- 1 - !"# $#% # # & ' ! ! "#$ ! ! % & '' ( )! ! ) *+++ $ & ( )! ! , #*-.! ! *+++ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # )) ! *+++ "+ ! "#$ % &!' !)/ !)( ) $$* $$ ) ) ( ) 0 ) +$+$ ! $ $# , + +$$+$ * $+$$$# +" ,)/ ( ) +"+$+$ , ) )) ) ) 0 )/ ( ) ) - 3 - 1'! & 1'!( 234345627824693:2;4<25<562=6=>=3:4=69=66=?=7@ ;:5 ;=A ;57B469 =A = 5@7=B=7C4B= 46 72A>56D263 5 @64E4>=F5@6E4F4A82<5723:4A5@73A22B469<5FF5;46972F42<A !"""#$% & '" ( ) * +,++-,./'0,'%,1 & '23 4 4 15 & '. 4 4 4) 6 7 6 3 8 ) 4 . 49 $ =A2 5< 3:2 >234345627 4A 3:=3 :27 :@A8=6D =6=>=3:4>=AA2D=;=G56$+$$++*F2=?46982:46D:4A;4<2 3:2 >234345627 :27246 =6D 3;5 D=@9:327A 6=C2FG !@C=74 2A:C= =6D !@C=74 =7?=34 :26 3:2 >234345627 ;=A 46 3:2 - 4 - >75E2AA5<A22B46972F2=A25<D2=3:E@C723472C2638262<43A5< A=4D =6=>=3:4 562 @F=H=CC= 58H2E32D 56 3:2 >72C4A2 3:=3 A:2824693:2F29=FFG;2DD2D;4<25<A=4D=6=>=3:472A@F3469 46A3=F2C=32A@4346 5 # $+*E=C23582<4F2D8G3:2 >234345627=6D:273;5D=@9:327A=9=46A33:2A=4D@FH=CC=46 ;:4E:3:25<<4E4=F72A>56D263A=72=FA5C=D2>=7342A:2A=4D A@43 ;=A <4F2D A22B469 D2EF=7=3456 3:=3 3:2 >234345627 :27246 4A 3:2 F29=FFG ;2DD2D ;4<2 5< A=4D =6=>=3:4 =6D 3;5 D=@9:327A ;272 8576 5@3 5< 3:2 A=4D C=774=92 56A2I@263 72F42< 5< >27C=6263 46H@6E3456 72A37=46469 A=4D @FH=CC= <75C D7=;469 72E24?469=6G>26A456;=A=FA5A5@9:3<576=DD43456 =D472E34563572E34<G3:2A27?4E27294A3275<A=4D=6=>=3:48G D2F23469 3:2 6=C2 5< A=4D @FH=CC= ;=A =FA5 A5@9:3 <57 E5C>75C4A2;=A263272D4635823;2263:2>234345627:273;5 D=@9:327A 56 3:2 562 >=73 =6D A=4D @FH=CC= 56 3:2 53:27 >=73 6 327CA 5< ;:4E: A=4D @FH=CC= =9722D =DC4332D E56<47C2D =6D D2EF=72D 3:=3 3:2 >234345627 :27246 ;:5 4A 3:2 >F=4634<< 5 46 3:2 A=4D A@43 ;=A 3:2 F29=FFG ;2DD2D ;4<2 5< A=4D=6=>=3:4=6D3:=3A=4D@FH=CC=D2<26D=63 5463:2 A=4D A@43 :=A 65 58H2E3456 46 72E34<G469 3:2 A27?4E2 72E57DA 5< D2E2=A2D =6=>=3:4 46 ;:4E: :27 6=C2 ;=A ;7569FG 263272D - 5 - =A3:265C4622:=33:2A=4D@FH=CC==FA5D4D653:=?2=6G 58H2E3456 46 >234345627 :27246 =6D :27 D=@9:327A 72E24?469 3:2 D2=3:E@C723472C263 A27?4E2 8262<43A 5< A=4D =6=>=3:4 :2 A=4DA@43;=A=EE57D469FGD2E722D46327CA5<3:2E5C>75C4A2 D=32D $+$+ =A2D 56 3:2 A=4D E5C>75C4A2 D2E722 >234345627 :27246 C=D2 = 72>72A263=3456 D=32D +"+$+$ 6 72A>56A2 3:2 6D27 2E723=7G )46=6E2 2>=73C263 5?276C263 5< !=76=3=B= 4AA@2D = E5CC@64E=3456 35 3:2 472E3575<26A456=6DC=FF=?469A46;:4E:434AE5632632D 3:=3 A46E2 3:2 4?4F 5@73 :=?2 65 H@74AD4E3456 35 =DH@D4E=32 @>56 3:2 4AA@2A ;43: 729=7D 35 3:2 >26A456 3:2 3=32 5?276C2634A65385@6D8G3:257D27A5<3:24?4F5@73:@A 94?46974A2353:2>72A263>2343456 # 2=762D E5@6A2F <57 3:2 >234345627 724327=3469 3:2 <=E3A 6=77=32D =85?2 A@8C43A 3:=3 46 3:2 F49:3 5< 3:2 D4A>@32823;2263:2>234345627=6D562@FH=CC=:=?4698226 =C4E=8FG72A5F?2D3:2724A654C>2D4C263<573:272A>56D263J 3=32 35 >75E2AA 3:2 >=GC263 5< >26A456 =6D 3:2 723472C263 8262<43A >=G=8F2 46 72A>2E3 5< 3:2 A27?4E2A 726D272D 8G D2E2=A2D=6=>=3:4:2A@8C43A3:=33:272=A56A=AA4962D8G 3:272A>56D2633=323:75@9:43A6D272E723=7G46327CA5< - 6 - 662K@72 =>=73 <75C 82469 @6A@A3=46=8F2 =FA5 E5637=7G 35 3:2<=E3A26E2A22BA<57=FF5;4693:2>2343456 74 5@74A: !:=A:=C>@7 F2=762D E5@6A2F ;:5 72>72A263A 72A>56D263 5 A@8C43A 3:=3 >@7A@=63 35 3:2 E5C>75C4A2 D2E722 3:=3 ;=A >=AA2D 46 5 # $+* 3:2 A27?4E2 72E57DA 5< D2E2=A2D =6=>=3:4 :=?2 8226 72E34<42D 46 327CA 5< 57D27 D=32D #$$+$$ =6D 3:2 6=C2 5< 3:2 >234345627 :27246 :=A 8226 46E57>57=32D 2 A@8C43A 3:=3 3:2 72A>56D263 5 :=A E5C>F42D ;43: 3:2 72I@472C263 5< F=; 3=B469 4635 E56A4D27=3456 3:2 E5C>75C4A2 D2E722 3:=3 ;=A =774?2D =3 823;226 3:2 >234345627 =6D @FH=CC= 2 :5;2?27 A@8C43A3:=33:2F4=84F43G5<D2327C46469=6D>=G4693:2>26A456 =6D723472C2638262<43A4A5<3:272A>56D263 5A$=6D#5?27 ;:4E:3:272A>56D263 5:=A65A=G 2=762DDD43456=F5?276C263D?5E=3272<277469 35>=7=97=>: 5#5<3:2A3=32C2635<58H2E3456AA@8C43A3:=3 3:5@9: 3:2 72A>56D263 5 :=A 2<<2E32D 3:2 E:=692A 46 3:2 A27?4E2 72E57DA 5< 3:2 D2E2=A2D =6=>=3:4 3:272 4A 65 >75?4A45635E:=6923:265C46=3456463:2<=C4FG>26A456=<327 - 7 - 3:2 D2=3: 5< 2C>F5G22 @6D27 3:2 !=76=3=B= )=C4FG 26A456 @F2A* $++$ * 2=7D>27@A2D3:272E57DA :=34A>273@784693726D92627=FFG=6D2A>2E4=FFG46 3:4AE=A24A3:2C=662746;:4E:3:22K2E@34?24A372=34693:2 57D27A =6D 3:2 D472E3456A 4AA@2D 8G 3:2 5@73A ;:4E: 56FG 72<F2E3 3:247 =@D=E43G F=E2D ;43: 49657=6E2 ;43: 729=7D 35 3:2 E56A343@3456=FA37@E3@72;43:;:4E:3:295?276=6E2622DA3582 E=7742D 56 8A5F@32 72<@A=F ;43: 4C>@643G 35 E5C>FG ;43: 3:2 57D27A>=AA2D8G3:25@73=>>2=7A35823:257D275<3:2D=G 234345627 ;:5 :=A C=D2 35 7@6 <75C >4FF=7 35 >5A3 A22B469 72F2=A25<>26A456=6D3:2723472C2638262<43A5<:27:@A8=6D :=A 8226 >@3 35 @635FD C4A27G =3 3:2 :=6DA 5< 46A26A434?2 5<<4E27A3:=33555<=7=6B5<6D272E723=7G2>=73C2635< )46=6E2 5?276C263 5< !=76=3=B= 23327 =3 662K@72 72I@472A 2K37=E3456 82E=@A2 5< 43A 32657 =6D F=69@=92 @A2D 3:27246 3:=3 A:5@FD 95 46 3:2 72E57D :2 A=4D F23327 72=DA =A @6D27 ! "#$ % & '%()* +,- ./ $ 01"2 34("56( 7 *"8.9:;*(),)<=> )?@*( - 8 - A"B C&'$"*(D@)).A"#;8E6F "#)G),) <=> ' % <=> H"(I& J 'K6 L"*B$ @"( A"8<C;()*BMA"G%J'K6/<6 "6(*BN*A) /D )O")P$6Q RS-$GO "C*O )?%Q& ) &GQ )( ' A"B C*)?;T'M/CUM()# "#$. " :26 56E2 3:2 D4A>@32 823;226 3:2 74?=F EF=4CA ;43:729=7D353:2>26A4568262<43A5<3:2D2E2=A2D2C>F5G224A D2E4D2D=6DA23=372A346327CA5<D2E722>=AA2D8G3:25@73 3:2 72A>56D263=@3:574342A :=A 65 8@A462AA 35 A43 56 =>>2=F 5?2743=6D72<@A23594?22<<2E3353:2A=C28GI@2A34564693:2 =@3:574342A5<3:25@73=AD562463:246A3=63E=A2 2A4D2A>=7=97=>: 5#5<3:258H2E3456A3=32C263 =FA572I@472A2K37=E3456463:257D27;:4E:72=DA=A@6D27 % 4 : 4 4) )4)76 4 6 8 6 ; 6 )!< :/ *4 6; 6 4 4; 4 4) ; 24) 8 /: 50, = ) & / 4 ; ">#/"'/ = ) 2 4'0 : 4 24) 8 4 ) 7 : 76 4 6 4 ;">#/"'/9 - 9 - + :2 A=4D 58H2E3456 A3=32C263 :=A 8226 ?274<42D 8G 562 7@6= AA4A3=63 472E357 2>=73C263 5< C=FF =?469A =6D AA23A =6D 4=84F4342A 564357469 4D=7 8G <4F469 = ?274<G469=<<4D=?43 :4A5@733=B2AA2745@A2KE2>3456353:2C=662746 ;:4E: 3:2A2 D2E57=32D 5<<4E27A :=?2 :=6DF2D 3:2 C=3327 F2=?4693:2E5CC56E434L26F4B2>23434562746F@7E: $ 3 4A 65 C572 ' 3:=3 C272FG 82E=@A2 = 65C46=3456 4A C=D2 46 =6G 72E57DA 46EF@D469 A27?4E2 72E57DA 3:26=3@7=F749:335A@EE2AA456=A>273:2=>>F4E=8F2F=;;5@FD 653 923 =<<2E32D 6 53:27 ;57DA 3:2 65C4622 ;5@FD 653 923 =8A5F@32749:35?273:22A3=325<3:2D2E2=A2D<57;:4E:A@E: 65C46=3456 ;=A C=D2 :2 F29=F :247A =72 653 2KEF@D2D 8G C272 65C46=3456 :5@FD 3:272 82 =6G D4A>@32 3:2 D4A8@7A2C2635<3:22A3=325<3:2D2E2=A2D;5@FD82A@8H2E335 3:257D27A5<3:2E5C>232635@73>2K5@73463:2E=A25< ?A J & (' ( ( 72<277469 35 ?=745@A>72E2D263A463:2C=3327=3>=7=97=>::=A:2FD=A @6D27 - 10 - 6 6 ; ) . : 6 4 4 ?4 4 4 4 6 ? ) 4 4 : 4 4 ) 4 = 6 &)6 4 9 # :2 58H2E3456 A3=32C263 5< 72A>56D263A =3 >=7=97=>: 5# D5 653 72<27 35 =6G A>2E4<4E 7@F2 5< 3:2 !=76=3=B= )=C4FG 26A456 @F2A ;:4E: >75:4843A E5772E3456 5< A27?4E272E57DA57D26G469>=GC2635<<=C4FG8262<43A=<3273:2 D2C4A25<3:22C>F5G22?264<A@E: >75:48434564AE563=462D @6D273:2@F2A3:2A=C2E=66533=B2=;=G3:2749:3A5<3:2 F29=F :247A 5< 3:2 D2E2=A2D 35 A@EE22D 35 :4A 2A3=32 46 =EE57D=6E2;43:F=; 6 3:2 =8A26E2 5< =6G F29=F 4C>2D4C263 3:2 72=A56A =AA4962D 8G 3:2 5<<4E27A =3 662K@72 =6D =3 >=7=97=>: 5# 5< 3:2 58H2E3456 A3=32C263 E=6653 82 E5@6326=6E2D 63:2F49:35<3:2<=E33:=33:2>234345627824693:2 F29=FFG;2DD2D;4<2=6D3:272824696558H2E3456<75C=6G562 - 11 - >=734E@F=7FG46?42;5<=?=F4DE5C>75C4A2D2E722:=?4698226 >=AA2D 8G E5C>23263 5@73 3:4A 5@73 D5 653 A22 =6G H@A34<4E=34564672A>56D263=@3:574342AD2EF46469=6DD26G46935 >75E2AA3:2D4A8@7A2C2635<>26A456=6D3:2D2=3:8262<435< 3:2D2E2=A2D353:2>234345627 22DF2AA35C263456>26A4564A 3:2 >75>273G 5< 3:2 2C>F5G22 =6D 43 4A 653 3:2 C27EG 82469 A:5;272D8G3:2=@3:574342A243:27563:2D2E2=A2D2C>F5G22 57:4AF29=F72>72A263=34?2A * 63:=3?42;5<3:2C=33273:2<5FF5;469/ &=( :2>23434564A &8( :2 72A>56D263 5$ 4A D472E32D 35 >75E2AA =6D 72F2=A23:2D2=3:E@C723472C2638262<43A=EE7@2D =6D >=G=8F2 46 3:2 =EE5@63 5< 3:2 D2E2=A2D =6=>=34 35 3:2 >234345627 56 A=34A<=E3456 5< :27 4D26343G 4< =F72=DG 653 72F2=A2D ;43:46 3:722 C563:A<75C3:2D=325<3:4A57D27 &E( C3 237=>7=8:= :==G=>@F2 3:2 6D27 2E723=7G 2>=73C263 5< )46=6E2 &DC464A37=3456 =6D D?=6E2A( =A ;2FF =A C3 7@6= 3:2 AA4A3=63 472E357 2>=73C263 5< C=FF =?469A =6DAA23A=6D4=84F4342A5643574694D=7A:=FF >=G E5A3 5< A$+++ 2=E: <75C 3:247 >27A56=F - 12 - =EE5@63 35 3:2 >234345627 <57 :=?469 C=D2 :27 35 E5C2353:4A5@73@E:E5A3AA:=FF8272E5?272D =6D D2>5A432D 82<572 3:4A 5@73 2>573 46 3:4A 729=7DA:=FF82<4F2D;43:46#+D=GA<75C3:2D=32 5<72E24>35<E5>G5<3:4A57D27 )* &# #' % ! 4A3 5F 5* !