Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66388 (KAR)
SHANKRAMMA AND ANR v. SYED KHALEEM AND ORS
MFA/201662/2022 · 2025-12-09
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66388 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66388 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $% #
$% "%&" ##
'&( )* ## ! )
*
! " # $
% &
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
" '()* +
"
+
" '()* +
&
'(,* #
"$%&- $
*,*.*
%% )& %$
% + )*)* / $ + +% $ &),
*. %+ "
!)
*
$
$ %% 0 !*!,. %% '(,* #
"$
- 3 -
! " '(,
&
%
$% !*. .&
" '()* + '()&. "
+ % !*. .&
" '()* + '()&. # $% - $
*&*( & - $
%% )& %$ + )*)* $ &),
*. $ + +% 0 %
- 4 -
%/ % + $
1+
1++ $
% 1+
% 2*
* 34 53678 9: ;<7 =6>3?>@;4 A<7B7>4 % 2**.*(
* 34 53678 9: ;<7 @4CB>@=7 2?D>@:C@87B7=;32@)& 25;<72;2B$7<3=674=;
.,, <7B73@>5;7B B757BB78 ;2 >4 E;<7 =;/ 52B 4<2B;
=<>667@F3@F ;<7 GC8F?7@; >@8 >A>B8 8>;78 )*)* D>44789:;<77@32B3H36+C8F7>@8+%3@F>4>FCB3@ $ 24&),
*. %>=;4 F3H3@F B347 ;2 ;<7 5363@F 25 ;<7 >DD7>64 9B3756:
4;>;78 >B7 ;<>; 2@ &***. >; >92C; )&* D? ;<7 87=7>478 >H3 >H3 C?>B A>4 DB2=7783@F 2@ ?2;2B=:=67 97>B3@F B7F34;B>;32@ 2 !&
,)*) 2@ >4I3'>6F>@22BB2>8<7@<7B7>=<78@7>B>4<>4>9 6>@8 >; ;<>; ;3?7 > 62BB: 97>B3@F B7F34;B>;32@ 2 ! *. .& A<3=< A>4 973@F 8B3H7@ 3@ > B>4< >@8 @7F63F7@;
- 5 -
?>@@7B=>?75B2?2DD243;783B7=;32@>@88>4<78>F>3@4; ;<7?2;2B=:=674>B74C6;25;<7>52B74>38>==387@;;<7 87=7>478>H34C4;>3@78FB37H2C43@GCB374>@84C==C?978 ;2;<73@GCB3742@;<74D2;
& <7 =6>3?>@;4 53678 > D7;3;32@ C@87B 7=;32@ 25 ;<7 =; 477I3@F =2?D7@4>;32@ 52B ;<7 87>;< 25 ;<7 87=7>478>62@FA3;<3@;7B74;
D2@ 47BH3=7 25 @2;3=7 ;<7 B74D2@87@; 2& >DD7>B78 ;<B2CF< =2C@476 >@8 53678 AB3;;7@ 4;>;7?7@;
87@:3@F ;<7 >H7B?7@;4 ?>87 3@ ;<7 =6>3? D7;3;32@ 74D2@87@; 2 >DD7>B78 ;<B2CF< =2C@476 9C; 838 @2;
5367 ;<7 AB3;;7@ 4;>;7?7@; <7 B74D2@87@; 2 874D3;7 47BH3=7 25 @2;3=7 838 @2; >DD7>B 9752B7 ;<7 B39C@>6 >@8 A>4D6>=787J!D>B;7 ( @ ;<7 9>434 25 ;<7 D67>83@F4 25 ;<7 D>B;374 ;<7 6>3?4B39C@>65B>?78;<7344C74>@8;<7B7>5;7BB7=2B878 ;<7 7H387@=7 <7 B39C@>6 9: 3?DCF@78 GC8F?7@; >@8 >A>B8<>4D>B;6:>662A78;<7=6>3?D7;3;32@>@8<768;<>;
;<7 =6>3?>@;4 >B7 7@;3;678 ;2 > F629>6 =2?D7@4>;32@ 25
- 6 -
4*)&**
!>62@FA3;<3@;7B74;>;;<7B>;725KD> >@8 83B7=;78 ;<7 B74D2@87@; 2& ;2 87D243; ;<7 =2?D7@4>;32@ >?2C@; >62@F A3;< 3@;7B74; 73@F >FFB37H78;<7DB747@;>DD7>64<>H7977@53678
<767>B@78=2C@47652B;<7=6>3?>@;4<>4B>3478;<7 52662A3@F=2@;7@;32@4 > %3B4;6: ;<7 =6>3?>@;4 >447B; ;<>; ;<7 87=7>478 A>4 >F78>92C;:7>B4>;;<7;3?725;<7>==387@;>@8<>8> ?2@;<6: 3@=2?7 25 4****
!
9: A2BI3@F >4 ?>42@ 2A7H7B ;<7 >44744?7@; 25 ?2@;<6: 3@=2?7 25 ;<7 87=7>478>;4&(*
!9:;<7B39C@>634C@GC4;35378>@8 7BB2@72C4 9 7=2@86: >4 D7B ;<7 6>A 6>38 82A@ 9: ;<7 2@/967 CDB7?7 2CB; 3@ ;<7 =>47 25 +#" ,
- 3@ =>474 A<7B7 ;<7 87=7>478 A>4 4765! 7?D62:782BB7=73H78>53J784>6>B:>@>883;32@25*K25 ;<7 74;>9634<78 3@=2?7 ;2A>B84 E5C;CB7 DB24D7=;4/ 34 A>BB>@;78 A<7@ ;<7 87=7>478 A>4 9762A ;<7 >F7 25 *
- 7 -
:7>B4 <7 4>38 DB3@=3D67 34 B3F<;6: >DD6378 ;2 ;<7 DB747@; =>47 = <3B86:>4D7B;<7GC8F?7@;25;<72@/967CDB7?7 2CB;3@;<7=>4725 .& , / % / - 7>=< 25 ;<7 =6>3?>@;4347@;3;678;2=2?D7@4>;32@254****
!C@87B ;<7<7>825E62442562H7>@8>557=;32@>@8=2@42B;3C?/ 8 %2CB;<6:>42@;<78>;725;<7>==387@;;<78B3H7B25 ;<7 62BB: A>4 <2683@F > H>638 8B3H3@F 63=7@47 ;2 8B3H7 > ;B>@4D2B;H7<3=67>@8;<72557@83@F62BB:A>4>642<>H3@F >D7B?3;<7B39C@>6>5;7B=2@4387B3@F>66;<747?>;7B3>64 <>4 B3F<;6: 5>4;7@78 ;<7 63>9363;: 2@ ;<7 @4CB>@=7 2?D>@: 7 >4;6: =2@4387B3@F ;<7 >F7 >@8 >H2=>;32@ 25 ;<7 87=7>478 ;<7 2H7B>66 =2?D7@4>;32@ >A>B878 9: ;<7 B39C@>6343@>87LC>;7>@82@;<762A7B4387 3;< ;<7 >92H7 =2@;7@;32@4 ;<7 67>B@78 =2C@476 42CF<;;2>662A;<7>DD7>6536789:;<7=6>3?>@;4
- 8 -
) @ ;<7 2;<7B <>@8 ;<7 67>B@78 =2C@476 52B ;<7 @4CB>@=7 2?D>@: <>4 B>3478 ;<7 52662A3@F =2C@;7B! =2@;7@;32@4 > %3B4;6: >6;<2CF< ;<7 =6>3?>@;4 =6>3? ;<>; ;<7 87=7>478 A>4 7>B@3@F 4****
! D7B ?2@;< ;<7: <>H7 5>3678 ;2 4C94;>@;3>;7 ;<73B =6>3? A3;< 4CDD2B;3@F 82=C?7@;4 2@47LC7@;6: ;<7 B39C@>6 <>4 =2BB7=;6: >4474478;<73@=2?725;<787=7>478@2;32@>66: 9 7=2@86: >; ;<7 ;3?7 25 ;<7 >==387@; ;<7 8B3H7B 25 ;<72557@83@F62BB:838@2;D244744>H>6388B3H3@F63=7@47 ; 34 5CB;<7B >447B;78 ;<>; ;<7 4>38 62BB: 838 @2; <>H7 > D7B?3;;2D6:2@;<7B2>83@=7;<73@4CB78<>4H326>;78 ;<7 ;7B?4 >@8 =2@83;32@4 25 ;<7 @4CB>@=7 D263=: ;<7 @4CB>@=72?D>@:34@2;63>967;2D>:;<7=2?D7@4>;32@ <7 B39C@>6 <>4 7BB78 3@ 5>4;7@3@F ;<7 63>9363;: 2@ ;<7 @4CB>@=72?D>@: = <3B86:43@=7;<7=6>3?>@;4<>H7@2;74;>9634<78;<7 3@=2?7 25 ;<7 87=7>478 ;<7: >B7 @2; 7@;3;678 52B =2?D7@4>;32@;2A>B84E5C;CB7DB24D7=;4/
- 9 -
8 %2CB;<6: 2@ >DDB7=3>;32@ 25 2B>6 >@8 82=C?7@;>B:
7H387@=7 >@8 =2@4387B3@F ;<7 >F7 >@8 >H2=>;32@ 25 ;<7 87=7>478 ;<7 2H7B>66 =2?D7@4>;32@ >A>B878 9: ;<7 B39C@>6342@;<7<3F<7B4387>@8B7LC3B74;297B78C=78 3;< ;<7 >92H7 =2@;7@;32@4 ;<7 67>B@78 =2C@476 42CF<;;2>662A;<7>DD7>6536789:;<7@4CB>@=72?D>@: 9:834?3443@F;<7>DD7>6536789:;<7=6>3?>@;4
, 7>B8 ;<7 67>B@78 =2C@476 52B ;<7 D>B;374 >@8 D7BC478;<7GC8F?7@;>@8>A>B825;<7B39C@>6
. ;34@2;3@834DC;7;<>;87=7>478>H3 C?>B83783@ ;<7 B2>8 ;B>553= >==387@; 2==CBB78 2@ &***. 8C7 ;2 B>4< >@8@7F63F7@; 8B3H3@F 25 ;<7 2557@83@F H7<3=67 9: 3;4 8B3H7B
* 3;< B7F>B8 ;2 ;<7 =2@;7@;32@ B>3478 9: ;<7 @4CB>@=72?D>@:;<>;;<78B3H7B25;<72557@83@FH7<3=67 838 @2; D244744 > H>638 8B3H3@F 63=7@=7 >@8 ;<>; ;<7 2557@83@FH7<3=67838@2;<>H7>H>638D7B?3;;<7B39C@>6 <>4 5B>?78 44C7 2 >@8 44C7 2& >@8 <>4
- 10 -
=>;7F2B3=>66: >@4A7B78 ;<7 4>?7 9: =2@4387B3@F ;<7 2B3F3@>6 B7=2B84 <7 B767H>@; 53@83@F4 25 ;<7 B39C@>6 >4 7J;B>=;783@D>B>FB>D<*25;<7GC8F?7@;B7>8>4C@87B
!" #$"
%
&
' ( )& )&
*+), &
-.-.-/
0.--0
*1)2
3.-.--
..-0 %
)
4
%
5-26/ $'' ,, !7 .
&
'
8 9
7
)&' ( *1):9
- 11 -
#$" -0./.- ;
)5
6 < %
4
=
! "# "$ %
@B74D7=;25LC>@;C?25=2?D7@4>;32@34=2@=7B@78 3@H37A25;<76>A6>3882A@9:;<7CDB7?72CB;3@;<7 =>47 25 0 1 4CDB> =6>3?>@; 24 >@8 >B7 7@;3;678 52B =2?D7@4>;32@ 25 23) 7>=< C@87B ;<7 <7>8 25 E6244 25 5363>6 =2@42B;3C?/
3;< B7F>B8 ;2 ;<7 =2?D7@4>;32@ >A>B878 C@87B 2;<7B <7>84 ;<34 2CB; 53@84 ;<>; ;<7 =2?D7@4>;32@ >A>B8789:;<7B39C@>634GC4;>@8B7>42@>967>@88274 @2;A>BB>@;3@;7B57B7@=7
& <C4 ;<7 =6>3?>@;4 >B7 7@;3;678 ;2 ;<7 52662A3@F =2?D7@4>;32@
- 12 -
4567289:7;7<6= <:6=67968<2 4;79>? 9@6 =:>;78A '2( 4;79>? 9@:2 ;=9 '2( 24425@=2?78C7;2;<7 87>;<25;<787=7>478 **&** **&** %C@7B>67JD7@474 (*** (*** 2442574;>;7 (*** (*** 24425%363>6=2@42B;3C? **** ,**** 98A
3
3
@;<7B74C6;;<752662A3@F2B87B34D>4478
> <7>DD7>6536789:;<7=6>3?>@;4348AAB6<:7 58=9 9 <7 >DD7>6 53678 9: ;<7 @4CB>@=7 2?D>@: 34 & = <7GC8F?7@;25;<76>3?4B39C@>634?2835378
- 13 -
8 <7 =6>3?>@;4 >B7 7@;3;678 ;2 > ;2;>6 =2?D7@4>;32@ 25 2 3) >4 >F>3@4;
4*)&**
!>A>B8789:;<7B39C@>6 7 <7 @4CB>@=7 2?D>@: 34 83B7=;78 ;2 87D243; ;<7=2?D7@4>;32@>?2C@;>62@FA3;<3@;7B74;>; K D> 5B2? ;<7 8>;7 25 5363@F 25 ;<7 =6>3? D7;3;32@ ;366 ;<7 8>;7 25 B7>63M>;32@ A3;<3@ > D7B3282543JA77I45B2?;<78>;725B7=73D;25> =2D:25;<34GC8F?7@; 5 <7 >DD2B;32@?7@; 87D243; >@8 B767>47 25 >?2C@; 4<>66 97 ?>87 3@ >==2B8>@=7 A3;< ;<7 ;7B?425;<7>A>B825;<7B39C@>6
<) '# ( %
<) '"%&"( %
34; 26 2