- 1 - ! " #$ % % "" &%' ( !"#$% &'' (% "% ! )' )(' %%*+,*+- ( !"$*% Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $% ' ( )' )(' %%*+,*+- ( ( !"#"% *% % %% )) !"#"% &' ) *. $-%#"%$#$ "'. #*%#%$#$ $' ) ) "* " ) ' ) ) ' ( $$%#$%$#"- ' ( % %$*$$#"+ ) ( % ) ) ( - 3 - / %( $ 012 344536 12 71658 9: ;05 3445663<; , =631>3<; 255?1<@5<03<=5>5<;A7=A>45<23;1A<323B3C8581<;05 DE8@>5<; 3<8 3B3C8 83;58 $$%#$%$#"- 432258 1< %A%$*$$#"+ 9: ;05 881;1A<36 12;C1=; 3<8 5221A<2(E8@53<831=0EC7AC20AC;FC19E<36G% #$% 05 73=;2 65381<@ ;A 7161<@ A7 =631> 45;1;1A< 3C5 32E<85C, 03; A< "-%#%$#"! ;05 =631>3<; 3<8 3<A;05C B5C5 4CA=5581<@ A< 3 >A;AC=:=65 953C1<@ 5@%A%,*,, **$B05<;05:C53=058<53C1C536639C18@5A<3<H1 31=0ECCA383;39AE;#%*#4%>%3;;03;;1>58C1H5CA7 AA73<(554953C1<@5@%A%,*+,*+-=3>51<301@0 245583<81<3C3203<8<5@61@5<;>3<<5C3<8832058;A ;05>A;AC=:=65A7;05=631>3<;%05:75668AB<A<;05CA38 3<8 2E2;31<58 25H5C5 1<DEC152% 05 =631>3<; ;3?5< ;C53;>5<; 3<8 71658 ;05 =631> 45;1;1A<% 05 C19E<36 32252258 =A>45<23;1A< 3<8 432258 ;05 1>4E@<583B3C8% 05 =631>3<; 032 71658 ;05 4C525<; 344536 255?1<@ 5<03<=5>5<;A7;05=A>45<23;1A<% - 4 - #*% 53C8 653C<58 =AE<256 7AC ;05 3445663<; , =631>3<; 3<8 653C<58 =AE<256 7AC C524A<85<; A%$ 1<2EC3<=5=A>43<:% #% 53C<58 =AE<256 7AC ;05 3445663<; , =631>3<; BAE68=A<;5<8;03;I%'%- 81239161;:=5C;171=3;5032955< 122E589:;05581=36 A3C8B05<;05>3;;5C12C575CC58;A ;05> 9: ;05 AEC; B05C51< ;05 81239161;: A7 ;05 B0A65 9A8:A7;05=631>3<;123225225832$#J%05C19E<36032 5CC581<;3?1<@;0581239161;:3;+JB1;0AE;3<:C532A<7AC ;0523183245=;%57EC;05C2E9>1;2;03;3245C;0503C; 4C543C587AC25;;65>5<;A78124E;521<A?,8363;09:;05 3C<3;3?3 5@36 5CH1=52 E;0AC1;: ;05 <A;1A<36 1<=A>5 7AC ;05 :53C $#"! 12 2%###, 45C >A<;0% 05 C19E<36 032 5CC58 1< ;3?1<@ ;05 1<=A>5 A7 ;05 =631>3<; 3; 2%###, 45C >A<;0% 5 7EC;05C 2E9>1;2 ;03; ;05 =A>45<23;1A<3B3C8587ACA;05C053821%5%6A22A71<=A>5 8EC1<@ ;05 6318 45C 45C1A8 3<8 6A22 A7 3>5<1;152 3C5 A< 6AB5C2185%1;0;0525054C3:2;A366AB;05344536% - 5 - #!% 53C<58 =AE<256 7AC C524A<85<; A%$ 1<2EC3<=5 =A>43<: BAE68 =A<;5<8 ;03; ;05 C19E<36 032 C1@0;6:;3?5<;0581239161;:3;+J3<8C1@0;6:3B3C858;05 =A>45<23;1A< E<85C 366 A;05C 05382 3<8 ;05C5 3C5 <A @CAE<82 ;A 5<03<=5 ;05 =A>45<23;1A<% 1;0 ;0525 05 4C3:2;A812>122;05344536% #+% 3H1<@053C8653C<58=AE<2567AC;053445663<;2 3<8 653C<58 =AE<256 7AC C524A<85<; A%$ 1<2EC3<=5 =A>43<:;012AEC;45CE258;051>4E@<58DE8@>5<;3<8 C136AEC;C5=AC82% #% 05 =631>3<; B32 3@58 39AE; ! :53C2 32 A< ;0583;5A73==185<;1%5%A<"-%#%$#"!3<8;056139161;:A7 ;05 1<2EC3<=5 =A>43<: 3C5 <A; 1< 8124E;5% 05 =631>3<; 032 2E2;31<58 7C3=;EC5 A7 7AC53C>% 5 E<85C@A<5 2EC@5C: 3<8;0523187C3=;EC512>36,E<1;58%I%'%-12;0581239161;: =5C;171=3;5 122E58 9: ;05 581=36 A3C8% 05 =631>3<; 032 955< C575CC58 ;A ;05 581=36 A3C8 7AC 3225221<@ ;05 81239161;:%05581=36 A3C837;5C3225221<@;0581239161;: 032 122E58 I%'%- 81239161;: =5C;171=3;5 B05C51< 1; 12 - 6 - 2;3;58 ;03; ;05 =631>3<; 12 03H1<@ 45C>3<5<; 40:21=36 81239161;:3;$#JA7;05B0A659A8:%H5<;0AE@0;052318 81239161;:12122E589:;05581=36 A3C8A<;051<2;CE=;1A< A7;05AEC;;05C19E<360325CC581<;3?1<@;0581239161;: 3;+J323@31<2;$#J%05C57AC5;0581239161;:032;A95 ;3?5<3;$#JA7;05B0A659A8:3245CI%'%- 81239161;: =5C;171=3;5% 05 C19E<36 032 ;3?5< ;05 1<=A>5 3; 2%###, 9E; 32 45C ;05 03C; 4C543C58 7AC 25;;65>5<; A78124E;521<A?,8363;09:;053C<3;3?35@365CH1=52 E;0AC1;: ;05 <A;1A<36 1<=A>5 7AC ;05 :53C 12 $#"! 12 2%###,3<8;0523181<=A>5032;A95;3?5<% #% <H15BA7;0539AH5;05=631>3<;125<;1;658;A 6A22A77E;EC51<=A>532E<85C, 2%###,I"$I"I$#JK2%$+##,% #-% 05 C19E<36 032 C1@0;6: 3B3C858 ;05 =A>45<23;1A< ;AB3C82 431< 3<8 2E775C1<@ 3; 2%*####, >581=365I45<2523;2%!###,% - 7 - "#% 05C5 12 <A 8A=E>5<; 7AC;0=A>1<@ 1< ;05 C5=AC82 ;A 20AB ;05 <E>95C A7 83:2 A7 38>1221A< A7 ;05 =631>3<; 1< ;05 0A241;36% 05 C19E<36 032 3B3C858 =A>45<23;1A< ;AB3C82 3;;5<83<; =03C@52 A7 2%"####, 3<8;AB3C827AA8<AEC120>5<;3<8=A<H5:3<=5=03C@523; 2%"####,% 05 =631>3<; 12 5<;1;658 ;A 2%"####, ;AB3C82 3;;5<83<; 7AA8 <AEC120>5<; 3<8 =A<H5:3<=5 =03C@523;2%"####,323@31<2;2%$####,323B3C858 9:;05C19E<36% ""% 05 C19E<36 032 3B3C858 =A>45<23;1A< ;AB3C826A22A7 1<=A>58EC1<@6318 E445C1A81<32E>A7 2%"###,% AB ;05 1<=A>5 12 ;3?5< 3; 2%###, 45C >A<;0;05=631>3<;125<;1;658;A2%"+###,2%###, I$;AB3C826A22A71<=A>58EC1<@;056318E445C1A8% "$% A<2185C1<@ ;03; ;05C5 12 3 7C3=;EC5 ;05 =631>3<; 12 5<;1;658 ;A 6A22 A7 3>5<1;152 1< 3 2E> A7 2%*####, 32 3@31<2; 2%"####, 32 3B3C858 9: ;05 C19E<36% - 8 - "*% <H15BA7;0539AH5;053445663<; =631>3<;12 5<;1;658;A;A;36=A>45<23;1A<32E<85C, ) *+,- ./0*1-+231 /0*1-+231 +4+5,*,67283-952 " A22A77E;EC51<=A>5 2%$+##, $ '31<3<82E775C1<@ 2%*####, * 581=365I45<252 2%!###, ;;5<83<; 7AA8 <AEC120>5<; 3<8 =A<H5:3<=5=03C@52 2%"####, ! A22 A7 1<=A>5 8EC1<@ 6318E445C1A8 2%"+###, + A22A73>5<1;152 2%*####, 2+) -:;< "% <H15BA7;0539AH5;053445663<; =631>3<;12 5<;1;658 ;A =A>45<23;1A< A7 2%*!-##, 32 3@31<2; 2%"-+##,323B3C8589:;05C19E<36B1;01<;5C52;3; ;05 C3;5 A7 +J 4%3% 7CA> ;05 83;5 A7 45;1;1A< ;166 1;2 C5361L3;1A<% 05 C19E<36 032 3B3C858 ;05 1<;5C52; 3; ;05 C3;5 A7 J 4%3% 3<8 1; 12 A< 01@05C 2185% 5<=5 ;05 =631>3<;125<;1;658;A;051<;5C52;;05C3;5A7+J4%3% "!% <H15BA7;0539AH5;057A66AB1<@. - 9 - % 0534453612366AB581<43C;% % 05DE8@>5<;3<83B3C883;58$$%#$%$#"-4322581< %A%$*$$#"+ 9: ;05 881;1A<36 12;C1=; 3<8 5221A<2 (E8@5 3<8 31=0EC 12 >A817158 32 E<85C, % 05 3445663<; =631>3<; 12 5<;1;658 ;A ;A;36 =A>45<23;1A< A7 2%*!-##, 32 3@31<2; 2%"-+##,323B3C8589:;05C19E<3636A<@B1;0 1<;5C52; 3; ;05 C3;5 A7 +J 4%3% 7CA> ;05 83;5 A7 45;1;1A<;1661;2C5361L3;1A<% % 05 C524A<85<; A%$ 1<2EC3<=5 =A>43<: 20366 854A21; ;05 2318 3B3C8 3>AE<; B1;0 1<;5C52; 957AC5 ;05 C19E<36 B1;01< # B55?2 7CA> ;012 83: 73161<@ B01=0 1; 12 613965 ;A 43: 1<;5C52; 3; ;05 C3;5 A7 -J 4%3% % 05C5@12;C:1281C5=;58;A25<893=?;05C136AEC; C5=AC8236A<@B1;0=A4:A7;012DE8@>5<;7AC;0B1;0% ,< & % %' $ (( 12;A%"6A%*"