- 1 - !" #"$"" "%% &'()&** + !"# $ % # &# ' # ( # ) % # ' ) !(# # *# # ) ! # $ % # #' +) ( ' ,%(' %( !#!-#! # #.! & ' ,"'# # # #!" #-! ' ) ' ' / & # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #.! ' '' ," , "" ". , !, !. ,- ' ###/ "% (%("% (% ("%(%(' ### ' & 0#& $" % 0#& ( 1234567892:45524;7<=7;2:>?433@<2: 8#,@9:2A 236789 ,%( 8= 612 312:@;2: 4<62< 49: 312:@;2: A7>2< %A2B296789 8= 6A837672<( 36 -- %=8A <18A6 C %(36D(<22E79FA2F@;4A>47;79 5;#4<2 8#.!529:79F89612=7;28=)::767894;7<6A73649: 2<<789< &@:F2 4;4>@A4F7 =8A 612 8==2932< 5@97<14>;2 @9:2A 236789< ," , "" ". , !, 49: !. A24: G761 236789 ,- 8= 9:749 294; 8:2 .! 49: 236789<"% (%A( "% (%<(49:"%(%B(8=612 %( 36# # 18@F1 612 4552;;496 G4< 29;4AF2: 89 >47; <@>H236 68 32A6479 389:76789< 12 G4< =8@9: 68 14B2 - 3 - B78;462:612<47:389:76789<49:A2I4792:4><389:79F=8A4 52A78:8=629I8961<#9B72G8=<@31989)38I5;74932612 >47; 455;7346789 =7;2: >? 612 4552;;496 >2=8A2 612 ;24A92: 2<<789<&@:F234I268>2A2H2362:# "# 24A: 612 ;24A92: 38@9<2; 45524A79F =8A 612 4552;;49649:612;24A92:7F18@A68B2A9I296;24:2A 45524A79F=8AA2<589:296 8# 6462# ,# 12 ;24A92: 7F1 8@A6 8B2A9I296 ;24:2A 5;4379FA2;7493289612I462A74;<89A238A:389629:<6146 6124552;;49614<986>22938852A4679F=8A6122J52:7678@< :7<58<4; 8= 612 6A74; 49: 6146 17< 5A8;89F2: 4><2932 14< A2<@;62: 79 @9G4AA4962: :2;4? 79 612 5A8322:79F<# 6 7< =@A612A<@>I7662:61466124552;;49614:2B4:2:2J23@6789 8=612G4AA496=8A924A;?629I8961<49:614617<5A2<2932 G4<@;67I462;?<23@A2:89;?>?7<<@493249:2J23@67898= 4989)>47;4>;2G4AA49689 ,#!#!#2932767<@AF2: 6146617<7<9864=7634<2682J629:49?:7<3A267894A?A2;72= 79=4B8@A8=6124552;;496# - 4 - # 589 52A@<4; 8= 612 I462A74; 4B47;4>;2 89 A238A:767<A2B24;2:61466125A793754;433@<2:7961234<2 7< 433@<2: 8# G12A24< 612 8B2A6 436 466A7>@62: 68 612 5A2<2964552;;496G187<4AA4?2:4<433@<2: 8#,7<6146 12 4;;2F2:;? 4<<4@;62: #, 89 612 A7F16 =886 G761 4 G88:29 <673E 34@<79F 4 >;22:79F 79H@A?# 6 =@A612A 6A49<57A2< =A8I 612 A238A: 6146 612 @9:2A;?79F :7<5@62 7< 5A7I4A7;?>26G229433@<2: 8# 49:#,4A7<79F8@68=4 149:;8496A49<436789>26G229612I# .# 2 6146 4< 76 I4? 612 4552;;496 14< >229 4AA2<62: 49: 7< 79 H@:7374; 3@<68:? <7932 ,#!#!# 12 8==2932< =8A G1731 12 7< 314AF2)<12262: 4A2 986 8= 4 12798@< 946@A2# ;618@F1 612 A238A: :7<3;8<2< 6146 612 4552;;496 14: 5A2B78@<;? B78;462: 612 389:76789< 8= >47; 389<7:2A79F17<;7I762:A8;2796124;;2F2:7937:29649:612 =43661461214<>229793@<68:?=8A4389<7:2A4>;252A78: 617<8@A6:22I<76455A85A74626829;4AF26124552;;49689 >47; >? 7I58<79F <6A79F296 389:76789<# 92 8= <@31 - 5 - 389:76789<<14;;>261466124552;;496<14;;9864<4I4662A 8= 38@A<2 <22E 2J2I56789 =A8I 52A<894; 45524A4932 :@A79F6A74;#9?455;7346789<22E79F<@312J2I56789<14;; >2 2962A64792: 89;? @9:2A 2J32567894; 37A3@I<64932< 68 612<467<=4367898=612;24A92:A74;&@:F2# # 9 B72G 8= 612 =8A2F879F :7<3@<<789 612 =8;;8G79F8A:2A7<54<<2: 7#123A7I794;45524;7<12A2>?4;;8G2:# 77#127I5@F92:8A:2A:462:!#!-#!54<<2:>? 612 ;24A92: ::767894; 7<6A736 49: 2<<789< &@:F2 4;4>@A4F779 5;#4<2% ( 8#.!7<<264<7:2# 777# 12 4552;;496433@<2: 8#, <14;; >2 A2;24<2: 89 >47; 79 3899236789 G761 5;# 4<2 % ( 8#.! %4A7<79F8@68=A7I2 8#-!A2F7<62A2:>? @>) A>49 8;732 646789 4;4>@A4F7( 529:79F >2=8A2 612 ;24A92: - 6 - ::767894;7<6A73649: 2<<789<&@:F24;4>@A4F7<@>H236 68612=8;;8G79F389:76789< 4#124552;;496<14;;2J23@62452A<894;>89: =8A4<@I8=<#!!!!!)%@522<G84E1< 89;?(G7616G8<@A2672<=8A612;7E2<@I68612 <467<=4367898=612A74;8@A6+ ># 12 4552;;496 <14;; 986 64I52A G761 612 5A8<23@6789 G7692<<2< 8A 2B7:2932 27612A :7A236;?8A79:7A236;?+ 3# 12 4552;;496 <14;; 986 =7;2 49? 455;7346789 <22E79F 2J2I56789 =A8I 52A<894; 45524A4932 89 612 :462< =7J2: =8A 124A79F 2J3256 @9:2A 2J6A48A:794A?49:2J32567894;37A3@I<64932<68 612<467<=4367898=612;24A92:A74;&@:F2G18 <14;; A238A: A24<89< 7= <@31 2J2I56789 7< FA4962:+ :# 12 4552;;496 <14;; 2J629: =@;; 38852A46789 =8A6122J52:7678@<3893;@<7898=6126A74;+ 2# 12 4552;;496 <14;; A2F@;4A;? 45524A >2=8A2 612 A74; 8@A6 :@A79F 612 38@A<2 8= 612 - 7 - 5A8322:79F< @9;2<< <5237=734;;? 2J2I562: =8A B4;7:A24<89<>?612<47:8@A6+ =#124552;;496<14;;98679B8;B217I<2;=7949? 3A7I794; 4367B76? <7I7;4A 8A 8612AG7<2 :@A79F 612529:293?8=61234<2+49: F#124552;;496<14;;986;24B2612H@A7<:736789 8= 612 A74; 8@A6 G7618@6 5A78A 52AI7<<789 8= 612 <47: 8@A6 @967; :7<58<4; 8= 612 529:79F 34<2# ,' &""* $ 7<6 8# ; 8#,