Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66375 (KAR)

MAHADEV MAATHAPTHI v. ARCHANA MATHAPATHI

CRL.RP/200162/2024 · 2025-09-01

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "!#!! !$ %&'(%)*+ &,%** - !" # $ % $ % &' "& '!&( # $ % ) &( ) $ %'& ''" ) "!"& $% " ) Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "!"& !*! "!"' ) ) (( ) "!" ) ) ) !!"!"" ) + $ + % ,-./01,02/30453-6/(("!"/027,835, /827,5,940,1 11323/0953:35;1<,901) 3194 =8/4-7/42>27,4395/;42?@3-3A.;<030<27,/41,4192,1 !!"!"" .9--,1 ;01,4 ,623/0 " /8 27, 4/2,623/0 /8 /A,084/A/A,-2363/5,06,62"!!$8/4-7/42>27, 62?@134,6230<73A2/.9BA9302,0906,/8-"!!! .,4 A/027 2/ 27, .,2323/0,4 27,4,30 84/A 27, 192, /8 .,2323/0 2355 7,4 538,23A,C 2/ .9B 6/A.,0-923/0 /8 -"!!!!D32730/0,A/02784/A27,192,/827,/41,4C 901134,6230<95527,4,-./01,02-EB.4/73E3230<27,A84/A 6/AA32230< 90B 962 /8 1/A,-236 :3/5,06, 30 90B A900,4 D7367D9-6/0834A,13043A3095..,95/""!"&/027, - 3 - 835,/8 27, 5,940,1 11323/095 3-24362901 ,--3/0- ;1<, 3194=8/4-7/42>27,)34-2..,5592,/;42?@:31,F;1<A,02 192,1!*! "!"' " 9423,-7,4,3094,4,8,44,12/9-.,427,34490G E,8/4,27,4395/;428/427,-9G,/86/0:,03,06, & )962-/827,69-,30E43,894,279227,.,2323/0,4 791 835,1 453-6/(("!" E,8/4, 27, 4395 /;42 ;01,4 ,623/0 " /8 27, 62 6/02,0130< 2792 -7, A9443,1 4,-./01,02 / /0 &!&"!* 901 982,4 A94439<,-7,5,1A943295538,79..35BD3274,-./01,02/ 8/49.,43/1/82D/A/027-92,427,4,-./01,02--2942,1 9E;-30< 7,4 30 83527B 590<;9<, 901 35524,9230< 7,4 53G, 9 -,4:9027,0,:,427,.,2323/0,4;-,12/69557,4.94,02- /:,4 .7/0, 27, 4,-./01,02- ;-,1 2/ 9E;-, 7,4 901 30-3-2,1 7,4 2/ </ 901 53:, 30 7,4 .94,02-? 7/;-, 7, .,2323/0,4 -.,63836955B 6/02,01,1 2792 ,:,0 27/;<7 -7, 79..35B 4,-31,1 30 27, A9243A/0395 7/;-, 8/4 9 .,43/1 /8 2D/ A/027- 27,4, D9- 0/ 6/0-;AA923/0 /8 A94439<, 9- - 4 - 27,BD,4,0/279:30<90B.7B-36954,5923/0-73.7,4,8/4, 27,.,2323/0,4-2942,14,-3130<307,49;02?-;065,?-7/;-, 8/49E/;2"!19B-7,027,.,2323/0,4791</0,E96G2/ 7,4 A9243A/0395 7/;-, 95/0< D327 7,4 ;065, D7/ 4,H;,-2,1 27,4,-./01,02-2/29G,694, /8 27, .,2323/0,4 ,-./01,02 / 24,92,1 7,4 D327 64;,52B 9E;-,1 7,4 30 83527B 590<;9<, 7,4,-./01,02-9-G,1 27, .,2323/0,4 2/ </ E96G 2/ 7,4 .94,0295 7/;-, 7,4,8/4, 4,-./01,02 /&5,82.,2323/0,430979<9/0:3559<,901982,4!2/" 19B- 4,-./01,02- 69A, 2/ 979<9/0 901 <9:, E96G 955 7,4 E,5/0<30<- 7,4,8/4, 1;, 2/ 27, .,2323/0,4?- 89A35B E,30< .//4 27, .,2323/0,4 D9- 4,-3130< 30 7,4 A92,4095 9;02?- 7/;-, 92 3194 7,4,982,4 -7, 835,1 27, .,2323/0 -,,G30<A9302,0906,9016/A.,0-923/0 ' 7,0/236,/827,43A30953-6,5590,/;- ,2323/0 D9- /41,4,1 9<930-2 27, 4,-./01,02- 2 3- -292,1 2792 -;67 0/236, D9- 4,2;40,1 E96G 9- >4,8;-,1? 901 7,06, 4,-./01,02- D,4, .596,1 7, .,2323/0,4 ,I9A30,17,4-,589- 90127,2D//27,4D320,--,-9- - 5 - -" 901 & 901 </2 A94G,1 I- 2/ & 7, 4395 /;42982,429G30<302/6/0-31,4923/095527,-,A92,4395-/0 4,6/41 .9--,1 27, 3A.;<0,1 /41,4 955/D30< 27, .,2323/0 ;01,4 ,623/0 " /8 27, 62 134,6230< 4,-./01,02 / 2/ .9B A9302,0906, /8 -"!!! .,4 A/027 901 6/A.,0-923/0 /8 -"!!!!C 955 27, 4,-./01,02- D,4, 134,62,10/22/6/AA3290B962/81/A,-236:3/5,06,2/27, .,2323/0,4,30<9<<43,:,1EB27,-9A,4,-./01,02/ 835,143A3095..,95/""!"&E,8/4,27,)34-2..,5592, /;427,)34-2..,5592,/;42/04,9..4,63923/0/827, A92,4395-/04,6/4113-A3--,127,9..,95:31,/41,4192,1 !*! "!"' ,30< 9<<43,:,1 EB 27, -9A, 4,-./01,02 /E,8/4,27,4395/;4279-835,1273-4,:3-3/0.,2323/0 ,94143794900;94919<35,940,16/;0-,5 8/427,.,2323/0,490143 491,,.;A945,940,1 8/4 27, 4,-./01,02 ,4;-,1 27, A92,4395- /0 4,6/41 - 6 - * 0 :3,D /8 27, 43:95 6/02,023/0- ;4<,1 EB 27, 5,940,16/;0-,58/4E/2727,.9423,-27,./3022792D/;51 943-,8/4AB6/0-31,4923/03- ! "# $ "" % B90-D,42/27,9E/:,./3023-3027, 8/427,8/55/D30< ( 2 3- 27, 6/02,023/0 /8 4,-./01,02 / D7/ 3- 27, .,2323/0,4 7,4,30 2792 0/ 0/236, 30 453-6/(( "!"69A,2/E,-,4:,1/027,4,-./01,02-7,B0,:,4 4,8;-,190B0/236,306,27,4,D9-/:31D9:,323- -292,127920/0/236,D9-2,01,4,12/27,A 0 6/0-31,4923/0 /8 27, A92,4395- /0 4,6/41 -,:,495 H;,-23/0- 943-, 9E/;2 27, 69-, A91, /;2 EB 27, .,2323/0,4 E,8/4, 27, 4395 /;42 :,0 966/4130< 2/ 27, .,2323/0,4 -7, -29B,1 8/4 2D/ A/027- 79..35B 30 27, - 7 - A9243A/0395 7/;-, 3AA,1392,5B 982,4 27, A94439<, 2355 27,4,D9-0/6/0-;AA923/0/8A94439<,:,08,D19B- 27,4,982,4-7,-2942,14,-3130<307,49;02;065,?-7/;-, 1A322,15B 0,327,4 27, .,2323/0,4 0/4 4,-./01,02 / 79:,3--;,190B0/236,2/27,/27,4.942B2/-,243<7227, 13-.;2, 1A322,15B 27, A94439<, E,2D,,0 27, .9423,- 2//G .596, /0 &!&"!* 7, 43A3095 3-6,5590,/;- ,2323/0 69A, 2/ E, 835,1 /0 !"!" 9G30< 302/ 6/0-31,4923/027,-,8962-/827,69-, 9A/827,/.303/0 2792 27, 3A.;<0,1 /41,4 .9--,1 EB 27, 4395 /;42 3- 2/ E, -,2 9-31, 2/ .4/:31, 90 /../42;032B 2/ 27, 4,-./01,02- E,8/4, 27, 4395 /;42 2/ .;2 30 27,34 9..,94906,9012/6/02,-227,A922,4 2 3- A91, 65,94 2792 273- /;42 79- 0/2 ,I.4,--,1 90B /.303/0 /0 27, 6/02,023/0 29G,0 EB 27, .9423,-7,4,-./01,02-94,9253E,42B2/.;28/42727,34 1,8,06, 901 6/02,-2 27, A922,4 /D,:,4 E/27 27, .9423,-94,134,62,12/9..,94E,8/4,27,4395/;42/027, 192, 83I,1 EB 273- /;42 901 .4/6,,1 D327 27, 24395 7, - 8 - 4395/;423-4,H;34,12/6/065;1,27,243959012/13-./-, /8 27, -9A, 30 9 23A, E/;01 A900,4 66/4130<5B 90-D,427,9E/:,./3023027,>98834A923:,?901.4/6,,12/ .9--27,8/55/D30< $3% 7,,:3-3/0 ,2323/03- $33% 7, 3A.;<0,1 /41,4 192,1 !!"!"" .9--,1 30 453-6/(("!" EB 27, 5,940,1 11323/0953:35;1<,901) 3194 D7367 D9- 6/0834A,1 EB 27, 5,940,1 11323/095 3-24362 901 ,--3/0- ;1<, 3194 30 43A3095 ..,95 /""!"& EB F;1<A,02 192,1 !*! "!"' 3- 7,4,EB 7,A922,43-4,A901,1E96G2/ 27,4395/;428/484,-76/0-31,4923/0 $333% 7, .,2323/0,4 901 27, 4,-./01,02 7,4,30 94, 134,62,1 2/ 9..,94 E,8/4, 27, 4395 /;42 /0 D327/;2 D93230< 8/4 84,-70/236, - 9 - $3:% 7, .,2323/0,4 7,4,30 E,30< 4,-./01,02 / E,8/4, 27, 4395 /;42 -7/;51 835, 73- -292,A,02 /8 /EF,623/0- 38 90B D32730 19B- 84/A 27, 192, /8 73- 9..,94906, E,8/4,27,4395/;42 $:% 7, 4395 /;42 3- 4,H;34,1 2/ .4/:31, 4,9-/09E5, /../42;032B 2/ E/27 27, .9423,- 2/.;28/42727,346/02,023/0-90113-./-,/8 27, A922,4 ,I.,1323/;-5B 925,9-2 D32730 84/A27,192,/89..,94906,/827, .9423,-E,8/4,32 $:3% 7, /E-,4:923/0- A91, 30 273- /41,4 -7955 0/2 3085;,06, 27, 4395 /;42 30 13-./-95 /8 27,A922,4E,8/4,32/0A,432- $:33% 8,327,4/827,.9423,-89352/9..,94E,8/4, 27,4395 /;42 /0 27, 192, 83I,1 27, 4395 /;423-9253E,42B2/.4/6,,130966/41906, D32759D - 10 - ,8/4, .94230< D327 27, A922,4 27, 8,,- /8 3-83I,192-!!!! 7, 5,940,1 11323/095 ,<3-2494 ,0,495 3- 134,62,1 2/A9G,0,6,--94B94490<,A,02-8/4.9BA,02/827,8,,- 2/27,5,940,1 .+ %!!* # 3-2/5/!