Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66396 (KAR)
SANNAPPA S/O YAMANAPPA PYATI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200145/2016 · 2025-08-14
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66396 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66396 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $%&#
$%&%
%##
'
! ! !
"#$#%&' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ()' * %$('&% '(&+'&% %&('&'# * , , (&% , -./01.2.345466745./8.5790-45573:.3:;-7<=9:273; >8 0>3?.0;.>3 439 >1971 >8 /73;7307 .26>/79 4:4.3/; ;-7 46675543; 8>1 ;-7 >887307/ 6=3./-4@57 =3971 70;.>3/ &' 439#&'>839.437345>9764//79.37//.>3/ 4/7>%$('&% 94;79'(&+'&%@A ;-7>=1;>8 ;-7 99.;.>345 7//.>3/ =9:7 .<4A46=1 -717.348;71 17871179;>4/B 1.45>=1;C8>1@17?.;A ' -7840;=4524;1.D>804/7>861>/70=;.>3./;-4; >377E-4>42434664-495>9:794F1.;;730>2654.3; - 3 - >3 &)&'&% @78>17 ;-7 45.E>;7 >5.07 ;4;.>3 .<4A46=1 24E.3: 43 4557:4;.>3 ;-4; >3 '(&#'&% ;-7 :14392>;-71>8;-70>2654.343;4/42244392>;-71>8 ;-7400=/794EE4??4-49G=4117579F.;-740->;-71.3;-7 7415A2>13.3:>?71E776.3:>88.17F>>9.381>3;>8->=/7>8 4/4224;./8=1;-714557:79;-4;;-7400=/79F->0427 ;> ->=/7 -4?.3: 1707.?79 ;-7 .38>124;.>3 81>2 ;-7 /4.9 4EE4??4 0427 3741 ;-7 ->=/7 >8 4/4224 4; 4@>=; (& 62 439 G=4117579 F.;- 4/4224 5.8;79 -71 439 ;-17F-71;F.074/417/=5;/-7-4//=/;4.379.3<=1A;>-71 F4./; 439 >;-71 641;/ >8 ;-7 @>9A 439 /=00=2@79;> ;-7 .3<=1.7/;./45/>/;4;79.3;-70>2654.3;;-4;-71/./;71" =<4;4 -71 0>=/.3 /./;71 73=E4 > -.24334 439 -71 37.:-@>=1 4554224-4?7F.;37//79;-./.30.973; ; ./ 8=1;-71 4557:79 ;-4; ;-7 400=/79 -49 ;-174;7379 ;-7 0>2654.343; 439 -71 /./;71/ >8 9.17 0>3/7G=7307/439@7.3:4814.9>8-./;-174;;-7A9.93>; 176>1; ;-7 /427 ;> ;-7 6>5.07 =; 0>39=0;79 8=37145 >8 ;-7.1:14392>;-71>3;-737D;94A.7'$&#'&%4/79 - 4 - >3 ;-./ 0>2654.3; 6>5.07 -4?7 17:./;7179 ;-7 01.27 .3 1.27 >+$'&% 8>1 ;-7 >887307/ 6=3./-4@57 =3971 70;.>3/&'439#&>8 ) -7 6>5.07 48;71 .3?7/;.:4;.>3 8.579 0-41:7H /-77; 00=/79 F4/ /70=179@78>17;-7>=1; -7 9.9 3>; 65749 :=.5;A 439 054.279 ;> @7 ;1.79 7307 ;-7 61>/70=;.>3 175.79 =6>3;-77?.97307>8 */%;> % 439 45/>:>;241E799>0=273;/4/D/%;>%43;-7 >;-71 -439 9787307 45/> 7D42.379 >37 F.;37// 4/ *% 439 :>; 241E79 9>0=273;/ 4/ D/% 439 ' -7 1.45 >=1; -4?.3: 0>3/.97179 ;-7 @>;- >145 439 9>0=273;41A 7?.97307 4?4.54@57 >3 170>19 43/F7179 6>.3;/ 8>1 0>3/.9714;.>34/488.124;.?74390>3?.0;79;-7400=/798>1 ;-7>887307/6=3./-4@57=397170;.>3/&'439#&'>8 -7 1.45>=1;45/>-4?.3:-741917:419.3:/73;7307 >197179 ;> =3971:> 1.:>1>=/ .261./>3273; 8>1 5.87 439 ;> 64A 4 8.37 >8 #&&&&H 8>1 ;-7 >887307 6=3./-4@57 =3971 70;.>3 &' >8 439 8=1;-71 =3971:> 1.:>1>=/ .261./>3273; 8>1 /.D 2>3;-/ .3 04/7 >8 9784=5; -7 - 5 - 400=/79 45/> /73;73079 8>1 ;-7 >887307 6=3./-4@57 =3971 70;.>3 #&>8;> =3971:>1.:>1>=/.261./>3273; 8>1 ;-177 A741/ 439 ;> 64A 4 8.37 >8 %&&&&H .3 9784=5; ;> 64A 8.37 -7 /-455 8=1;-71 =3971:> 1.:>1>=/ .261./>3273; 8>1;-1772>3;-/439@>;-;-7/73;7307/1=30>30=1173;5A -7 671.>9 >8 97;73;.>3 >8 ;-7 400=/79 .3 ;-7 0>22.;;45 >=1;4/F7554/ 9=1.3:;-7;1.45-4/@773/7;>884:4.3/; ;-7;712/>8/73;7307>81.:>1>=/.261./>3273;;./45/> 9.170;79>=;>88.3742>=3;&&&&H;>@764.9;>:7;-71 ;>*$"-.24334439*+"42434664F->417;-7 />3/ >8 97074/79 H 4/4224 7.3: 4::1.7?79 @A <=9:273;>80>3?.0;.>3439>1971>8/73;7307;-7617/73; 466745./8.579@78>17;-./>=1; # -7 24.3 0>3;73;.>3 >8 5741379 0>=3/75 466741.3:8>1;-746675543;@78>17;-./>=1;./;-4;;-717 ./ 4 9754A >8 7.:-; 94A/ .3 5>9:.3: ;-7 0>2654.3; 439 3> 61>671 7D65434;.>3 ./ 8>1;-0>2.3:7.;-71 .3 ;-7 0>2654.3; >1.3;-77?.97307>861>/70=;.>3F.;37//7/439-7307;-7 1.45>=1;>=:-;3>;;>-4?7175.79=6>3;-77?.97307>8 - 6 - F.;37//7/;./45/>;-70>3;73;.>3;-4;.3>1971;>.3?>E7 70;.>3 &'>83> .3:179.73;/ 417 2497>=;3<=1.7/ 273;.>379 .3 ;-7 6>/; 2>1;72 176>1; 9> 3>; 0>117/6>39 F.;- ;-7 4557:79 40; 0>22.;;79 @A ;-7 400=/79 439 45/> ;-7.3<=1.7/273;.>379.3;-70>2654.3; -70>=3/7545/> ?7-7273;5A0>3;739;-4;
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
# $
$
%% 4?.3: 174345AI79 @>;- >145 439 9>0=273;41A 7?.97307 439 45/> ;-7 840;=45 4/670;/ >8 ;-7 04/7 .; ./ 05741 ;-4; 97074/79 4/4224 *> .3:4664 4E45.
F4/ 4:79 4@>=; (& A741/ 439 /-7 F4/ ;-7 64;71345 :14392>;-71 >8 ;-7 0>2654.343; " .// 7E-4 F-> -49 5>9:79 ;-7 0>2654.3; 00>19.3: ;> ;-7 61>/70=;.>3 */%')439#4177A7F.;37//7/@=;*/%439' -4?73>;/=66>1;79;-704/7>8;-761>/70=;.>3 -7>35A 7?.97307 4?4.54@57 @78>17 ;-7 >=1; ./ */ ;> # *$
- 12 -
439*+ -7>;-7124;71.457?.97307./*%&H>0;>1 439/>45/>>;-71>88.0.45F.;37//7/>86>5.0797641;273; %'
-7 04/7 >8 61>/70=;.>3 ./ ;-4; ;-7 0>2654.343;C/84;-7142434664-4/4A>=3:71@1>;-71@A 3427 -.24334 439 ;-7 ->=/7 >8 400=/79 4334664 ./ 49<4073; ;> ;-7 ->=/7 >8 -.24334 4; -.?46=1 ?.554:7
-797074/794/4224 F4/ 17/.9.3: F.;- -.24334 439 ;-7/427./3>;.39./6=;7;./;-704/7>8;-761>/70=;.>3 ;-4;;-717F4/4:454;4@7;F7734/4224439;-72>;-71 >8 ;-7 400=/79 .3 ;-7 7415A 2>13.3: >8 '(&#'&% .3 0>3370;.>3F.;-8.17F>>9;-4;F4/E76;3741;-7->=/7>8 2;4EE4??4 .7 ;-7 2>;-71 >8 ;-7 400=/79 3 ;-4;
0>3370;.>3 43 .30.973; F4/ ;4E73 65407 .3 ;-7 7?73.3:
8;71 0>2.3: ;> E3>F 4@>=; ;-7 /427 ;-7 400=/79 4334664F73;3741;-7->=/7>84/4224*>.3:4664 4; (& 62 6.0E79 =6 G=41175 F.;- 97074/79 4/4224 439 9=1.3: ;-7 45;7104;.>3 -7 -49 5.8;79 ;-7 97074/79 4/4224 ;-17F -71 >3 ;-7 :1>=39 ;F.07 4/ 4 17/=5;
97074/79 4/4224 /=/;4.379 .3<=1.7/ >3/7G=73;5A
- 13 -
:14392>;-71 >8 */ ;> # -4/ 9.79 @704=/7 >8 .3<=1.7/ 04=/79;>-71.3;-7.30.973; % >F;-./>=1;-4/;>;4E73>;7>8;-77?.97307 >8 *%&H>0;>1 F-> -49 0>39=0;79 ;-7 6>/; 2>1;72 7D42.34;.>3.3>1971;>4/071;4.3F-7;-71.;./404/7>8 ->2.0.945 974;- >1 3>; *%& .3 -./ 7?.97307 -4/ 04;7:>1.0455A976>/79;-4;-70>39=0;79;-76>/;2>1;72 7D42.34;.>34393>;.079;-78>55>F.3:.3<=1.7/ . >3;=/.>3>?711.:-;/.97<=/;@75>F;-7@174/;>?71 ;-754;71454/670;274/=1.3:%'02D(02 .. >3;=/.>3 >?71 @40E >8 0-7/; .3 073;71 274/=1.3: %'02D+02 ...
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
45/> ;-7 04=/7 8>1 ;-7 .30.973;1754;7/ ;>E776.3:>8 8.17F>>9 3741 ;-7 ->=/7>8 4EE4??4 71 7?.97307 ./ ?71A 05741 439 0>3/./;73; ;-4; F-73;-7.30.973;-49;4E73654074;;-4;;.27-71/./;71 ;1.79;>17/0=7;-7:14392>;-71439400=/794@=/79439 /0>5979 -71 439 2497 43 4;;726; ;> 4//4=5; -71 71 7?.97307 ./ ;-4; 4 ;-174; F4/ 04=/79 3>; ;> 17?745 ;-7 /427 ;> 43A@>9A 4/ /=0- >=; 8741 >8 9.17 0>3/7G=7307/ 6>/79@A;-7400=/79/427F4/3>;17?74579*-71/758 -4/ :.?73 ;-7 0>265.43; /-7 F4/ 45/> 6=1/.3: 4; - 18 - ;-7;.27>8.30.973;439/-745/>.973;.8.7/-71/.:34;=17.3 D439/427./241E79;-1>=:--71 %( >F;-./>=1;-4/;>0>3/.971;-70>3;73;/>8 0>2654.3;F-.0-./241E794/D*45/>17.;714;79 .3;-70>2654.3;;-4;.3;-77415A2>13.3:>3;-794;7>8 .30.973;;-717F4/4G=41175@7;F773-71:14392>;-71439 ;-7 2>;-71 >8 ;-7 400=/79 @=; 400=/79 0427 439 2497 :454;4 .3 ;-7 7?73.3: 4; (& 62 -./ .30.973; F4/ F.;37//79 @A 0>2654.343; -71 /./;71 " =<4;4 F-> -4/ @773 7D42.379 4/ *# 439 -71 0>=/.3 /./;71 " 73=E4 F-> -4/ @773 7D42.379 4/ *) /> 45/> .; ./ -71 /;4;7273; .3 ;-7 0>2654.3; ;-4; 37.:-@>171 " 4554224 F4/ 45/> 617/73; =; /4.9 4554224 -4/ 3>; /=66>1;79 439 /-7 -4/ ;=1379 ->/;.57 ;> ;-7 04/7 =; .3 ;-7 0>2654.3;.;.//670.8.0455A273;.>379;-4;400=/7904=/79 ;-7;-174;3>;;>17?745;-7/427;>43A@>9A75/7.8;-7A 9./05>/7/ ;-7 /427 -7 ./ :>.3: ;> ;4E7 4F4A ;-7.1 5.87 7307 0>2654.3; F4/ 3>; 5>9:79 =; ;-7A 2497 01724;.>3>8 ;-7@>9A37D;94A439 /670.8.0455A /;4;79 .3 - 19 - ;-70>2654.3;->F43.30.973;F4/;4E73654074/F7554/ ;-7 40; >8 ;-7 400=/79 =; .3 ;-7 01>//H7D42.34;.>3 3> 9>=@; ;-7 5>04;.>3 >8 ;-7 ->=/7 ./ 75.0.;79 ;-4; ->=/7 >8 4554224F4/5>04;79?71A37D;;>;-7->=/7>897074/79 4/4224 /> 45/> ;-7 ->=/7 >8 >37 !-491. 7:42 ;-7 ->=/7 >8 *%& " 497224 439 ;-7 ->=/7 >8 >37 7;;7664 ; ./ 45/> .26>1;43; ;> 3>;7 ;-4; * 492.;/ ;-4; .8 43A 974;- >00=1/ .3 ;-7 ->=/7 945464;-.
4/434:>F94 =/79 ;> .38>12 ;-7 /427 ;> >;-71/ * 492.;/ ;-4; 400=/79 4;;73979 ;-7 01724;.>3 @=; 3>; 4;;73979@A455;-7842.5A272@71/=;/-7492.;/;-4; -71 =3057 439 4=3; 0427 48;71 ;-7 01724;.>3 81>2
>4
-724;71.459./05>/7/;-4;;-7A0427>3;-737D;94A439 ;-71748;71 >35A 01724;.>3 F4/ 2497 @=; 492.;/ ;-4; .3 D/-79.93>;273;.>3;-4;-7164173;/F717.3
>4 *973.7/;-7/=::7/;.>3;-4;974;->8-71:14392>;-71 F4/ 34;=145 974;- =; /-7 04;7:>1.0455A /4A/ ;-4; 6>5.07 0427;>->=/7>3&&'&%
- 20 -
%$
-7>;-71F.;37//./*)F->./;-794=:-;71 >8=3057>8*439/-717.;714;7/;-7976>/.;.>3>8* .3 -71 0-.78H7D42.34;.>3 *) 45/> 492.;/ 17:419.3: 5>04;.>3>8;-7->=/7@=;/-7/4A/;-4;-712>;-710427 >3 ;-7 37D; 94A >8 ;-7 974;- >8 ;-7.1 :14392>;-71 =;
-71 /73.>1 =3057 439 4=3; 0427 .3 ;-7 617?.>=/ 94A 7?73.3: ; ./ /=::7/;79 ;-4; 400=/79 F4/ ;4E.3: 0417 >8 4/4224439/427F4/973.79/=::7/;.>3F4/2497 ;-4; 4/4224 -4/ 3>; :.?73 43A /-417 439 -7307 ;-7A F717 -4?.3: .55HF.55 4:4.3/; -71 439 /427 F4/ 973.79 =1;-71/=::7/;.>3F4/2497;-4;F-73;-7400=/79F4/ ;4E.3: 0417 >8 4/4224 439 ;-7A F717 -4?.3: .55HF.55 4:4.3/; -.2 439 /427 F4/ 973.79 ; ./ 45/> /=::7/;79 ;-4;;-7A-4?73>;;4E.3:0417>84/4224439/427F4/ 973.79=;3>;-.3:./75.0.;79.3;-701>//H7D42.34;.>3>8 *)45/>F.;-17:419;>;-7.30.973;4394//4=5;2497>3 -71 %+
-7>;-71F.;37//./*#F->./45/>;-7/./;71 >8*439/-745/>17.;714;7/.3-717?.97307.30-.784/
- 21 -
976>/79@A*43945/>.3;-701>//H7D42.34;.>3492.;/ F.;-17:419;>5>04;.>3>865407>8.30.973;439.317/670; >8 .30.973; 439 243371 >8 4//4=5; 2497 >3 4/4224 3>;-.3:./75.0.;797D076;;-7/=::7/;.>3/439>35A43/F71 75.0.;79./;-74//4=5;F4/17?74579.2279.4;75A '&
-7>;-71 F.;37//7/ 417*/$439 +*$./ >37 >8 ;-7 />3 >8 4/4224 492.;;795A -7 F4/ 3>; 617/73;>3;-794;7>8.30.973;=;>35A-7/4A/;-4;-7 0427;>E3>F4@>=;;-7974;->84/4224;-1>=:-* >?71;-76->37439-4?7578;
>4>3;-7/4273.:-;439 1740-79 ?.554:7 >3 ;-7 37D; 94;7 439 6718>1279 ;-7 01724;.>3 7 04;7:>1.0455A /4A/ ;-4; -7 0427 ;> E3>F 4@>=; 0>22.;;.3: >8 2=1971 48;71 7.:-; 94A/ /.307 * 17?74579 ;-7 /427 4@>=; 5.8;.3: >8 4/4224 @A ;-7 400=/79439;-1>F3-71>3;-7:1>=39=;.3;-701>//H 7D42.34;.>3 -7 45/> 492.;/ F.;- 17:419 ;> ;-7 65407 >8 ->=/74395>04;.>3439-7/4A/;-4;*17?74579;-740; >8 ;-7 400=/79 439 ;-4; -7 17?74579 ;-7 /427 ;> ;-7 ?.554:71/ -717 417 0>3;149.0;.>3/ F.;- 17:419 ;> -./
- 22 -
E3>F579:74@>=;;-7.30.973;439.30-.78-7/4A/;-4;-7 0427;>E3>F;-7/42748;717.:-;94A/@=;.3;-701>//H 7D42.34;.>3/4A/;-4;*.38>12794@>=;;-7/427>?71 ;-7 6->37 439 .3 ;=13 -7 .38>1279 ;-7 /427 ;> ;-7 ?.554:71/ '%
-7 >;-71 F.;37// ./ -./ @1>;-71 *+ 439 -7 45/>/4A/;-4;-./94=:-;71*.38>12794@>=;;-7974;- >8 -./ 2>;-71 439 6718>12.3: >8 01724;.>3 439 .3 ;-7 7?.97307 -7 /4A/ ;-4; -7 0427 ;> E3>F 4@>=; ;-7 /427 48;71(H$94A/4/;-7/427F4/17?74579;>-.2@A* =; .3 ;-7 01>//H7D42.34;.>3 -7 492.;/ ;-4; -7 -49 .38>1279 945464;-.
4/434:>F94 ;-4; .; F4/ 4 34;=145 974;- 439 -7 9.9 3>; 24E7 43A /;4;7273; .3 ;712/ >8 D/%439' -7>;-71F.;37//7/4178>1245F.;37//7/ >86>5.07F->-4?70>39=0;79.3?7/;.:4;.>343917:./;7179 ;-704/7 ''
-7 8.1/; 4;;40E 2497 @A ;-7 5741379 0>=3/75 466741.3:8>1;-746675543;;-4;;-717F4/9754A.35>9:.3: ;-70>2654.3;439;-7?71A.30.973;./9>=@;8=5 -7>=1;
- 23 -
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
- 24 -
3>;7 ;-4; ;-7 0>3;73;/ >8 D ./ .3 ;-7 -439F1.;.3: >8 *4393>;-.3:.//=::7/;79;>*;-4;>3.3/./;7307 >8 6>5.07 >35A 9754A F4/ 273;.>379 =; .3;-7 2.9957>8 ;-70>2654.3;.;/7589754A./273;.>379439-7307;-78.1/; 0>3;73;.>3;-4;;-717F4/49754A0433>;@740076;798>1 ;-7174/>3;-4;4;;-7;.27>804=/.3:>8;-174;*/$439 +F7173>;617/73; ->=:-*$.3;-701>//H7D42.34;.>3 /4A/;-4;>?71;-76->37.;/758.38>1279;-7/427;-1>=:- * @=; .3 ;-7 0-.78H7D42.34;.>3 @>;- */$ 439 + 976>/7/;-4;;-7A0427;>E3>F4@>=;;-7/42748;71$H+ 94A/>9>=@;*+/4A/;-4;-7-49.38>1279945464;-.
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
- 33 -
.? *.;- 17:419 ;> ;-7 8.37 ./ 0>3071379 /427 ./ =345;7179 ? -7 671.>9 >8 =3971 ;1.45 61./>3 F-.0- -7 -49 =3971:>37 043 @7 :.?73 4/ /7;H>88 =3971 70;.>3)'$>81 ?. -7 46675543;400=/79 ./ 9.170;79 ;> /=1173971 @78>17 ;-7>=1; >8 ;-7 99.;.>345 7//.>3/ =9:7.<4A46=1F.;-.34671.>9>8;F>F77E/ 8-784.5/;>/=1173971;>=3971:>8>1/73;7307 ;-73 ;-7 7//.>3/ =9:7 ./ 9.170;79 ;> /70=17 ;-7 617/7307 >8 ;-7 400=/79 439 /739 -.2 ;> 61./>3;>/71?7;-7/73;7307
)* +#, &
)* +%, &
./;>'