Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66531 (KAR)
THE PRIMARY v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203297/2025 · 2025-11-06
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66531 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66531 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
!#$%
& %'"%"%
(")%* )
(")%*
+
(")%*
)
! "
# #$
%% $
& ' ()
! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
"
$
(
+
,,
"
*
(
(
""" &
' # ( # ( +-
-
*)
- 3 -
# ""*
""
) #
#
"*
"*# " ."" !" ) #
)
"
! " $
%*% $
& ' ()
- 4 -
! *
"
$
(
+
,,
"
*
(
(
- 5 -
"""
&
' # ( # ( +-
-
*)
# ""*
""
) #
#
"*
"*# " ."" ! ) #
- 6 -
+)
+
! " ( $ %++% $(#
'() + & ' ()
! *
"
$
(
+
,,
"
- 7 -
*
(
(
&
' # ( #
(
+-
-
*)
# ""*
""
) #
#
" *
" * # " ."" )#
#
%
% , (
- 8 -
! '%, (
)
/010 2345 605454781 39410 :7;;78 <=0154781 7> >9:5 98?@92@0:54781575/0301678?08579@9A=39B498? 9?9B434 41534:508539@ 77603954C0 98D 930 1:/0?=@0? 57 A0 /0@? 78 ."" 48 503;1 7> 5/0 :9@08?93 7> 0C08516=A@41/0?78"""05454780317:405401930 9BB340C0? AE 5/043 489A4@45E 57 69354:46950 48 5/0 0@0:5478 5/37=B/ 5/043 30160:54C0 ?0@0B9501 48 C402 7> 480@4B4A@0 C75031 @415 6306930? AE 301678?085 7* 98? 100D48B ?430:5478 57 48:@=?0 5/043 89;01 48 5/0 0@4B4A@0 C75031 @415 930A0>7305/417=35
#7"".$""%
" /0 B340C98:0 7> 5/0 60545478031 41 5/95 98 ?;4841539573/9?A00896674850?4830160:57>5/09>>9431 7> 5/0 6054547803 77:405E AE 5/0 11415985 0B415393 7> 77603954C0 7:405401 C4?0 73?03 ?950? "" 245/ 9 ?430:5478 57 :78?=:5 0@0:5478 57 5/0 793? 7>
989B0;085 7> 6054547803 77:405E 245/48 5/300
- 9 -
;785/1>37;5/0?9507>/0911=;48B5/07>>4:0/0194? ?;4841539573?4?875:78?=:55/00@0:5478575/0793?7> 430:5731 7> 5/0 6054547803 77:405E 245/48 5/300 ;785/1 91 ?430:50? A=5 :78?=:50? 78 ."" /0309>503 0@0:5478 57 5/0 7>>4:0 A093031 7> 5/0 6054547803 77:405E291:78?=:50?78""
/95485/0;0982/4@098754:0=8?030:5478
"'")'9) 7> 5/0 938959D9 77603954C0 7:405401 :5 ..'>731/735F5/0:5..G):9;057A0411=0?AE5/0 /40>H0:=54C0>>4:037>301678?08577:405E:9@@48B >731=A;4114787>?0@0B95048503;17>0:5478"'")'9)7> 5/0:5..245/5/0@915?950>731=:/1=A;411478A048B +.""956;
+ =35/03 :910 7> 5/0 60545478031 41 5/95 78 :781545=5478 7> 793? 7> 430:5731 7> 5/0 6054547803 7 7:405E 98? 78 5/0 0@0:5478 7> 451 7>>4:0 A093031 9 30630108595478 291 ;9?0 78 """ 57 5/0 @0:5478 >>4:03 7> 5/0 301678?085 798D 1=A;45548B 5/0
- 10 -
?0@0B95478 >73; >73 5/0 081=48B 0@0:5478 57 A0 /0@? 78 .""7>451793?7>430:5731720C03485/0@415 7> 480@4B4A@0 C75031 6306930? 98? 6=A@41/0?
AE 5/0 /40> H0:=54C0>>4:037>5/0301678?085798D9130B93?1 57 5/0 6054547803 77:405E 45 41 30;93D0? 98? 1/728 91I8781=A;4114787>?0@0B950J/=15/060545478031930 8759A@05769354:4695098?:9155/043C750485/00@0:5478
#7""..$""%
/0 :910 7> 5/0 60545478031 41 5/95 0@0:5478 57 605454780377:405E>735/07>>4:07>793?7>430:5731 291 /0@? 78 ."" 98? 05=3848B >>4:03 ?0:@930? 5/0301=@578.""@0:5478575/07>>4:0A0930317> 605454780377:405E291/0@?78""
* /0 6054547803 77:405E 41 ;0;A03 7> 301678?085 798D /0 301678?085 798D 411=0? 8754>4:95478 ?950? "."" :9@@48B >73 ;0;A031 57 1=A;45 5/043 ?0@0B95478 78 73 A0>730 +."" /0309>5030@0:547812030?0:@930?>735/07>>4:07>793? - 11 -
7> 430:5731 7> 301678?085 798D 98? :9@08?93 7> 0C0851291411=0?78"""
/95 78 "" 6054547803 77:405E :78?=:50?451;00548B98?3017@C0?5787;489506054547803 7" 91 451 ?0@0B9500 57 C750 48 5/0 081=48B 0@0:5478 7> 301678?085 798D 1:/0?=@0? 57 A0 /0@? 78 .""
86=31=98:0575/0;00548B?950?"" 785/019;0?9E60545478037;9?03063010859547857 301678?085 798D 98? 30<=0150? 57 30:04C0 5/0 ?0@0B950>73;98?75/03?7:=;0851
. /955/7=B/301678?085798D30:04C0?5/0 30630108595478 ?950? "" 45 6=A@41/0? 5/0 >489@ C75031@4152/030485/089;07>605454780377:405E41 1/728485/0480@4B4A@0C75031@415
8#7"+.$""%
/0 :910 7> 5/0 60545478031 41 5/95 0@0:5478 57 5/07>>4:07>793?7>430:57317>605454780377:405E
- 12 -
291 /0@? 78 "*"" 98? 05=3848B >>4:03 ?0:@930? 5/0301=@578"*""@0:5478575/07>>4:0A0930317> 605454780377:405E291/0@?78""
/0 6054547803 77:405E 41 ;0;A03 7> 301678?085 798D /0 301678?085 798D 411=0? 8754>4:95478 :9@@48B =678 451 ;0;A031 57 1=A;45 5/043 ?0@0B9547898?5/0309>503:9@08?937>0C0851291411=0?78
"""
" /95 98 ?;4841539573 291 96674850? 148:0 5/0 503; 7> 5/0 793? 7> 430:5731 7> 6054547803 77:405E /9? :7;0 57 98 08? ?=348B "8? 200D 7> 0A3=93E "" 98?5/0?;4841539573?4?875:78?=:55/00@0:5478245/48 5/300 ;785/1 6054547803 77:405E :7=@? 875 :78?=:5 451;00548B98?5787;489507807>451793?7>430:57391 9?0@0B95057C75098?:7850155/0081=48B0@0:54781
/955/0@9610291785/069357>?;4841539573 48 :78?=:548B 5/0 0@0:5478 245/48 5/0 54;0 1546=@950? 98? 19;0:98875A05/0B37=8??0634C48B5/060545478031>37;
- 13 -
0H03:4148B5/04334B/557C750485/00@0:5478157301678?085 7793? 7> 430:573 1:/0?=@0? 57 A0 /0@? 78 .""
+ /95485/0@4157>480@4B4A@0C750316306930?98? 6=A@41/0?AE5/0/40>H0:=54C0>>4:037>5/0301678?085 798D9130B93?1575/0605454780374541;93D0? 98?1/72891I8781=A;4114787>?0@0B950J
09380? :7=810@ >73 5/0 60545478031 59D48B 5/41 7=355/37=B/ 5/0 30:73?1 955/0 7=5105 1=A;451 5/95 5/0 ?0@9E 48 1=A;411478 7> ?0@0B95478 73 8781=A;411478 7> ?0@0B95478 :98875 A0 95534A=50? 57 5/0 60545478031 4891;=:/915/0605454780377:405E485/010605454781 291 =8?03 5/0 ;989B0;085 98? :78537@ 7> 5/0 ?;48415395732/7AE5/0C03E73?037>9667485;085291 =8?03 5/0 ;98?950 57 /7@? 5/0 0@0:5478 57 5/0 793? 7> 430:5731 7> 6054547803 77:405E 245/48 5/0 54;0 1546=@950? 78?=:548B 5/0 0@0:5478 57 793? 7> 430:5731 98? 5/0309>503 57 5/0 7>>4:0 A093031 41 875 245/48 5/0
- 14 -
:78537@7>5/06054547803111=:/8780B@4B08:073?0@9E :98A095534A=50?785/0436935485/0E8751=A;45548B5/0 ?0@0B95478 245/48 5/0 54;0 1546=@950? 48 5/0 8754:0 411=0? =8?030:5478"'")'9)7>5/0:5.. * 09380? :7=810@ 30@401 =678 5/0 73?03 7> 5/0 773?48950 08:/ 7> 5/41 7=35 69110? 48
48 5/0 :910 7> !" #!$ %!
"#!! &'!'!(98?1=A;4515/955/0 145=95478 7> 5/0 60545478031 48 5/0 6301085 605454781 930 14;4@93575/957>5/060545478031485/0194?:91011=:/ 785/06348:46@07>69345E5/0:9107>5/060545478031;9E 9@17 A0 :7814?030? 603;45548B 5/0; 57 69354:46950 48 5/0 081=48B0@0:547817>301678?085798D
09380? 08473 7=810@ 96609348B >73 5/0 301678?085 777603954C0 7:405E 1=A;451 5/95 5/0 411=0 39410? AE 5/0 60545478031 41 780 603594848B 57 5/0 630693954787>5/0C75031@415/955/0?416=50245/30B93? - 15 -
57 5/0 C9@4?45E 75/032410 7> 5/0 637:011 7> 63069395478 7> C75031 @415 41 105 95 3015 AE 5/41 7=35 0@E48B =678 5/0 73?03169110?AE5/417=3548 )*
48 5/0 :910 7> +,( ' !( " #!! &'!'!(1=A;4515/955/417=35 /91 :781415085@E /0@? 5/95 98E ?416=50 245/ 30B93? 57 630693954787> C75031@415 411=AK0:5;95503 7>5/0?416=50 =8?03 0:5478 7> 5/0 :5 .. 98? 5/7=B/ 5/0 60545478031 930 394148B 5/0 411=0 245/ 30B93? 57 ?;4841539573875:78?=:548B5/00@0:5478575/0793?7> 430:5731 7> 6054547803 77:405E 48 54;0 301=@548B 48 ?0@9E481=A;45548B5/0?0@0B954785/019;027=@?B757 5/0C03E19;0<=0154787>630693954787>C75031@4152/4:/ 41 9 ?416=50? <=015478 7> >9:5 57 A0 ?0503;480? =8?03 0:54787>5/0:5.. 0 >=35/03 1=A;451 0C08 78 5/0 >9:51 5/7=B/ 5/0 60545478031 48 #7"".$"" :@94;0? 57 /9C0 ;9?093063010859547878"""91603880H=30 5/0 19;0 9660931 57 /9C0 A008 ;9?0 1=A10<=085 57
- 16 -
411=98:0 7> 5/0 :9@08?93 7> 0C0851 ?950? """ 0 9@17 30>031 57 880H=30 57 67485 7=5 5/95 5/030 41 87 ;950349@6@9:0?7830:73?AE5/060545478031245/30B93?57 194?30630108595478/9C48BA008?0@4C030?$9::0650?AE5/0 @0:5478 >>4:03 7> 5/0 301678?085 777603954C0 17:405E /030>730 /0 1=A;451 0C08 5/0 194? >9:51 930 30<=430?57A0637C0?485/0;98803D872857@922/4:/ :98875A0B7804857485/02345605454781
. 130B93?5730@498:06@9:0?78AE5/0@09380? :7=810@>735/060545478031785/073?0369110?AE5/07 73?4895008:/7>5/417=35/030>031576939B396/7" 7> 5/0 194? 73?03 57 67485 7=5 5/95 48 5/0 194? :910 5/0 ?0@0B9501 2030 87;48950? 48 9 ;00548B /0@? 78
"" 57 5/0 0@0:5478 57 A0 /0@? 78 """ 2/4:/ 41 ;=:/ A0>730 5/0 411=98:0 7> 5/0 :9@08?93 7> 0C0851/0>=35/03>9:517>5/0:9105/03048415/955/0@915 ?950 >73 1=A;45548B 5/0 ?0@0B95478 >73; 291 *"" 98? 5/0 ?0@0B95478 /9C48B A008 1=A;4550? A0@950?@E 78
"" 291 :78?780? 48 C402 7> 5/0 485034; 73?03
- 17 -
?950? """ 5/95 /9? A008 69110? AE 5/0 7=35 603;45548B 60545478031 5/03048 57 C750 48 5/0 194? 0@0:5478 5/952911:/0?=@0?57A0/0@?78"""
" /95 48 4815985 :910 0C08 5/7=B/ 5/0 0@0:5478 575/0605454780377:405E291/0@?78.""54@@ 6=367350?
1=A;411478 7> 5/0 30630108595478 30B93?48B 1=A;45548B 5/0 ?0@0B95478 78 """ 87 9:5478 41 59D08 AE 5/0 60545478031 /95 5/0 194? 306301085954781 ;9?0 1=A10<=085 57 411=98:0 7> 5/0 :9@08?93 7> 0C0851 /030>7305/06@097>489A4@45E7>5/060545478031:98875A0 :7=850898:0? 0 1=A;451 60545478031 /9? 9;6@0 54;0 A052008.""7395 @0915 A052008 ""98? 5/0?950782/4:/:9@08?937>0C08512030411=0?57/9C0 30?30119@ 7> 5/043 B340C98:0 /030>730 /0 1=A;451 5/0 30@498:0 6@9:0? 78 5/0 73?03 7> 5/41 7=35 41 7> 87 9C94@ 08:0100D1>73?41;4119@7>5/0605454781
" 09380???454789@?C7:950
08039@96609348B 5/37=B/C4?07:78>0308:48B30@E48B=6785/073?037>5/0
- 18 -
773?48950 08:/ 7> 5/41 7=35 48 5/0 :910 7> -.( #(" / 0.1 ' 2
" 0' #( 3 ' 2 3067350? 48 ) 45 # 1=A;451 5/95 45 41 1055@0? @92 98? 78:0 0@0:5478 930 9887=8:0? 5/0 9BB340C0? 6935E 24@@ 78@E /9C0 57 6=31=0 /41 30;0?E 48 9::73?98:0 245/ 637C414781 7> @92 /95 48 5/0 @4B/5 7> 0:5478 '") 7> 5/0 :5 .. 637C4?48B >73 5/0 0>>0:54C0 30;0?E 5/0 60545478031 ;9E /9C0 57 A0 30@0B950? 57 30?3011 5/043 B340C98:0 5/030=8?03 0 9@17 30@401 =678 5/0 73?03 7> 5/0 773?48950 08:/ 7> 5/41 7=35 ?950?"""69110?48
48 5/0 :910 7> 6& &'!(, ' !( " #!! &'!'2/571=A;455/955/417=35/9154;0 98?9B948?0:@480?5748503>030245/5/0637:0117>0@0:5478 69354:=@93@E 2/08 5/0 411=0 41 39410? 245/ 30B93? 57 630693954787>C75031@41508:0100D1>73?41;4119@7>5/0 605454781
"" 8 306@E @09380? :7=810@ >73 5/0 60545478031 1=A;4515/955/0411=039410?485/0630108560545478141875
- 19 -
780 245/ 30B93? 57 5/0 63069395478 7> C75031 @415 0 1=A;4515/95?416=50$411=039410?AE5/060545478031/03048 485/41:91041780603594848B575/0489:5478785/069357> 5/0 ?;4841539573 57 /9C0 :78?=:50? 5/0 0@0:54781 57 6054547803 77:405E 245/48 5/0 54;0 1546=@950? /95 /9?5/0?;4841539573:78?=:50?5/00@0:5478575/0793? 7> 430:5731 7> 5/0 054547803 77:405E 245/48 54;0 1546=@950?485/0C03E73?03966748548B/4;5/060545478031 27=@?875/9C0@7155/0766735=845E7>69354:469548B485/0 0@0:5478 57 5/0 301678?085 798D /030>730 /0 1=A;4550?5/955/0411=039410?485/0605454781:98875A0 0<=950?245/5/0780603594848B575/0630693954787>5/0 C75031@415
" 093?03=10?5/030:73?1
"+ 37; 5/0 >9:51 8933950? 9A7C0 45 41 :@093 5/95 0@0:54781575/0793?7>430:57317>5/060545478037 7:405E291/0@?78.""98?0@0:5478574517>>4:0 A093031 291 /0@? 78 "" /0 @915 ?950 >73 1=A;4114787>?0@0B9501>73;5769354:46950485/00@0:5478
- 20 -
575/0793?7>430:57317>301678?085777603954C0 98D 291 78 +."" ?=348B 2/4:/ 60347? 5/030 291 87793?7>430:5731480H41508:0
" 5 41 603548085 57 30>03 57 637C414781 7> 0:5478
"7>5/0:5..2/4:/410H539:50?/030=8?03% ''
7' "!
!"
#
$ %
" $ %
&
'
" "
# "
"
" ()# $ ) %*#$##
% + , # # ##
"
##,# # # #
"
-. $
%
###
- 21 -
$ % #"# /
" 0
# 1" $
%
"
2 # % 3
" # " 44
"* 930 603=19@ 7> 5/0 9>730194? 637C41478 27=@? 48?4:9505/9534B/557C7504157A00H03:410?78@EAEI0C03E ;0;A03J I0C03E 306301085954C0J I0C03E ?0@0B950J 98? I0C03E87;4800J485/0B08039@0@0:5478173485/00@0:5478 7>5/0;0;A0317>5/0793?7>977603954C07:405E 5 ?701 875 :7850;6@950 0C085=9@45401 91 48C7@C0? 48 5/0 4815985 :9101 89;0@E 5/0 7:405E :78:0380? A048B =8?03 5/0 :78537@ 7> 98 ?;4841539573 8 75/03 273?1 48 5/0 9A108:07>98E637C41478=8?035/0:545410H6@4:45@E:@093 5/95 45 41 78@E 5/0 ;0;A03 306301085954C0 ?0@0B950 73 87;48001/9@@08545@0?570H03:4105/034B/557C75078 0H41508:0 7> 793? 98? 451 0;A031 7> 9 7:405E ?=0 57 9667485;085 7> ?;4841539573 :98875 A0 9 B37=8? 57 :78508? 5/95 45 291 A0E78? 5/043 :78537@ 57 69354:46950 48
- 22 -
5/0 0@0:5478 637:011 667485;085 7> ?;4841539573 41 9 69357>?=0637:0117>@92/7=@?5/030A098E4@@0B9@45E 734330B=@9345E485/09667485;0857>98?;484153957398? :78548=954787>/41503;7>9667485;0855/019;0;9EA0 9 ;95503 57 A0 ?09@5 245/ 48 9::73?98:0 245/ @92 78548=95478 7> 5/0 ?;4841539573 5/030>730 :98875 A0 9 B37=8?57100DA080>45485/0895=307>0H50814787>54;0 57 69354:46950 48 5/0 0@0:5478 637:011 AE 966748548B$87;489548B 9 ?0@0B950 91 637C4?0? =8?03 0:5478 " 7> 5/0 :5 .. 2/4:/ 5/0 60545478031 930 100D48B57:98C91485/04815985:9101
" 0@498:0 6@9:0? 78 AE 5/0 @09380? :7=810@ >73 5/0 60545478031 57 5/0 73?03 69110? AE 5/0 773?48950 08:/ 7> 5/41 7=35 48 5/0 :910 7> !" #!$ %.! '#) 41 ?41548B=41/9A@0 91 34B/5@E 674850? AE @09380? 08473 7=810@ 96609348B >73 5/0 301678?085 7 2/03048 5/7=B/ 5/030 291 9 ?0@9E 7> " ?9E1 48 1=A;45548B 5/0 ?0@0B950>73;96693085@E5/019;02911=A;4550?;=:/
- 23 -
63473 57 411=98:0 7> 5/0 :9@08?93 7> 0C0851 2/4:/ 41 875 5/0:91095/98? " /0:9@08?937>0C0851485/04815985:9102030 411=0?78"""306301085954786=367350?@E;9?0 78"""0C085/7=B/9793?7> 989B0;085291 :781545=50?4830160:57>5/0605454780377:405E91>93 A9:D9178.""?=348B2/4:/60347?5/03029187 :9@08?937>0C085148<=015478/030>7305/0>9:51A048B ?41548B=41/9A@0 5/0 73?03 69110? AE 5/0 773?48950 08:/7>5/417=35417>879C94@
". /41=@54;950@E@09?1579:78:@=14785/9589;01 7> 5/0 6054547803 77:405E 48 5/010 605454781 /9C48B A008@0>57=5>37;5/0@4157>0@4B4A@0C75031>735/03091781 8750? 9A7C0 27=@? 48C9349A@E 9;7=851 57 9 ?416=50 603594848B 57 5/0 637:011 7> 0@0:5478 48C7@C48B >9:5=9@ 9160:57>5/0;95503
00?@011 57 15950 5/0 194?
411=0 /9C48B A008 105 95 3015 AE 5/0 73?031 7> 5/0 60H 7=35 98? 7> 5/41
- 24 -
7=35 /7@?48B 5/95 ?416=50 245/ 30B93? 57 63069395478 7> C75031@41524@@/9C057A09?K=?4:950?48503;17>0:5478 7>5/0:5.. 8?03 5/010 :43:=;1598:01 5/41 7=35 ?7 875 >48?98E3091785748503>030955/41K=8:5=300@0B9548B5/0 60545478031579C94@1=:/30;0?E91;9EA09C94@9A@04>17 9?C410?605454781930?41;4110? ",) (%"%* '! %%+" %