Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66381 (KAR)
MAHESH v. SURYAKANTH
CRL.A/200224/2023 · 2025-09-17
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66381 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66381 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$""
"!! %
&%'!()*+%(( ),
"!! *
%
&%'!()*+%((
)
,
!"
#$$ % $$ &
'(
!"
#$ % &
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$$ )
" %'&)$$ ) !(!(! $
) (!(!*
)))$ * *'!) * *
*)
,
'*
!"
#$$ % $$ &
'! !"
#$ % &
$$ )
" %'& ) $ $ )!(!(!$
)
**!(!* ) )) $ * *'! ) * *
- 3 -
$$))
+
$" %$+ &
,- .//-00.12 31 452, 2,-6- 7.6-6 4-318 2,- 759/0.31.12 31 5(!(!* .1: 5**!(!* 51 2,-;30-5;2,-0-.<1-:3=30>:8-.1:) .6.=.?.0@.1 A;5< 6,5<2 B2,- <3.0 5><2CD 36 39/>81318 2,- E>:89-12 :.2-: !(!(! .7F>322318 2,- <-6/51:-12.77>6-: ;5< 2,- 5;;-17- />136,.40- >1:-< -72351 * 5; -8523.40- 162<>9-12672* *A;5<6,5<2B2,-72CD ! ).7265;2,-7.6-314<3-;.<-2,.22,-.//-00.12 759/0.31.1231452,7.6-6,.6;30-:2,-/<3=.2-759/0.312 31$56!(!(!(.1:*!(!(.8.31622,-<-6/51:-12 .77>6-: .00-8318 7599366351 5; 2,- 5;;-17- />136,.40- >1:-<-72351* 5;722362,-7512-123515;2,- 759/0.31.12 2,.2,- 36 . 4>631-669-1 4@/<5;-66351 .1:
G.6 ,.=318 75<:3.0 <-0.23516,3/ G32, <-6/51:-12.77>6-:
- 4 -
317- 2,- <-6/51:-12.77>6-: G.6 31 1--: 5; 951-@ ,- <-F>-62-: 2,- 759/0.31.12 25 /.@ ,.1: 05.1 5;
6H((((( 775<:3180@ 2,- 759/0.31.12 0-12 .1 .95>12 5; 6H((((( 51 *((!(* ,- .77>6-:
/<5936-: 25 <-/.@ 2,- 6.9- G32,31 63I 9512,6 ,- 759/0.31.12 :-9.1:-:4.7?2,-.95>12<-/-.2-:0@ .;2-< 759/0-23515;63I9512,6-17-2,-.77>6-:366>-:2G5 7,-F>-6 4-.<318 56!!(H .1: !!(H' :.2-:
(*!!(* ;5< 6((((( -.7, :<.G1 51 @1:37.2- .1? <.17, .6.=.?.0@.1 25G.<:6 2,- :367,.<8- 5;
0-8.00@ -1;5<7-.40- :-42
,-1 2,- 6.3: 7,-F>-6 G-<- /<-6-12-: ;5< -17.6,9-12 2,- 6.9- G-<- :36,515<-: .6 2,-<-G.6316>;;373-12;>1:312,-.775>125;2,-.77>6-:
,- 0-8.0 15237- G.6 366>-: 25 2,- .77>6-:
31;5<9318 ,39 <-8.<:318 :36,515< 5; 2,- 7,-F>-6 .1: 7.00318>/5125/.@2,-7,-F>-6.95>12,-.77>6-:,.:
152 <-/.3: 2,- 7,-F>-6 .95>12 15< :3: ,- <-/0@ 25 2,- 0-8.0 15237- .1: 2,-<-4@ ,- ,.6 7599322-: 2,- 5;;-17- />136,.40->1:-<-72351* 5;72775<:3180@2,-
- 5 -
759/0.31.12<-F>-62-:2,-<3.05><2252.?-75813J.17- 5;2,-5;;-17-.1:2531323.2-0-8.0.72351 ' ,- <3.0 5><2 255?
75813J.17- 5; 2,- 5;;-17- .1:<-8362-<-:2,-7.6-63156(!(!*.1:**!(!* ,- .77>6-: ,.6 .//-.<-: 4-;5<- 2,- <3.0 5><2 31 452, 7.6-6/0-.:-:1528>302@.1:70.39-:254-2<3-:15<:-< 25 /<5=- ,36 7512-12351 2,- 759/0.31.12 31 452, 7.6-6 -I.931-:,396-0;.6$
*.1:8529.<?-:I6$*25$ ,- .77>6-: ,.6 :-13-: .00 2,- 317<3931.2318 9.2-<3.06 .=.30.40- 51 <-75<: 4>2 ,.6 152 0-: .1@ -=3:-17- 31 6>//5<25;,36:-;-17-,-<3.05><2.;2-<2.?3183125 75163:-<.2351 .00 2,-6- 9.2-<3.06 51 <-75<: 7.9- 25 2,- 75170>6351 2,.2 2,- 759/0.31.12 ,.6 152 /<5=-: ,36 ;31.173.07./.732@250-1:.1.95>125;6(((((-.7, 31 452, 7.6-6 ,-<-;5<- 2,- .77>6-: 36 6>77-66;>0 31 <-4>22318 2,- 0-8.0 /<-6>9/2351 >1:-< -723516 ** .1:
* 5; 72 775<:3180@ 2,- 39/>81-: E>:89-12 5;
.7F>322.0 7.9- 25 4- /.66-: -318 .88<3-=-: 4@ 2,- 6.9-2,-759/0.31.1231452,7.6-6364-;5<-2,365><2
- 6 -
-.<: <3 $<.:--/ >9.< 0-.<1-: 75>16-0 ;5< 2,-.//-00.12.1:<3.7,31.,.E.10-.<1-:75>16-0 ;5<<-6/51:-12$-<>6-:2,-9.2-<3.063170>:3182,-<3.0 5><2<-75<:6 H 1 =3-G 5; 2,- <3=.0 7512-123516 ><8-: 4@ 2,- 0-.<1-:75>16-0;5<452,2,-/.<23-62,-/53122,.2G5>0: .<36-;5<9@75163:-<.235136
@.16G-<252,-.45=-/531236312,-BC ;5<2,-;5005G318
" 2362,-7512-123515;2,-759/0.31.122,.2,- 36 . 4>631-669-1 .1: ,.: 0-12 6H((((( 25 2,- .77>6-:51*((!(*5G.<:6<-/.@9-125;2,-6.9- 2,-.77>6-:366>-:2G57,-F>-6;5<6(((((-.7,.6 /-< I$*
,-1 2,-6- 7,-F>-6 G-<- /<-6-12-: ;5< -17.6,9-12 2,-@ G-<- :36,515<-: .6 2,-<- G.6
- 7 -
316>;;373-12 ;>1: 31 2,- .775>12 5; 2,- .77>6-: =-1 2,5>8, 51- 5; 2,- 0-8.0 15237- G.6 6-<=-: ,- ,.: 152 <-/.3:2,-7,-F>-.95>12.1:2,-<-4@,-,.:7599322-: 2,-5;;-17->1:-<-72351* 5;72
1 5<:-< 25 /<5=- ,36 7512-12351 2,- 759/0.31.12 -I.931-: ,396-0; .6 $
* 31 452, 7.6-6 I$*.<-2,-7,-F>-66.3:25,.=-366>-:4@2,-.77>6-:
I$! .<- 2,- 4.1? -1:5<6-9-126 ;5< ,.=318 :36,515<-: 2,-7,-F>-;5<316>;;373-17@5;;>1:6I$.<-2,-75/3-6 5; 2,- 0-8.0 15237-6 I$'.<- 2,- /562.0 <-7-3/26 I$ .<-2,-/562.0.7?15G0-:8-9-125;2,-.77>6-:;5<,.=318 6-<=-:2,-0-8.015237-6
><318 7<566-I.931.2351 5; $
* 32 36 .:9322-: 2,.2 2,- 7,-F>-6 I$* 31 452, 7.6-6 G-<- /-<2.31318 25 2,- 4.1? .775>12 5; 2,- .77>6-: .1: 2,- 7,-F>-64-.<6381.2><-65;2,-.77>6-:2366>88-62-:25 $
* 31 452, 2,-6- 7.6-6 2,.2 2,- 759/0.31.12 G.6 2,- 4>631-669.1 ,.=318 4.9455 6,5/ .1: 2,- .77>6-: 36 G5<?318 .6 . 2-.7,-< 2 36 62.2-: 2,.2 2,- 759/0.31.12
- 8 -
4-318G-00.7F>.312-:G32,2,-.77>6-:.1:.66-7><32@2,- .77>6-: ,.: 366>-: 2,- 2G5 7,-F>-6 31 F>-62351 G32, ,36 6381.2><-6,-6.9-G-<-936>6-:4@2,-759/0.31.1225 ;30-2,-6-7.6-6 *( ,- .77>6-: ,.6 152 62-//-: 3125 2,- G321-66 45I 25 :-/56- .45>2 2,- 936>6- 5; 2,- 7,-F>-6 G,-1 2,56- 7,-F>-6 G-<- 366>-: G,-2,-< .1@ 759/0.312 G.6 ;30-: <-8.<:318 936>6- G,-2,-< 2,56- 7,-F>-6 G-<- :-9.1:-: 4.7?
.1: G,@ 15 B625/ /.@9-12C <-F>-62 G.6 366>-: 25 2,- 4.1? 9.1.8-< 36 1-=-< -I/0.31-: 4@ 2,- .77>6-: ** 2 36 6>88-62-: 25 $
* :><318 7<566 -I.931.2351 2,.2 ,36 4<52,-< >/-6, .1: 2,- 4<52,-< 5;
2,- .77>6-: 3:<.9 G-<- <>11318 4>631-66 .1: 25G.<:66-7><32@2,-.77>6-:.1:,364<52,-<,.:366>-: 2,-7,-F>-31F>-62351252,-6.3:>/-6,2,-4<52,-<5;
2,- /<-6-12 759/0.31.12.,-6, ,36 6>88-62351 G.6 ;0.20@:-13-:4@$
*,-.77>6-:,.6152/<5:>7-:.1@ 9.2-<3.0 25 /<54.4036- ,36 7512-12351 2,.2 ,36 4<52,-<
- 9 -
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
2,- 51C40- /-I 5><2 31 !" G,-<- 2,- 51C40- /-I 5><2 <-;-<<-: 25 326 =.<35>6 :-7363516 51 2,- 6>4E-72 .1: ,-0: 31 /.<.8<./, 56'.1:H.6>1:-<
1 !"#
- 10 -
$%%&' () *+
' ,
( ,
"
,-# %,.( (
/ .) (
) ( (
(
& + ) (
/,
/&+ /) ,( ()
"
%-/
& %!& + . ) ( (,/ (
, ( ( ( & / ) & /
() /
) & %0&11111 %2& 3)
. , )
) ,//
(
, / ( (
"
% * +
', ) / /
&4
- 11 -
* ,- 51C40- /-I 5><2 .8.31 31 # $ % & # ' ( ) $
' * <-32-<.2-: 2,- 6-220-: /5632351 5;
0.G .1: <-E-72-: 2,- :-;-17- 2.?-1 4@ 2,- .77>6-: 2,.2 7,-F>- 31 F>-62351 G.6 366>-: .6 6-7><32@ .1: ,- 36 152 03.40-;5<751=372351>1:-<-72351* 5;2,-72 *' ,- 51C40- /-I 5><2 31
!) +% '
# ), <-;-<<318 25 326 -.<03-< :-7363516 3170>:318326:-73635131%6>/<.
<-32-<.2-:2,- /5632351 5; 0.G 2,.2 366>.17- 5;40.1?7,-F>- =50>12.<30@ 6318-:.1:,.1:-:5=-<4@2,-.77>6-:G,37,3625G.<:6 659- /.@9-12 G5>0: .22<.72 2,- /<-6>9/2351 >1:-< -72351*5;2,-72G,37,3170>:-62,--I362-17-5; 0-8.00@-1;5<7-.40-:-42 * ,>6 2,- /5632351 5; 0.G 36 =-<@ G-00 6-220-: 2,.2>10-662,-.77>6-:<-4>262,-0-8.0/<-6>9/2351,-
2 '+5"!0 3 0"-%
- 12 -
36 152 -12320-: ;5< .7F>322.0 317- 2,- .77>6-: ,.6 152 <-4>22-:2,-0-8.0/<-6>9/2351312,-/<-6-127.6-,-36 03.40-;5<751=372351 *H ,.=- 851- 2,<5>8, 2,- 39/>81-: E>:89-12 /.66-: 4@ 2,- <3.0 5><2 .7F>322318 2,- .77>6-: ;5< 2,- 5;;-17-/>136,.40->1:-<-72351* 5;2,-72,- <3.0 5><2 /<57--:-: 25 ;5<9 .1 5/31351 2,.2 9-<- />223184.0:6>88-6235125$
*4@2,-0-.<1-:75>16-0;5< 2,- .77>6-: .95>126 25 <-4>22318 5; 2,- 0-8.0 /<-6>9/2351 -=-1 2,5>8, 2,- G321-66 :-13-: 2,- 6.3: 6>88-62351
32, 6>7, -<<51-5>6 ;31:318 2,- <3.0 5><2 /<57--:-: 25 6,3;2 2,- 4><:-1 51 2,- 759/0.31.12 .1: ;5<9-: .1 5/31351 2,.2 2,- 759/0.31.12 ,.6 152 /<5=-: 0-1:3185;2,-.95>1210-662,-.77>6-:<-4>262,-0-8.0 /<-6>9/23512,-4><:-1G3001526,3;2512,-759/0.31.12 -32,-< 25 /<5=- 0-1:318 5; 2,- .95>12 5< 25 /<5=- 2,- -I362-17-5; 0-8.00@ -1;5<7-.40-:-42.6 2,- /<-6>9/2351 >1:-<-72351*5;2,-723170>:-62,-/<-6>9/2351 <-8.<:318-I362-17-5;0-8.00@-1;5<7-.40-:-42,-<-;5<-
- 13 -
.95;2,-5/313512,.22,-<3.05><2,.67599322-:.1 -<<5< 31 /.66318 2,- 39/>81-: E>:89-12 .7F>322318 2,- .77>6-:G32,5>2.1@4.636-17-2,-6.9-3603.40-254- 6-2.63:- *" 1=3-G5;2,-.45=-.16G-<2,-.45=-/5312 312,-.;;3<9.23=-.1:/<57--:25/.662,-;5005G318
%3& 52,2,-.//-.06.<-/
%33& ,-39/>81-:E>:89-1265;.7F>322.0:.2-: !(!(!/.66-:3156(!(!*.1: **!(!* <-6/-723=-0@ 51 2,- ;30- 5; 2,- 0-.<1-:3=30>:8-.1:) .6.=.?.0@.1 .<-,-<-4@6-2.63:- %333& 516-F>-120@ 2,- <-6/51:-12.77>6-: 31 452,2,-7.6-636 751=372-:;5<2,-5;;-17- />136,.40->1:-<-72351* 5;72.1: ,-366-12-17-:25/.@;31-5;6((((( A>/--6 )3=-.?,6 510@D -.7, 31 452, 2,- 7.6-6 G32,31 ;5>< G--?6 ;<59 25:.@ 1
- 14 -
:-;.>0225/.@;31-,-6,.00>1:-<85639/0- 39/<36519-12;5<./-<35:5;131-9512,6 %3=& >2 5; 2,- ;31- .95>12 6'(((( 31 452, 2,- 7.6-6 36 25 4- 83=-1 25 2,- .//-00.12.6759/-16.2351 -8362<@ 36 :3<-72-: 25 6-1: 4.7? 2,- <3.0 5><2 <-75<:6 .0518 G32, 75/@ 5; 2,36 E>:89-12 ;5< 31;5<9.2351 .1: 1--:;>0 .72351 3- ;5< 366>.17- 5; 2,- 751=372351 G.<<.12 .8.3162 2,- .77>6-: 3; ,- ;.306 25 /.@ 2,- ;31- .95>12G32,31;5><G--?6
-) %""( $
3625*05*"