- 1 - !" #! $%!&!%% % ' '()* '!!)) + ! " #$%&&'! %( #$($'' #$($! ' ' ( #!&&&$ ' %! %( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #$($'' #$($! ! ) #$( #$($'&% ' * ) " #$($'% * ) + ) !( $( " (&! ) ) - 3 - $ % '$ '$ '$ ! ($ &' , , - ) , - ) ./ 0/121234/56 7/248 9::;6/< 36 13 ! 24 52=/ 3(&&! 3> .2419?2 3@2:/ 191234 5/8261/5/< >35 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97@/ ;4</5/:12346 $ % '$ '$ '$!($3>1./.95912A9 A9A994.219&' B>35 6.351 C1./ &'DE 95/ 6//?248 13 F;96. 1./ :52=249@053://<24862421291/<98924611./= /95<527.2G//192@/954/<:3;46/@>35 1./ 0/121234/56 94< 52 )9=9<95 .9.97;<<24 @/954/< 28. 3;51 3H/54=/41 @/9</5 >35 5/6034</41 3 - 4 - 5294G;491.2442@/954/<:3;46/@>355/6034</41 3 /5;6/<1./=91/529@6345/:35< ' 4 H2/I 3> 1./ 52H9@ :341/412346 ;58/< 7A 1./ @/954/<:3;46/@>35731.1./09512/61./032411.91I3;@< 9526/>35=A:3462</59123426, !"#$% A 946I/5 13 1./ 973H/ 03241 26 >351./>3@@3I248, !! ! /6034</41 3 96 24>35=941 >2@/< 1./ >2561 24>35=91234 I21. .2419?2 3@2:/ 191234 9892461 9::;6/< 3613!9@@/82481.916./.9<=9552/<9::;6/< 334 !& 94< 61951/< 5/62<248 I21. .2= 24 1./ 03@2:/ F;951/56 91 /489@;5; 96 ./ I96 I35?248 96 3@2:/ 346197@/ ::;6/< 3 26 1./7531./5 9::;6/< 3'26 1./=31./594<9::;6/< 3!261./6261/53>9::;6/< 3 - 5 - @@1./9::;6/<61951/<2@@#15/912481./24>35=941::;6/< 3 ;6/< 13 9669;@1 1./ 24>35=941 91 1./ 24612891234 3> 9::;6/< 36 13 ! 3H/5 0.34/ ;5248 :137/5 &! 9::;6/< 3@/>11./24>35=94124./5095/419@.3;6/I21. 9 053=26/ 13 19?/ ./5 79:? 7;1 4/H/5 5/1;54/< ./ 9::;6/<;6/<13:9@@./53H/50.34/94<;6/<1315/91./5 :5;/@@A73;1>/I<9A6/95@2/513>2@2483>1./:3=0@9241 9::;6/< 3 .9< :9=/ 13 1./ 095/419@ .3;6/ 3> 1./ 24>35=941 91 973;1 ('& 0= 97;6/< 24 >2@1.A @948;98/ 6@900/< ./5 94<9@63 :52=249@@A 2412=2<91/< 1./ 24>35=941 94<./5>9=2@A=/=7/5691/5./5949I9A>53=1./6031 ./5/>35/ 6./ 5/F;/61/< 1./ 03@2:/ 13 5/8261/5 1./ :96/ 94<132421291/@/89@9:1234::35<248@A1./ :9=/13 7/ 5/8261/5/< 94< 24H/612891234 I96 ;4</519?/4 4 1./ =/9412=/9::;6/< 3613!.9<900539:./<1.263;51 6//?248 13 F;96. 1./ :52=249@ 053://<2486 4 241/52= 35</53>619AI9685941/<94<1./5/>35/1./:.958/6.//1 .96431A/17//4>2@/< - 6 - $ ./ :341/416 3> 1./ >2561 24>35=91234 <26:@36/ 1.911./5/95/60/:2>2:9@@/891234698924619::;6/< 3>35 .9H248 :3==211/< 1./ 3>>/4:/ 3> 15/91248 1./ 24>35=941 I21.:5;/@1A6@900248./594<:52=249@@A2412=2<91248./5 ;1 1./ 9@@/8912346 9892461 9::;6/< 36 13 ! I.3 95/ 0/121234/5 3613!./5/2495/H/5A79@<94<8/4/59@ 1 261./60/:2>2::341/412343>1./0/121234/561.910/121234/5 37/2481./7531./53>9::;6/< 3261./5/62</413> ;=7920/121234/5 3'7/2481./=31./5261./5/62</41 3>9@97;598294<0/121234/5 3!7/2481./=9552/<6261/5 3> 9::;6/< 3 26 1./ 5/62</41 3> .24:.3@2 19@;? 9@97;5982 4 6;00351 3> 1./25 :341/41234 5/62</4129@ 0533> :30A 3> 1./ 9<.995 :95< 0/51924248 13 0/121234/5 3613!95/053<;:/<& 21<26:@36/61.911./A 95/ 5/62<248 6/09591/@A I.2@/ 1./ 24>35=941 94< 9::;6/< 3 I/5/ 5/62<248 138/1./5 91 /489@;5; 4</5 6;:. :25:;=6194:/61./:341/412343>1./24>35=9411.911./A ;6/<13:9@@9::;6/< 394<24612891/.2=13:3==211./ 3>>/4:/ 94< 96 0/5 6;:. 24612891234 ./ ;6/< 13 15/91 ./5 - 7 - I21.:5;/@1A:944317/9::/01/<./5/>35/ 9=3>1./30242341.9124H2/I3>1./=9152=3429@<260;1/ 7/1I//41./I2>/94<1./.;6794<1./05/6/41:3=0@9241 :9=/ 13 7/ >2@/<=9?248 79@< 9@@/8912346 98924619::;6/< 36 13 ! 7/248 1./ >9=2@A =/=7/56 3> 9::;6/< 3 /4:/ 9= 3> 1./ 3024234 1.911./ :52=249@ 053://<2486 9892461 9::;6/< 36 13 ! 26 @297@/ 13 7/ F;96./< 3I/H/5 1./ :341/41234 3> 1./ @/954/< :3;46/@ >35 1./ 0/121234/56 1.91 0/121234/5 3 I96 .360219@2J/< >35 1./ 0/523< >35= (1. :137/5 &! 13 !1. )94;95A &$ 94< 1./5/>35/ 1./5/ I96 43 :.94:/ 3> ./ :3==211248 94A 3>>/4:/:944317/9::/01/<911.266198//121234/5 3 :9419?/6;:.</>/4:/7/>35/1./529@3;517;11./69=/ :944317/9853;4<>35F;96.2481./:52=249@053://<2486 961./5/95/60/:2>2:9@@/8912346=9</9892461.2= % ::35<248@A 946I/51./973H/03241C0951@A24 1./9>>25=912H/D94<053://<1309661./>3@@3I248, - 8 - 2 ./0/12123426 22 ./0/121234>2@/<7A0/121234/5 39::;6/< 326./5/7A 222 ./ 0/121234 >2@/< 7A 0/121234/5 36 13 !9::;6/< 3613!26./5/7A 2H 52=249@ 053://<2486 2421291/< 9892461 0/121234/5 3613!9::;6/< 3613! 24 52=/ 3(&&!3>.2419?23@2:/191234 0/4<248341./>2@/3>1./@/954/<2H2@);<8/ 94< ) 91 ;59< >35 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97@/ ;4</5 /:12346 $ % '$ '$ '$ ! ($ 3> &' 26 ./5/7A !,* '%%) & 261 3,@ 3,!' ,