;:<?7:=5 54E 72=584272@ D/7 412 /DD26>283?6581:<;2?6@272>45/68$! *#* " " "$ 72:@ F541 2>45/6 * /D 6/F 326@56= 56 /,#"#* /6412 D5;2 /D 412 ;2:762@ @@545/6:; 5A5;?@=2:6@):;:<?7:=5581272<EC?:812@ +' #!!& " 584/;/#,