Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66516 (KAR)
HANMANTH AND ORS v. SANTOSH AND ANR
MFA/201497/2018 · 2025-07-21
Ravi V Hosmani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66516 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66516 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#"
$#!%%! !!&&
'% ( )* !!&& +
!!&& +
!!&& +
)
,
! ! "
"
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
## $ %
&
'
%(()
%
"
* +
"
"
(
(
+ ,
&
'
("
- (
$
"")
" "
') " (
" % !$
( %
"
(,
" % *
+)
,
,
%
- 3 -
& '
%(()
%
"
* +
"
"
(
( + , &
'
("
- ()
" "
') " (
"
%
!$
( %
"
(
"% *
+)
,
"
"
(
(
+ ,
& '
()
- 4 -
,
% * +
%
"
* +
&
'
%(("
- ()
" "
') " ( % !$ (
( %
"% *
+ )
,
"
"
(
(
+ , ' . )
& '
()
- 5 -
## $ %
+
! ! "
"
## $ % +
&
'
%(("
/01!- ! - ()
" "
') " ( % !$ (,
( %
"% *
- 6 -
"
( ("
%! "
2
%
((
%# 3455678978 :0;;07 <=>8;67/ 47> 4?41> >4/6> !$@4AA6>BC 679019D95%=>8647>39//4@=1 'E/19B=745FG01A301/)97(A70, 47> /36A6 4@@645A416G956>BC:549;47/A4A?6554A97A=161
3956 97A=161 34A G956>
" 70 $
:3455678978 4?41> 97 ( 70
47>
" 70 $ :3455678978 4?41> 97 ( 70, - :549;47/A34D6G956>"70!,$ :34556789784?41>97 ( 70 47> " 70!, 48497A/ 4?41> 97 (70,
;/166/9 4/95 65H=7>9 564176> :0=7A65 G01 4@@65547/#97A=161A=B;9//6>97:549;@6/9/9079/?4AA/4/6>/34/ 4/4;07$$4554;;447>34774;;4?616 /14D65978 97 /14:/01#/149561 34AA9A 70( !,$ 78976 70, ! , 47> /149561 :34AA9A 70 4G/61 504>978 A/076A G01 :07A/1=:/907 0G B0=7>41C?4556414=>/90/6539//4@=19/A>19D61>10D69/
- 7 -
9714A347>76859867/47>97I98#I48;4776147>4@@596>B14H6A A=>>675C >=6 /0 ?39:3 9/ /=176> /=1/56 47> :4=A6> 4::9>67/ =6 /0 A/076A G455978 07 /36; 4554;;4 >96> 07 A@0/ ?3956 34774;;4 A=A/4976> 8196D0=A 97<=196A 6A@9/6 /4H978 /164/;67/ 34774;;4 >9> 70/ 16:0D61 G=55C 47> A=A/4976> @61;4767/ @3CA9:45 >9A4B959/C 50AA 0G 6417978 :4@4:9/C =6 /0 A4;6 A36 G956> ( 70 9H6?9A6 3=AB47> 47> :395>1670G4554;;4G956>(70, 48497A/0?76147> 97A=1610G/14:/0147>/149561 !
7A61D9:60G70/9:60?761>9>70/4@@64147>?4A @54:6>7A=1610@@0A6>:549;@6/9/907A>67C978486 0::=@4/90747>97:0;60G>6:64A6> 97<=16>4@41/G10;45568978 D9054/907 0G /61;A 47> :07>9/907A 0G @059:C 549; ?4A 45A0 0@@0A6>4AB69786J01B9/47/
4A6> 07 @564>978A /19B=745 G14;6> 9AA=6A 47> 16:01>6> 6D9>67:6 549;47/ 70 97 ( 70,
6J4;976>39;A65G4A#47>80/;41H6>JA/0?3956 97 ( 70
:549;47/ 6J4;976> 361A65G 47> 1
4<67>140/34194AA#47>47>80/;41H6>6J39B9/A# /0#7B0/3:4A6A97A=1616J4;976>9/FA4?GG9:614A 47>80/;41H6>JA
47>
- 8 -
$ 7:07A9>614/907/19B=745@4AA6>A6@414/64?41>A 305>9784::9>67/0::=116>>=6/014A347>76859867/>19D9780G /14:/01#/149561 BC 9/A >19D61 564>978 /0 >64/3 0G 4554;;4 47> :549;47/#34774;;4A=A/497978@61;4767/@3CA9:45>9A4B959/C 16A=5/9789750AA0G6417978:4@4:9/C47>97A=161B6978594B56/0 @4C:0;@67A4/9074AG0550?A 7(70,
0AA0G>6@67>67:C A$! # 0?41>A50D647>4GG6:/907 A # 0?41>A /147A@01/4/907 0G >64> B0>C A # ! 0?41>AG=761456J@67A6A A #
0/45 A,! #
7(70
0?41>A@49747>A=GG61978 A # 0?41>A;6>9:456J@67A6A A # 0?41>A >96/ 47> 4//67>47/ :34186A A # ! 0?41>A50AA0GG=/=166417978A A ,, # 0AA 0G 97:0;6 >=1978 /164/;67/ @6190> A #
0/45 0=7>6>0GG A,, # A #
88196D6> /36A6 4@@645A ?616 G956> / ?4A G91A/5C A=B;9//6>4A@61J#34186 366/>19D610G97A=16>/14:/01# /149561 ?4A @10A6:=/6> G01 0GG67:6A @=79A34B56 =7>61 6:/907A , 47> !# 0G 164> ?9/3 6:/907A 47> 0G 0/01 (639:56A :/ 97>9:4/978 /3616BC /34/ >19D61 0G 97A=16> D639:56?4A70/305>978D459>47>6GG6:/9D6>19D97859:67:64A07
- 9 -
>4/6 0G 4::9>67/ / ?4A G=1/361 :07/67>6> 4A @61 @059:6 97D6A/984/907 16:01>A B0/3 4554;;4 47> 34774;;4 ?616 =74=/3019I6>@4AA67861A/14D6597897800>AD639:56?30A619AH ?4A70/:0D616>=7>6197A=147:6@059:C3616G016G4A/679780G 594B959/C077A=161?4A70/<=A/9G96>
7 K=47/=; 9/ ?4A A=B;9//6> /19B=745 34> :07A9>616> G4:/A 47> :91:=;A/47:6A 97 @10@61 @61A@6:/9D6 97 B0/3:4A6A47>4?41>6><=A/:0;@67A4/90747>/3616G016/3616 ?4A 70 A:0@6 G01 67347:6;67/ / ?4A A=B;9//6> :0;@67A4/90797(70 ?4A97G4:/6J:6AA9D647> :4556> G01 16>=:/907 4A /19B=745 34> 4?41>6> A=; 0G A ,, # /0?41>A E50AA 0G G=/=16 6417978AF 6D67 /30=83 :549;47/34>A=A/4976>075C>6@16AA6>G14:/=160G56G/;4J95541C A97=A47>A=B5=J4/9070G:410;:54D9:=541?39:3?0=5>70/564> /0 47C G=7:/90745 >9A4B959/C 7 A49> 810=7>A A0=83/ G01 4550?9787A=161FA4@@645A
, 7 0/361 347> 19 47<66D 4/95 564176> :0=7A65 G01:549;47/A0@@0A6>7A=161FA4@@645A47>@16AA6>:549;47/AF 4@@645AG0167347:6;67/
- 10 -
/ ?4A A=B;9//6> A97:6 D9:/9;A 0G ;0/01 D639:56 4::9>67/ 97 @16A67/ :4A6 ?616 /391> @41/96A /0 :07/14:/ 0G 97A=147:6 7A=161 :0=5> 70/ 4D09> 594B959/C 48497A/ /36; BC 165C978 =@07 "=55 67:3 >6:9A907 0G /39A 0=1/ 97 !!"# $ %& ' ( )) '' *
+ % , #
47> 0G 07FB56 =@16;6 0=1/ 97 - .." &/#!
' 0 ,"1 # % 12 16@01/6> 97 3
4 5 + / ?4A A=B;9//6> 7A=161 :0=5> 4/ B6A/ A66H G01 ;0>9G9:4/9070G4?41>/00760G@4C47>16:0D61C
7K=47/=;97(70, 9/?4AA=B;9//6> >6:64A6>4554;;4?4AC641A0G486?01H9784A54B0=161 47> A/4/6> /0B66417978
A, #@61 ;07/3 =/ 19B=745 4AA6AA6> 9/ 4/
A$ # / ?4A A=B;9//6> 19B=745 6116> 97 70/ 4?41>978 4@@10@194/6 :0;@67A4/907 =7>61 07D67/90745 364>A
7 ( 70 9/ ?4A A=B;9//6> :549;47/ ?4A C641A 0G 486 ?01H978 4A 54B0=161 47> 6417978 A, #@61;07/3=/19B=7454AA6AA6>9/4/
A$ # /?4AA=B;9//6>:549;47/34>A=A/4976>G14:/=160G;6>94547> 54/6145 ?455 0G 56G/ ;4J95541C A97=A 47> G14:/=16 0G 56G/ IC80/9:
B076 6A@9/6 A4;6 4?41> 0G
A # /0?41>A E@497 47>
- 11 -
A=GG61978F ?4A 07 50?61 A9>6 D67 4?41> 0G
A # /0?41>A E50AA 0G 97:0;6 >=1978 549>#=@ @6190>F ?4A 45A0 974>6K=4/6 47> A0=83/ 67347:6;67/ / ?4A 54A/5C A=B;9//6> 19B=74534>6116>9770/4?41>97847C4;0=7//0?41>AE50AA0G 4;679/96AF
641> 564176> :0=7A65 G01 @41/96A @61=A6> <=>8;67/47>4?41>47>16:01>A ! "10; 4B0D6 0::=1167:6 0G 4::9>67/ 97D05D978 97A=16> D639:56 564>978 /0 >64/3 0G 4554;;4 47> @61;4767/ @3CA9:45>9A4B959/CA=A/4976>BC34774;;441670/97>9A@=/6 097/A/34/?0=5>419A6G01:07A9>614/907416
-.&/010
416 @61=A45 0G J + 34186 A366/ ?0=5> 97>9:4/6/34/>19D610G/14:/01#/149561?4A@10A6:=/6>G01>19D978 ;0/01D639:56?9/30=/305>978D459>47>6GG6:/9D6>19D97859:67:6 4@41/G10;:4=A9784::9>67/>=6/014A347>76859867/>19D978 JA 47> + "
47> :0;@5497/ ?0=5> 97>9:4/6 /34/ B0/3
- 12 -
D9:/9;A 96 4554;;4 47> 34774;;4 ?616 /14D65978 97 504>6> /14:/01#/149561 ?367 9/ ;6/ ?9/3 4::9>67/ J
+ 7A=147:6 @059:C ?0=5> :0D61 19AH 0G 0?761 >19D61 =@/0
A 4H3A 47> 59;9/6> 594B959/C 4A @61 # 97 16A@6:/ 0G @49> >19D61 :07>=:/01 :564761 0?6D61 9/FA A64/978 :4@4:9/C 9A A30?7 4A EF 075C 3616G016 D9:/9;A ?0=5> B6 =74=/3019I6> @4AA67861A=/97D96?0G>6:9A90797( )) '' FA:4A6'A=@14) 7A=161 ?0=5> B6 594B56 /0 @4C :0;@67A4/907 /0 :549;47/A 97 G91A/97A/47:647>/36164G/6116:0D61A4;6G10;97A=16>
$ 9;9541 @0A9/907 ?0=5> 4D495 6D67 97 :4A6 >19D61 0G 97A=16>D639:56?61670/305>978D459>59:67:697D96?0G14/9097 - .."FA:4A6'A=@14)
097/709A/3616G016@41/5C4GG91;4/9D64A4B0D6
-.&/010 /0%0 )
7A0G41 4A ;07/35C 97:0;6 9/ 9A A/4/6> /34/ >6:64A6>4554;;4?4AC641A0G486?01H9784A4819:=5/=145 :0059647>6417978
A, #@61;07/30?6D61A4;6?4A 70/ A=BA/47/94/6> ?9/3 A@6:9G9: ;4/61945 7 4BA67:6 /19B=745 ?4A <=A/9G96> 9/ 70/907455C =/ 70/90745 97:0;6 G01 @6190> 0G
- 13 -
4::9>67/96$B6978
A #4A4>0@/6>BC4174/4H4 /4/6 6845 61D9:6A =/3019/C G01 A6//56;67/ 0G :4A6A B6G016 0H>454/3/19B=745?4A70/<=A/9G96>97/4H9789/4/
A$ # /34A/0B6:07A9>616>4/
A #@61;07/3 , 549;47/A4163=AB47>47>/3166;9701:395>1670G >6:64A6> 19B=745 1983/5C >6>=:/6> !/3 /0?41>A @61A0745 6J@67A6A47>4@@596>:0116:/;=5/9@59610G$=/G4956>/04>> G=/=16 @10A@6:/A /0 ;07/35C 97:0;6 A @61 >6:9A907 97 & )!"# $ 1. 6%1&' -# 6+&/ &/#!16@01/6>973
74
+A97:6>6:64A6>?4A C641A 0G 486 47> A65G#6;@50C6> !L 34A /0 B6 4>>6> 4A G=/=16 @10A@6:/A 3=A :0;@=/4/907 0G 50AA 0G >6@67>67:C ?0=5>B64AG0550?A
M'
A #N!L)+ !/3OJJ$P
A$! #
@41/G10;4B0D6:549;47/ 70?0=5>B667/9/56> G01 A@0=A45 :07A01/9=; 47> :549;47/A 70 /0 ! ?0=5> B6 67/9/56> G01 @4167/45 :07A01/9=; 0G
A!
# 64:3 96 A$ # 7 4>>9/907 /36C ?0=5> B6 67/9/56> G01 A # /0?41>A 50AA 0G 6A/4/6 47>
A # /0?41>A G=76145 6J@67A6A ?41> 0G :0;@67A4/907 /0?41>A 50D6 47>
- 14 -
4GG6:/907 47> /147A@01/4/907 0G >64> B0>C ?0=5> 70/ B6 <=A/9G96> "=1/361 4A @61 >6:9A907 0G 07FB56 =@16;6 0=1/ 97 :4A6 0G -# 6 +&/8! 'A=@14) L 6A:454/907 34A /0 B6 4>>6> G01 6D61C /3166 C641A /0 4?41> =7>61 :07D67/90745 364>A 97:6 A9J C641A 34D6 54@A6> 4G/61 >6:9A907 0G -# 6 +&/8!:4A6'A=@14)L34A/0B64>>6>/0?41>A6A:454/907 ?39:3 ?0=5> B6
A # 3=A /0/45 :0;@67A4/907 ?0=5> B6 7(70,
0AA0G>6@67>67:C A$! # 0AA0G:07A01/9=;97/0/45 A$ # 0AA0G6A/4/6 A # ! "=761456J@67A6A A # A:454/907 A #
0/45 A,, #
-.&/010 /0%0 )
7A0G414A;07/35C97:0;634774;;4?4AA/4/6> /0B6C641A0G486?01H9784A4819:=5/=145:0059647>6417978 A, # @61 ;07/3 0?6D61 A4;6 ?4A 70/ A=BA/47/94/6> ?9/3 A@6:9G9: ;4/61945 7 4BA67:6 /19B=745 ?4A <=A/9G96> 9/ 70/907455C=/70/9074597:0;6G01@6190>0G4::9>67/96$ B6978
A #4A4>0@/6>BC4174/4H4 /4/66845 61D9:6A =/3019/C G01 A6//56;67/ 0G :4A6A B6G016 0H >454/3 /19B=745
- 15 -
?4A 70/ <=A/9G96> 97 /4H978 9/ 4/
A$ # / 34A /0 B6 :07A9>616>4/
A #@61;07/3
A 0BA61D6> BC /19B=745 BC 16G611978 /0 J # ?0=7> :61/9G9:4/6 :549;47/ A=A/4976> /3166 8196D0=A 97<=196A 0?6D61 7076 0G /36; ?616 G14:/=145 97<=196A =/ /19B=745 70/6>J#Q#14C16@01/A30?9786D9>67:60G05>G14:/=160G ;6>945 47> 54/6145 ?455 0G 56G/ ;4J95541C A97=A 47> 56G/ IC80/9:
B0764H97870/60GA4;64?41>0G
A #/0?41>A@497 47>A=GG61978?0=5>4@@641974>6K=4/647>A/47>A67347:6>/0 A #
19B=745 4?41>6> A # /0?41>A ;6>9:45 6J@67A6A 48497A/ B955A @10>=:6> 97:6 /3616 9A 16# 9;B=1A6;67/ /3616 ?0=5> B6 70 A:0@6 0G 67347:6;67/ 19B=745 4?41>6>
A # /0?41>A >96/ 4//67>47/ 47> :07D6C47:6G0197@4/967/@6190>0G >4CA 4;64@@641A/0B6 <=A/47>@10@6147>7067347:6;67/01;455CG14:/=16A/4H6 4B0=/ /3166 ;07/3A /0 3645 07A9>61978 A4;6 4A 54C#0GG :549;47/9A4?41>6>
A$ # !
6J4;976>:549;47/47>4AA6AA6>>9A4B959/C0G L 61=A45 0G J#>9A4B959/C :61/9G9:4/6 ?0=5> 16D645
- 16 -
4AA6AA;67/ 0G @61;4767/ @3CA9:45 >9A4B959/C 9A B4A6> 07 A:47 0G B1497 47> Q#14C 16@01/A =/ J#Q#14C 16@01/ 0G AH=55 >06A 70/ 16D645 47C 6D9>67:6 0G 4B701;459/C 0160D61 #1
4<67>140/34199A4 =1860747>70/6=10# =18607 01AC:394/19A/634A45A016G6116>/0Q#14C16@01/47>0@976> :549;47/ 34> A=A/4976> L>9A4B959/C >=6 /0G14:/=16 0GAH=55 47> L >=6 /0 A=B5=J4/907 0G 4:10;0#:54D9:=541 6 34A 30?6D61 70/ 89D67 @41/9:=541A 0G B4A9A 0G 4AA6AA;67/ A=:3 4A 6J/67/ 0G 16A/19:/907 0G ;0D6;67/ 6/: 3616G016 4AA6AA;67/ 4@@641A6J488614/6>47>16K=916A;0>614/90701;455C6D67 G14:/=160G:54D9:56>06A70/16A=5/9750AA0G6417978:4@4:9/C 7>61 A=:3 :91:=;A/47:6A 4AA6AA;67/ 0G G=7:/90745 >9A4B959/C 4/LBC/19B=745?0=5>4@@6416J:6AA9D647>70/A=@@01/6> BC ;4/61945 07 16:01> AA=;@/907 0G 1> 59;B >9A4B959/C 4A ?3056B0>C>9A4B959/C?0=5>70/69/361B6@10@6101<=A/9G94B56 4H97870/60G74/=160G97<=196AA=A/4976> L50AA0G6417978 :4@4:9/C :47 B6 :07A9>616> 97:6 :549;47/ ?4A C641A 0G 486 ;=5/9@5961 4@@59:4B56 ?0=5> B6 3=A G=/=16 50AA 0G 97:0;6?0=5>B6 A #J LJJP
A, #
- 17 -
19B=745 34A 70/ 4?41>6> 47C :0;@67A4/907 /0?41>A 50AA 0G 4;679/96A 4H978 70/6 0G A;455 6J/67/ 0G >9A4B959/C:4=A6>9/?0=5>B64@@10@194/6/04?41>
A # /0?41>AA4;6 $ 3=A/0/45:0;@67A4/907?0=5>B6 7(70
0?41>A@49747>A=GG61978 A # 0?41>A;6>9:456J@67A6A A # 0?41>A >96/ 47> 4//67>47/ :34186A A # ! 0?41>A50AA0GG=/=166417978A A, # 0AA 0G 97:0;6 >=1978 /164/;67/ @6190> A$ # $ 0AA0G4;679/96A A #
0/45
A #
097/ 70 97 /3616G016 47A?616> @41/5C 97 4GG91;4/9D64A4B0D607A6K=67/5CG0550?978
9 7A=161FA4@@64597"A70 $ 47>
" 70 $ 416 )) . #& 075C 97A0G41 4A 594B959/C ?361697 59B61/C 9A 16A61D6> /0 9/ /0 @4C :0;@67A4/907 /0 :549;47/A 47> /36164G/61 16:0D61 9/ G10; 97A=16> 0?761 99 549;47/AF 4@@645 97 " 70!, 9A )) . #& 549;47/FA 4@@645 97 " 70!,$ 9A!1!! - 18 -
999 %=>8;67/47>4?41>>4/6>!$@4AA6> BC 67901 9D95 %=>86 47> 39//4@=1 97 ( 70,
549;47/A 97 ( 70,
416 365> 67/9/56> G01 /0/45 :0;@67A4/907 0G
A,, # 4A 48497A/ A,! # 4?41>6> BC 19B=745 ?9/3 97/616A/4/$L@61477=;G10;>4/60G@6/9/907 /955@4C;67/G10;97A=161 9D 6A@07>67/#97A=161 9A >916:/6> /0 >6@0A9/ 67347:6>:0;@67A4/907B6G01619B=745?9/397 4@6190>0GA9J?66HA D 549;47/ 97 ( 70 9A 365> 67/9/56> G01 /0/45 :0;@67A4/907 0G
A # 4A 48497A/
A # 4?41>6> BC 19B=745 ?9/3 97/616A/ 4/ $L @61 477=; G10; >4/6 0G @6/9/907/955@4C;67/G10;97A=161 D9 ;0=7/97>6@0A9/97B0/397A=161FA4@@645A416 01>616> /0 B6 /147A;9//6> /0 /19B=745 G01 @4C;67/
!2) '%%!( #
AV/msr