Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66432 (KAR)

SANGAPPA v. MOHAMMED FAIYAZ ALI AND ANR

MFA/203617/2024 · 2025-11-20

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '#( ) ! " # # $ % $ & ' # $ % $$())! ! $#$ * $ $# ) " # $# & ! !+)!!)! * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ +( * $ $ $ $ # $ *)+ !!)!!#$ # , ! !) $ $ *$ $ -# $ % $ -# $ ./0 122314 /0 5/436 78 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 =:63> 3;9/?: +( ?5 ?9?>3./;430;9 @;.1443:A/:A9.3 B=6A<3:9 1:6 1C1>6 61936 )+ !!)!! 210036 78 9.3 ?=>9?566/9/?:143:/?>/D/4=6A31:6 ,19 /B1812=>1 /: ? ! !) 9? <?6/58 9.3 01/6 B=6A<3:91:63:.1:;39.3;?<23:019/?: ! $31>69.31>A=<3:90?59.3431>:36;?=:0345?> 9.3 1223441:9 1:6 431>:36 ;?=:034 5?> >302?:63:9 ?! ?9/;39?>302?:63:9? /06/023:036C/9. ( .3 /:B=>36 ;41/<1:9 1A36 ) 831>0 6?/:A 1A>/;=49=>14C?>E<39C/9.1:1;;/63:9?: ()!) 1:6 - 3 - 5/436 ;41/< 239/9/?: ;41/</:A ;?<23:019/?: ?5 0 )))))) .3 >/7=:14 ;?:0/63>/:A 9.3 3:9/>3 3D/63:;3 ?: >3;?>6 A>1:936 0+))) C/9. /:93>309 19 9.3 >193 ?5 F 21 5>?< 9.3 6193 ?5 239/9/?: 9/44 >314/019/?: ' AA>/3D36 78 9.3 01/6 ?>63> .3 2>353>>36 1: 1223141:6<1/:48;?:93:6369.19.33G1</:366?;9?>10 *! 1:69.3 6?;9?> 100300369.36/017/4/9810 F9? 9.3 43594?C3>4/<77=99.39>/7=:143>>36/:91E/:A9.301<3 10(F101C.?437?686/017/4/98.39>/7=:14140?91E3: 0@))) <31A3> /:;?<3 .3 1<?=:90 A>1:936 =:63> 9.3 ?9.3> .3160 1>3 140? ?: 9.3 4?C3> 0/63 .3>35?>3 >3H=309365?>3:.1:;3<3:9 .?=A. 239/9/?:3> 091936 9.19 .3 C10 31>:/:A 0 )))23><?:9..3.10:?95/4361:8/:;?<32>??5 $3 <39 C/9. 1: 1;;/63:9 ?: ()!) 0 23> 9.3 A=/634/:30?51>:191E191933A143>D/;30=9.?>/98./0 - 4 - :?9/?:14/:;?<3/09?7391E3:100 +)23><?:9. $3C101A36*+,-.1:69.3<=49/24/3>91E3:/0 023>9.3C?=:6;3>9/5/;1935/436=:63>G'.3 0=091/:36 17>10/?: ?D3> 4359 214< G ' ;<0 >366/0. 03;?:6 /:B=>8 21/: 0C344/:A 1:6 >309>/;936 <?D3<3:9 ?5 4359 43A 0 23> G>18 4359 E:33 5>1;9=>3 033: ?D3> 4359 9/7/1.316 + .3 239/9/?:3> 3G1</:36 9.3 6?;9?> 10 *! 1:6 .3 10030036 9.3 6/017/4/98 9? 9.3 4359 4/<7 10 F 9 C10 0919369.199.3>3C10.314365>1;9=>3?543590/63.316?5 9.3 9/7/14 7?:3 1:6 4359 0/63 5/7=41> 7?:3 12231>0 9? 73 :?><14 ?:0/63>/:A 9.3 :19=>3 ?5 9.3 /:B=>/30 1:6 9.3 3D/63:;3 ?5 9.3 6?;9?> 9./0 ;?=>9 5/:60 /9 >310?:1743 9? 91E39.36/017/4/9810F$3C10.?02/914/I365?>!6180 .3>35?>3 9.3 4?00 ?5 5=9=>3 31>:/:A ;121;/98 ;?<30 9? 0 +) G ! G G F J . /0 >/7=:14 A>1:936 1: 1<?=:9 ?5 ./10 9?C1>60 <36/;14 - 5 - 3G23:030 1:6 /9 :3360 :? /:93>53>3:;3 ?:0/63>/:A 9.3 :19=>3 ?5 /:B=>/30 ?;;=219/?: 1:6 1A3 ?5 9.3 239/9/?:3> 9./0 ;?=>9 5/:60 /9 >310?:1743 9? A>1:9 1: 1<?=:9 ?5 .05?>21/:1:60=553>/:A. 05?>4?00 ?5 1<3:/9/30 .0 5?> 9>1:02?>919/?: 3G9>1 :?=>/0.<3:9 1:6 1993:61:9 ;.1>A30 .3 ;41/<1:9 </A.9 :?9.1D31993:6361:8?9.3>C?>E19431095?>123>/?6?5 ' <?:9.0 6=3 9? 9.3 /:B=>/30 0=091/:36 /: 9.3 1;;/63:9 .3>35?>3. 0 +)G'/0A>1:936=:63>9.3 .3164?00?5/:;?<36=>/:A41/6=223>/?6 @ .3 <1::3> ?5 1;;/63:9 0.?C0 9.19 C./43 239/9/?:3>C10?:9.33G9>3<33:6?59.3>?16<?9?>;8;43 731>/:A3A?()'(@;1<35>?<#1A14E?9;>?00 0/63/:1>10.1:6:3A4/A3:9<1::3>1:69.3>/63>?59.3 <?9?>;8;43 C10 =:1743 9? ;?:9>?4 9.3 01<3 ;1<3 ?: C>?:A0/631:6610.369?239/9/?:3> )31>:36;?=:0345?>9.3>302?:63:900919369.19 239/9/?:3> ./<0345 /: 9.3 ;>?003G1</:19/?: .16 16</9936 - 6 - 9.19.3C10;>?00/:A9.3>?16199.39/<3?59.31;;/63:9 0 0=;. 9.3 9>/7=:14 .10 5/G36 =2 9.3 ;?:9>/7=9/?: :3A4/A3:;310+F?:9.3>/63>?59.3<?9?>;8;431:6!F ?: 9.3 239/9/?:3> 6</993648 9.3 239/9/?:3> C10 ?: 9.3 3G9>3<33:6?59.3>?16?>3D3:/5/9/0;?:0/63>369.19.3 C10;>?00/:A9.3>?16<3>3;>?00/:A?59.3>?16/0:?91 ;?:9>/7=9?>8 :3A4/A3:;3 1:6 /9 /0 :?9 9.3 ;103 ?5 9.3 >302?:63:99.19.3 /0 /: 1 6>=:E3: ;?:6/9/?: .3>35?>3 9.3 ;?:9>/7=9?>8 :3A4/A3:;3 10030036 1A1/:09 239/9/?:3> /0 03910/63.3:3A4/A3:;3/09?91448?:9.321>9?59.3>/63> ?5 9.3 <?9?>;8;43 1:6 9.3 /:0=>1:;3 ;?<21:8 /0 4/1743 9? 218 9.3 3:9/>3 ;?<23:019/?: .3>35?>3 /9 /0 091936 9.19 /:0=>1:;3;?<21:8632?0/936+F?59.31C1>6361<?=:9 735?>39.39>/7=:14>302?:63:9?!/06/>3;9369?2189.3 7141:;31<?=:9 .=0 /: 144 ;?<2?:3:90 1C1>636 78 9./0 ;?=>9 1>310734?C - 7 - $3:;3 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 /0 3:9/9436 5?> 9?914 ;?<23:019/?:?5. /1/014?:AC/9./:93>309199.3 >193?5F21/:09316?50+)))10A>1:936789.3 9>/7=:14 ! :9.3>30=499.35?44?C/:A?>63>/0210036 / 22314/0 /:21>9 // .3 B=6A<3:9 1:6 1C1>6 61936 )+ !!)!! 210036 78 9.3 ?=>9 ?5 66/9/?:14 3:/?> /D/4 =6A3 1:6 3<73> , 19 /B1812=>1 /: ? ! !) /0<?6/5/36 1>9/;=41>0 <?=:9/:0 ?00 ?5 5=9=>3 31>:/:A ;121;/98 !')) 36/;143G23:030 @)) 1/:1:60=553>/:A )))) ?00?51<3:/9/30 !))) >1:02?>919/?: 3G9>1 :?=>/0.<3:9 1:6 1993:61:9 ;.1>A30 ()))) /:;?<36=>/:A41/6=223>/?6 '+))) 2,3 /1/ - 8 - /// .3 ;41/<1:9 /0 3:9/9436 9? 1 0=< ?5 . /1/ 14?:A C/9. /:93>309 19 F 215>?<9.36193?5239/9/?:9/449.36193 ?5 >314/I19/?: /:09316 ?5 0+))) A>1:936789.39>/7=:14 /D 302?:63:9 ?!:0=>1:;3 ;?<21:8 632?0/936+F?59.31C1>6361<?=:9/3 0 ))) 735?>3 9.3 9>/7=:14 1:6 /0 6/>3;936 9? 632?0/9 9.3 7141:;3 1<?=:9 C/9. /:93>309 K F 23> 1::=< /: ?:3 <?:9.5>?<9.36193?5?>63>L D : 0=;. 632?0/9 ;41/<1:9 /0 23></9936 9? C/9.6>1C 9.3 3:9/>3 1<?=:9 14?:A C/9. /:93>3091;;>=36?:9.301<3 .40 '&!! ( % /09? 4?