Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66417 (KAR)
BUTALI AND ORS v. THE STATE AND ANR
CRL.P/200123/2025 · 2025-07-11
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66417 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66417 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"! #$" %
$
&' &()* & )) +
! "
"#
$ ! $ ! %
&
$ ! "#
$ ! '
(
)
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
**
*
*
$ "
"
*
$ ! '
( +,
" )
+ % "+()
" +
""
+ ""%
**
"""% + ++ %"%+ + +
+
+
-
(-
)
./01 02
3/4/53.662 7./08.1 9:;85.7 <:0 63. =.6262:8.05 /81 02 ..0/8/4:;1/ /72=/627 7./08.1 243
- 3 -
:;06 :>.08?.86 7./1.0 <:0 0.5=:81.86 : .5=:81.86:"5.0>.1/81;80.=0.5.86.1
" .6262:8 25 <27.1 ;81.0 .962:8 " :<
""@26363.<:77:@284=0/A.0 B
! "#$ % &
&& $ ' ( & ) & & *+,,-)$) & . /
02.<</965@3293/0.8.9.55/0A<:0125=:5/7:< 63.=0.5.86=.6262:8/0./5;81.0 .5=:81.86 :" 6: 63. =.6262:8 3/5 <27.1 / 9:?=7/286 @263 */7/C.02 =:729. 2D/A/=;0 12560296 /77.4284 9:??2552:8 :< 63. :<<.89. =;8253/E7. ;81.0 .962:8 %" 0./1 @263 5.962:8 % :< @3293 @/5 0.4256.0.1 :8
"""%28+ :""%
- 4 -
"
256 :< 63. 9:?=7/286 />.0?.865 @:;71 0.>./7 63/6 63. =.6262:8.05 3.0.28 /0. 63. 0.521.865 :< /@/7/0 >277/4. /81 /99;5.1 :! E.284 63. /8C /8/4.0 :< */08/6/C/ 2C/5
0/?..8 /8C
:7/4.02 (<:0 53:06 F* /8CG)3/>.93./6.163.9:?=7/28/86 6 25 /77.4.1 28
63. 9:?=7/286 63/6
63. 9:?=7/28/863/1/==0:/93.163.*
/8C<:07:/82863. A./0"""/81/663/6D;896;0./99;5.1:!6:7132?63/6
63. 9:?=7/28/86 3/5 6: <2056 0.=/A 63. :;656/81284 7:/8 /?:;86 :< 5!$ /81120.96.1 63/6 E0284 /99;5.1 :@3:259/=/E7.:<4.6628463./11262:8/77:/8/53. 25/8/4.866:63.*
/8C % 5 =.0 63. 28560;962:85 :< /99;5.1 :! 9:?=7/28/86/==0:/93.1/99;5.1:/813.3/56:=/A 63.E0:C.0/4.<:04.6628463.7:/8<0:?63.*
/8C. 3/5 /75: /55;0.1 63. 9:?=7/28/86 63/6 3. @:;71 =/A 63. :;656/81284 7:/8 /?:;86 @3293 53:;71 E. 0.=/21 28 /
- 5 -
?:863 /81 :8 63/6 9:81262:8 /11262:8/7 7:/8 @:;71 E. 5/8962:8.1 5 =.0 63. 28560;962:85 :< /99;5.1 : 9:?=7/28/86/<6.04.6628463./11262:8/77:/83/5=/2163. :;656/81284 7:/8 /?:;86 /81 4:6 5;? :< 5#&$ <0:? 63. *
/8C /5 63. /11262:8/7 7:/8 /?:;86 /81 /99;5.1:@3:9/?.:;6:<63.*
/8C6::C/@/A 63..8620.5;?:<5#&$ ! 8 "" /77 63. /99;5.1 =.05:85 9/?. 6:
63. 3:;5. :<
63. 9:?=7/28/86 /81 1.?/81.1 :;656/81284 ?:8.A 3. 9:?=7/28/86 3/1 5:71 63. 53..= /81 3/1 4:6 63. =0:9..15 :< 5 $ /81 .8620. 5;? :< 5 $ @/5 6/C.8 /@/A EA 63. /99;5.1 =.05:85 28 63. 4;25. :< 97./0284 63. 7:/8 /=/06 <0:? 5$ 7:/8 0.9.2>.1 EA /99;5.1 : <0:? 63. 9:?=7/28/86 %
3. =:729. /<6.0 0.4256.0284 63. 9/5. /0. 28>.5624/6284 63. ?/66.0 .0A 0.42560/62:8 :< 63. + 25
- 6 -
9/77.1 28 H;.562:8 28 6325 =.6262:8 EA 63. =.6262:8.05 @3: /0./99;5.1:56:
.26.0/6284 63.
40:;815 ;04.1 28 =.6262:8
02
3/4/53.662 7./08.1 9:;85.7 <:0 63. =.6262:8.05 9:86.815 63/6 <27284 :< 5;93 / 9:?=7/286 25 2?=.0?2552E7. /815:;436<:0H;/5328463.=.81284+ ! 85;==:06:<3259:86.862:853.=7/9.50.72/89. :863.D;14?.86:<63.:8:;0/E7.=.I:;062863.9/5. :<
0.=:06.128
.28>26.163./66.862:8:<6325:;066:=/0/40/=3:5 6: # /0/40/=3:56: /0.9;77.1:;63.0.;81.0 <:00./1A0.<.0.89. !" 0 ) ! & . )
! +
&
& ! & ) 1
&
+
&
2 &&
- 7 -
$ 3 & . & ) +)
+
#) !&
' ! & . 0 . & ! $ 4 &
& & !& %%%50
+
#" $%&&
'( &
" )
#* & $
& )
!+
&&
)
&
! &61 $+"7 8
& && & 0
& && &9
9 &
6
& !#&
! ! 2 &
&
+
&! +
- 8 -
&
+2
#
! ) )
" 0
&& )
! ) ! &
)
+
+
+
)
#)
+! :
! & ! +
+! ;9 ," $ ! $-"." /
" 0 1
$+2*8
! &
&
0 &<
<) &$ % &
)8 & &
& #
&) & + ! &
&
& )
- 9 -
! &
+
&
& && !&
)
=
8 . $ 4 & $ 4 &
+
&
= ) +
+>
& & ! &)
&&
! &
! ) ! &
&&
! 0 -"."/:;
+ $3
3 )45")'$2
,* $' 6
" 78 '
"$ # +2* $-
9
& " : & 4 5$ ,
+
$ 4% '
"" ;) &/$, !" +" =+
)
)
$. ?< + & &
- 10 -
) &
1$. ?< 0
1 $. ? ! %%% 34%@ 0 &
& ()@3) )(1 +! &%)5)5%)(41/
89/0.<;79:8521.0/62:8:<63.=02892=7.5:<7/@ .8;892/6.1 EA 63. :8:;0/E7. =.I :;06 28 63. 9/5. :<
28 63. 72436 :< 63. </96;/7 /5=.965 28>:7>.1 28 63. 9/5. :8 3/81 63.0. 25 8: E0./93 :< 9:860/96 E.6@..8 63.
9:?=7/28/86 /81 :63.0 /99;5.1 =.05:85 & 6 25 63. 9:?=7/28/86G5 9/5. 63/6 63. /99;5.1 =.05:853/>.D:28.16:4.63.0/8193./6.132?28/5;?:< 5"!&$ 8 :63.0 @:015 63.0. 25 / 97./0 125628962:8 E.6@..863.93./6284/81E0./93:<9:860/96/59:;71E. 5..8 <0:? 63. =02892=7.5 :< 7/@ .8;892/6.1 EA 63. :8:;0/E7. =.I :;06 28 0.72.1 :8 EA
- 11 -
63. 9:;85.7 <:0 63. =.6262:8.05 265.7< 3.0.<:0. 63. =02892=7.5:<7/@.8;892/6.128 <9/5.25 8:6/==729/E7.6:63.9/5.:83/81
289.63.+ 25;81.093/77.84./8163.=:729. /0. 28>.5624/6284 63. ?/66.0 0.5.0>284 63. 02436 :< 63. =.6262:8.05 6: 93/77.84. 63. /1>.05. 0.=:06 2< /8A 63. =0.5.86=.6262:88..156:E.125?255.1
" .89.63.<:77:@284
3.02?28/7.6262:825125?255.1
,* &% )
"
256: 7:"& *