Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66360 (KAR)
ABUJ ISHWARI SANJAY AND ORS v. THE UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
WP/201721/2024 · 2025-12-08
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66360 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66360 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%#& # #
'() *
'()
+
'()
*
!"#"
!$%#
!"#"
!$%&
'
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"#"
!$%"
%
!"#"
!$%$
! !"#"
!$! #
!"#"
!$! &
!"#"
!$! - 3 -
"
!"#"
!$!'
$
!"#"
!$!%
!"#"
!$!! !"#"
!$!#
!"#"
!$!&
- 4 -
'
!"#" !$!"
% (
!"#"
!$!$
! !"#"
!$#
#
!"#"
!$#
&
!"#"
!$#
- 5 -
"
!"#"
!$#'
$
!"#"
!$#%
!"#"
!$#! !"#"
!$##
!"#"
!$#&
- 6 -
'
!"#"
!$#"
%
!"#"
!$#$
! !"#"
!$&
#
!"#"
!$&
&
!"#"
!$&
- 7 -
"
!"#"
!$&'
$
!"#"
!$&%
'
!"#" !$&! '
!"#"
!$&#
'
!"#"
!$&&
- 8 -
''
!"#"
!$&"
'%
!"#"
!$&$
'! !"#"
!$"
'#
!"#"
!$"
'&
!"#"
!$"'
- 9 -
'"
!"#"
!$"%
'$
!"#"
!$"! %
)
))
!"#"
%
!"#"
* + ,
)
)
,
)
) )
)
- 10 -
)
) +
,# #! !"
'
)
%
!#
% (
"
-!# (
*
+ )
. ). )',
)
# )
)
, )
'+ ,
)
)
/012'32
%04 (
)
)
)
) ( )
+
,
) . ,
5
) )
) . ,
) )
- 11 -
)
) 6
*
)
!"#"
"%'
!"#"
"%'
'
!"#"
"%'%
%
!"#"
- 12 -
"%'#
! !"#"
"%'
#
!"#"
"%''
&
!"#"
"%''
"
!"#"
"%'"
$
- 13 -
!"#"
"%'
!"#"
"%''
!"#"
"%'! !"#"
"%''
'
!"#"
- 14 -
"%''
%
!"#"
"%'''
! )
!"#"
"%''%
#
!"#"
"%''&
&
!"#"
"%''"
"
)
))
- 15 -
!"#"
$
!"#"
+ ,
)
)
+ ,
)
) )
)
)
) +
, # #! !"
'
)
% !#
% (
"
!# (
- 16 -
+
). ). )'. )%,
)
#)
)
, )
' + ,
)
) '
% (
)
)
)
) ( )
+
,
) . ,
5
) )
" $ ) . ,
) ) )
) 6
+*
70
!"#"
$!''
- 17 -
70
!"#"
$!''
'
70
!"#"
$!'''
%
70
!"#"
$!''%
! 70
!"#"
$!''!
#
70
!"#"
- 18 -
$!''#
&
70
!"#"
$!''&
"
70
!"#"
$!''"
$
70
!"#"
$!''$
70
!"#"
$!'%
- 19 -
70
!"#" $!'%
5
70
!"#"
$!'%
'
70
!"#"
$!'%'
%
70
!"#"
$!'%%
! 70
!"#"
$!'%! - 20 -
#
70
!"#"
$!'%#
&
70
!"#"
$!'%&
"
70
!"#"
$!'%"
$
5
70
!"#"
$!'%$
70
- 21 -
!"#"
$!'! 70
!"#"
$!'! 70
!"#"
$!'! '
70
!"#"
$!'!'
%
70
!"#"
$!'!%
- 22 -
! 70
!"#"
$!'!! #
70
!"#"
$!'!#
&
70
!"#"
$!'!&
"
70
!"#"
$!'!"
$
70
- 23 -
!"#"
$!'!$
'
70
!"#"
$!'#
'
70
!"#"
$!'#
'
70
!"#"
$!'#
''
70
!"#"
$!'#'
- 24 -
'%
70
!"#"
$!'#%
'! 70
!"#"
$!'#! '#
70
!"#"
$!'##
'&
70
!"#"
$!'#&
'"
70
- 25 -
!"#"
$!'#"
'$
70
!"#"
$!'#$
%
70
!"#"
$!'&
%
)
))
%
+ ,
- 26 -
)
)
+ , )
)) )
)
) +
, # #! !"
'
)
%
-!#
% (
"
(
+
). ). )'. )%,
)
#)
)
, )
' + ,
)
)
- 27 -
'
% (
)
)
)
) ( )
+
,
) . ,
5
)
) $ ) .,
)
)
)
)
6
)
8
9
4: ;:0<0<=1:3/ <1
=/& & 712 &'=>%/::?<1@04:>=AA=B<1@3:A<:>/
!"
" # $
% % %
& ' %%
"' ($ )* ! +,
%-
- 28 -
% . &
(/ 0!1)0!2" 0!2)00 00)0!" 3
"
4 % +
4:7>=3:/7<23:A<:>/73:/=C@40=104:;3:D</:
0470 04: ;:0<0<=1:3/ 4:3:<1 D=3: ;730<ECA73AF ;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 17D:AF 7AC?7 4<?/4717 37/737?
4747?737 7127A< 71 FC3G:2<E :2<E7A =AA:@: 712 =/;<07A B7/ <//C:2 B<04 7 1=0<E: HF 3:/;=12:10
= /::?<1@ E=D;A<71E: => 04: ;3=G</<=1/ => 12<71 :2<E<1: :1037A =C1E<A +:3D<//<=1 0= I</0<1@ :2<E7A =AA:@:/, :@CA70<=1/ # ;=<10<1@ =C0 E:307<1 2:><E<:1E<:/ <1 04:
<1>37/03CE0C3: 712 04: >7ECA0F 3:JC<3:D:10 7/ D71270:2 04:3:C12:32:1F<1@04:;:3D<//<=10=72D<004:/0C2:10/ >=3 04: 7E72:D<E F:73 " $ $ 712 3:/;:E0<G:AF ' :<1@ 7@@3<:G:2 04: ;:0<0<=1:3/ 472 7;;3=7E4:2 04</ =C30 HF ><A<1@ 04: ;:0<0<=1/ <1
- 29 -
=&'$ ='!# !&$ 712 =%&$% $!"3:/;:E0<G:AF4</=C30HF=32:3 270:2"#;7//:2<1
=&'$71204: =32:3 270:2 &# ;7//:2 <1
='!#$ 712 <1
=%&$%" 472 2<3:E0:2 04: ;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 0= E=1/<2:3 04: =32:3 ;7//:2 HF 3:/;=12:10 = 270:2 &$" !' 712 &$ 3:/;:E0<G:AF7//4=BE7C/:1=0<E:/7124722<3:E0:204:D 0=E=D;AFB<047AA04:2:>:E0//4=30E=D<1@/;=<10:2=C0HF 3:/;=12:10
=3:@732<1@<1>37/03CE0C3:71204:3:7>0:30= ><A: 1:E://73F 7;;A<E70<=13:;3:/:1070<=1 H:>=3:
3:/;=12:10
= >=3 3:E=1/<2:370<=1 => <0/ 2:E</<=1/ <D;C@1:2<104:/7<2B3<0;:0<0<=1/0>C304:32<3:E0:20470 C;=1 ><A<1@ => 04: /CE4 3:;3:/:1070<=1/ HF 04: ;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=13:/;=12:10
=/7120=E=1/<2:304:/7D: <17EE=3271E:B<04A7B:I;:2<0<=C/AFB<04<171=C0:3A<D<0 =>0B=D=104/>3=D04:270:=>04:=32:3 % 4: /7<2 =32:3 7A/= 2<3:E0:2 04: 3:/CA0/ => /0C2:10/B4=4727;;:73:2<1712 E=C3/:/
- 30 -
3:/;:E0<G:AF H: 711=C1E:2 712 B:3: 7A/= 2<3:E0:2 0= ;:3D<004:D0=7;;:73<104::1/C<1@:I7D<170<=1/ ! A:73AF H7/:2 =1 04: /7<2 <10:3<D =32:3 04:
/0C2:10/ B4= 73: 72D<00:2 0= 04: 7E72:D<E F:73 " $ $ 712 B4=73:04: ;730<:/<1 04:/: 043:: B3<0 ;:0<0<=1/ 47G: ;C3/C:2 712 E=10<1C:2 04:<3/0C2<:/ # 4:@3<:G71E:=>04:;:0<0<=1:3/</04702:/;<0:
04:=32:3HF04</=C307/1=0:27H=G:3:/;=12:10
=/ 712 47G: 1=0 E=1/<2:3:2 04: 3:;3:/:1070<=1 0<AA 270:
4:3:>=3: 04:F B:3: E=1/037<1:2 0= ><A: 04: ;3:/:10 B3<0 ;:0<0<=1//::?<1@04:3:A<:>7/1=0:27H=G: & :731:2E=C1/:A=>04:;:0<0<=1:3//CHD<0/0470 1=1 E=1/<2:370<=1 => 04: 3:;3:/:1070<=1 HF 3:/;=12:10 =/71247/E3:70:27/07A:D70:<1B4<E404:/0C2:10/ => 04: H70E4 >=3 04: 7E72:D<E F:73 " $ B4= 47G:
E=D;A:0:2 04:<3 E=C3/: 712 04: /0C2:10/ => 04: H70E4 => $ 712 B4= 73: 7H=C0 0= E=D;A:0:
- 31 -
04:<3 E=C3/:/ B=CA2 H: >7E<1@ :I03:D: 2<>><ECA0 /<0C70<=1 712 4732/4<; 4:3:>=3: 3:/;=12:10
=/ 712 H:
2<3:E0:2 0= E=1/<2:3 04: 3:;3:/:1070<=1 B4<E4 </ 7A3:72F /CHD<00:2 HF 04: ;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1/ <1 0:3D/ => 04:
=32:3 ;7//:2 HF 04</ =C30 270:2 &# 712
"#
" 1 3:/;=1/: A:731:2 E=C1/:A 3< ::;7? 7372 7;;:73<1@ >=3 3:/;=12:10
= 3:>:33<1@ 0= 04:
KC2@D:10 => 04: ;:I =C30 <1 04: E7/: => !
"#3:;=30:2<1'
) D=3: ;730<ECA73AF 0= ;737@37;4
='" /CHD<0/ ;=/0 E=D;A<71E:=>04:3:JC<3:D:10/</=>1=E=1/:JC:1E:/712 /7D: E711=0 47G: 3:03=/;:E0<G: :>>:E0 3:E0<>F<1@ 04:
2:>:E0/ => 04: 3:A:G710 F:73 : /CHD<0/ 04</ H:<1@ 04:
A7B 04: ;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1/ 3:;3:/:1070<=1 E711=0 H: E=1/<2:3:271204:3:/;=1/<H<A<0F>=304:E=1/:JC:1E:/=> 72D<00<1@ 04: /0C2:10/ >=3 04: H70E4 " $ $ 712 /47AA H: 0470 => 04: ;:0<0<=1:3
- 32 -
<1/0<0C0<=1 712 2<3:E0<=1 0= 3:E=1/<2:3 04: =32:3 7A3:72F ;7//:2 B=CA2 H: 71 :I:3E</: <1 >C0<A<0F :1E: 4: /::?/ >=32</D<//7A=>B3<0;:0<0<=1/ $
:7A/=3:A<:/C;=104:=32:3=>04:= =32<170: :1E4=>04:=C30<1+!,,*
712E=11:E0:2 D700:3/ 270:2
+ 0= E=10:12 0470 04: = =32<170: :1E4 => 04</ =C30 47G<1@ 07?:1 <10= E=1/<2:370<=1 04: 3=C0<1: 47H<0/ => 04: D:2<E7A E=AA:@:/ 3C11<1@ B<04=C0 ;:3D<//<=1 712 72D<00<1@ 04: /0C2:10/ 2:/;<0: 1=0<E:/ H:<1@ <//C:2 HF 04: 7C04=3<0<:/ 07?<1@ :IE:;0<=10=04:/7<2;37E0<E:4722</7AA=B:204:3:JC:/0
:/CHD<0/:G:1<104:<1/0710E7/:;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 47G<1@H::1E7AA:2C;=10=E=D;AFB<0404:3:JC<3:D:10=> 04: 3:@CA70<=1 712 2:/;<0: =32:3 47G<1@ H::1 ;7//:2 04=C@4EA7<D:20=47G:E=D;A<:2B<04B=CA21=07;;AF>=3 04: 3:A:G710 7E72:D<E F:73 4:3:>=3: 1= ;C3;=/: </ /:3G:2:G:1<>04:D700:3</3:D<00:2 3< C24<3/<1@4 <K7;C3 /CHD<0/ 0470 /<1E: 04: = =32<170: :1E4 => 04</ =C30 472 HF =32:3
- 33 -
270:2 &# 712 "# 472 2<3:E0:2 >=3 3:E=1/<2:370<=1=>04:D700:371204:;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 EA7<D:2 0= 47G: D72: 7 3:;3:/:1070<=1 7>0:3 47G<1@ E=D;A<:2B<0404:3:JC<3:D:107/2<3:E0:2<0B<AAE=1/<2:3 04: 3:;3:/:1070<=1 712 <> <0 </ >=C12 7EE:;07HA: 7;;3=;3<70:=32:3/B<AAH:;7//:2 3< 4C/73: 712 3< 7/7G737K 704 A:731:2 E=C1/:A 7;;:73<1@ >=3 3:/;=12:10
=/' 712 % 3:/;:E0<G:AF/CHD<0047004:<33=A:B<AAE=D:<10=;A7F=1AF 7>0:3 E=1/<2:370<=1 => 04: 3:;3:/:1070<=1 => 3:/;=12:10 =/ 712 712 04:F B=CA2 E=D;AF B<04 B470:G:3 2<3:E0<=1/73:<//C:2
:732:3C/:204:3:E=32/ ' 4:3:</1=2</;C0:=>04:>7E004703:/;=12:10 = 472 ;=<10:2 =C0 E:307<1 2:><E<:1E<:/ <1 E=D;A<71E:
B<04 04: 3:JC<3:D:10 => 04: 3:@CA70<=1/ B<04 3:/;:E0 0= <1>37/03CE0C3:/ >=3 04: 7E72:D<E F:73/ " $ $
712
B4<E4 472 E=1/037<1:2 04:
- 34 -
;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 0= 7;;3=7E4 04</ =C30 B<04 =&'$ ='!# !&$ 712 =%&$% $!"3:/;:E0<G:AF4</=C30HF=32:3 270:2 &# 712 "# 7/ 1=0:2 7H=G: 472 2<3:E0:2 04: ;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 0= E=D;AF B<04 04:/7<2 2:><E<:1E<:/ 712 0= /CHD<0 04: 3:;3:/:1070<=1 :0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 EA7<D:2 0= 47G: E=D;A<:2 B<04 04: /7<2 3:JC<3:D:10 712 47/ 7A/= D72: 3:;3:/:1070<=1/ 0= 3:/;=12:10
=/ 712 ' 4: 3:;3:/:1070<=1/ 47G: 1=0 H::1E=1/<2:3:20<AA270:
% 4=C@4 A:731:2 E=C1/:A 7;;:73<1@ >=3 3:/;=12:10
=3:>:33:20=04:=32:3=>04:;:I=C30<1 04:E7/:=>
+/C;37, 712 04: =32:3 => 04: = =32<170: :1E4 => 04</ =C30 <1 ='"$$ 712 =04:3 E=11:E0:3 D700:3/ 0= E=10:12047004:3:JC:/0/>=33:E=1/<2:370<=1=>04:D700:3 B=CA2H:71:I:3E</:<1>C0<A<0F<0<//::1047004=C@404:
= =32<170: :1E4 => 04</ =C30 472 07?:1 /:3<=C/ :IE:;0<=1 0= 04: <1/0<0C0<=1/ 3C11<1@ 04: =AA:@:/ 07?<1@
- 35 -
72D<//<=1 E=10373F 0= 04: 3:@CA70<=1/ E=1/<2:3<1@ 04:
<10:3:/0 => 04: /0C2:10/ 472 2<3:E0:2 04: ;:0<0<=1:3/ E=AA:@:04:3:<11=00=2</0C3H04:/0C2:10/B4=73:<AA:@7AAF 72D<00:2 0= 04: 7E72:D<E F:73 " $ $ 712
!
1: ;:ECA<73 >7E0 B4<E4 </ E=DD=1 <1 04:/:
;:0<0<=1/71204:=32:3;7//:2HF04:= 32<170::1E4 => 04</ =C30 3:>:33:2 0= 7H=G: </ 0470 04:/: 7AA:@:2 2:><E<:1E<:/47G:H::1;=<10:2=C0>=304:;:3<=2"0= 4</B7/04:;:3<=2B4:3:1=3D7AA<>:@A=H7AAF472 @=1: 47FB<3:=17EE=C10=> $ 712:D<E :1037A =G:31D:10 <0/:A> 472 H3=C@40 <1 ;=A<E<:/ 3:A7I<1@ 04: /03<E0E=D;A<71E:=>E:307<1;3=G</<=1/=>A7BG:1<104:
<1/0710 E7/:/ 04: G:3F
70<=17A =DD<//<=1 >=3 12<71 :2<E7A E<:1E:/ 7A/= 472 <//C:2 E:307<1 1=0<><E70<=1/ >=3 3:A7I<1@=>E:307<1E=12<0<=1/ # 4</ =C30 0=27F B4<A: 7AA=B<1@ 04: B3<0 ;:0<0<=1/ ><A:2 HF 04: ;:0<0<=1:3/ <1
=$!!' 712 =&"% 07?<1@ <10= E=1/<2:370<=1
- 36 -
;:ECA<73 >7E0 /<0C70<=1 => $ 712:D<E ;:3<=2 712 7A/= 04: ;=A<EF 0470 B:3: <103=2CE:2 HF 04: :1037A =G:31D:103:A7I<1@/03<E0E=D;A<71E:=>;3=G</<=1/=>A7B 2C3<1@ /7<2 ;:3<=2 47/ 2<3:E0:2 04: 3:/;=12:10
= 0= 3:E=1/<2:304:E7/:=>04:;:0<0<=1:3 E=AA:@:10470G<:B =>04:D700:3;3:/:10;:0<0<=1</$!% & :/;=12:10
=71273:2<3:E0:20=E=1/<2:3 04:3:;3:/:1070<=1><A:27/;:311:IC3: )?::;<1@<1D<12 04: =H/:3G70<=1 D72: 4:3:<1 7H=C0 /;:E<><E7AAF B<04 3:>:3:1E: 0= $ ;712:D<E ;:3<=2 712 ;7// =32:3 B<04 ;37@D70<E 7;;3=7E4 7A/= ?::;<1@ <1 G<:B 04:
/0C2:10/ B4= 73: 72D<00:2 2C3<1@ 04: /7<2 ;:3<=2 47G:
7A3:72F E=D;A:0:27H=C0 0= E=D;A:0: 04:<3 E=C3/:/ 712 04:<3A<>:C12:304:/:;:ECA<73>7E0//<0C70<=1E711=0H:A:>0 <1AC3E4 CE4=32:3/47AAH:;7//:2B<04<171=C0:3A<D<0=> #27F/ <1E:H=043:/;=12:10
=/71273:3:JC<3:2 0= E=1/<2:3 04: 3:;3:/:1070<=1 <0 </ H:0B::1 04:D 0= E=33:/;=12 <10:317AAF 712 0= E=D: 0= 7 ><17A E=1EAC/<=1
- 37 -
B<04=C0 D7?<1@ 04: ;:0<0<=1:3 <1/0<0C0<=1 0= 3:D<12 04:D <12<G<2C7AAF;C3/C7100=04</=32:3
" =D;A<71E: => 04</ =32:3 /47AA H: 3:;=30:2 HF 3:/;=12:10
=/712=1=3H:>=3:'/0=>73E4# $ 0</D72:EA:73047004:3:/;=12:10
=' 7K<G 7124< 1<G:3/<0F => :7A04 E<:1E:/ + , /47AA 711=C1E:04:3:/CA0/=>04:/0C2:10/=>04::I7D<170<=1/ B4<E404:F47G:7A3:72F07?:1<104:D=104=>C@C/0712 :;0:DH:3-! -* '# #) &
</0
= A
= '