Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66371 (KAR)
THE ENQUIRY OFFICER AND THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER v. MASJID E MAHAL KALLAN AND ANR
CRP/200081/2023 · 2025-11-26
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66371 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66371 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$%
&%'!%!%
$$! () $$! *
$$! "
$$! $$! $$! *
$$! ""
$$! "
$$! $$! $$! $$! $$! $$! $$! $$! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
! " !! #
$ %%& ! "#
'() ! %*&& +% *
'(,
! " ! #
! '("-#
! ! ) ! !! ,*$ ! !! ,*$ ! - 3 -
*
)
! " !! #
$
! ! ! '$$ ! * * $$$$'$$$' !* ! '$
! "*$$ $ !#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! $'*$ . ! . - 4 -
!! $'*$ ! "
)
! ! " !! #
! +% *! + *!! &! &! '($
! "*$$
$ !#
! '("-#
! ! ) ! !! (*$- . ! . !! (*$-
! - 5 -
)
! " !! #
$ %
"% #
! # % *
*% +%
&& *% %
& *% %
*% %
- 6 -
*% %
,)* & % ! '$)
( % *
+% *,,,! % '$)
! "*$$
"# "# (!#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! ''*$ . ! . !! ''*$
! )
! " !! #
- 7 -
$ % &! &! '$)
! +% *! *!)! (,*) &! &! '$)
! "*$$ $ !#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! *$ . ! . !! *$ ! *
)
! " !! #
- 8 -
$ % &! &! '$)
+% *! *!-)! (,*-) &! &! '$)
! "*$$ $ !#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! )'*$
! . !! )'*$
! ""
)
! " !! #
- 9 -
$ % "% # ! '$) ! *% +%
( & * +%
)
& *% %
) *
! ,')* $)$'(
, ! '$)
! "*$$ $ )!#
!*'("-# $-- ! ! ) ! !! $*$
! !! $*$ ! - 10 -
"
)
! " !! #
$ % &! &! '$)
& +% *& *!,'! (,*,' &! &! '$)
! "*$$ $ !#
!*'("-# $-- ! ! ) ! !! )*$
. ! . - 11 -
!! )*$ ! )
! " !! #
$ & "# %! ! ! * % +%
(
+% * %
) !
+% * %
!! % * %
! * !! - 12 -
! %! ! "
)/ / *$$ $!#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! $*$ . ! . !! $*$ ! )
! " !! #
$ % &! &! '$)
- 13 -
+% *! *!$$! (,*$$ &! &! '$)
! " $ / *$$ !#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! *$ . ! . !! *$ ! )
! " !! #
$ % &! &! - 14 -
'$)
+% *! *!')! (,*') &! &! '$)
! "*$$ !#
!*'("-# $-- ! ! ) ! !! )*$ . ! . !! )*$
! )
! " !! #
$ % &! - 15 -
&! '$)
&
+% *! *!! (,* &! &! '$) ! " $ / *$$ !#
! '( "-#
! ! ! ) ! !! )*$ . ! . !! )*$ ! )
! " !! #
- 16 -
$ % &! &! '$)
% *! *!)'! (,*)' &! &! '$)
! "*$$ $ !#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! (*$ . ! . !! (*$ ! )
! " !! #
- 17 -
$ %
"% #
! % ! & % *'*$$*
'$)
+% *
*))*$ ! '$)
! " $ / *$$ !#
! '-"-#
$--! ! ) ! !! $)*$ . ! . !! $)*$
! )
- 18 -
! " !! #
$ % &! &! '$)
% &&! +% *! *!$'! (,*$' &! &! '$)
! " $ / *$$ $ !#
! '("-#
$--! ! ) ! !! ,*$ . ! . !! ,*$ ! - 19 -
)
! " !! #
$ % &! &! '$)
+% *! *!$'
! (,*$' &! &! '$)
! " $ / *$$ $ !#
! '("-#
$-- ! ! ) ! !! (-*$ .
- 20 -
! . !! (-*$ ! ! +
+ 0 %
"! +0 %
#
1232 4566273 572 65829:; <=7 1257>9? 59@ 595A=?=:3@>3;=35A
1232 ;26>6>=93 ;:6 >9 B:236>=9 612 >4;:?92@ =7@273 @562@ ) ;5332@ >9 ;;A>C56>=9 =3,*$ $'*$ (*$- ''*$ *$ )'*$$*$)*$$*$*$)*$ )*$ (*$ $)*$ ,*$ 59@ (-*$ DE 612 57956585 5B< 7>D:95A 5A5D:7?> F1272>95<627 72<2772@ 6= 53 G612 7>D:95A. <=7 D72H>6EI :;=9 612 5;;A>C56>=93 <>A2@ DE 612 ;26>6>=9273 9B:>7E <<>C27 59@ 1>2< J2C:6>H2 <<>C27 57956585 6562 =57@ =< :B5< = 57:A :B5<
:99>9?154 =5@ 59?5A=72 >9
- 21 -
<:7612759C26=612;7=H>3>=93=<2C6>=9)")#=<6125B< C6 $-- F1272>95<627 72<2772@ 6= 53 G612 C6 $--. <=7 D72H>6EI;=93:C15;;A>C56>=936127>D:95A153<7542@ 53459E53$B:236>=9353<=:9@56;5?2=6=-=<612 =7@273 ( !27:35A=<61235>@B:236>=93K=:A@>9@>C562612 7>D:95A 153 65829 :;=9 >632A< 612 >33:23 K>61 72?57@ 6= L:7>3@>C6>=9;=K2759@5:61=7>6E=<6129B:>7E<<>C2759@ 1>2< J2C:6>H2 <<>C27 =< 612 57956585 6562 =57@ =< :B5<6=>9>6>562;7=C22@>9?3:9@272C6>=9)=<6125B< C6 $-- 59@ 153 C=42 6= 612 C=9CA:3>=9 6156 5 C=4;721293>H2 3:>6 <=7 @2CA5756>=9 59@ <=7 C=932B:296>5A 72A>2<=<72C=H27E;=33233>=9>3612=9AE7242@E5H5>A5DA2 6= 612 57956585 6562 =57@ =< :B5< 59@ 153 5CC=7@>9?AE 72L2C62@ 61232 5;;A>C56>=93 1=A@>9? 612 ;26>6>=927
1>2< J2C:6>H2 <<>C27 153 9= L:7>3@>C6>=9 6= >9H=822C6>=9)=<6125B<C6$-- ) 7>!5AA>!56>AA25792@C=:932A5;;257>9?<=7 612;26>6>=92733:D4>6361563:C1=7@27315H2D229;5332@
- 22 -
DE 612 67>D:95A 2H29 K>61=:6 >33:>9? 9=6>C23 6= 612 723;=9@2963 9542@ 61272>9 2 3:D4>63 3>4>A57 B:236>=9 <2AA <=7 C=93>@2756>=9 D2<=72 61>3
=:76 >9 +,+- .,+/+0 .1+1+0
" (
K1272>9 612
==7@>9562 29C1 =< 61>3
=:76 5@H276>9? 6= 612 ;7=H>3>=9 =< 2C6>=9 ) =< 612 5B< C6 $-- 153 12A@ 6156
1>2< J2C:6>H2 <<>C27 M :B5< =57@ >3 C=4;26296 6= >9>6>562 5C6>=9 <=7 724=H5A =< 29C7=5C14296 >9 723;2C6 6= 5B< ;7=;276E >9 2J27C>32 =< >63 ;=K27 :9@27 2C6>=9 ) =< 612 5B< C6 $--59@533:C16127>D:95AK53>9277=7>9;533>9?612 >4;:?92@=7@27359@5CC=7@>9?AE15@32653>@2612=7@27 ;5332@DE6127>D:95A
2<277>9?
6= 612 35>@ =7@27 A25792@ C=:932A 7> !5A> !56>A 3:D4>63 61563>9C2612 >33:2 >39= 4=72 612=7@273>4;:?92@>961232;26>6>=93D2326 53>@2 59@ 456627 6= D2 724>662@ 6= 612 7>D:95A K>61 5 @>72C6>=96=;7=C22@>95CC=7@59C2K>61A5K
>9C2 612 >33:2 75>32@ >9 61232 ;26>6>=93 153 5A725@E D229 593K272@ DE 612
==7@>9562 29C1 =< 61>3
- 23 -
=:76 >9 >63 =7@27 @562@ *
;5332@ >9 +,+- .,+/+0 .1+1+0
"(
53 9=62@ 5D=H2 61>3
=:76@=9=632259E7253=96=@><<27<7=46123542 , 96156H>2K=<612456627612>4;:?92@=7@273 @562@ ) ;5332@ >9 ;;A>C56>=9 =3,*$ $'*$(*$-''*$*$)'*$$*$ )*$$*$*$)*$)*$(*$ $)*$ ,*$ 59@ (-*$ DE 612 57956585 5B< 7>D:95A 5A5D:75?> 572 32653>@2 59@ 612 4566273 572 724>662@ 6= 612 7>D:95A K1>C1 315AA 5<627 >33:>9? 612 9=6>C2 59@ 5<<=7@>9? =;;=76:9>6E 6= 612 723;=9@2963 61272>9;7=C22@<:76127>95CC=7@59C2K>61A5K ' N
>H>A72H>3>=9;26>6>=93572 - AAC=96296>=93:7?2@59@6=D2:7?2@57282;6 =;296=D2C=93>@272@DE6127>D:95A !2( 3%!%4 ' *>36=+A=+$ +! N
=772C62@H>@2C154D27=7@27@562@$,$