- 1 - ! "!#$!$ $ % ! "#$#% & ' ( ) # * ! "#$+ & ' () ( * * * +%# * ( ( * Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( * , ( ( -./ 012.2.34 ./ 5.617 89 2-1 012.2.341: ;.51 /11<.4= 2:>4/51:35 3+%#0147.4=342-15.613514.3: .?.6@7=1>.6-34=>623*>A.693@:2>6>8@:>=. 1>:761>:417B3@4/1653:2-1012.2.341: 4/0.21 35/1:?.B135432.B12-1:1/0347142:1A>.417>8/142>47 @4:10:1/14217 + -1 :1/0347142 ->/ 5.617 012.2.34 /11<.4= 7.//36@2.34 35 A>::.>=1 .4 3+%# >47 .2 ./ 0147.4=342-15.613514.3:.?.6@7=1>.6-34=>6 1>:417B3@4/1653:2-1012.2.341:";.51/@8A.2/ 2->22-17./2>4B1812;114>6>8@:>=.23>.6-34=>6./A3:1 2->4%%>47.2./.4B34?14.14253:2-1012.2.341:23 2:>?16 2-1 />.7 7./2>4B1 >47 A3:1 /3 /-1 ./ ->?.4= 4.41 91>:A.43:B-.67.2-2-1/1-10:>9/23>663;2-1012.2.34 - 3 - # >?.4= -1>:7 61>:417 B3@4/16 2-./ 3@:2 ->/ 01:@/17012.2.340>01:/ C -1 :1/0347142 ->/ 5.617 2-1 012.2.34 /11<.4= 7.//36@2.34 35 A>::.>=1 .4 3+%# >47 .2 ./ 0147.4=342-15.61352-114.3:.?.6@7=1>.6-34=>6 4 2-1 B>@/1 2.261 35 3+%# :1/.714B1 35 2-1 :1/0347142 ;-3 ./ 012.2.341: -1:1.4 ./ /-3;4 >/ >6>8@:>=.-17./2>4B1812;114>6>8@:>=.23>.6-34=>6 ./>83@2%%-1012.2.341:./->?.4=4.4191>:A.43: B-.67 2 ./ .4B34?14.142 53: 2-1 012.2.341: 23 2:>?16 5:3A >6>8@:>=.23>.6-34=>6 C -1 34D861 01E 3@:2 .4 2-1 B>/1 35 1 ->/ -167 >/ @471:F ! 1 Reported in AIR 2022 SC 4318 - 4 - " # # #$ # " # % " & ' ! % % ( # " ) 34/.71:.4= 2-1 >83?1 >/01B2 .5 2-1 B>/1 ./ 432 2:>4/51::17 >/ /3@=-2 .2 ;.66 B>@/1 .4B34?14.14B1 23 2-1 012.2.341:-1012.2.341:->/A>713@2B>/153:2:>4/51: >//3@=-2 G 42-1:1/@622-153663;.4= .) -1012.2.34./ - 5 - ..) 3+%# 0147.4= 34 2-1 5.61 35 2-1 14.3:.?.6@7=1>.6-34=>616>=>?../2:.B2 ./ 3:71:17 23 81 ;.2-7:>;4 >47 2:>4/51::17 23 *>A.693@:2>6>8@:>=.237./03/1352-1B>/1 .4>BB3:7>4B1;.2-6>; &' ($!$) # ./2 36 3+G