- 1 - ! "#" $" %!&"$"" %!&" "!"$$! '() * !" # $ % $ $ $ Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ &$$ $ '"#( ) * $ + $$ $$ $ '! '# $ &$ ,!(% $ $ '"#( )$ * $ - $$ $ $(((+ $ $ *+ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ #((# $ $ $ ( ( $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ . $ $ . $ - 3 - !& *. $+ /01 233425 01 67 852092:;1 144<0:= 9>?0@082;0>: >@ AB?=94:; 2:? 2C2D? ?2;4? #((# 32114? 67 D5 4:0>D 0E05 B?=4 2:? 208/BD 0: >( ( 8/2554:=0:=;/4FB2:;B92:?8>:;D06B;>D7:4=50=4:84 /4?2;4>@2880?4:;0:E>5E494:;>@9>;>D87854 21C455216B1645>:=0:=;>D413>:?4:;:>'>D3>D2;0>: ?42;/>@/0E2D2A2D4:>;0:?013B;4:57?013B;401C0;/ D4=2D?;>@21;4:0:=>@5026050;7>:;/4?D0E4D>@;/46B121 C455D0?4D>@;/49>;>D87854 D06B:25@21;4:4?8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 2; (G >: ;/4 ?D0E4D>@ 6B1 2:? (G >: ;/4 D0?4D>@9>;>D8785404?484214? 42D? 9;2;05 /2:;2620 B621/ 542D:4? 8>B:145@>D2334552:;12:?D02:AB:2;/2552772/4;;7 542D:4?8>B:145@>D>D3>D2;0>: # />B=/542D:4?8>B:145@>D2334552:;1/21@054? ;/01 233425 @>D 4:/2:8494:; >@ 8>934:12;0>: 21 C455 21 82550:=0:FB41;0>:;/48>:;D06B;>D7:4=50=4:84;/4542D:4? - 4 - 8>B:145 /21 D41;D08;4? ;/4 233425 >:57 ;> ;/4 4H;4:; >@ 8>:;D06B;>D7:4=50=4:8421 D06B:25/212C2D?4?AB1;2:? 233D>3D02;48>934:12;0>: 9;2;05 /2:;2620 B621/ 542D:4? 8>B:145 E4/494:;578>:;4:?4?;/2;;D06B:25C/054?018B110:=011B4 >@ 8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 2; 32D2=D23/ :> >@ ;/4 093B=:4? AB?=94:; 8>990;;4? 2: 4DD>D @21;4:0:= ;/4 8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 >:57 >: ;/4 =D>B:? ;/2; 5>>? 58>/>5>:84:;D2;0>:>@?484214?C212;"%(9=34D (( 95 21 34D H'* D43>D;+ 2:? @BD;/4D ;/2; ;/4 3>5084 /2E4 0:E><4? 48;0>: % D42? C0;/ 48;0>: " D42? C0;/ 48;0>: " %! >@ 8; 2=20:1; ?484214? D06B:250:;/42614:84>@2:74E0?4:84;>;/4 @28; ;/2; ;/4 ?484214? /2? 8>:;D06B;4? ;> 2880?4:; /2? 4DD>:4>B157 @21;4:4? ;/4 8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 >:57 >: ;/4=D>B:?;/2; 5>>?58>/>5>:84:;D2;0>:@>B:?2;;/4 D2;4 1;2;4? 1B3D2 01 9>D4 ;/2: 34D90110654 5090; 21 3D>E0?4?B:?4D48;0>:">@8; D06B:253D>844?4? >: ;/4 =D>B:? ;/2; ;/4 ?484214? C21 0: 2 ?DB:<4: - 5 - 8>:?0;0>: /2E0:= 8>:1B94? 258>/>5 4H844?0:= 5090; /21 251> 8>:;D06B;4? ;> 2880?4:; 42D:4? 8>B:145 /21 ;2<4: ;/01>BD;;>32D2=D23/:>>@;/4093B=:4?AB?=94:; B:?4D ;/4 /42? >@ 5026050;7 C/4D40: D06B:25 @21;4:4? 8>:;D06B;>D7:4=50=4:842;(G>:;/4D0?4D>@9>;>D87854 2:?(G>:;/4?D0E4D>@;/46B1 ! > 6B;;D411 /4D 2D=B94:;1 542D:4? 8>B:145 D4504? >: AB?=94:; 32114? 67 >'>D?0:2;4 4:8/ >@ ;/01 >BD; 0: :>((!# (# 8>::48;4? C0;/ :>(( (# ?013>14? >@@ >: (!(" C/4D40: 2; 32D2=D23/ :>! ;/01 >BD; /45? ;/2; 0: 2614:84 >@ 2:7 4E0?4:84 ;> ;/4 @28; ;/2; ;/4 ?484214? /21 82B14? 8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 4H>:4D2;0>: >@ 0:1BD4D @D>9 5026050;7>:57>:;/4=D>B:?>@ 5>>?58>/>5>:84:;D2;0>: @>B:?0:;/465>>?D43>D;01:>;1B1;20:26540:52C2:?;/4 0:1BD4D 82::>; 64 255>C4? ;> 418234 @D>9 0;1 5026050;7 ;> 12;01@7;/42C2D? /4542D:4?8>B:145>:26>E4=D>B:?1 1>B=/; ;> 255>C 233425 2:? @21;4: 4:;0D4 :4=50=4:84 >: ?D0E4D>@;/46B1 - 6 - 4D 8>:;D2 D0 2:AB:2;/ 2552772 /4;;7 542D:4? 8>B:145 E4/494:;57 8>:;4:?4? ;/2; ;/4 ?D0E4D >@ ;/46B1/21644:4H290:4?21 '2:?0:/014E0?4:84 /4/2113480@0825571;2;4?;/2;;/49>;>D878501;C/>C21 =>0:=2/42?>@6B10:2I0='I2=92::4D1B??4:57;>><;/4 9>;>D87854 >: D0=/; 10?4 ;> => ;> 92D2E2;0 D>2? 0: ;/2; @21/0>: ;/4 2880?4:; /21 >88BDD4? 4E4: ;/>B=/ ?D0E4D >@ ;/4 6B1 ;>>< 4H;D494 3D482B;0>: ;> 3D4E4:; ;/4 2880?4:; 67 ;2<0:= 6B1 >: ;/4 4H;D494 D0=/; 10?4 B; B:@>D;B:2;4572880?4:;;>><35284852090:=50@4>@/0E2D2A 4 /21 @BD;/4D 1B690;;4? ;/2; D43>D; 2; H' 8542D57 1/>C1 ;/2; ;/4 ?484214? C21 0: 2: 0:46D02;4? 8>:?0;0>: 9>D4 ;/2: 34D90110654 5090; 21 3D>E0?4? B:?4D 48;0>:">@8;58>/>58>:84:;D2;0>:@>B:?0:;/4 65>>? 8542D57 1/>C1 ;/2; ;/4 ?484214? C21 /2E0:= :> 8>:;D>5>E4D;/49>;>D878548843;0:=;/41294 D06B:25 /21 D0=/;57 @21;4:4? (G 5026050;7 >: ?484214? ;>C2D?1 8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 2:? 1294 ?>41 :>; 8255 @>D 2:7 - 7 - 0:;4D@4D4:84 2; ;/4 /2:?1 >@ ;/01 >BD; 88>D?0:=57 1>B=/;;>?019011;/4233425 " 2E0:= /42D? 8>B:145 @>D 32D;041 2:? 34DB10:= 4:;0D4 233425 3234D1 2:? D025 >BD; 48>D?1 ;/4 3>0:;1 ;/2;C>B5?2D014@>D>BD8>:10?4D2;0>:2D4 % BD2:1C4D;>26>E43>0:;10132D;572@@0D92;0E4 @>D;/4@>55>C0:= "" ( ;01:>;0:?013B;4;/2;;/42880?4:;>88BDD4?>: ;/44H;D494D0=/;10?4>@;/4D>2?134D;D2@@08DB5410: :?02 ;/4 E4/08541 C/4;/4D 6B1 >D 9>;>D87854 01 ;> 64 ?D0E4:>DD0??4:>:54@;10?4>@;/4D>2? /413>;>@;/4 2880?4:; 01 >: ;/4 4H;D494 D0=/; 10?4 ; 82::>; 64 5>1; 10=/; ;/2; 21 34D H' ;/4 ?484214? C21 0: 2: - 8 - 0:46D02;4?8>:?0;0>:2158>/>5>:84:;D2;0>:@>B:?0:/01 65>>? 01 "%( 9= 34D (( 95 C/08/ 01 26>E4 ;/4 34D901106545090;B:?4D48;0>:">@8;04(9= 34D (( 95 >C4E4D =>0:= ;/D>B=/ 4E0?4:84 >@ D413>:?4:; :>'?D0E4D >@ E4/0854 ;/4 8>:;4:;0>: >@ 8>B:145@>D>D3>D2;0>:82::>;6428843;4?D421>:640:= ;/4?D0E4D>@6B1/21:>;2;2551;2;4?2:7;/0:=D4=2D?0:= 1B??4:8D>110:=>@;/4D>2?67;/4?484214?C/054/4C21 D0?0:=/0160<42/42?>@6B10:/018/04@4E0?4:842@@0?2E0; /2;/4/211;2;4?C21;/2;;/4?484214?C21D0?0:=0:2 I0='I2= 92::4D 2:? 5>1; 8>:;D>5 2:? /0; ;/4 D0=/; 10?4 >@ ;/46B1?90;;4?57;/49>;>D87854C219>E0:=2/42?>@ ;/46B14:84;/4D401:>8/2:84@>D;/49>;>D878501;;> /0; ;/4 6B1 >: ;/4 >;/4D /2:? ;/4 6B1 /0;;0:= ;/4 9>;>D87854 H'! D43>D; 8542D57 1/>C1 ;/2; ;/4D4 2D4 18D2;8/41 @>B:? >: ;/4 D0=/; 10?4 6B934D >@ ;/4 6B1 2:? D0=/; 0:?082;>D C21 6D><4: ;/2; 232D; 2880?4:; >88BDD4?>:4H;D494D0=/;10?4>@;/4D>2? - 9 - 5;>=4;/4D 0@ 8>:10?4D4? ;/4 2880?4:; /21 >88BDD4?92764671>948>:;D06B;>D7:4=50=4:84>:32D; >@ ;/4 ?484214? D0?4D >@ ;/4 9>;>D87854 6B; :>; ;> ;/4 4H;4:; >@ (G 21 /21 644: @21;4:4? 67 D06B:25 0: 2614:84 >@ 2:7 4E0?4:84 ;> ;/4 @28; ;/2; D0?4D /21 1B??4:57 8D>114? ;/4 D>2? ;> => ;> 92D2E2;0 D>2? 21 8>:;4:?4?678>B:145@>D>D3>D2;0>:88>D?0:=57@0:?0:= >@ D06B:25 D4FB0D41 9>?0@082;0>: 2; ;/4 /2:?1 >@ ;/01 >BD;:3D414:84>@;/4@28;;/2;D0?4D>@9>;>D87854C21 0: 2: 0:46D02;4? 8>:?0;0>: 21 34D H' 2:? 0: ;/4 2614:84 >@ 2:7 4E0?4:84 26>B; E08;09 8D>110:= ;/4 D>2? 26DB3;57 ;/4 8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 82: 64 D4'2114114? 2; G >: ;/4 D0?4D >@ 9>;>D87854 >;/4DC014 ;/4 3D>3>D;0>:4?8>:;D06B;>D7:4=50=4:84;>;/44H;4:;>@(G 01>:/0=/4D10?42:?"G>:;/4?D0E4D>@;/46B10:E04C >@ AB?=94:; 80;4? *1B3D2+ >@ >'>D?0:2;4 4:8/ >@ ;/01 >BD;3>0:;1D2014?2D42:1C4D4?288>D?0:=57 >D ;/4 @>D4=>0:= D421>:1 C4 3211 ;/4 @>55>C0:= - 10 - 0 3342501255>C4?0:32D;0:?0:=>@ D06B:25 >: 8>:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 01 9>?0@04? >:;D06B;>D7 :4=50=4:84 >: D0?4D >@ 9>;>D8785401@0H4?2;G2:?>:?D0E4D>@ 6B12;"G 00 413>:?4:; :>'>D3>D2;0>: 1/255 ?43>10; ;> ;/4 4H;4:; >@ 8>934:12;0>: 04 G D4?B84? :4=50=4:84 25>:= C0;/ 0:;4D41; 2; !G 32 @D>9 ;/4 ?2;4 >@ 34;0;0>: ;055 D4250I2;0>:C0;/0:234D0>?>@10HC44<1@D>9 ?2;4>@D48403;>@84D;0@04?8>37>@;/01>D?4D 64@>D4;/48>:84D:4? D06B:25 000 33>D;0>:94:; 2:? ?016BD1494:; >@ 8>934:12;0>: 01 21 34D ;/4 >D?4D >@ ;/4 D06B:25 0E >>D?4D21;>8>1; - 11 - E 4=01;D7 01 ?0D48;4? ;> 14:? 628< D48>D?1 @>D;/C0;/ "+, '$"") & "+, ') & 01;>5>