Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66369 (KAR)
SANTOSH v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201505/2025 · 2025-10-29
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66369 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66369 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$##
#
%&%'()&*%(( +
! !"#$#%&'! ( )! *
!#$#%&' !!!! * ! ( !! * % * !!! %$*
!!!#&++&+#* * ! ) * ** '&'+$+%*+&+ * !#+&+# ! *
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
, !)
, !)
-./012345.61.23234537839.6:;2-.749.0//<7.6<56.= ./2345 %$ 48 -0=023;0 0>0=3? <=0?7-0 05-320 +&+ 7..?35> -37 =.9.07. 45 =.><90= :039 35 !!4!#&++&+# 1.5635>452-.839.48663234509372=3/2056.773457)<6>. 360=732235>02070@0?09;0584=2-.488.5/.71<537-0:9.<56.= ./23457 '&' +$ +% 48 -0=023;0 ;0;0 05-320 +&+! +! *0/2735:=3.80=.0784994A7 -.1=47./<2345 /07. 35 :=3.8 37 2-02 45. 7B0 .><B 946>.60/4B190352099.>35>2-02-.=7372.=.7-B0.><B05 <5B0==3.6A4B05A4=?35>070CD=4<1.B194;..352-.32;
<53/3109 4<5/39 070@0?09;05 A07 84<56 6.06 35 -.= =.736.5/. 45 &!&!+&+#! //4=635> 24 2-. /4B19035052 =.1.02.6 1-45. /0997 B06. 24 2-.3= :.6=366.5 B42-.= A.52 <5057A.=.6 A-3/- =037.6 7<713/345 056 1=4B12.6 2-. /4B190350520560542-.=7372.=:42-=.73635>35070@0?09;05 24 =.E<.72 0 5.3>-:4<= 24 @3732 2-. -4<7. 056 07/.=2035 2-.3=
- 3 -
A.99:.35>!2378<=2-.=099.>.62-02A-.52-.5.3>-:4<=A.52 24 2-. -4<7. 056 0945> A32- 2-. B42-.= .52.=.6 2-. 6./.07.6D7=44B2-.;84<56.7-B0.><B9;35>6.06A32- 93>02<=.B0=?70=4<56-.=5./?!52-.:0737482-37/4B190352 0/07./0B.24:.=.>372.=.684=2-.488.5/.1<537-0:9.<56.= ./2345 '&' 48 2-. -0=023;0 ;0;0 05-320 +&+ /4==.7145635>24./2345&+482-.!<=35>2-./4<=7.48 35@.723>02345 2-. 1=.7.52 1.232345.= A07 0==.72.6 45 &'!&%!+&+# 056 -07 735/. :..5 35 F<63/309 /<7246;! -. 35@.723>02345 37 54A /4B19.2.6 056 0 /-0=>. 7-..2 -07 :..5 839.6! ! .0=5.6 /4<57.9 84= 2-. 1.232345.= =.32.=0235> 2-. 0@.=B.527B06.352-.1.232345/452.5672-022-.1.232345.=37 3554/.52 056 -07 54 5.G<7 A32- 2-. 099.>.6 488.5/.! 2 37 7<:B322.6 2-02 2-. .523=. 1=47./<2345 /07. 37 :07.6 45 /3=/<B72052309 .@36.5/. 2-.=. :.35> 54 .;.A325.77.7 24 2-. 4//<==.5/.! -. 099.>.6 /458.7734509 7202.B.52 022=3:<2.6 24 2-.1.232345.=6<=35>/<7246;373506B3773:9.3590A:.35>-32:;
./23457+#056+H482-.56305@36.5/./2'$I+! .0=5.6 /4<57.98<=2-.=1435274<22-022-.1=47./<2345D7=.9305/.452-. - 4 -
7202.B.527 48
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
2-374<=2352-..@.5248-37=.9.07.45:039! %! 45@.=7.9; 2-. 9.0=5.6 3>- 4<=2 4@.=5B.52 9.06.= 41147.7 2-. 1.232345 /452.5635> 2-02 2-. B02.=3097 /499./2.6 6<=35> 35@.723>02345 1=3B0 80/3. 3563/02. 2-. 1.232345.=D7 35@49@.B.52 35 2-. 488.5/.! 2 37 7<:B322.6 2-02 84420>. 7./<=.6 8=4B @0=34<7 94/023457 35/9<635> 5.0= 3@.?050560/-449056906350*<=532<=.-41190/.72-. - 5 -
1.232345.=352-.@3/3532;482-.6./.07.6D7-4<7.022-.=.9.@052 23B.!*<=2-.=2-.=./4@.=;480B4:39./-0=>35>A3=.099.>.69;
:07.6 45 2-. @49<520=; 7202.B.52 48 2-. 1.232345.= 9.567 /4==4:4=02345 24 2-. 1=47./<2345 @.=7345! -. 9.0=5.6 7<:B3272-02-0@35>=.>0=6242-.>=0@32;482-.488.5/.382-. 1.232345.= 37 .590=>.6 45 :039 2-.=. 37 0 93?.93-446 48 -37 20B1.=35>A32-1=47./<2345A325.77.73589<.5/35>2-./4<=7.48 2=30905689..35>8=4BF<723/.! #! 0@35> >3@.5 2-4<>-28<9 /45736.=02345 24 2-.
=3@09 7<:B3773457 056 <145 1.=<709 48 2-. =./4=67 2-. 84994A35> 143520=37.784=6.2.=B3502345
H! 2 37 542 35 6371<2. 2-02 2-. 35@.723>02345 37 /4B19.2.60562-./-0=>.7-..2-07:..5839.6!-.1.232345.= -07:..535/<7246;84=5.0=9;73GB452-7!-..523=./07.48 2-. 1=47./<2345 =.727 45 /3=/<B72052309 .@36.5/. 056 2-. @.=0/32; 48 .0/- /3=/<B7205/. /05 :. 2.72.6 459; 6<=35> 2-. /4<=7.482=309!237A.997.229.62-02022-.720>.48/45736.=35>
- 6 -
:0392-.4<=237542=.E<3=.624.G0B35.2-.1=4:023@.@09<.48 2-. B02.=3097 /499./2.6 :; 2-. 1=47./<2345! -. 2.72 24 :. 01193.6 37 542 2-02 48 1=448 48 ><392 :<2 A-.2-.= 2-.=. .G372 =.07450:9.>=4<56724:.93.@.2-022-.0//<7.63754293?.9;24 0:7/4564=20B1.=A32-.@36.5/.38=.9.07.645:039! I! 2 37 .E<099; 7.229.6 2-02 1=.2=309 6.2.52345 /05542 :.1<5323@.0562-02.@.=;0//<7.6371=.7<B.63554/.52<5239 1=4@.5><392;!-.099.>.6=./4@.=;482-.B4:39./-0=>.A3=. :.35> :07.6 45 0 @49<520=; 7202.B.52 056 2-. 1=47./<2345 327.9806B32235>2-022-./07.=.72745/3=/<B72052309.@36.5/. 2-..@36.5230=;A4=2-487</-B02.=309370B022.=84=2=309!-. /452.52345 48 2-. 6.8.5/. 2-02 2-.=. .G3727 0 637/=.105/; :.2A..52-.1472B4=2.B835635>70562-.099.>.6J90727..5K @.=7345482-.A325.77.7=037.706.:020:9.80/2<09377<.A-3/- /05542:./45/9<73@.9;06F<63/02.6022-.:039720>.! $! 5 2-. :0/?>=4<56 48 2-. 084=.7036 80/27 056 2-. 7.229.6147323454890A323724:.:4=5.35B3562-022-.>=0@32; 48 2-. 488.5/. 2-4<>- 0 =.9.@052 80/24= /05542 :; 327.98 41.=02. 07 0 :0= 24 >=052 48 :039! 2 37 .E<099; 2=32. 2-02 011=.-.57345482-.1=47./<23452-022-.0//<7.6B0;20B1.=
- 7 -
A32- A325.77.7 4= 89.. 8=4B F<723/. B<72 :. :07.6 45 /4>.52 B02.=309 056 542 45 B.=. 71./<902345! 4A 2-02 2-. 35@.723>02345 -07 /<9B3502.6 35 0 /-0=>. 7-..2 056 2-. 1.232345.= -07 =.B035.6 35 /<7246; 84= 0 /45736.=0:9. 1.=346 /45235<.635/0=/.=02345A4<967.=@.548<=2-.=1<=147.! ! -. 1.232345.= 37 0 >4@.=5B.52 7.=@052 B0==3.6 056 -07 84<= B354= 60<>-2.=7 6.1.56.52 45 -3B! -. 1=47./<2345 -07 542 099.>.6 05; 1=34= /=3B3509 052./.6.527! .0=35>35B3562-.8<560B.52091=35/319.2-02:039372-.=<9. 056F0393705.G/.123450562-022-.4:F./248:03937247./<=. 2-.1=.7.5/.482-.0//<7.66<=35>2=309=02-.=2-05241<537- :.84=./45@3/23452-374<=237482-. @3.A2-022-.1.232345.= /05:..590=>.645:039:;3B14735>72=35>.52056011=41=302. /456323457! </- /456323457 A4<96 06.E<02.9; 708.><0=6 2-. 352.=.72482-.1=47./<2345056.57<=.2-022-./4<=7.48F<723/. 375421=.F<63/.6! '&! *4=2-.84=.>435>=.0745705635@3.A482-.7.229.6 1=35/319.7>4@.=535>>=05248:03950B.9;2-02:039372-.=<9. 056 F039 37 05 .G/.12345 2-02 1=.7<B12345 48 3554/.5/. /45235<.7 2399 ><392 37 .720:937-.6 056 2-02 1=.2=309 6.2.52345
- 8 -
/05542:.1<5323@.45/.35@.723>0234537/4B19.2.2-374<=237 48 2-. /45736.=.6 4135345 2-02 8<=2-.= 35/0=/.=02345 48 2-. 1.232345.=37542A0==052.6!-.1<=147.48:039:.35>247./<=. 2-. 1=.7.5/. 48 2-. 0//<7.6 6<=35> 2=309 2-. 70B. /05 :. 7<883/3.529;.57<=.6:;3B14735>72=35>.52/456323457! //4=635>9;2-.1.2323457205670994A.6! -. 1.232345.=0//<7.6 7-099 :. .590=>.6 45 :039 35 !!4!#&++&+# 1.5635> 45 2-. 839. 48 2-. 663234509 372=3/2056.773457)<6>.360=732235>02070@0?09;0584= 2-. 488.5/.7 1<537-0:9. <56.= ./23457 '&' +$ 056 +% 48 2-. -0=023;0 ;0;0 05-320 +&+ 7<:F./2 24 2-. 84994A35>/456323457
3-.1.232345.=7-099.G./<2.01.=74509:45684=0 7<B 48 7!'&&&&& <1..7 5. 0?- 459; A32- 2A4 7<=.23.7 84= 2-. 93?.
7<B 24 2-. 7023780/2345 48 2-.=3094<=2L
33 -. 1.232345.= 7-099 542 20B1.= A32- 2-. 1=47./<2345A325.77.74=.@36.5/..32-.=63=./29;4= 3563=./29;L
- 9 -
333-.1.232345.=7-099011.0=:.84=.2-.=3094<=2 =.><90=9;45099602.748-.0=35><59.77.G.B12.6:; 2-.70364<=284=@09360567<883/3.52=.07457L
3@ -. 1.232345.= 7-099 542 9.0@. 2-. F<=3763/2345 48 2-. =309 4<=2 A32-4<2 4:203535> 1=34= 1.=B377345 <523963714709482-./07.L
@-.1.232345.=7-0998<=537--37/<==.52=.736.52309 066=.77 056 /4520/2 5<B:.= 24 2-. 5@.723>0235> 883/.=0567-099542/-05>.2-.70B.A32-4<21=34= 3523B02345L
@352-..@.5248:=.0/-4805;482-.7./456323457 2-. 1=47./<2345 7-099 :. 02 93:.=2; 24 7..? /05/.990234548:039350//4=605/.A32-90A! ,) %##( $
3724!'94!'