- 1 - ! " # $ % %% &'( ) ! !" # ! $ %&'& ( ! ! # ()((* !## +* #! ! # "! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *((( "! ! )( ' ! ! ! #" ! # ! "!, !, -!" $ ./01. 2.34 562278 .64 9/57 0: ;/8 6<53443/= >32. 9/=47=2 /; ?768=7< 9/0=47? ;/8 :682374 32 34 26@7= 0: ;/8 .7683=1 .34 6::76? 34 ;3?7< 6163=422.7 A0<157=2 6=< 6>68< <627<*(((:6447<BC2.77=3/83D3?"0<176=<! .3=9./?33=!/ )/;( ' * .7 3=A087< 9?6356=2 617< C7684 >/8@3=1 64 6 <83D78572>32.6=6993<7=2/=E()( +6=<;3?7<69?635 6::?39623/= 9?6353=1 9/5:7=4623/= /; 4&&(((% >32. 3=278742 .7 83B0=6? 9/=43<783=1 2.7 7=2387 7D3<7=97 /= 879/8< 186=27< 2.7 9/5:7=4623/= /; 4E)((% >32. 3=278742622.78627/;F:786==05;8/52.7<627/;:72323/= 23??876?34623/= - 3 - E11837D7<BC2.7463</8<782.346::76?34:87;7887< BC2.76::7??6=2%9?6356=23=>.39.3234563=?C9/=27=<7<2.62 .7 .64 404263=7< 2.7 1837D/04 3=A08374 7 >64 768=3=1 4 &(((%:785/=2..7</92/86447447<2.7<346B3?32C64 & **F B02 2.7 83B0=6? .64 26@7= /=?C &F <346B3?32C 6=< 6?4/ 186=27< 576178 9/5:7=4623/= 0=<78 2.7 /2.78 .76<4 .0487G07427<;/87=.6=9757=2/;2.79/5:7=4623/= &768<2.7681057=24/;B/2.43<74 .7 :72323/=78%9?6356=2 .64 =/2 ;3?7< 6=C :8//; /; 3=9/57 4 .7 572 >32. 6993<7=2 3= ( + 2.7 83B0=6? .64 831.2?C26@7=.343=9/57644 (&(%:785/=2.64:782.7 9.682:87:687<BC68=626@62627716?78D397402./832C7 >64617<C7684622.72357/;6993<7=26=<2.750?23:?37834 ' + 72323/=787H653=7<2.7</92/864 H.3B32 34 2.7 >/0=< 97823;39627 4 :78 >/0=< 97823;39627 :72323/=78 404263=7< ;8692087 /; 831.2 ;7508 ;8692087 /; =646? B/=7 ;86920873=.76<;8692087/;9?6D39?7 B/=7 6=< ?/44 /; E 2772. /B478D7<2.622.7873456?0=327<;8692087/;831.253<<?7 - 4 - 4.6;2;7508>32.35:?6=23=4320*(F?/44 (<71877831.2.3: ;?7H3/= 6B<0923/= 687 :63=;0? ?35327< 2.787 34 4./827=3=1 3= 4./82?35:16322.7873456?0=327<;8692087/;831.24.6;29?6D39?7 >32.35:?6=23=4320% (F?69@4 (F4./0?<786855/D757=234 :63=;0?6=<?35327<2.7873456?0=327<;8692087=646?B/=76=< <77: 7H:38623/=4 3=4:38623/=4I (F <3;;390?2 <083=1 9/?< 4764/= 6=< B796047 /; ?/44/;0::782.877;8/=22772. 2.7 :72323/=78 34 =/2 6B?7 2/ .6D7 ;0?? B327 /; ;//< 6=< 6447447< <346B3?32C62& **F2/2.7>./?7B/<C//=72.38</;2.7 4657 9/574 2/ +F <346B3?32C .787;/87 ?/44 /; ;02087 768=3=196:6932C9/5742/4*+*'(% (&(H H 'H +F .7 83B0=6? 186=27< 4+(((% 2/>68<4 57<396? 7H:7=474 >.39. =77<4 =/ 3=278;787=97 .7 :72323/=78 >64 ./4:326?3J7<;/8(<6C4/=43<783=12.7=62087/;3=A08374.34 /990:623/= 6=< /2.78 87?7D6=2 ;692/84 2.34 /082 ;3=<4 32 8764/=6B?7 2/ 186=2 4&((((% ;/8 :63= 6=< 40;;783=1 4&(((% ;/8 ?/44 /; 657=32374 4*((((% ;/8 286=4:/82623/=7H286=/0834.57=26=<6227=<6=29.68174.7 :72323/=78531.2=/2.6D76227=<7<6=C/2.78>/8@62?7642;/8 6:783/</;*5/=2.4.787;/87.7347=232?7<;/84*(+&(% - 5 - (&(H*0=<782.7.76<?/44/;3=9/57<083=12.7?63<0: :783/< ' %</92/8 3= 2.7 <346B3?32C 97823;39627 .64 42627< 2.62 2.7 :72323/=78 87G03874 2>/ 5/87 408178374 ;/8 3=;?65562/8C /=7 ;8/5 831.2 ;7508 6=< 831.2 9?6D39?7 6=< .7 .64 74235627< 2.7 9/42 /; 408178C 64 4 (((((% .787;/872.34/082;3=<4328764/=6B?72/186=26=65/0=2/; 4+&(((%;/8;0208757<396?7H:7=474 ) .04 3= 6?? 2.7 9?6356=2 34 7=232?7< ;/8 2.7 9/5:7=4623/=/;4&) *(%>32.3=27874262F:786==05 646163=424E)((%6>68<7<BC2.783B0=6? (.76>68</;9/5:7=4623/=:6447<BC2.783B0=6? 345/<3;37<640=<78, 76<4 5/0=23=4 /44/;;020873=9/57 *+*'(% !7<396?7H:7=474 +(((% * 63=6=<0;;783=1 &((((% E/44/;657=32374 &(((% &86=4:/82623/=7H286 =/0834.57=26=<6227=<6=29.68174 *((((% /44/;768=3=1<083=12.7?63<0: *(+&(% - 6 - :783/< +#0208757<396?7H:7=474 +&(((% /26? *!+ =2.78740?22.7;/??/>3=1/8<7834:6447<, 3 ::76?346??/>7<3=:682 33 .7 :72323/=78%9?6356=2 34 7=232?7< ;/8 2.7 2/26? 9/5:7=4623/=/;4&) *(%>32.3=27874262F:786==05 ;8/52.7<627/;:72323/=23??2.7<627/;876?3J623/= 333 .7 874:/=<7=2 3=4086=97 9/5:6=C .64 6?876<C <7:/4327< 2.7 6>68<7< 65/0=2 B7;/87 2.7 83B0=6? 6=< 2.787;/872.7C687<387927<2/<7:/4322.77=.6=97<65/0=2/; 4 &*(%>32.3=27874262F:786==05>32.3=/=75/=2. ;8/52.7<627/;2.34/8<78 3D = 409. <7:/432 2.7 :72323/=78%9?6356=2 34 :7853227<2/>32.<86>2.77=238765/0=26?/=1>32.2.73=278742 699807</=32 ,-+ &% ( $ 342/, ?/,(