- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( !"" # $"" %& % &' ( $" !"" ' %) *%%%+ # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' *&!# ' " ' ' , &*%% &*% " ' ' -" # ! -" # ./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 % 3<8 /==./> <8 :<>.1 /4/<782 23. ?5146.72 /71 /@/011/2.1&*%%=/88.1;A23.11>.7<90<B<> 514./71.6;.0,<?/A/=50/<79&*9: % & 3. :/C28 9: 23. C/8. /0. 23/2 97 +% @3<>. 23. C>/<6/72 /4.1 A./08 @90D<74 /8 CC95728 /7/4.0 <7 785>/2<978 71</ <6<2.1 @/8 =09C..1<74 ;A @/>D 97 96=/7A 588/7 - 3 - /0109/1/2$51/4<23.10<B.09:23.C0/<7>900A;./0<74 .4 9$%E+ 109B. <2 <7 3<43 8=..1 /71 0/83 /717.4><4.726/77.0/71>982C97209>9B.023.8/6./71 1/83.1 29 23. C>/<6/72 /71 23.0.;AC/58.123. /CC<1.72 15.29@3<C3C>/<6/728582/<7.140<.B958<7?50<.8 + 3.0.:90. 3. :<>.1 / C>/<6 =.2<2<97 ;.:90. 23. 0<;57/> C>/<6<74 C96=.78/2<97 9: 8%* 3. 0<;57/> C978<1.0<74 23. .72<0. .B<1.7C. 97 0.C901 40/72.1 C96=.78/2<97 9: 8E*E% @<23 <72.0.82 /2 F =/ :096 23. 1/2. 9: =.2<2<97 2<>> 0./><8/2<97 /71 1<0.C2.1 0.8=971.72 9%7850/7C. 96=/7A 29 1.=98<2 23.8/6.@<23><;.02A290.C9B.023.8/6.:0960.8=971.72 9 440<.B.1;A23.8/<1?5146.72/71/@/0123. <7?50.1 C>/<6/72 3/8 =0.:.00.1 23<8 /==./> <7 @3<C3 <2 <8 C972.71.123/26./40./69572@/840/72.1:90=/<7/71 85::.0<74 >988 9: /6.7<2<.8 20/78=902/2<97 :991 /71 7950<836.72>9889:./07<74150<74>/<15==.0<91/71/>89 - 4 - :90 /22.71/72 C3/04.8 3.0.:90. 3. 0.G5.82.1 :90 .73/7C.6.729:23.C96=.78/2<97 8 =.0 H+@9571 C.02<:<C/2. 23. /==.>>/72 3/8 8582/<7.1 :0/C250. 9: 2<;</ /71 :<;5>/ @<23 8.C971 6.2/2/08/> ;97.@3<C3 <8 40<.B958 <7 7/250. ;52 3. 3/8 792.H/6<7.123.9C290885C323.1<8/;<><2AC/7792;. /88.88.1 /71 23.0.;A 79 C96=.78/2<97 7..18 29 ;. 40/72.1:90>9889::5250../07<748 * 3. /==.>>/72 3/8 <7C500.1 8*&E& 29@/018 6.1<C/> .H=.78.8 /71 23. 8/<1 /69572 @/8 40/72.1;A23.0<;57/>/71<27..1879<72.0:.0.7C. 3./==.>>/723/8=0915C.11<8C3/04.8566/0A 571.0 H . @/8 398=<2/><8.1 :096 +% 29 *%<.:90230..1/A8/7123.73.@/820./2.1<7 3.77/<:096%29%*%<.:90+1/A8 /71 2358 <7 />> 3. @/8 398=<2/><8.1 :90 1/A8 978<1.0<74 23. 7/250. 9: <7?50<.8 /71 =.0<91 9: 398=<2/><8/2<97 23<8 9502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 40/72 /7 - 5 - /695729:8:90=/<7/7185::.0<748% :90 :991 7950<836.72 8=.C</> 1<.2 8+ :90 /22.71/72 /71 C97B.A/7C. C3/04.8 /71 8% :90 >9889:/6.7<2<.8 E 3. /69572 />0./1A 40/72.1 ;A 23. 0<;57/> 571.023.3./1I>9889:<7C96.150<7423.>/<15==.0<91J /2 8*+ <8 :90 8<H 697238 @3<C3 <8 ?582 /71 =09=.0/717..1879<72.0:.0.7C. .7C.23./==.>>/72<8.72<2>.1:9023.691<:<.1 C96=.78/2<97571.01<::.0.723./18/8;.>9@ /<7/7185::.0<74 8 .1<C/>.H=.78.8 8*&E& '9917950<836.728=.C</>1<.2 8% 22.71/72/71C97B.A/7C.C3/04.8 8+ 9889:<7C96.150<74>/<15==.0<91 8*+ 9889:/6.7<2<.8 8% 92/> .88/@/01.1;A0<;57/> 73/7C.6.72 8+& 8E*E% ) *+ 358 23. /==.>>/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 .73/7C.1 C96=.78/2<97 9: 8E+& @<23 <72.0.82 /2 F =.0 - 6 - /7756/7123.0.:90.23./==./>1.8.0B.829;./>>9@.1<7 =/02 723.0.85>223.:9>>9@<74901.0<8=/88.1 !<# ==./><8/>>9@.1<7=/02 !<<# 3. /==.>>/72C>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 23. .73/7C.1 C96=.78/2<97 9: 8E+& @<23 <72.0.82 /2 F =.0 /7756 :096 23. 1/2. 9: =.2<2<97 2<>> 23. 1/2. 9: 0./><8/2<97 !<<<# .8=971.72 9%7850/7C. 96=/7A <8 1<0.C2.1 29 1.=98<2 23. /:90.8/<1 C96=.78/2<97 /69572 @<23<797.69723:09623.1/2.9:23<8?5146.72 !<B# 7 85C3 1.=98<2 23. /==.>>/72 <8 =.06<22.1 29 @<2310/@ 23. .72<0. /69572 />974 @<23 <72.0.82 /CC05.1 97<2 ),- %$ ' # <829>9E