- 1 - ! "#$ %$&!$!$ '!!( ! " # $ # %&" %&" $ %'('&" ) * ## %'('&" Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ! %'('&" ## ( %'('&" * # " )+ # '! # , # # "! # # # &$&$&"( ) -%# # # % % # )""&", )""&", -%! # # # # - 3 - .* .* ! /01234040560170839133:06;75<4/375885=06;<380371% !" #$% & &! ' (& )&& ! ' #*+ ,-./*& % 0 ) 0 !" #! 1 & & & >13 57 4/3 234040563< 01 4/>4 4/3 <312569364 5$ />9 ?>8839 75< >2280?>4056 45 4/3 2514 57 6;>6=>90 5<:3<1 06 >08>2@< A088>;3 ?5B06; =04/06 4/3 C@<0190?4056 57 <>B >6?/>D>4/ <>:3<> ! A088>;3 >9;0<0 014<0?4 >69>8@:/>44/3<301>454>8252@8>405657""("064/3 1>09A088>;3 @457=/0?/4/3252@8>4056574/3?/39@839 >143?5BB@604D3E?3391)&F/3234040563<G3856;3945 - 4 - 4/3 ?/39@839 >143 ?5BB@604D =/5 01 B5<3 9313<A06; 3A36 06 43<B1 57 4/3 ?0<?@8>< 011@39 GD 4/3 <312569364 % 4>435A3<6B364011@06;4/3;@0938063175<4/32@<251357 >225064B364 57 6;>6>=>90 =5<:3<1 />4 <312569364 5=/595654G3856;454/3?/39@839>143>43;5<D />1 G336 >22506439 06 A058>4056 57 4/3 <313<A>4056 2580?D ?5643B28>439@693<4/3;@0938063136?34/323404056 &$ 3><639 ?5@6138 75< 4/3 234040563< 4>:06; 4/01 5@<4 45 4/3 <3?5<91 1@GB041 4/>4 >1 23< 663E@<3% > ?3<4070?>439>439&$&(&"(4/3>6?/>D>4/3A3852B364 770?3<57<>:3<> !A088>;357>9;0<0>8@:/>193?8><39 4/>44/3<301)&F252@8>4056G3856;06;45?/39@839>143 ?5BB@604D 06 >08>2@< A088>;3 3 7@<4/3< 1@GB041 4/>4 @2564/3<32<31364>4056B>93GD4/3234040563<4/3/089 3A3852B364 8>6606; @4/5<04D >9;0<0 />9 5<>88D 90<3?439 75< ?569@?406; 57 36H@0<D =04/ <3;><9 45 4/3 >225064B364 57 <312569364 5 45 4/3 2514 57 6;>6>=>90 =5<:3< =/0?/ />1 654 G336 ?569@?439 4088 9>43 #@<4/3< 4/3 <312569364 5 G3856;1 45 >GG>80:> - 5 - 5BB@604D >69 1/3 9531 654 H@>807D 75< 4/3 2514 /3<375<3 /3 1@GB041 4/>4 4/3 A3<D >225064B364 57 <312569364 5 G306; @61@14>06>G83 >69 4/3 234040563<I1 ?>6909>4@<35@;/445/>A3G336?561093<39 &) 3><639 9904056>8 5A3<6B364 9A5?>43 <373<<06;454/3<325<4574/3/0893A3852B364@4/5<04D 9>439J&J&"(1@GB0414/>44/36;>6=>903643< 5 57 >08>2@< A088>;3 ?5610141 57 "&(" 252@8>4056 57 =/0?/ 568DFG3856;451?/39@83?>143?5BB@604D=/0834/3 454>8 252@8>4056 57 6;>6>=>90 3643< 5 57 >08>2@< A088>;3?561014157"&),57=/0?/$,,G3856;45?/39@839 >143=/0?/=5<:1>G5@4$F/3<375<3/31@GB0414/>4 4/3 1>09 ><9 ?5@89 654 G3 <313<A39 75< 4/3 ?/39@839 >143 1 <3;><91 4/3 >225064B364 B>93 45 <312569364 5 01 ?56?3<639 /3 1@GB041 4/>4 <312569364 5 />1 G336>22506439454/36;>6>=>903643< 5>11/3=>1 ?>6909>43?8>0B06;G363704@693<=095=H@54>=/0?//>145 G3 ;0A36 2<05<04D >1 23< 4/3 ;@09380631 /3<375<3 /3 1@GB041 4/>4 4/3<3 01 65 3<<5< 06 >22506406; <312569364 5 - 6 - &' 3><93<@1394/3<3?5<91 & /3 568D ?564364056 @<;39 GD 4/3 234040563< 01 4/>4>123<4/3<325<457>6?/>D>4/3A3852B364 770?3< 2<59@?39 >4 663E@<3% 4/3 >08>2@< A088>;3 />1 ;54 >G5@4 )&F 57 4/3 454>8 252@8>4056 G3856;06; 45 1?/39@83 ?>143?5BB@604D4/3<375<34/31>B35@;/445/>A3G336 <313<A39 @693< 1?/39@83 ?>14 H@54> 06 43<B1 57 8>@13%' 57 4/3 @09380631 2<5A0939 06 4/3 654070?>4056 9>439 )""&",011@39GD4/35A3<6B36457 ><6>4>:> &, /3;@0938063 5'>123<4/3654070?>40569>439 )""&",2<5A093175<<313<A>4056576;>6>=>903643< 75< ?/39@839 >1431 >69 ?/39@839 <0G31 07 4/3 1>09 6;>6>=>90 3643< ?5610141 57 B5<3 4/>6 )&F 57 4/3 252@8>4056 G3856;06; 45 ?/39@839 >1431 >69 ?/39@839 <0G31?5BB@604D &( 3<@1>8 57 4/3 14>43B364 57 5GC3?40561 70839 GD 4/3 <312569364 K 4>43 >69 4/3 95?@B3641 36?85139 4/3<3=04/B5<32><40?@8><5706H@0<D<325<457/089387><3 - 7 - 32><4B364 =5@89 0690?>43 4/>4 4/3<3 ><3 4=5 6;>6>=>90 3643<1 ?5B06; =04/06 4/3 80B041 57 >08>2@< A088>;3 =/0?/ 01 ?>8839 >08>2@<% >69 >08>2@<% /3 ><3>?5B06;@693<1>09>08>2@<%0114>43945/>A3>454>8 252@8>405657"&(J57=/0?/4/3<3><365B3BG3<G3856; 45 ?/39@839 >143 5BB@604D >69 568D &, B3BG3<1 G3856;45?/39@839<0G31>69&JB3BG3<1G3856;454/3 065<04D 5BB@604D 1 <3;><91 6;>6>=>90 3643< >4 >08>2@<% 01 ?56?3<639 4/3 454>8 252@8>4056 57 4/3 1>09 ><3> 01 14>439 45 G3 6@BG3< 57 "&), 57 =/0?/ B3BG3<1 G3856; 45 ?/39@839 >1431 01 1/5=6 >1 $,, >69 <3B>0606;><37<5B4/354/3<?5BB@60403111@?/G54/ 4/3 6;>6>=>90 3643<1 57 >08>2@<% >69 />A3 G336 :324523675<;363<>8?>6909>431 &J #@<4/3< 8>@13 5, 000! 57 4/3 654070?>4056 2<5A0906; 75< >225064B364 57 6;>6>=>90 5<:3< B>69>431 4/>4 2<373<36?3 45 G3 ;0A36 45 =5B36 @693< =095= H@54> 5A3< 54/3<1 /3 <312569364 5 />1 G336 >22506439454/36;>6>=>903643<%>11/3=>1?8>0B06; - 8 - G363704 @693< =095= H@54> =/3<3 4/3 252@8>4056 57 ?/39@83>143183114/36F11@?/653<<5<?>6G3 75@69=04/4/3>225064B36457<312569364 5454/32514 574/36;>6>=>905<:3<456;>6>=>90364<3 5 "& 4 01 1@GB04439 4/>4 95?@B364 >4 663E@<3% <38039@256GD4/3234040563<01>22<5E0B>4306<3123?457 252@8>4056573640<3A088>;3>6965406<3123?457>65407039 6;>6>=>90><3>=013 "" 6 4/3 80;/4 57 4/3 >75<31>09 7>?4@>8 >123?4 57 4/3 B>443< >69 106?3 4/3 36H@0<D <325<4 57 4/3 /089 387><3 32><4B364 770?3< 01 28>?39 56 <3?5<9 1/5=06; 4/3 >?4@>8 252@8>4056 57 4/3 1>09 ><3> 4/01 5@<4 95 654 133>6D<3>156450643<73<3 " /3 23404056 8>?:1 B3<04 >69 4/3 1>B3 01 >??5<906;8D !)* '$!$( & ** 014 5"8 5 42: