Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66517 (KAR)

ASHOK REDDY AND ORS v. THE STATE THROUGH CHINCHOLI POLICE STATION

CRL.A/200184/2023 · 2025-08-06

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$## #%% &' ()%*+ (*, - ! ! " # " ! $ %"" & " $ ' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " "" ( % " & $ "' "" ( ) &!' ( " " * +) ! " $ +) ! , $ ! ! , "" "" ( ( $ - $ $# &" - $ ' ./ 011/220345 6/738 099:5/; +5 4+ 73 +) ! +3 4./ <72/ +< 4./ 2/0=3/; ;;747+302 754=794 03; /557+35 $:;8/0206:=0875744738 04/;0> ?<+=5.+=4@4./=702+:=4AB0=/7>1:837384./C:;8>/34+< 9+3D7947+3;04/; ! !03;+=;/=+<5/34/39/;04/; ! #! ! 9+3D794738 099:5/; + <+= 4./ +<</39/5 - 3 - 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+35 !# ! # =/0; E74. /947+3 +< " 9+3D794738 099:5/; +5! 4+ <+= 4./ +<</39/51:375.062/:3;/=/947+35! 03; #=/0; E74./947+3+<"E.72/09F:7447380224./099:5/;+< 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 ) 09F:744738 099:5/; +5! 4+ +< 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3!#+<"03;5/34/39738 99:5/;+54+4+10G<73/+< 5 /09.<+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 ! =/0; E74. /947+3 +< " 03; 73 ;/<0:24 +< 10G>/34 +< <73/ 4+ :3;/=8+57>12/7>1=75+3>/34<+=01/=7+;+<+3/E//HI 99:5/;+54+4+10G<73/+< 5 /09.<+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 =/0; E74. /947+3 +< " 03; 73 ;/<0:24 +< 10G>/34 +< <73/ 4+ :3;/=8+57>12/7>1=75+3>/34<+=01/=7+;+<+3/E//HI 99:5/;+54+4+10G<73/+< 5 /09.<+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 # =/0; E74. /947+3 +< " 03; 73 ;/<0:24 +< 10G>/34 +< <73/ 4+ - 4 - :3;/=8+ 57>12/ 7>1=75+3>/34 <+= 0 1/=7+; +< +3/ E//HI 03; 99:5/; + 4+ :3;/=8+ 57>12/ =78+=+:5 7>1=75+3>/34<+=01/=7+;+<4E+G/0=503;4+10G<73/+< 5! 03; 73 ;/<0:24 +< 10G>/34 +< <73/ 4+ :3;/=8+ 57>12/ 7>1=75+3>/34 <+= 0 1/=7+; +< 4E+ >+34.5 <+= 4./ +<</39/1:375.062/:3;/=/947+3!#+<" ! (0945 +< 4./ 905/ 73 6=7/< 0=/ 4.04 +3 #! # 04 1> 099:5/; +5 4+ 73 <:=4./=039/ +< 4./7= 9+>>+3 734/347+3 90>/ 03; 179H/; :1 F:0==/2 E74. " 06:5/; .7> 73 <724.G 2038:08/ 735:24/; 03; 9=7>73022G 7347>7;04/; .7> 99:5/; + 0550:24/;.7>E74.030J/E74.03734/347+34+90:5/.75 ;/04.E.72/099:5/;+!0550:24/;4./9+>12073034E74. .03;5 03; 4./=/6G 4./ 099:5/; .0D/ 9+>>744/; 4./ 06+D/>/347+3/; +<</39/5 3 4./ 60575 +< 4./ <7=54 73<+=>047+3 J" ( 90>/ 4+ 6/ =/8754/=/; 05 1/= J"# 73D/5478047+3 E05 9+>12/4/; 03; 9.0=8/ 5.//4 90>/4+6/<72/; - 5 - ./ 2/0=3/; 08754=04/ 4++H 9+837K039/ +< 4./ +<</39/03;9+>>744/;4./>044/=4+4.//557+35+:=4 ./ =702 +:=4 5:>>+3/; 4./ 099:5/; ./ 099:5/; 011/0=/; 6/<+=/ 4./ +:=4 12/0;/; 3+4 8:724G 03; 9207>/; 4+ 6/ 4=7/; "=+5/9:47+3 /J0>73/; "5 4+ 8+4>0=H/; J5"4+"#03;7;/347<7/;735:11+=4 +<7459+34/347+399:5/;.0D/;/37/;0224./739=7>7304738 >04/=70250D072062/+3=/9+=;6:4.0D/3+49.+5/34+2/0; 03G/D7;/39/735:11+=4+<4./7=;/</39/./=702+:=4 0<4/= 40H738 734+ 9+357;/=047+3 022 4./5/ >04/=7025 +3 =/9+=; 90>/ 4+ 4./ 9+392:57+3 4.04 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 .05 3+4>0;/+:49+>>7557+3+<+<</39/6G099:5/;+54+ <+=4./+<</39/1:375.062/:3;/=/947+3 )+<"74.05 3+4 >0;/ +:4 4./ 905/ <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3!#0807354099:5/;+5!4+6:4<+:3;4.044./ 1=+5/9:47+3 75 5:99/55<:2 73 1=+D738 4./ 8:724 +< 099:5/; +<+=4./+<</39/1:375.062/:3;/=/947+35!#! #+<"E.72/74755:99/55<:2731=+D7384./8:724 +< 099:5/; +5! 4+ <+= 4./ +<</39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= - 6 - /947+35 # ! +< " 99+=;7382G 1055/; 4./ 7>1:83/; C:;8>/34 /738 088=7/D/; 6G 4./ 50>/ 4./ 099:5/;0=/6/<+=/4.75+:=4 /0=; =7 0C/5. +;;0>037 2/0=3/; 9+:35/2 <+= 4./ 011/220345 03; =7 $0>0;0= .0.06:;;73 2/0=3/; 78.+:=4+D/=3>/34"2/0;/=<+=4./=/51+3;/34 3 D7/E +< 4./ =7D02 9+34/347+35 :=8/; 6G 2/0=3/;9+:35/2<+=4./10=47/54./1+7344.04E+:2;0=75/ <+=>G9+357;/=047+375 G 035E/= 4+ 4./ 06+D/ 1+734 75 @ A<+=4./<+22+E738 # 5 1/= 4./ 905/ >0;/ +:4 6G 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 099:5/; + 0550:24/; 4./ 73C:=/; " E74. 4./ 0J/ - 7 - E74. 03 734/347+3 4+ 90:5/ .75 ;/04. +E/D/= 4./ =702 +:=4 09F:744/; 099:5/; + <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/:3;/=/947+3 )+<"03;9+3D794/;.7><+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 !# +< " ./ 404/.053+49.022/38/;4./507;C:;8>/34+<09F:74402 ) 4 75 4./ 9+34/347+3 +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 4.04 099:5/; +! 0550:24/; 4./ 73C:=/; E74. .03;5 03; 9+>>744/; 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 ! +< " 4 75 025+ 4./ 9+34/347+3 +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 4.04 099:5/; +5 4+ .0D/ 06:5/; 4./ 73C:=/; 73 <724.G 2038:08/.:>72704/;03;9=7>73022G7347>7;04/;.7> " 75 4./ 73C:=/; /G/E743/55 E.+ <72/; 4./ <7=5473<+=>047+3051/= J""754.//G/E743/554+ 4./7397;/34 E.+9+==+6+=04/;4./50G +<" =/80=;738 9+>>7557+3 +< 4./ +<</39/ D/3 4.+:8. " 75 /J0>73/;0503/G/E743/55./754=/04/;10=42G.+5472/05 ./.05;/1+5/;4.04./90>/4+4./51+40<4/=9+>>7557+3 +<4./+<</39/./=/<+=/./9+:2;3+46/4=/04/;0503 /G/E743/554+4./7397;/34"!754./>0.0K0=E743/55 - 8 - 4+ J"!:3;/=E.79.E05=/9+D/=/;743/55.05 3+4 5:11+=4/; 4./ 905/ +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 6:4 4./ 3D/547804738 <<79/= .05 ;/1+5/; =/80=;738 J"! 03; "5)03;0=/4./<+=>02E743/55/5"#75 4./3D/547804738<<79/= E.+ <72/; 4./ 9.0=8/ 5.//4" 75 4./ 3D/547804738 <<79/= E.+ =/8754/=/; 4./ ( 05 1/= J"# L "L754./+94+=E.+4=/04/;4./73C:=/;03; 755:/;4./E+:3;9/=47<7904/051/= J"3C:=/;" E05/J0>73/;6G"L+3 #! #7/+34./;04/+< 7397;/34745/2<04"E+9:4209/=04/;E+:3;5+D/= 2/<4 10=7/402 =/87+3 03; 2/<4 2/8 6/2+E H3// C+734 E/=/ 3+479/;E.79.0=/8=7/D+:573304:=//025+5:<</=/;1073 03;4/3;/=3/55+D/=<09/03;=78.4H3//E.79.0=/57>12/ 73 304:=/ "L 51/97<79022G 5404/5 4.04 8=7/D+:5 73C:=7/5 =/</==/;4+73 J"L9+:2;6/90:5/;7<./E050550:24/; E74. 0J/ ./=/ 75 065+2:4/2G 3+ 9=+55 /J0>73047+34+4.75/<</94 - 9 - /0=3/; 9+:35/2 <+= 4./ 011/220345 9+34/3;5 4.04 4./=/ E05 722E722 6/4E//3 " 03; 4./ 099:5/; E.79.2/;4+<025/7>1279047+3+<4./099:5/;./>+47D/75 0;+:62//;8/;E/01+3E.79.9+:2;9:4+3/74./=57;/ 38+7384.=+:8.4.//D7;/39/+<"503; L ;+ 3+4 <73; 03G =/05+3 4+ <+=> 03 +1737+3 4.04 099:5/; E/=/ <025/2G 7>127904/; 73 4./ >044/= 3 4./ +4./=.03;4./099:5/;.0D/3+454/11/;734+4./E743/55 6+J3+=/27974/;03G4.738;:=7389=+55/J0>73047+3+<4./ >04/=702E743/55/54+1=+60627K/4./7=9+34/347+34.044./G 0=/<025/2G7>127904/;./=/<+=/0>+<4./+1737+34.04 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 75 5:99/55<:2 73 1=+D738 4./ 8:724 +< 099:5/; + <+= 4./ +<</39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+35 !# 03; # +< " E./=/05 74 75 5:99/55<:2 73 1=+D738 4./ 8:724 +< 099:5/; +5! 4+ <+= 4./ +<</39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+35 03; # +< " ;+ 3+4 <73; 03G 50475<094+=G >04/=702 <+= 4./ 9+>>7557+3 +< 4./ +<</39/6G099:5/;+54+<+=4./+<</39/1:375.062/ :3;/=/947+3!+<"./=/<+=/035E/=4./06+D/ - 10 - 1+734 10=42G 73 4./ 0<<7=>047D/ 03; 1=+9//; 4+ 1055 4./ <+22+E738 &7' =7>730211/0275 &77' ./ C:;8>/34 +< 9+3D7947+3 ;04/; ! ! 03; +=;/= +< 5/34/39/ ;04/; ! #! ! 1055/; 73 +) ! 6G 4./ ;;747+302 754=794 03; /557+35 $:;8/ 0206:=087 5744738 04 /;0> 9+3D794738 099:5/; + <+= 4./ +<</39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+35 !# 03; #+<"75./=/6G &777' ./ C:;8>/34 9+3D794738 099:5/; +5 4+ <+= 4./ +<</39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+35 03; # +< " 75 ./=/6G &7D' ./ C:;8>/34 9+3D794738 099:5/; +5 4+ <+=4./ +<</39/1:375.062/ :3;/=/947+3 !+<"75 - 11 - &D' 99:5/; + 75 5/34/39/; 4+ :3;/=8+ 57>12/ 7>1=75+3>/34 <+= 0 1/=7+; +< +3/ >+34. 03; 4+ 10G 0 <73/ +< 5 <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= 73 ;/<0:24 +< 10G>/34 +< <73/ ./ 5.022 :3;/=8+ 57>12/ 7>1=75+3>/34 <+= ) ;0G5 &D7' 99:5/;+54+0=/5/34/39/;4+10G0 <73/ +< 5 /09. <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= 73 ;/<0:24 +< 10G>/34 +< <73/ 4./G 5.022 :3;/=8+57>12/7>1=75+3>/34<+=);0G5 &D77' 99:5/;+54+0=/5/34/39/;4+10G0 <73/ +< 5 /09. <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= 73 ;/<0:24 4+ 10G <73/ 4./G 5.022 :3;/=8+ 57>12/7>1=75+3>/34<+=);0G5 - 12 - /8754=G 75 ;7=/94/; 4+ 5/3; 609H 4./ =702 +:=4 =/9+=;5 02+38 E74. 9+1G +< 4.75 C:;8>/34 <+= 73<+=>047+3 03;3//;<:20947+3 .+ (##* $ 754+2+ "