Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66540 (KAR)
SRI RAJASAB S/O MEERSAB v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.RP/200077/2016 · 2025-07-10
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66540 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66540 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" &
%&
'
(')*+,
' ** -
!! !! ! "#$ %&'
&&(&')
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(&'%
''&'
(#&&'&
$
*
*
' +,-. -/ ,0,12+30 ,2/4 4+,-1+. 56713+4 86- 20+ -+9/3/61:+2/2/61+-,1.-/++-,1,;67., ,4/:,2/44+,-1+./;0 67-2
69+-1<+124+,.+-
0+-+9/3/61:+2/2/61+-/320+,5573+.=063788+-+. ,1 6-.+- 68 5619/52/61 /1 6(#&&'& .,2+. ''&' >?20+-/15/:,4 /1.0,17-86-306-2@-/,4 ,;/32-,2+A 86-20+688+15+3:71/30,>4+71.+-+52/613#"#(&% 68,1.+52/61'(#68 626-+0/54+352
6- 20+ 688+15+ #" 68 3/B <61203 3/<:4+ /<:-/361<+12 86- 20+ 688+15+3 # ,1. ( 68 20-++ <61203 3/<:4+ /<:-/361<+12,1. 86- 20+ 688+15+ &% 68
- 3 -
3/B <61203 3/<:4+ /<:-/361<+12 /3 6-.+-+. >? 20+ -/,4
,;/32-,2+
% ,4/./2?6820+6-.+-685619/52/61,1.3+12+15+=,3 C7+32/61+.>+86-+20+ /-32::+44,2+67-2/1-46(&'% >?20+-+9/3/61:+2/2/61+-
D +,-1+. 7.;+ /1 20+ /-32 ::+44,2+ 67-2 ,82+- 3+57-/1; 20+ -+56-.3 0+,-. 20+ ,-;7<+123 /1 .+2,/4 ,1. >? 5613/.+-+.E7.;<+12.,2+.&&(&')./3</33+.20+,::+,468 20+ ,5573+. ,1. 5618/-<+. 20+ 6-.+- 68 5619/52/61 ,1. 3+12+15+
) +/1; 87-20+- ,;;-/+9+. >? 20+ 3,<+ ,5573+. /3 >+86-+20/367-2/120/3-+9/3/61:+2/2/61
# 3:+-20+50,-;+F30++2<,2+-/,4320+5,3+6820+ :-63+572/61/320,220+-+9/3/61:+2/2/61+-=,320+.-/9+-6820+ 726 /5G30,= >+,-/1; 6!F)"((& 1 '&D&'& ,2 ,>672%&&:<20+3,/.726/5G30,==,3:-65++./1;8-6< 61,4 /44,;+ 26=,-.3 ,3G/ 5573+. =,3 .-/9/1; 20+ 726 /5G30,= /1 -,30 ,1. 1+;4/;+12 <,11+- ,1. =0+1 20+ 726
- 4 -
/5G30,= -+,50+. 7.,.7- 1+,- 20+ -/.;+ 68 5,1,4 6D% .-/9+-6820+726/5G30,=46325612-6469+-20+726/5G30,= ,1.0,.32++-+.20+726/5G30,=2620+-/;023/.+220,2 E71527-+ ,726 -/5G30,= 4632 20+ >,4,15+ 61 ,556712 68 '& <+<>+-3>+/1;5,--/+./120+726/5G30,=,:,-28-6<.-/9+- ,1. 8+44 /126 20+ 5,1,4 <61; 20+ /1<,2+3 2=6 :+-3613 >? 1,<+,3,9,-,E,1./..,::,3732,/1+.;-/+9673/1E7-/+3,1. ./+.6120+3:62
( 0+ 620+- /1<,2+3 ,436 3732,/1+. 3/<:4+ ,1. ;-/+9673/1E7-/+3,1.+9+1162,22+1./1;2620+/1E7-+.:+-3613 20+-+9/3/61:+2/2/61+--,1,=,?8-6<20+3:62,1.20+:+-3613 =06=+-+56<<72/1;6120+3,/.-6,.3+57-+.20+,<>74,15+ ,1.20+/1E7-+.:+-3613=+-+8/-3230/82+.2620+-/<,-?+,420 +12-+ ,3G/ ,1. 20+ :+-3613 =06 3788+-+. ;-/+9673 /1E7-/+3 =+-+,4362,G+1260/;0+-<+./5,45,-+
" 1 -+5+/:2 68 20+ /186-<,2/61 ,1. 20+ 56<:4,/12 ,4,;17- 64/5+ -+;/32+-+. 20+ 5,3+ /1 -/<+ 6'&)&'& 86- 20+ 688+15+3 :71/30,>4+ 71.+- +52/613 #" # ( ,1. &% 68 ,1. 71.+- +52/61 '(# 68 626- +0/54+3 52
- 5 -
/19+32/;,2+. 20+ <,22+- ,1. ,82+- .+2,/4 /19+32/;,2/61 8/4+. 50,-;+30++2
'& +,-1+. -/,4 ,;/32-,2+ 3+57-+. 20+ :-+3+15+ 68 20+ ,5573+. ,1. ,82+- -+56-./1; 20+ 50,-;+ 0+4. 20+ 2-/,4 ,3 ,5573+.:4+,.+.162;7/42? '' 16-.+-26>-/1;06<+20+;7/426820+,5573+.20+ :-63+572/61 +B,</1+. =/21+33+3 56<:-/3/1; 68 /1E7-+. +?+=/21+33+3 6<:4,/1,12 6526- =06 /337+. 20+ $671. +-2/8/5,2+3,1.20+632 6-2+<+:6-2,1.20+$1;/1++- =06:-+:,-+.:62G+250,1.20+19+32/;,2/1; 88/5+-
' -63+572/61 :4,5+. ' .657<+123 56<:-/3/1; 68 6<:4,/12 1C7+32 ,0,H,- -+:6-2 -+:6-23 ,1.$671.+-2/8/5,2+3
' 1 5615473/61 68 -+56-./1; 68 +9/.+15+ 4+,-1+. -/,4 ,;/32-,2+ -+56-.+. 20+ ,5573+. 32,2+<+12 ,3 /3 5612+<:4,2+.71.+-+52/61'68-5573+.0,3.+1/+. ,44 20+ /15-/</1,2/1; 5/-57<32,15+3 >72 ./. 162 :4,5+ ,1? .+8+15++9/.+15+16-0/39+-3/6161-+56-. - 6 -
'% 0+-+,82+- 4+,-1+. -/,4
,;/32-,2+ 0+,-. ,-;7<+123,1.:,33+.20+E7.;<+12685619/52/1;20+-+9/3/61 :+2/2/61+-,1.3+12+15/1;,3-+8+--+.2637:-,
'D 0+,::+,48/4+.>?20+,::+44,12=,3./3</33+.61 <+-/23,1.20+-+,82+-20+,5573+./3>+86-+20/367-2
') -/ ,0,12+30,2/44+,-1+.56713+486-20+-+9/3/61 :+2/2/61+-F,5573+.-+/2+-,2/1;20+;-671.37-;+./120+:+2/2/61 5612+1.+.20,2>62020+67-230,9+162:-6:+-4?,::-+5/,2+. 20+ <,2+-/,4 +9/.+15+ 61 -+56-. 20+-+ =,3 16 1+;4/;+15+ 61 20+ :,-2 68 20+ ,5573+.
/1 .-/9/1; 20+ 9+0/54+ ,1. =-61;4? 5619/52+. 20+ ,5573+. ,1. 0+15+ 0+ 367;02 86- ,446=/1; 20+ -+9/3/61
'# 42+-1,2/9+4? 0+ =674. 5612+1. 20,2 3/15+ 20+ ,5573+./320+614?>-+,.+,-1+-/120+8,</4?+10,15/1;8/1+ ,<671220+3+12+15+<,?>+3+2,3/.+
'( -/++-,1,;67., ,4/:,2/44+,-1+./;0 67-2
69+-1<+124+,.+-37::6-2320+/<:7;1+.E7.;<+12
- 7 -
'" +=674.87-20+-5612+1.20,220+9+-?8,5220,220+ ,5573+. 20+ ,446=+. '& :,33+1;+-3 26 >6,-. 726 /5G30,= /23+48306=31+;4/;+15+6120+:,-26820+,5573+. & + =674. ,436 5612+1. 20+ 8,52 68 726 /5G30,= >+/1; .-/9+1 /1 1+;4/;+12 <,11+- ,1. 20+ ,5573+. >+/1; 20+ .-/9+-6820+726/5G30,=/33:+44+.6725,2+;6-/5,44?>?20+ /1E7-+. +?+=/21+33+3 =063+ 2+32/<61/+3 <732 >+ G+:2 61 0/;0+- :+.+32,4 ,1. 367;02 86- ./3</33,4 68 20+ -+9/3/61 :+2/2/61
' ,9/1; 0+,-. 20+ ,-;7<+123 61 >620 3/.+3 20/3 67-2:+-73+.20+<,2+-/,461-+56-.<+2/5746734? 1 3750 :+-73,4 68 20+ <,2+-/,4 61 -+56-. /2 /3 5-?32,454+,-20,220+,55/.+12,3/36557--+.61'&D&'&,2 ,>672 %&&:< 1+,- 5,1,4 6D% 6161,4F ,3G/ 6,.1+,- 7.,.7- /44,;+ 32,1.3 +32,>4/30+. >? :4,5/1; 1+5+33,-? 6-,4 ,1..657<+12,-?+9/.+15+61-+56-. 7-20+- 20+-+ /3 16 ./3:72+ 20,2 20+ -+9/3/61 :+2/2/61+-/320+.-/9+-6820+688+1./1;726/5G30,=
- 8 -
% 1E7-+. +?+=/21+33+3 0,9+ 3:+5/,44? -+:6-2 20,2 20+-+ =+-+ '& :+-3613 /1 20+ 726 /5G30,= 68 =0/50 ,3,9,-,E ,1. /..,::, 4632 20+/- 4/8+ 61 20+ 3:62 1E7-+. :+-3613 =+-+ 30/82+. >? 620+- 56<<72+-3 61 20+ -6,. /1 ,1 <>74,15+ ,1. 20+? 0,9+ 2,G+1 2-+,2<+12 /1 -/<,-? +,420 +12-+ ,3G/
D 0+ $671. +-2/8/5,2+3 <,-G+. ,3 B'% 26 '" 632 6-2+< +:6-23 <,-G+. ,3 B'& ,1. B'' =674. 56--6>6-,2+20+2+32/<61/+36820+/1E7-+.=/21+33+3
) 6526- =06 +B,</1+. 20+ /1E7-+. :+-3613 ,1. 561.752+. 20+ :632 <6-2+< +B,</1,2/61 0,9+ ,436 >++1 +B,</1+.>+86-+20+67-2,1.,446820+<0,9+37::6-2+.20+ 5,3+6820+:-63+572/61
# -6=1/1; ,44 20+3+ ,3:+523 68 20+ <,22+- ,5573+. ./. 162 688+- 0/3 3,? /1 -+3:+52 68 20+ /15/.+12 ,2 20+ 2/<+ 68 -+56-./1;20+,5573+.32,2+<+12
( 2/33+224+.:-/15/:4+3684,=-+C7/-+316+<:0,3/3 20,2/1,<,22+-6820/31,27-+20+,5573+./3>671.26:4,5+
- 9 -
0/3 9+-3/61 61 -+56-. ,2 20+ 2/<+ 68 -+56-./1; ,5573+. 32,2+<+12
" +56-./1; 68 ,5573+. 32,2+<+12 /3 162 ,1 +<:2? 86-<,4/2? ,1. /2 =,3 86- .7,4 :7-:63+ /-324? 26 ,886-. ,1 6::6-271/2? 86- 20+ ,5573+. 26 +B:4,/1 /15-/</1,2/1; 5/-57<32,15+38671.,;,/1320/<+561.4? /2 =674. ,886-. , 37/2,>4+ 6::6-271/2? 86- ,5573+. :4,5+ 0/3 9+-3/61 ,>672 20+ /15/.+12
& 1 20+ 5,3+ 61 0,1. 20+ ,5573+. 8,/4+. 26 72/4/H+ 20/3 6::6-271/2? >? 3/<:4?
.+1?/1; ,55/.+12 1.+- 3750 5/-57<32,15+35613+C7+15+3/14,=0,9+2686446==0/500,3 >++186446=+.,1.-+F,::-+5/,2+.>?20+4+,-1+.7.;+/120+ /-32::+44,2+67-2
' /+=6820/367-2/120/3-+;,-./337::6-2+.>?20+ :-/15/:4+3 68 4,= +1715/,2+. >? 20+ :+B 67-2 /1 20+ 5,3+ 68
-+:6-2+./1
- 10 -
073 /1 20+ 4/</2+. 356:+ 68 20+ -+9/3/61,4 E7-/3./52/61 =0+1 20+ <,2+-/,4 61 -+56-. /3 -+F,::-+5/,2+. 6-.+-685619/52/61-+C7/-+316/12+-8+-+15+
0+ ,42+-1,2+ 37></33/61 20,2 20+ 3+12+15+ 1++.3 26 >+ -+.75+. >? +10,15/1; 8/1+ ,<6712 5,1162 ,436 >+ 56712+1,15+./14,=/19/+=688,5220,2614?3/B<612033/<:4+ /<:-/361<+12 0,3 >++1 ;-,12+. >? 20+ -/,4 ,;/32-,2+ =0+-+/1 2=6 .+,203 0,9+ 2,G+1 :4,5+ 61 ,556712 68 20+ 1+;4/;+15+.-/9/1;6820+9+-?726/5G30,=
% 6446=/1; 20+ ./527< 68 61A>4+ :+B 67-2 /1 20+ 5,3+ 68 !"#$ % & !$' $'( -+:6-2+./1))20/367-2.6+31628/1.,1? <+-/23 /1 20+ ,-;7<+123 :72 86-20 61 >+0,48 68 20+ -+9/3/61 :+2/2/61+-86--+.752/61683+12+15+
D 556-./1;4? 86- 20+ 86-+;6/1; ./35733/61 20+ 86446=/1;
- 11 -
/ 0+ -+9/3/61 :+2/2/61 /3 <+-/24+33 ,1. /2 /3 0+-+>?./3</33+. // /<+/3;-,12+.86-20+-+9/3/61:+2/2/61+-26 37--+1.+- >+86-+ 20+ -/,4 ,;/32-,2+ 2/44 '&#&D
88/5+ /3 ./-+52+. 26 3+1. 20+ -/,4 67-2 +56-.3 =/20 56:?6820/36-.+-86-20=/20
.+ '& *
"
/326'46% !