Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66413 (KAR)
LAXMI v. NAGAPPA AND ANR
MFA/202568/2023 · 2025-10-23
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66413 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66413 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$ "
#$ !$%! ""
&%'
(
!"! #
$%& % '
! & &
()&("*! %
!+
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+
%
!"! #
$ ,% +- % !+"+"+
! '
!.$!'
%
&
!.!"+"++
&
% *+"+! &
,
& %
/&
/&
&%
- 3 -
$ $ /&
'
012 344536 12 78 905 :631;3<9 =165> ?<>5@ 5:91A< !.$!'A=905A9A@%501:652:9!* 751<B3BB@15C5>78 905D?>B;5<93<>3E3@>>395>!.!"+"++43225>78905 @1<:1436129@1:93<>5221A<2&?>B53<> 31:0?@1< %A*+"+!255F1<B5<03<:5;5<9A=:A;45<2391A<
+ 3:92 B1C1<B @125 9A 905 =161<B A= 905 344536 7@15=6829395>3@59039A<"."*+"+"3937A?9""4; 9051<D?@5>459191A<5@E324@A:55>1<B32341661A<@1>5@A< A9A@:8:65 753@1<B 5BA()( .+ >@1C5< 78 A<5 @;3@520E05<9058:3;5<53@1@E3@3C36F3631< @A3> @524A<>5<9 A! 751<B 905 @1>5@ A= A9A@:8:65 753@1<B 5BA()&("*! :3;5 1< 01B0 2455> @320 3<> <5B61B5<9 ;3<<5@ 3<> >3205> 9A 905 459191A<5@G2 C501:65 3<> 905@578 :3?25> 905 3::1>5<9 2 3 @52?69 A= E01:0 459191A<5@ 2?2931<5> 25C5@5 1<D?@152 653>1<B 9A 05@ 0A2419361H391A< 9A A241936 31:0?@ 3<> 905@53=95@ 205 E32 201=95> 9A 3<> 43@203 A241936 39
- 4 -
5<B36?@? =A@ 01B05@ 9@539;5<9 3<> 205 032 755< 2?7D5:95> =A@ 2?@B1:36 3<> A@36 9@539;5<9 3<> =1<3668 205 E32>12:03@B5>A<!*"*+"+"78245<>1<B0?B53;A?<9 5<:5905:631;3<9=165>905:631;459191A<?<>5@5:91A< !)) A= A9A@ %501:652 :9 75=A@5 905 631;2 @17?<36 255F1<B :A;45<2391A< =A@ 905 1<D?@152 2?2931<5> 1< 905 @A3>9@3==1:3::1>5<9
<25@C1:5A=2?;;A<2@524A<>5<9A2!3<> + 34453@5> 524A<>5<9 A+ =165> E@1995< 29395;5<9 >5<81<B9055<91@53C5@;5<92;3>51<905:631;459191A<
<90573212A=9054653>1<B2A=90543@9152905 631;2 @17?<36=@3;5>905122?523<>905@53=95@@5:A@>5> 905 5C1>5<:5 05 :631;3<9 1< A@>5@ 9A 4@AC5 905 :325 5I3;1<5> 01;256= 32 (! 7521>52 5I3;1<1<B 905 >A:9A@ 32 (+ 3<> BA9 5I017195> >A:?;5<92 <3;568 I! 9A I++ < 75036= A= @524A<>5<92 90@55 E19<52252 3@5 5I3;1<5>322!9A3<>BA9;3@F5>90@55>A:?;5<92 32I2!9A
- 5 -
05 631;2
@17?<36 78 905 1;4?B<5> D?>B;5<9056>90399053::1>5<99AAF463:5A< 3::A?<9 A= @320 3<> <5B61B5<9 @1>1<B 78 905 @1>5@ A= 905 A==5<>1<BC501:659053::1>5<99AAF463:53<>905:631;3<9 2?2931<5>1<D?@152 05 @17?<36?4A<:A<21>5@1<B905A@36 3<>>A:?;5<93@85C1>5<:5463:5>75=A@519056>9039905 :631;3<9 12 5<91965> 9A :A;45<2391A< A= 2""+""( 36A<BE1901<95@52939905@395A=)J433<>>1@5:95>905 <2?@3<:5 :A;43<8 9A >54A219 905 :A;45<2391A< 3;A?<9 36A<BE1901<95@52951<B3BB@15C5>9012344536032755< =165>
)
05653@<5>:A?<256=A@905:631;3<9032@3125> 905=A66AE1<B:A<95<91A<2
3' 1@2968 >?5 9A 905 3::1>5<9 905 :631;3<9 032 2?==5@5> B@15CA?2 1<D?@152 05 :631;3<9 12 :A;4659568 75>@1>>5<3<>205?<37659AE36F3<>>A05@>38(9A(>38 EA@F 05 032 5I3;1<5> 905 >A:9A@ 32 + E0A >54A25> 9039 905 :631;3<9 032 2?==5@5> >123716198 A= *!J 9A 905 E0A65 7A>8 5 =?@905@ :A<95<>5> 9039 >?5 9A
- 6 -
45@;3<5<9>12371619820512?<37659A;AC5=@A;90575> 3<> 205 @5K?1@5> 905 0564 A= 3< 39931<>5@ 9166 05@ 6329 7@5390 5 =?@905@ 2?7;192 9039 <A :A;45<2391A< 12 3E3@>5>?<>5@9039053>AAF1<B9A9051<D?@1522?==5@5> 78905:631;3<9905>1237161983225225>78905 @17?<3639 *!J 12 A< 905 6AE5@ 21>5 3<> !""J >123716198 032 9A 75 93F5<1<9A:A<21>5@391A<6AAF1<B9A9051<D?@1522?==5@5>78 905:631;3<9
7' 32968 05 032 :A<95<>5> 9039 1< C15E A= D?>B;5<9 A= A<G765 45I 1< 905 :325 A=
!
905 @17?<36 032 <A9 3>>5> +J 9A 905 1<:A;5 A= 905 :631;3<9 9AE3@>2 =?9?@5 4@A245:92 03C1<B @5B3@> 9A 905 3B5 A= 905 :631;3<9 5<:5 05 2A?B09 =A@ 5<03<:5;5<9A=:A;45<2391A<78366AE1<B905344536
. < 905 A905@ 03<> @1 A0> 7>?6 ,?38?;
653@<5> :A?<256 =A@ 905 @524A<>5<9 A+ ( <2?@3<:5 A;43<8 :A<95<> 9039 905 :631;3<9 032 5I3;1<5> 905
- 7 -
>A:9A@32+<0125C1>5<:505032>54A25>9039905 :631;3<9 032 2?==5@5> *!J >123716198 9A 905 E0A65 7A>8 A<21>5@1<B 905 5C1>5<:5 A= >A:9A@ 905 @17?<36 032 @1B0968 3225225> E0A65 7A>8 39 *!J 5 =?@905@ :A<95<>5> 9039 905 >A:9A@ 032 >54A25> 9039 :631;3<9 12 @5K?1@5>3<9931<>5@90@A?B0A?905@61=59A>A05@>38(9A( >38EA@F3<><A;5>1:36@5:A@>203C5755<4@A>?:5>9A 529376120 905 231> :A<95<91A< 05@5=A@5 905 @17?<36 @1B0968<A93E3@>5>3<8:A;45<2391A<?<>5@9039053>
32968 05 032 :A<95<>5> 9039 :A<21>5@1<B 905 1<D?@152 2?==5@5> 78 905 :631;3<9 5C1>5<:5 A= >A:9A@ 3<> ;5>1:36 5C1>5<:5 905 AC5@366 :A;45<2391A< 3E3@>5> 78 905 @17?<36 12 D?29 3<> @532A<3765 3<> 2A?B09 =A@ >12;12236A=905344536
* 53@> 905 653@<5> :A?<256 =A@ 905 43@9152 45@?25>905D?>B;5<93<>3E3@>A=905 @17?<363<>362A 9053445364345@2
- 8 -
!" 9 12 <A9 1< >124?95 9039 905 :631;3<9 032 2?==5@5> 1<D?@8 1< 3 @A3> 9@3==1: 3::1>5<9 A::?@@5> A<
"."*+"+">?59A@3203<><5B61B5<9@1>1<BA=905@1>5@A= 905 A==5<>1<B ;A9A@:8:65 753@1<B 5BA()&("*! 912362A<A91<>124?959039>?59A90537AC53::1>5<9905 :631;3<90322?==5@5>905=A66AE1<B1<D?@152
!! 05:631;3<90325I3;1<5>905>A:9A@32+ E0A9@5395>05@503C5BA<590@A?B0905@5:A@>23<> 5C1>5<:5 A= 905 >A:9A@ 05 >123716198 3225225> 78 905 >A:9A@ 12 39 *!J 9A 905 E0A65 7A>8 05 :631;3<9 032 4@A>?:5>40A9AB@3402E01:03@5;3@F5>32I2!9A!* 9A 20AE 9039 >?5 9A 3::1>5<936 1<D?@8 905 :631;3<9 12 ?<3765 9A E36F 3<> >A 05@ >38(9A(>38 EA@F 3<> 205 12 ?<37659A5C5<;AC5E190A?99052?44A@9A=3<39931<>5@ 322051275>@1>>5<A<21>5@1<B9012;395@1363C3163765A<
- 9 -
@5:A@> 905 ;5>1:36 @5:A@>2 >123716198 :5@91=1:395 3<> 5C1>5<:5A=905>A:9A@905>1237161980329A753225225>39 !""JL!245@""#$%
&'(
M+"+" <61<5.+N905:631;3<9125<91965>9A =?9?@54@A245:92 05 @17?<36 1< 905 3725<:5 A= 4@AA= A= 1<:A;5 032 3225225> ;A<9068 1<:A;5 A= 905 :631;3<9 39 2!."( 4; E01:0 12 D?29 3<> 4@A45@ 3<> <A 1<95@=5@5<:512:3665>789012A?@9
!+ < C15E A= 905 D?>B;5<9 A= 905 A<G765 45I A?@9 1< 905 :325 A= $
' +J A= 905 1<:A;5 032 9A 75 3>>5> 9AE3@>2 6A22 A= =?9?@5 1<:A;5 L+152!.! ( 053B5A=905:631;3<912"853@2 05 ;?6914615@ 34461:3765 9A 905 3B5 B@A?4 A= 905 :631;3<9 12 O!G <@5(>595@;1<391A<3<>@5(322522;5<9905:631;3<9 12 5<91965> 9A 3 2?; A= L2"* "( L$2!.! L!+L!L!""J'?<>5@905053>O6A22A==?9?@5 1<:A;5G
! ?@905@ >?5 9A 905 3::1>5<936 1<D?@8 905 :631;3<90322?==5@5>!""J>1237161983<>20512?<37659A ;AC5 =@A; 905 75> 3<> 905@5=A@5 205 @5K?1@52 A<5 39931<>5@=A@05@2?44A@9916605@63297@5390A<21>5@1<B L!L+<25@95>C1>503;75@A@>5@>9!.!!+"+ LLA@@5:95>C1>503;75@A@>5@>9!.!!+"+
- 10 -
9055C1>5<:5A=>A:9A@3<>1<D?@82?==5@5>78905:631;3<9 19EA?6>;5599055<>2A=D?291:51=32?;A=2+"""""( 12 3E3@>5> 9AE3@>2 O=?9?@5 39931<>5@ :03@B52G 05 :A;45<2391A<3E3@>5>78905 @17?<36?<>5@A905@053>2 3@5D?293<>@532A<3765
! < @5(322522;5<9 3<> @5(>595@;1<391A< 905 :A;4?9391A<A=:A;45<2391A<1232?<>5@
)*+,-./-0 1/2-*3,/ 31<3<>2?==5@1<B 2!"""""( A22A=&A83<> 6532?@5 2!"""""( 5>1:363995<>3<9G2 :A<C583<:53<> <A?@120;5<95I45<252 2""""( A22A==?9?@5 1<:A;553@<1<B2 L2"* "( 5>1:365I45<252 $329@525<93<> =?9?@5;5>1:36 5I45<252' 2"""""( ?9?@59931<>5@G2 :03@B52 +"""""( /45 6*7778
!
<905@52?69E54322905=A66AE1<B LA@@5:95>C1>503;75@A@>5@>9!.!!+"+
- 11 -
3' 0534453612)"
7' 05 D?>B;5<9 A= 905 631;2 @17?<36 12 ;A>1=15>
:' 05 :631;3<9 12 5<91965> 9A 3 9A936 :A;45<2391A< A= L2" "( 32 3B31<29 2""+""(3E3@>5>78905 @17?<3636A<B E1901<95@52939905@395A=)J45@3<<?;
>' 05524A<>5<9A+(<2?@3<:5A;43<812 >1@5:95> 9A >54A219 5<91@5 :A;45<2391A< 3;A?<9 36A<B E190 1<95@529 39 905 @395 A= )J 45@3<<?;=@A;905>395A==161<BA=905:631;
459191A< 9166 905 >395 A= @5361H391A< E1901< 3 45@1A>A=21IE55F2=@A;905>395A=@5:5149A= 3:A48A=9012D?>B;5<9
5' 05 >54A219 3<> @565325 20366 75 32 45@ 905 A@>5@A=905 @17?<36
98 &" ' $
98 &!$%!' $
129A!6A LA@@5:95>C1>503;75@A@>5@>9!.!!+"+