- 1 - !"# $#% # # & ' ! "!!##" $ % &' ( ! )###! ' ' ! #" Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & '*)! $ % ' ! ( & ) (& & + )"+#!#" # ## , ' -( & & + )"+#!#" ) #)## , & . ' % . ' ( /010232345063781639820:3;320<=4;185>05?8?0< 35 2/0 @A735077 4B 7A11:> ;8=/3506307 B46 35<A72630707145<0524 441068239074=302>05?8?0< 2/070693=074B2/01023234506C4;185>B462/01A61470 - 3 - 4B0D18573454B3277A?861:85235206;74B858?600;052 <820< "#E#!* /0 783< 8?600;052 F87 052060< 3524 1A67A852 24 205<06 164=077 35323820< @> 607145<0524 4410682390 74=302> /060 F87 =062835 <0:8> 35 =4;1:02345 4B 2/0 0D1857345 164G0=2 1A614620<:> 45 8==4A52 4B <0:8>0< 18>;052 @> 607145<052 4 4 41086239074=302>&/3:02/01023234506F87352/0164=077 4B 700H35? 60<60778: 4B 327 ?630985=0 8?83572 607145<052 4 32 60=0390< 8 5423=0 B64; 607145<052 4 C '4352 0?3726864B44106823904=302307A5<060=2345)"4B2/0 865828H8 4410682390 4=302307 =2 ! I/060358B206 60B0660< 24 87 J2/0 =2 !K B46 @60932>L 45 2/0 160;370 4B 607145<052 4 4410682390 74=302> 7A7283535? B3585=38: :47707 45 450 4B 2/0 6087457 @035? 0D1857345 4B F46H 542 /8935? @005 =4;1:020< @> 2/0 1023234506F32/352/07231A:820<10634< /0 :08650< 05346 =4A570: 81108635? B46 2/0 1023234506 28H35? 2/37 4A62 2/64A?/ 2/0 60=46<7 85< 8:74 2/016493734574B0=2345)"4B2/0=2!7A@;327 - 4 - 2/0205464B2/05423=07164<A=0<35550DA60785< 24 2/0F6321023234585<2/02/60821470<2/0603581862B64; @035?3::0?8:85<A57A728358@:08:74F32/4A285>8A2/4632> 4B :8F 0 7A@;327 2/82 35 2/0 783< 5423=0 164<A=0< 82 550DA60 2/0 607145<052 4'4352 0?372686 4B 4 41068239074=302>3735205<35?2405MA36035242/08BB83674B 2/0 1023234506 C 4;185> 2/4A?/ F32/ 60B0605=0 24 2/0 =45268=22/8232/87052060<3524F32/607145<0524 4 410862390 74=302> /82 35 BA62/0685=0 24 5423=0 82 550DA60 =8::35? A145 2/0 1023234506 24 18623=31820 35 2/0 1A614620< 05MA36> 32 37 2/6082050< 2/82 3B 2/0 1023234506 <3< 542 =44106820 85< B83:0< 24 7A@;32 327 0D1:8582345 1023234506 F4A:< @0 ;8<0 :38@:0 B46 2/0 B3585=38: :47707 85< 2/0 78;0 F4A:< @0 60=49060< 35 8==46<85=0F32/:8F02/A77A@;3272/0603754164937345 A5<06 2/0 4410682390 4=302307 =2 ;A=/ :077 A5<06 1649373457 4B 0=2345 )" 4B 2/0 =2 ! 058@:35? 607145<052 4'4352 0?372686 24 377A0 7A=/ 5423=07 35205<35? 24 B3D 2/0 :38@3:32> 45 2/0 1023234506 C4;185> - 5 - F/3=/378535<0105<05205232>0D=012/8935?268578=2345 35 206;7 4B 2/0 8?600;052 052060< 3524 F32/ 607145<052 4 C 4=302> /A7 /0 7A@;327 2/82 2/0 7=410 85< 1A61462 4B 2/0 5423=07 377A0< 0D=00<7 2/0 4@G0=2 =4520;1:820<A5<060=2345)"% (%@(4B2/0=2! F86685235?35206B0605=0822/0/85<74B2/374A62 08650< <<323458: 49065;052 <94=820 7A@;327 2/82 2/4A?/ 2/0 :85?A8?0 811:30< 35 5423=07 82 550DA607JK85<J K35<3=8201023234506C4;185>@035? 7A@G0=20<242/005MA36>2/01A614704B377A85=04B783< 5423=07 37 45:> 7A;;4535? 2/0 1023234506 C 4;185> 24 18623=31820 35 2/0 05MA36> @> BA6537/35? 2/0 <0283:7 85< 42/06 35B46;82345 106283535? 24 2/0 268578=2345 F/3=/ 2/0 1023234506 4;185> /87 /8< F32/ 2/0 607145<052 4 4410682390 74=302> 0 7A@;327 2/82 2/0 5423=07 82 550DA607 JK 85< J K 7/8:: @0 608< 45:> 24 2/0 :3;320< 0D20524B=8::35?A1452/01023234506C4;185>24811086 352/005MA36>B462/01A614704B164<A=23454B60=46<785< BA6537/35?35B46;82345106283535?242/0268578=2345F/3=/ - 6 - 32 /8< 052060< 3524 F32/ 607145<052 4 44108628390 4=302>85<542/35?;46005=0/07A@;3272/822/06037 5460MA360;0524B85>35206B0605=0352/0;82206 " 086<06A70<2/060=46<7 <;3220<:> 2/0 1023234506C4;185> /87 052060< 3524 85 8?600;052 <820< "#E#!* F32/ 607145<052 4 4=032> B46 2/0 1A61470 4B 0D1857345 4B 3277A?861:852/070693=07A5<0628H0524@0605<060<@> 2/0 10232345064;185> F87 BA6537/35? 2/0 <073?57 ;85AB8=2A60 7A11:> 85< 26857146282345 4B ;8=/3506> B46 2/0 1A61470 4B 0D1857345 4B 2/0 7A?86 1:852 B64; ### 24!#### 0D185<8@:024!## 164G0=245 @8737 /060 8110867 24 /890 @005 =062835 <371A207 86470 @02F005 2/0 10232345064;185> 85< 607145<052 4 4=302> 35 106B46;85=0 4B 2/0 206;7 4B 2/0 783< 8?600;052 ) 5 2/0 =36=A;7285=07 607145<052 4 '4352 0?372686350D06=3704B/3714F06A5<060=2345)"4B2/0 - 7 - =2!/87B4A5<3281164163820243532382005MA36> 4F0906352/0164=077607145<0524'43520?372686 /87 377A0< 2/0 05MA36> 5423=0 87 106 550DA60 /0 377A074A?/224@08<<60770<352/0783<5423=0106283535? 241023234506C4;185>3787B4::4F7 ! "# ! "! # !!! ! !! $ %! ! & ' ())* + ! ! !! !! ,+! + , -)+. , ! - 8 - * / 0 & & 1 ! ) *! 23 E 550DA60 378542/065423=04B05MA36>377A0< A5<060=23457)"% (%8(N%@(4B2/0=2!85< A:0 4B 2/0 865828H8 4410682390 4=302307 A:07 !)#I/060358B20660B0660<2487J2/0A:07!)#KB46 @60932>L/0783<5423=0608<787A5<06 4 5 / 6 7! 8 ( 5 )& ' 94! % : &! - ( / 6 .,. ! &! # ; #;"#",! :# ; #;"#",% 0 ( ! : &! # ; #;"#", 1; #;"#", "5 #-;#.;"#",! !&! 1< #<"#", "5: - 9 - ! ! )! !! !! ( / 6 .,. + .-# ! ! ! )!$#<#.<"#",3 * /A78106A78:4B2/08B460783<377A077A@G0=2 ;82206 4B 550DA60 85< 2/0 20546 4B 2/0 5423=0 82 550DA60 87 0D268=20< 8@490 F4A:< 35<3=820 2/82 2/0 607145<052 4 '4352 0?372686 A5<06 2/0 ?86@ 4B 0D06=370 4B /37 14F06 A5<06 0=2345 )" 4B 2/0 =2 ! 37 35205<35? 24 05MA360 3524 2/0 8BB8367 4B 2/0 1023234506 4;185> 85</87 BA62/06 <0=:860< 2/82 35 2/0 090524BB83:A60452/018624B2/010232345062481108685< 7A@;322/0601:3072/060714573@3:32>F4A:<@0B3D0<452/0 10232345064;185> 0=2345 )" 4B 2/0 =2 ! 16493<35?B4605MA36>@>2/00?372686608<787A5<06 $" % ## & <= )+! !!> !!&!! - 10 - < ! ="&!< = < =<!! ? =4! !? 2< ! ="< &! < = ! !!+ @A@ B* 6 0 ! + &! ! @ =$ ) + > ! < = &! !< = !!! ! ! ! ! - 11 - & ! !? =2&!C!! ! !!! ! ! ! ! ! ! !! & ! 2&!C!& &!? = = ! ! !< ! ! & ! & ! ! !! ! ? =!= !<! !!< & ! = D &! +!&! &! ! - 12 - <!! ! ' /< = <C&! &! + ! ! ! A * ! < ! &!@ =,2&!< = ! ! ! !< ! &! &! + &!! ! +!)+ ! ! < ! ! 3 =E 0=2345 )" % (%@( 4B 2/0 =2 ! 87 0D268=20< 8@490 ;8H07 32 =:086 2/82 2/0 05MA36> =4520;1:820<A5<060=2345)"@>2/00?37268646@>85> 1067458A2/463O0<@>/3;37F32/60B0605=024=457232A2345 - 13 - F46H35? 85< B3585=38: =45<32345 4B 8 =4410682390 74=302> 85<B462/371A614702/005MA36>4BB3=06;8>7A;;4585> 4BB3=064B2/0B3585=38:@85H46=60<328?05=>872/0=870 ;8> @0 46 85> 106745 /8935? 85> H35< 4B @A735077 60:823457/31 F32/ 2/0 74=302> 46 85> 106745 F/4 37 =4550=20<F32/2/0BA5=234535?4B85<F/4/87H54F:0<?0 8@4A2 2/0 8BB8367 4B 74=302> 24 BA6537/ 46 24 164<A=0 85> 60=46<746<4=A;052760:820<242/0268578=2345F32/85< F46H35? 4B 2/0 74=302> 85< BA6537/ 35B46;82345 85< 0D1:8582345 82 2/0 60?372060< 4BB3=0 46 2/0 @685=/ 4B 2/0 74=302>4682 85>1A@:3= 4BB3=082 2/0 /08<MA862067 4B 2/0 74=302> 87 5MA36> BB3=06 ;8> 60MA360 B46 2/0 1A61470 4B 35MA36> !# /08B460783<16493734574B0=2345)"% (%@(4B 2/0=2!=85542@00D185<0<24/4:<35MA36>3524 2/08BB83674B05232>:3H01023234506C4;185>F/4/87/8< @A735077 268578=2345 F32/ 607145<052 4 4=032> 35 MA072345 85< 32 8:74 <407 542 =4520;1:820 B3D35? 85> :38@3:32> 45 7A=/ 05232> 7 63?/2:> 143520< 4A2 @> :08650< - 14 - 05346 4A570: 7A=/ 8 =4A670 4B 8=2345 B8::7 B4A: 4B 2/0 1649373457 4B 0=2345 )" 4B 2/0 =2 ! /0 3;1A?50< 5423=0 550DA607 85< 24 2/0 0D2052 0D268=20< /060358@490 2/060B460 A57A728358@:0 85< 860 :38@:024@0MA87/0<==46<35?:>2/0B4::4F35? %3( /0&632023234537 %33( /0 3;1A?50< 5423=0 <820< ### 164<A=0<82550DA60 37MA87/0< %333( /0 3;1A?50< 5423=0 <820< #)## 82 550DA60 24 2/0 0D2052 4B 377A0 %( 0D268=20</060358@4907285<7MA87/0< %39( 42F32/7285<35? 2/0 8@490 46<06 2/0 607145<052 4C'4352 0?372686 4B 4 410682390 4=302307 37 82 :3@062> 24 377A0 7A;;457242/010232345064;185>7263=2:> 35=4;1:385=0F32/2/016493734574B0=2345 - 15 - )" 4B 2/0 =2 ! 05=817A:820< /060358@490 () &# #' % & 3724!:4E