- 1 - ! "# $ ## #% &'(&)*+ '& ** , !"#$ % &'$ ( )#" )&! ((% *') *#"& % + , + + "*#$*#"' + **#*#*# Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + *& *#"' % &&&*& #) ( - + - + ./ 0/123245 6/727245/0 8/259 7./ :;;<3/= 25 4*') *#"& 45 7./ >2?/ 4> ?/:05/= 212? +<=9/ :5= + .40:6<0 23 2@6<95259 7./ A<=9@/57 4> ;4512;7245 :5= 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/ =:7/= "*#$*#"' ;4512;7259 7./ :;;<3/= >40 7./ 4>>/5;/3 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453 &*& && :5= #) 4> 7./ 5=2:5 /5:? 4=/ "!# >40 3.407 BC :5= 3/57/5;259 74 <5=/094 029404<3 2@602345@/57 >40 : 6/024= 4> "D/:0 :5= 746:D>25/ 4> 3"#### >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 && 4> E 74 <5=/09432@6?/2@602345@/57>40:6/024=4>"D/:0:5=74 6:D >25/ 4> 3"#### >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 #) 4> E 74 6:D >25/ 4> 3"### >40 7./ - 3 - 4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/<5=/0 /;7245&*&4>F27.=/>:<?7 3/57/5;/3 F.2;. F:3 ;45>20@/= 25 02@25:? 66/:? 4*& *#"' 8D 7./ ?/:05/= 23702;7 :5= /332453 +<=9/ :=9202 8D =23@233259 7./ :66/:? 12=/ A<=9@/57 =:7/= **#*#*# * ./ >:;73 4> 7./ ;:3/ 25 802/> :0/ 7.:7 (" 8/2597.//D/F275/33>2?/=>203725>40@:7245F27. .406:<0 64?2;/ :9:2537 7./ :;;<3/= :??/9259 ;4@@233245 4> 7./ 4>>/5;/3 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453 &*& && :5= #) 4> 72337:7/=7.:745&#""*#"*:7:84<7)##6@ 7./:;;<3/=62;G/= <6H<:00/? F27. 7./ 25A<0/= (:5= :33:<?7/= .2@ F27. .:5=3 ;:<3/= 25A<02/3 60/1/57/= .2@ >04@ =23;.:09259 .23 4>>2;2:? =<7D :3 :5;.:D:7 /1/?46@/57 >>2;/0 :5= 62;G/= <6 H<:00/? F27. :5 257/572457460414G/.2@74;4@@2780/:;.4>6/:;/5 7./ 8:323 4> 7./ 3:@/ 0/9237/0/= 8D 7./ 64?2;/ 251/3729:7245F:3<5=/07:G/5:5=7./>25:?0/6407;:@/74 8/>2?/= - 4 - & /:05/= :92370:7/ 744G ;4952I:5;/ 4> 7./ 4>>/5;/ :5= 0/9237/0/= 4*') *#"& ./ :;;<3/= :66/:0/= 8/>40/ 7./ 02:? 4<07 6?/:=/= 547 9<2?7D :5= ;?:2@/=748/702/=./6043/;<7245/J:@25/=(3"74$ :5=947@:0G/=J3"74'253<664074>273;457/57245 ./ :;;<3/= .:3 =/52/= :?? 7./ 25;02@25:7259 @:7/02:?3 :1:2?:8?/ 45 0/;40= 8<7 .:3 547 ?/= :5D /12=/5;/ 25 3<664074>.23=/>/5;/ ) ./ 02:? 4<07 :>7/0 7:G259 2574 ;4532=/0:7245 :?? 7./ @:7/02:?3 45 0/;40= ;:@/ 74 7./ ;45;?<3245 7.:7 7./ 6043/;<7245 23 3<;;/33><? 25 6041259 7./ 9<2?7 4> 7./ :;;<3/= 8/D45= 0/:345:8?/ =4<87 :5= :;;40=259?D ;4512;7/=:5=3/57/5;/=.2@:337:7/=:841/ /259 :9902/1/= 8D 7./ 3:@/ 7./ :;;<3/= 60/>/00/= :5 :66/:? 25 02@25:? 66/:? 4*& *#"' ./ 203766/??:7/4<07450/ :660/;2:72454>7./@:7/02:?345 0/;40=;45>20@/=7./A<=9@/574>;4512;7245:5=40=/04> 3/57/5;/8D=23@2332597./:66/:?/259:9902/1/=8D7./ 3:@/7./:;;<3/=.:360/>/00/=7.230/1232456/727245 - 5 - /:0= 02 0:=//6 <@:0 ?/:05/= >40 7./ 0/123245 6/727245/0 :5= @7 0:72 :72? ?/:05/= 29. 4<07 41/05@/57 ?/:=/0 >40 7./ 0/3645=/57 7:7//0<3/=7./@:7/02:?3450/;40= $ 512/F4>7./021:?;457/5724538D7./?/:05/= ;4<53/?>40847.7./6:072/37./642577.:7F4<?=:023/>40 @D;4532=/0:724523 D :53F/0 74 7./ :841/ 64257 23 >407./>4??4F259 ! 7 23 7./ ;457/57245 4> 7./ 6043/;<7245 7.:7 ( F:3 F40G259 :3 :5;.:D:7 /1/?46@/57 >>2;/0 25 7./ :?<G :5;.:D:7 4>>2;/ 5 &#""*#"* 7./ :;;<3/= ;:@/ 74 7./6:5;.:D:7 4>>2;/ 62;G/= <6 H<:00/? F27. 7./ - 6 - 25A<0/=3?:66/=.2@;:<3/=25A<02/360/1/57/=.2@>40@ =23;.:09259 .23 4>>2;2:? =<7D :5= :?34 25=<;/= 74 ;4@@27 80/:;.4>6/:;/46041/273;457/572457./6043/;<7245 /J:@25/=7./25>40@:57:3("1/57.4<9.("237./ /D/F275/33747./25;2=/57./.:3547><??D3<66407/=7./ ;:3/ 4> 7./ 6043/;<7245 2@2?:0?D () F.4 23 ;27/= :3 /D/F275/33 .:3 :?34 547 ><??D 3<66407/= 7./ ;:3/ 4> 7./ 6043/;<7245 ' ( 23 7./ 25A<0/= /D/F275/33 8/259 7./ :5;.:D:7 /1/?46@/57 >>2;/0 25 7./ :?<G :5;.:D:7 4>>2;/($23:?34:54>>2;2:?257./:?<G:5;.:D:7:5= ./ 23 ;27/= :3 /D/F275/33 47. (3 :5= $ .:1/ ><??D 3<66407/=7./;:3/4>7./6043/;<7245 "# J$237./F4<5=;/072>2;:7/6/07:25259747./ 25A<0/= ;;40=259 74 F.2;. 7./ 25A<0/= ( F:3 /J:@25/=8D7.//=2;:?>>2;/0457./1/0D3:@/=:D:7 $6@F27.:.23740D4>:33:<?78D7./:;;<3/=./0/ F:37/5=/05/3360/3/5741/07./?/>732=/4>;./374>7./ 25A<0/= F.2;. F:3 =/3;028/= :3 32@6?/ 25A<0D 7 23 - 7 - 6/0725/57 74 547/ 7.:7 45 7./ =:7/ 4> 25;2=/57 273/?> 7./ >2037 25>40@:7245 ;:@/ 74 8/ >2?/= :9:2537 7./ 6/727245/0 ./0/25 "" 4532=/0259 :?? 7./3/ >:;73 :5= ;20;<@37:5;/3 =4 547 >25= :5D 0/:345 74 3<36/;7 7./ 1/03245 4> 7./ 25A<0/= /D/F275/33 ( :5= 7./ /D/F275/33 ($ ./0/>40/ :@ 4> 7./ 4625245 7.:7 7./ 6043/;<7245 23 3<;;/33><? 25 6041259 7./ 9<2?7 4> 7./ :;;<3/= 8/D45= 0/:345:8?/=4<87:5=./23?2:8?/>40;4512;7245 "* .:1/945/7.04<9.7./2@6<95/=A<=9@/574> ;4512;72456:33/=8D7./02:?4<07:5=;45>20@/=8D7./ 2037 66/??:7/ 4<07 47. 7./ 4<073 .:1/ 7:G/5 2574 ;4532=/0:7245 7./ @:7/02:?3 45 0/;40= 25 6046/0 6/036/;721/=4547>25=:5D0/:34574257/0>/0/F27.7./ 3:@/ "& 7 7.23 37:9/ ?/:05/= @2;<3 <02:/ 3<8@273 7.:77./6/727245/0./0/25F:3:9/=D/:03:77./72@/ 4>7./25;2=/57:5=54F./23:9/=$!D/:03./:;725 - 8 - H</37245F:3547:5257/57245:?45/./0/>40/60:D3>40 3.4F259@:J2@<@?/52/5;D25.23>:14<0 ") 4532=/0259 7./ 3<8@233245 @:=/ 8D 7./ ?/:05/= @2;<3 <02:/ :@ 4> 7./ 4625245 7.:7 7./ 2@6<95/=40=/04>3/57/5;/2@6432593/57/5;/74<5=/094 32@6?/2@602345@/57>40:6/024=45/D/:0>407./4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 && :5= #) 4> ;4<?= 8/ @4=2>2/=:5=2@643259>25/4>3"#### >407./4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 &*& 4> ;4<?= :?34 8/ @4=2>2/= " 512/F4>7./:841/:53F/07./:841/64257 :5= 604;//= 74 6:33 7./ >4??4F259 2 02@25:?0/1232456/72724523 22 ./ A<=9@/57 4> ;4512;7245 =:7/= "*#$*#"' 6:33/= 25 4*') *#"& 45 7./ >2?/ 4> ?/:05/=212?+<=9/:5=+ .40:6<0>407./ - 9 - 4>>/5;/3 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453 &*& && :5= #) 4> :5= 7./ A<=9@/57 =:7/= **#*#*# 6:33/= 25 02@25:? 66/:? 66/:? 4*& *#"' 45 7./ >2?/ 4> ?/:05/= 23702;7 :5= /332453 +<=9/ :=9202 ;45>20@259 7./ A<=9@/57 4> ;4512;7245 6:33/= 8D 7./ 02:? 4<07:0/./0/8D;45>20@/= 222 4F/1/0 7./ 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/ 6:33/= 8D 7./ 02:?4<0723@4=2>2/=:3<5=/0 : ./ :;;<3/= 6/727245/0 23 3/57/5;/= 74 6:D >25/ 4> 3*### /:;. >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 &*& && :5= #) 4> :5= 25 =/>:<?7 74 6:D >25/ ./ 3.:?? <5=/09432@6?/2@602345@/57>40:6/024=4> "=:D3/:;. 8 25/:@4<576:2=25/J;/334>7./3/57/5;/3 2@643/= ./0/25 2> :5D 23 40=/0/= 74 8/ - 10 - 0/><5=/= 74 7./ :;;<3/= 45 =</ 2=/572>2;:7245 ./>//34>@2;<3<02:/23>2J/=:73"#### ./ ?/:05/= ==27245:? /92370:0 /5/0:? 23 =20/;7/= 74@:G/5/;/33:0D:00:59/@/573>406:D@/574>7./>//3 747./@2;<3<02:/ /92370D 23 =20/;7/= 74 3/5= 8:;G 7./ 02:? 4<07 0/;40=3 :?459 F27. 7./ ;46D 4> 7.23 A<=9@/57 >40 25>40@:7245:5=5//=><?:;7245 -+ &##* $ 2374" ?4**