- 1 - ! " # $% & %% %'' ( ( )(*')+ !( )) , !" # $ $ %&'"(") )&('"(" $ # Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * $ &% * $ +,-..,//-012,3041+,-5567,830%&'"(") %0 1+, 93/, %9 1+, /,-:0,8 88313%0-/ 371:351 -08 ,773%07 $684, -35+6: 7311304 -1 308+-06: 9%: 7+%:1 ;:3-/ %6:1< 37 3=.640304 1+, >684=,01 %9 5%0?3513%0 8-1,8 )&('"(" -08 %:8,: %9 7,01,05, 8-1,8 "!('"(" 5%0?351304 +3= 9%: 1+, %99,05, .6037+-2/, 608,:,513%0(! %91+, 083-0,0-/%8,)'@(9%: 7+%:1 ; < -08 7,01,05304 1% 608,:4% 73=./, 3=.:37%0=,019%:-.,:3%8%97,?,0A,-:7-081%.-A930, %9 7"((((BC31+8,9-6/17,01,05, " -517%91+,5-7,302:3,9-:,1+-11+,8,5,-7,8 -081+,-5567,8+-?,=-::3,8-2%61@A,-:7.:3%:1%1+, 30538,01 -08 1+,A 67,8 1% 71-A 30 ,04-/6:6 $671 - 8-A 2,9%:,1+,30538,011+,A5-=,1%1+,+%67,%9#)C+% 37 1+, -601 %9 1+, -5567,8 -08 -/7% :,/-13?, %9 1+, 8,5,-7,8 0 1+, 8-1, %9 1+, 30538,01 3, )'(&"()@ - 3 - 1+,:, C-7 - D6-::,/ 2,1C,,0 1+, +672-08 -08 C39, ==,83-1,/A1+,-5567,81%%E1+,E039,-0871-22,81+, 8,5,-7,8 %0 +,: 0,5E -08 %1+,: .-:17 %9 1+, 2%8A -7 - :,76/1%9C+35+7+,83,8-11+,7.%1#+,0#)1:3,81% 301,:?,0, 30 1+, =-11,: 1% .-539A 1+, 7316-13%0 7+, -/7% 7671-30,8 30>6:3,7 1 37 1+, 5%01,013%0 %9 1+, .:%7,5613%0 1+-11+,-5567,82,3041+,+672-08%91+,8,5,-7,867,8 1% 1:,-1 +,: C31+ 5:6,/1A -08 5:3=30-//A 3013=38-1,8 +,: 1+,:,2A 1+, -5567,8 5%==311,8 1+, %99,05,7 .6037+-2/, 608,:,513%07!&'(""!-08F(@%9 01+,2-737%91+,93:71309%:=-13%0/%84,82A 1+, 30>6:,8 ,A,BC310,77 #) 1+, 5-=, 1% 2, :,4371,:,8 +, 30?,7134-13%0 C-7 608,:1-E,0 -08 930-/ :,.%:1 5-=, 1% 2, 93/,8 +, /,-:0,8 -4371:-1, 1%%E 5%403G-05,9%:1+,-2%?,7-38%99,05,-085%==311,81+, =-11,: 1% 1+, ,773%07 %6:1 +, :3-/ %6:1 -91,: 7,56:304 1+, .:,7,05, %9 1+, -5567,8 9:-=,8 5+-:4,7 -4-3071+3=+,-5567,8-..,-:,82,9%:,1+,:3-/%6:1 8,03,8-//1+,5+-:4,7-4-3071+3=-085/-3=,81%2,1:3,8 - 4 - ! % .:%?, 1+, 463/1 %9 1+, -5567,8 1+, .:%7,5613%0,H-=30,8#7)1%""4%1=-:E,8 H7)1% "(-0838,01393,87)1%+,-5567,88,03,8-//1+, 305:3=30-1304 =-1,:3-/7 -?-3/-2/, %0 :,5%:8 30 +37 71-1,=,01608,:,513%0):-08261+-70%1/,8 -0A,?38,05,3076..%:1%9+378,9,05, F 91,:1-E304301%5%0738,:-13%0-//1+,=-1,:3-/7 %0:,5%:81+,:3-/%6:15-=,1%1+,5%05/673%01+-11+, %99,05,5%==311,82A1+,-5567,8C-70%1-.:,=,831-1,8 %0,26131%556::,8-11+,7.6:%9=%=,012AC+35++, 5-67,8 9-1-/ 30>6:3,7 -7 - :,76/1 %9 C+35+ +37 C39, 83,8 ,05,31C-70%11+,5-7,608,:,513%0("%9 26131 9-//7 608,: 1+, 9%6:1+ H5,.13%0 1% ,513%0 (( %9 .6037+-2/,608,:,513%0(! %9 55%:8304/A+, C-7 7,01,05,8 1% 608,:4% 73=./, 3=.:37%0=,01 9%: A,-:7-081%.-A930,%9 7"((((BC31+8,9-6/17,01,05, +, :3-/ %6:1 :,5%:8,8 1+-1 1+, .:%7,5613%0 37 0%1 7655,7796/ 30 .:%?304 1+, 463/1 %9 -5567,8 9%: 1+, %99,05, .6037+-2/,608,:,513%0!&'B"!-08F(@%9 -08 - 5 - -55%:8304/A+,C-7-5D6311,89%:1+,7-=,+,1-1,+-7 0%1.:,9,::,8-0A-..,-/-4-30711+,3=.640,8>684=,01 +, -5567,8 37 2,9%:, 1+37 %6:1 2A 93/304 1+, .:,7,01 -..,-/3=.6403041+,>684=,01%95%0?3513%0-08%:8,:%9 7,01,05,.-77,8-4-3071+3= @ ,-:8:3:-E-7+,/3/,-:0,85%607,/9%:1+, -..,//-01 -08 =1:-13 -13/ /,-:0,8 34+ %6:1 %?,:0=,01/,-8,:9%:1+,:,7.%08,01B1-1,,:67,81+, =-1,:3-/7305/683041+,:3-/%6:1:,5%:87 0 ?3,C %9 1+, :3?-/ 5%01,013%07 6:4,8 2A /,-:0,85%607,/9%:2%1+1+,.-:13,71+,.%3011+-1C%6/8 -:37,9%:=A5%0738,:-13%037 ' A-07C,:1%1+,-2%?,.%30137 9%:1+,9%//%C304 - 6 - & 8=311,89-517%91+,5-7,-:,1+-11+,-5567,8 -081+,8,5,-7,8C,:,301+,+%67,%9#)%01+,8-1, %91+,30538,013,)'(&"()@ 01+,=%:03041+,:,C-7 -D6-::,/2,1C,,01+,= 137-8=311,81+-11+,8,5,-7,8 +-883,82A7671-30304=6/13./,71-230>6:3,7301+,+%67, %9 #) 0 1+, ?,:A 7-=, 8-A #) /%84,8 1+, 93:71 309%:=-13%0 -7 .,: H) 0 ?3,C %9 -// 1+,7, 9-517 -08 53:56=71-05,71+,5-7,=-8,%612A1+,.:%7,5613%0371% 2,5%0738,:,8 )( #) 37 1+, 309%:=-01 C+% 37 1+, -601 %9 1+, -5567,8 -08 1+, 8,5,-7,8 -08 7+, 37 1+, 30>6:,8 ,A,B C310,77 +, 8,.%7,8 2,9%:, 1+, %6:1 :,4-:8304 1+, -5567,8 .35E304B6. D6-::,/ C31+ 1+, 8,5,-7,8 -08 7688,0/A71-22304+,:C31+E039,%?,:+,:0,5E-08%1+,: .-:17%91+,2%8A-7-:,76/1%9C+35+1+,8,5,-7,883,8 -1 1+, 7.%1 +, .%71 =%:1,= :,.%:1 37 .:%865,8 -7 .,: H)" 3776,8 2A #)! 7 .,: H)" 1+, 8,5,-7,8 7671-30,8 =6/13./, 30>6:3,7 -08 7+, 83,8 86, 1% - 7 - +,=%::+-435 7+%5E 9:%= 765+ =6/13./, 561 30>6:3,7 +,:,9%:, 1+, ,?38,05, %9 #)! -08 H)" 76..%:17 1+,5%01,013%0%91+,.:%7,5613%0#)&371+,-+73/8-: C+% 5%08651,8 1+, 30D6,71 =-+-G-: -7 .,: H" // 1+,7,=-1,:3-/776..%:171+,5%01,013%0%91+,.:%7,5613%0 C31+ :,4-:8 1% 1+, +%=3538-/ 8,-1+ %9 8,5,-7,8 2A 7671-30304=6/13./,56130>6:3,7 )) 137.,:130,011%0%1,1+-11+,8,5,-7,8370%0, %1+,: 1+-0 1+, C39, %9 -5567,8 +,:, 37 -27%/61,/A 0% ,H./-0-13%0 2A 1+, -5567,8 -7 1% +%C +37 C39, 7671-30,8 765+ 9-1-/ 30>6:3,7 30738, 1+, +%67,-08 83,8 -1 1+,7.%1 08,: 765+ 53:56=71-05,7 1+, ,?38,05, %9 #) 37 7699353,011%.:%?,1+,463/1%91+,-5567,8 )" ?,0 1+%64+ 1+, 5+-:4, C-7 9:-=,8 608,: ,513%0("%9 1+,:3-/%6:19%:=,8-0%.303%01+-1 1+, -5567,8 +-8 0% 301,013%0 -08 1+-1 +, +-8 0%1 =-8, -0A .:,.-:-13%0 1% 5-67, 1+, 8,-1+ %9 8,5,-7,8 -08 31 C-7%01+,7.6:%9=%=,01+,-..,-:71%+-?,71-22,8 1+,8,5,-7,8-71+,:,C-7-D6-::,/2,1C,,01+,1C% 8% - 8 - 0%1 9308 -0A :,-7%0 1% 8,9,: C31+ 1+, %.303%0 9%:=,8 2A 1+, :3-/ %6:1 0 1+, %1+,: +-08 5%056: C31+ 1+, 9308304:,5%:8,82A1+,:3-/%6:11+-11+,.:%7,5613%037 7655,7796/ 30 .:%?304 1+, 463/1 %9 1+, -5567,8 2,A%08 :,-7%0-2/,8%6219%:1+,%99,05,608,:,513%0(! %9 -08+,05,+,37/3-2/,9%:5%0?3513%0 ) 11+3771-4,/,-:0,85%607,/9%:1+,-..,//-01 5%01,08,81+-11+,30538,01+-8%556::,8%0)'(&"()@ 1+,-5567,8+-7-/:,-8A7699,:,8305-:5,:-13%09%:"A,-:7 )( =%01+7 "( 8-A7 -7 +, C-7 30 5671%8A 86:304 1:3-/ +,:,9%:, +,.:-A7 9%:7+%C304 /,03,05A 303=.%7304 1+, 7,01,05,,./-5,8:,/3-05,%01+,8,5373%0%91+,%0<2/, .,H%6:130 !)3076..%:1%9 +375%01,013%01+-19%:1+,%99,05,608,:,513%0(! %9 7,01,05, 5%6/8 2, =%8393,8 1% 1+, .,:3%8 -/:,-8A 608,:4%0,2A1+,-5567,8 1 "("! '(& - 9 - )! +, 9-517 -08 53:56=71-05,7 8375677,8 -2%?, 8375/%7,71+-11+,837.61,+-87688,0/A-:37,02,1C,,01+, +672-08 -08 C39, %0 1+, 8-1, %9 1+, 30538,01 C+35+ :,76/1,8 30 5-67304 9-1-/ 30>6:3,7 1% 1+, 8,5,-7,8 -7 - :,76/1 %9 C+35+ 7+, 83,8 -1 1+, 7.%1 09%:160-1,/A 1+, 0?,7134-1304 9935,: 5%6/8 0%1 1:-5, 1+, C,-.%0 67,8 30 1+, 5%==3773%0 %9 %99,05, 261 +%C,?,: 1+-1 C3// 0%1 ,06:,1%1+,2,0,931%91+,-5567,8 13771-1,81+-11+, -5567,8 C-7 30 5671%8A 9%: " A,-:7 )( =%01+7 "( 8-A7 86:3041+,1:3-/ )F %: 1+, %99,05, 608,: ,513%0 (! %9 1+,=-H3=6=7,01,05,1+-15%6/82,3=.%7,837)(A,-:7 %: C31+ 930, %: C31+ 2%1+ 8% 0%1 9308 -0A :,-7%0 1% 3=.%7, =-H3=6= 7,01,05, %0 1+, -5567,8 305, 1+, -5567,8 +-7 -/:,-8A 608,:4%0, 3=.:37%0=,01 9%: =%:, 1+-0"A,-:7)(=%01+7 -=%91+,%.303%01+-17,1B%99 5%6/8 2, 43?,0 9%: 765+ .,:3%8 9%: C+35+ +, +-7 -/:,-8A 608,:4%0,3=.:37%0=,012A=%839A3041+,3=.640,8%:8,: %97,01,05,.-77,82A1+,:3-/%6:1 - 10 - )@ 0?3,C%91+,-2%?, -=%91+,%.303%01+-1 1+, 3=.640,8 >684=,01 %9 5%0?3513%0 -08 %:8,: %9 7,01,05,.-77,82A1+,:3-/%6:137/3-2/,1%2,=%8393,8 55%:8304/A -07C,: 1+, -2%?, .%301 ;" #-08.:%5,,81%.-771+,9%//%C304 3 +,:3=30-/..,-/37 " 33 +, 3=.640,8 >684=,01 %9 5%0?3513%0 8-1,8 )&('"(".-77,830%&'"(")%01+, 93/, %9 /,-:0,8 88313%0-/ 371:351 -08 ,773%07 $684, -35+6: 7311304 -1 308+-06: 5%0?351304 1+, -..,//-01-5567,8 9%:1+,%99,05,608,:,513%0(!33%9 37+,:,2A5%093:=,8 333 +, %:8,: %9 7,01,05, .-77,8 2A 1+, :3-/ %6:137=%8393,8-7608,:I - 11 - 3? +, -..,//-01B-5567,8 37 7,01,05,8 9%: 1+, .,:3%8 C+35+ +, +-7 -/:,-8A 608,:4%0, 2A 43?3047,1B%99608,:,513%0!"'%9 ? =.%7313%0 %9 930, -08 8,9-6/1 7,01,05, 3=.%7,8 2A 1+, :3-/ %6:1 37 +,:,2A 5%093:=,8 ,4371:A 1% 7,082-5E 1+, :3-/%6:1 ,5%:87 -/%04 C31+5%.A%91+37>684=,019%:309%:=-13%0-089%:0,,896/ -513%0 -+ (%%) & 371%)/%