Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66347 (KAR)
AKKAMAHADEVI MAHILA UNIVERSTIY VIJAYAPURA AND ANR v. AJAY
WP/201991/2023 · 2025-11-12
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66347 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66347 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%$& $ $
'( )
!*
+'(
! +'(
! +
+'(
! +'(
!,! +'(
!! +'(
! +'(
+'(
)
! " #
$
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% ! &' & %! "
# (
$
( ' (
( ! $ ( )
! ( % '
*
$ ( (
!*)
+
! "
#
$
- 3 -
% ! &+, & %! -
"
# (
$
( '(
(!$ ( )
! ( % '
*
$ ( (
! )
+
! "
#
$
- 4 -
%
! &. & %! "
# (
$
( ' (
( ! ( $
( )
! ( % '
*
$ ( (
! +)
+
! " #
$
- 5 -
% ! &. & %! -
"
# (
$
( ' (
( ! $ ( )
! ( .% '
*
$ ( (
! )
+
- ! " #
$
- 6 -
% ! ! &+, & %! " # (
$
( ' (
( ! $
( )
! ( % '
*
$ ( (
!,!)
+
/
! " #
$
- 7 -
% ! & & %! "
# (
$
( ' (
( ! $ ( )
! ( % '
* $
( (
!!)
+
- ! " #
$
- 8 -
%! ! & & %! "
# (
$
( ' (
( ! $ ( )
! ( ,% '
*
0 $ ( /
(
!)
+
- ! " #
$
- 9 -
% ! &++ & %! "
# (
$
( ' (
( ! $ ( )
! ( % '
*
$ ( (
)
+
! "
#
$
- 10 -
%
! ! &+ & %! "
# (
$
( ' (
( ! $ ( )
! ( +% '
*
$ ( (
!((
! &
& /
!
- 11 -
# &/
!$
12 3245456728
75928:54; <257= 412 >6??67 57 @AA 412:2 B854 32454567: 82:367C274:68D?27 @82 412 2?3A6;22:B16:2428?57@45671@:<2273E4575::E2412:2 B854 32454567: @82 4@D27 E3 F68 @7@A6=6E: 12@857= @7C C5:36:@A@:412;=59285:246>6??67GE2:4567:6FF@>4@7C A@B
123245456728
75928:54;5:<2F682415:6E8457 412:2 B854 32454567: <257= @==85292C <; 412 68C28 C@42C ' 67 412 F5A2 6F 412 82:5C57= FF5>28 @<6E8 6E84 5H@;@3E8@ #F68 :1684 I412 @<6E8 6E84 $ 57 2F2827>26%7428?:6FB15>1B15A2@AA6B57=412 32454567:F5A2C<;41282:367C274:68D?27E7C282>4567 #$#$ 6F 412 7CE:485@A 5:3E42: >4 ,.' #F68 :1684 I412 >4 $ 412 @<6E8 6E84 1@: C2>A@82C 412 68@A 428?57@4567 6F 412 :2895>2: 6F 54: 2?3A6;22: ?@C2 <;
3245456728
75928:54;67'@:7EAA@7C965C12 3245456728
75928:54;1@:<227FE84128C582>42C468257:4@42
- 12 -
412 82:367C274:68D?27 5746 :2895>2 B541 FEAA <@>D B@=2: @7C B541 >67457E54; 6F :2895>2 6F 3245456728 75928:54;F86?'
+ 12 @F682:@5C 82F2827>232454567: B282 F5A2C <;
412 82:367C274:68D?27 128257 E7C28 2>4567 #$#$ 6F412>4>67427C57=41@4412;B28257545@AA;
@3365742C<;4123245456728
75928:54;128257@:B22328: 67C@5A;B@=2:2FF2>4592F86?412;2@8+@7C41@4412; >67457E2C46B68DC5A5=274A;@7C:57>282A;45AA41258:2895>2: B2825AA2=@AA;428?57@42C67'B5416E4@7;9@A5C 82@:67:
. 1@4 412 82:367C274:68D?27 1@C :2892C ?682 41@7 . C@;: CE857= >@A27C@8 ?6741: @: >6742?3A@42CE7C282>4567#$6F412>4::E>1 54 B@: 5?328@4592 67 412 3@84 6F 412 3245456728
75928:54;
46 1@92 >6?3A52C B541 412 ?@7C@468; 82GE582?274 6F 38695:567: 6F 2>4567 #($#@$#<$#>$ 6F 412 >4 :
:E>1412@>45676F4123245456728
75928:54;57428?57@457=
- 13 -
412 :2895>2: 6F 412 82:367C274:68D?27 @?6E74: 46 824827>1?274B54157412?2@757=6F2>4567#$6F412 >4 27>2 412 82:367C274:68D?27 128257 :6E=14 F68C2>A@8@456741@4412428?57@4567C@42C'B@:
7EAA @7C 965C @7C F68 >67:2GE274 82A52F 6F 8257:4@42?274 B541F8E54FEA<@>DB@=2:
12 3245456728
75928:54; F5A2C 54: B854427 :4@42?274%6<H2>4567:46412?@5732454567>67427C57=41@4 412 3245456728
75928:54; B@: 764 @7 57CE:48; @: 328 2>4567 #H$ 6F 412 >4 41282F682 82F2827>232454567: B282 764 ?@574@57@<A2 4 5: >6742742C 41@4 412 82:367C274:68D?27 :2892C E7C28 412 3245456728 75928:54; @: J@F@;22 @8?@>1@85K 67 C@5A; B@=2 <@:5:
1@4 412; B282 764 428?57@42C F86? :2895>2 <E4 1@C 96AE74@85A; :E<?5442C 41258 A24428 C@42C ' 57427C57= GE54 @: 412; B282 E7@<A2 46 >@88;6E4 412 B68D 2748E:42C 46 412? 1@4 41282 5: 76 :@7>4567 36:4 6F I@F@;22 @8?@>1@85 : :E>1 412 GE2:4567 6F =8@7457= 82A52F 6F 8257:4@42?274 68 >67457E54; 6F :2895>2 @: :6E=14
- 14 -
F68 B6EAC 764 @85:2 12 >A@5?
6F 412 82:367C274:
68D?27 6F 412; 1@957= >67457E2C 46 B68D F68 .C@;: CE857=>@A27C@8?6741:1@C@A:6<227C2752C
@:2C 67 412 3A2@C57=: 412 @<6E8 6E84 F8@?2C 412 F6AA6B57= 5::E2: F68 54: >67:5C28@4567 #:@?2 5::E2:@7C@CCA5::E2:57@AA82F2827>2:$&
' 95C27>2 B282 A2C <; 412 82:32>4592 3@8452: 2:367C274:68D?272L@?572C412?:2A92:@:@7C =64?@8D2C'#:2927$C6>E?274:@: L:46'@7C672 86F8E7C@7C@??@ 412 2=5:48@8 6F 3245456728 75928:54; B@: 2L@?572C @: @7C =64 ?@8D2C + #41822$C6>E?274:@: L:46+
- 15 -
7>67:5C28@45676F3A2@C57=:@7C412295C27>2 A2C412@<6E86E841@C@7:B282C4125::E2:8@5:2C57412 @FF58?@4592 16AC57= 41@4 41282 2L5:42C 82A@4567:153 6F 2?3A6;28 @7C 2?3A6;22 @7C 412 3245456728
75928:54;
128257 <257= 412 57CE:48; 412 82F2827>232454567: B282 ?@574@57@<A2@7C>67:2GE274A;@AA6B2C41232454567:<;54: @B@8CC@42C'@:7642C@<692257=@==85292C <;412:@?24123245456728
75928:54;5:<2F682415:6E84
, 2@872C >6E7:2A 85@957C8@ 2CC; @4 412 6E4:24 :E<?54: 41@4412@<6E8 6E84 F@5A2C 46@3382>5@42 412 F@>4 41@4 412 3245456728
75928:54; 1@C 27=@=2C 412 :2895>2:6F41282:367C274:68D?274186E=1@>6748@>468 @7C 412; 1@C 76 82A@4567:153 6F 2?3A6;28 @7C 2?3A6;22 2:E<?54:41@441282B@:76>67486A68:E32895:567<;412 3245456728
75928:54;692841282:367C274:68D?2715:
2A2?274@8; 82GE582?274 1@: <227 5=7682C <; 412 @<6E8 6E84
- 16 -
2 82F28: 46 @ 2?6 C@42C , 386CE>2C 57 @AA 412:2 B854 32454567: @A67= B541 41822 C6>E?274:7@?2A; ! " # $ % &
! "#&
'! ( )
*
"
2F28857= 46 :@5C C6>E?274: A2@872C >6E7:2A :E<?54: 41@4 @: F@8 <@>D @: 67 . @ 82:6AE4567 B@: 3@::2C <; 412 3245456728
75928:54; 38636:57= 46 27=@=2 412 :2895>2: 6F >284@57 85!@AAE8 @7C 57 FE84128@7>2412826F12B@:@B@8C2C412427C28>6748@>4 67:2GE274A; 412 :@5C !@AAE8 :E33A52C 412 82:367C274:68D?27 F68 @F@;22 @8?@>1@85 67 C@5A; B@=2<@:5:2:E<?54:41@4412:@5C@:32>46F412?@4428 1@:764<2274@D275746>67:5C28@4567<;412@<6E86E84 B15A2@885957=@4@>67>AE:5676F41282<257=@82A@4567:153 6F 2?3A6;28 @7C 2?3A6;22 <24B227 412 3245456728 75928:54;@7C41282:367C274:68D?272:E<?54:41@4
- 17 -
:57>2 412 82:367C274: B282 27=@=2C 4186E=1 412 >6748@>468 412; >@7764 >A@5? 46 <2 8257:4@42C B541 <@>D B@=2:@7C>67457E54;6F:2895>2:
2FE84128:E<?54:41@429275F412428?57@4567 12AC 46 <2 965C 412 3245456728
75928:54; 5: 82@C; @7C B5AA57=@:@7@A4287@4282?2C;463@;@?6E74@:67245?2 >6?327:@4567 57:42@C 6F 8257:4@42?274 27>2 :22D: F68 @AA6B57=6F412B85432454567:
+ 7:E336846F15:>674274567:1282A52:E367412 F6AA6B57=HEC=?274:0 #$
!" !# $% &% '("%% )*+!,%-&!."!/,.8236842C570 * 10
#$ (,# '+,$ 2" $% )")3! !4)3!8236842C570 '0
#+$ 3 &!!22 "+," !. ,3"% $%
"$!"!4 !. ,3"% 57
5
. 2@872C 27568 6E7:2A @332@857= F68 412 82:367C274:68D?2767412641281@7C:E<?54:41@4412 3245456728
75928:54; 1@C 4@D27 57>67:5:4274 :4@7C <2F682
- 18 -
412 @<6E8 6E84 15A2 57545@AA; 54 >67427C2C 41@4 412 82:367C274:68D?27 B282 2?3A6;2C @: C@5A; B@=2 2?3A6;22:B16412?:2A92:1@C96AE74@85A;82:5=72CF86?
412 2?3A6;?274 :E<:2GE274A; 412 3245456728
75928:54; >67427C2C412;764<257=54:2?3A6;22:
1@4 412 @<6E8 6E84 67 @3382>5@4567 6F C6>E?274@8; @7C 68@A 295C27>2 1@: >6?2 46 >@42=685> >67>AE:5676F3245456728
75928:54;<257=4122?3A6;28@7C 41282:367C274:68D?27<257=2?3A6;22:B15>1F57C57= 5: :57>2 <@:2C 67 412 ?@4285@A 295C27>2 >@7764 <2 57428F282C B541 1@4 @C?5442CA; 82:367C274:68D?27 B282 B68D57= @: C@5A; B@=2 2?3A6;22: @7C 41258 8257:4@42?274 B6EAC 82:4682 412 + B541 @AA 412 <272F54: B15>1 412; @82 27454A2C 46 2 :E<?54: 41@4 2927 @F428 412 68C28 6F 412 @<6E8 6E84 412 3245456728 75928:54;1@:764>6?3A52CB541412:4@4E468;82GE582?274 6F2>4567'#$6F412>4
- 19 -
2 @A:6 F5A2: @ 2?6 C@42C @A67= B541@76FF5>268C285::E2C<;4123245456728
75928:54;@7C :E<?54:41@44123245456728
75928:54;76B1@:>@AA2CE367 412 82:367C274:68D?27 46 82H657 412 B68D @: @F@;22 @8?@>1@85 : :E>1 412 >67CE>4 6F 412 3245456728 75928:54; 2:463: 412? F86? 3E8:E57= 412 382:274 B854 32454567: <E4 46 >6?3A; B541 412 68C28 3@::2C <; 412 @<6E86E84
' 7:E336846F15:>674274567:1282A52:E367412 F6AA6B57=HEC=?274:& #$ $." 23 $% &+(!* +*6 !!"8236842C570 0
#$ & ,% ,. . !,3" $% !"!,!7! *+,"+,# 8!". !. ,3"% 8236842C570
9!, 1-/0
#+$ &!!2 , ,!, 8!7 0.! $% :&&!3!("%3 8236842C 57
-/;
2@8C28E:2C41282>68C:
, 129212?274:E<?5::567:76B<257=E8=2C<;
412 A2@872C >6E7:2A F68 412 3245456728
75928:54; 5: 767
- 20 -
>67:5C28@4567 6F 412 >@:2 6F 412 3245456728
75928:54;
7@?2A; 82:367C274:68D?27 <257= 27=@=2C <; 412 3245456728
75928:54;4186E=167257C2327C274>6748@>468
28E:@A6FB854427:4@42?274>E?6<H2>4567:46 412?@57 32454567 F5A2C <; 4123245456728
75928:54; <2F682 412 @<6E8 6E84 57 412 82F2827>2 386>22C57=: B6EAC 57C5>@42 41@4 76 :E>1 =86E7C 1@: <227 4@D27 <; 412 3245456728
75928:54; @8@=8@31 6. 6F 412 B854427 :4@42?274%6<H2>4567:5:2L48@>42C1282E7C28& ,$
*
'
- . /
/
/
/ . 0" )0 1 !/ 12 #34'$! " ./ 5 6 / -/
"
- 21 -
7
E857= 412 >86::2L@?57@4567 >284@57 :E==2:4567: 1@92 <227 ?@C2 46 412 B5472::2: 82=@8C57= 41258:2895>2:1@957=<22727=@=2C4186E=1@>6748@>468 B15>11@:<227:46E4A;C2752C
@7@=2?274B5472::1@:>@42=685>@AA;@C?5442C 41@467@7C@F428+4123245456728
75928:54;1@:<227 >82C5457=412:@A@852:6F41282:367C274:68D?27C582>4A; 574641258@7D>>6E74:
+ 12:2 3A2@C57= @7C 412 295C27>2 67 82>68C 328:E@C2C 412 @<6E8 6E84 46 >67>AEC2 412 2L5:427>2 6F 82A@4567:153 6F 2?3A6;28 @7C 2?3A6;22: <24B227 3245456728
75928:54; @7C 412 82:367C274:68D?27 12 :@5C F57C57= 68 >67>AE:567 <@:2C 67 412 3A2@C57= @7C 295C27>2 A2C <; 412 3@8452: 57 412 @<:27>2 6F @7;
328928:54; 68 5AA2=@A54; <257= 365742C 6E4 >@7764 <2 57428F282C57412B854386>22C57=:
- 22 -
.
: 82=@8C: 412 C6>E?274: 76B :6E=14 46 <2 82A52C E367 <; 412 A2@872C >6E7:2A F68 412 3245456728 75928:54; 5: >67>2872C 41282 5: 76 @33A5>@4567 F5A2C :22D57=386CE>45676F412:@5CC6>E?274:6838695C57=@7;
2L3A@7@4567 6F 412; 764 <257= @<A2 46 386CE>2 412 :@5C C6>E?274:<2F682412@<6E86E84
1@4 @3@84 54 5::244A2C3857>53A2 6F A@B41@4 57 412 @<:27>2 6F 3A2@C57= 76 @?6E74 6F 295C27>2%3866F 5:
@C?5::5<A2 57>2 41282 5: 76 B15:328 57 412 B854427 :4@42?274%6<H2>4567: <; 412 3245456728
75928:54; 82=@8C57=82:367C274:68D?271@957=<22727=@=2C@: J@F@22@?@>1@85K4186E=1@>6748@>46829275F412:@5C C6>E?274: C5C 2L5:4 412 :@?2 @82 6F 76 E:2 57 412 @<:27>26F3A2@C57=123E836:26F415:5:764F@846:22D E>1 3A2@C57=: B6EAC 1@92 @FF68C2C 633684E754; F68 412 82:367C274:68D?27 46 >6E7428 412 :@?2 4 415:
<2A@42C :4@=2 415: 6E84 82F8@57: F86? 82A;57= E367 412 :@?2@::6E=1446<257:5:42C<;412A2@872C>6E7:2AF68 4123245456728
75928:54;
- 23 -
2A5@7>2 3A@>2C 67 <; 412 A2@872C >6E7:2A F68 412 3245456728
75928:54; 67 46 412 HEC=?274 6F 412 32L 6E8457412>@:26F)")3!!4)3!#
$5:6F76 @9@5A57@:?E>1@:412F@>4:5796A92C57412:@5C?@4428B@:
41@4 412 B68D?@7 B16 1@C B68D2C @: @ C@5A; B@=28 1@C 8@5:2C412C5:3E42<2F682412@<6E86E84@F428;2@8: 6F@AA2=2C428?57@456745:E7C28412:@5C>58>E?:4@7>2: 41232L6E841@C@>>2342C4123A2@6FAE?3:E?@?6E74 <257=3@5C@:412HE:4>6?327:@4567
' 7 412 >@:2 6F !" !##
$ 412 5::E2B@:B54182=@8C46@336574?2746F@E7568 7=57228 B16 B@: 386?642C @: ::5:4@74 7=57228 67 412 @C?575:48@4592:5C2@7C67428?57@4567412:@5C2?3A6;22 1@C@>>2342C412>12GE23@5C46B@8C:672?6741/::@A@8;
57 A52E6F 7645>2 4 5: E7C2841E: :@5C >58>E?:4@7>2: 412 32L6E84@FF58?2C41268C286F4125=16E8457:6F@8@:
412 @B@8C <257= :24 @:5C2 46 8257:4@42 412 2?3A6;22 57 :2895>2@7C463@;412>6?327:@45676F:'%57A52E 6F<@7DB@=2:
- 24 -
: 82=@8C: 412 68C28 6F 412 595:567 27>1 6F 415: 6E84 57 412 >@:2 6F $!"!4 #
$ 412 :@5C @332@A B@: <; 412 @7@=2?274 @=@57:4 412 68C28 6F 412 A2@872C 57=A2 EC=2 B15>1 1@C C582>42C F68 3@;?274 6F >6?327:@45676F:+%67@>>6E746FFEAA@7CF57@A :244A2?274 6F 41258 >A@5? 12 B854 32454567 57 412 :@5C 386>22C57=: 1@C <227 F5A2C <; 412 B68D?@7 B16:2 82F2827>21@C<227@7:B282C@=@57:4412B68D?@7
, 12F@>4:7@88@42C@<6925741257:4@74>@:2@82 >6?3A242A;C5FF28274@7CC5:457>4F86?4126725796A92C57 412 @F682:@5C 68C28: @7C HEC=?274 82A52C <; 412 A2@872C >6E7:2AF684123245456728
75928:54;
+ 2@872C>6E7:2AF684123245456728
75928:54;@4 412 HE7>4E82 :E<?54: 41@4 412 68C28 6F 412 @<6E8 6E84 C582>457=F68412<@>DB@=2:@7C>67457E54;6F:2895>2?@; 764@33A;5741257:4@74>@:257@:?E>1@:4123245456728:
B282 C@5A; B@=2 2?3A6;22: @7C B6EAC <2 27454A2C 67A; @=@57:4412B68DC672
- 25 -
+ 2@872C 27568 6E7:2A F@58A; :E<?54: 41@4 <24B22741232856CF86?'45AA3@::57=6F@B@8C<;412 @<6E8 6E84 8257:4@457= 412? 412; ?@; 764 <2 27454A2C F68B@=2:@:412;C5C764B68D
+ 12:E<?5::5674@D276782>68C
++ 541412@<6926<:289@4567:412B85432454567: @82.% %%. -) '$ $( &
&&' &